What do you think?
Rate this book
The Winter Witch
Two sisters set sail on a bride ship from Normandy hoping to leave a curse behind them and find better lives in the wilds of 17th-century Quebec, only to meet a mysterious witch who forces them to confront the truth about magic—and their past. For fans of Emilia Hart, Sarah Penner, Alix E. Harrow, Ami McKay, and Roberta Rich.
Élisabeth Jossard boards a bride ship to New France with her sister Marthe, forced to start a new life after a scandal in her village in Normandy. She’s harbouring a dark secret and hopes that by coming to Montreal—the holiest place in the world, she’s been told—the saints will hear her pleas and lift the curse that plagues her.
When Élisabeth’s prayers go unanswered and she is unable to banish the spirit she believes is tormenting her, Marthe encourages her to turn to a powerful witch for help, the enigmatic stowaway Jeanne Roy. But Jeanne has secrets of her own, and when she refuses to help, Élisabeth’s resentment kindles a dangerous fire.
Inspired by the tales of Canada’s Filles du Roi, The Winter Witch examines how lies, arrogance, and ignorance can lead to witch hunts in any society.
Élisabeth Jossard boards a bride ship to New France with her sister Marthe, forced to start a new life after a scandal in her village in Normandy. She’s harbouring a dark secret and hopes that by coming to Montreal—the holiest place in the world, she’s been told—the saints will hear her pleas and lift the curse that plagues her.
When Élisabeth’s prayers go unanswered and she is unable to banish the spirit she believes is tormenting her, Marthe encourages her to turn to a powerful witch for help, the enigmatic stowaway Jeanne Roy. But Jeanne has secrets of her own, and when she refuses to help, Élisabeth’s resentment kindles a dangerous fire.
Inspired by the tales of Canada’s Filles du Roi, The Winter Witch examines how lies, arrogance, and ignorance can lead to witch hunts in any society.
384 pages, Paperback
Published January 27, 2026
91 people are currently reading
3415 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
November 5, 2025
A few years before the Salem Witch Trials in America, superstitious and oppressed people in France and Canada were also chasing shadows and pointing fingers. Senior producer at CBC and debut novelist, Jennifer Chevalier, sets out to show that lies, arrogance, and ignorance can lead to witch hunts.
Inspired by Canada’s filles du roi, Chevalier invites readers along for the journey as two sisters, Marthe and Elisabeth (Lili) Jossard board the Saint-Jean-Baptiste along with other girls who have accepted the King’s dowry in exchange for a promise to marry a settler in New France. These girls, Montrealistes, are headed to Ville-Marie, a missionary village on an island called Montreal in Canada. Some are adventurous, some are afraid of becoming spinsters, and some, like the Jossard girls, are escaping scandal.
Readers soon discover that naïveté, secrets and societal expecations/constraints are the root cause of Lili and Marthe’s predicament. Unable to outrun these ties, the girls are unsuccessful transplants in the new world until they are forced to confront the truth about their past, confront their fears, and confront their beliefs concerning magic.
Chevalier’s storytelling is sublime, her characters feel like you already know them, and the attention she gives to the setting creates a feeling of place that anchors the story. I thoroughly enjoyed this thought-provoking read centered around my country's history. I hope we hear more from Marthe and Lili and Ville-Marie.
I was gifted this copy by Simon&Schuster Canada and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Inspired by Canada’s filles du roi, Chevalier invites readers along for the journey as two sisters, Marthe and Elisabeth (Lili) Jossard board the Saint-Jean-Baptiste along with other girls who have accepted the King’s dowry in exchange for a promise to marry a settler in New France. These girls, Montrealistes, are headed to Ville-Marie, a missionary village on an island called Montreal in Canada. Some are adventurous, some are afraid of becoming spinsters, and some, like the Jossard girls, are escaping scandal.
Readers soon discover that naïveté, secrets and societal expecations/constraints are the root cause of Lili and Marthe’s predicament. Unable to outrun these ties, the girls are unsuccessful transplants in the new world until they are forced to confront the truth about their past, confront their fears, and confront their beliefs concerning magic.
Chevalier’s storytelling is sublime, her characters feel like you already know them, and the attention she gives to the setting creates a feeling of place that anchors the story. I thoroughly enjoyed this thought-provoking read centered around my country's history. I hope we hear more from Marthe and Lili and Ville-Marie.
I was gifted this copy by Simon&Schuster Canada and was under no obligation to provide a review.
January 8, 2026
super intéressant mais Élisabeth était vraiment déplaisante haha
January 30, 2026
I received this ARC from a Goodreads giveaway.
As a Quebecer with French coloniser ancestry as far back as the 1700s myself, it was really interesting to read and match this novel's plot and setting against what I learned of the Filles du Roy in History classes in school. The author did a great job painting a vivid picture of the girls' experience journeying over by ship, setting foot on New France soil, meeting the strangers they might marry out of duty and may never love, and then settling into remote shacks with them. Life was tough in New France, and this was captured well in my opinion.
I enjoyed the sisters' story overall. Elisabeth and the priest de Sancy encapsulated perfectly how the Church instilled the fear of God, the Devil, and demons in those days. Lilly drove my agnostic mind CRAZY, I wanted to shake some @#$%& sense into her. But, I do think the concussion she gets on the ship is to blame for most of her religious fervour thereafter. I might have pulled all my hair out if .
As a Quebecer with French coloniser ancestry as far back as the 1700s myself, it was really interesting to read and match this novel's plot and setting against what I learned of the Filles du Roy in History classes in school. The author did a great job painting a vivid picture of the girls' experience journeying over by ship, setting foot on New France soil, meeting the strangers they might marry out of duty and may never love, and then settling into remote shacks with them. Life was tough in New France, and this was captured well in my opinion.
I enjoyed the sisters' story overall. Elisabeth and the priest de Sancy encapsulated perfectly how the Church instilled the fear of God, the Devil, and demons in those days. Lilly drove my agnostic mind CRAZY, I wanted to shake some @#$%& sense into her. But, I do think the concussion she gets on the ship is to blame for most of her religious fervour thereafter. I might have pulled all my hair out if .
November 25, 2025
I wanted to read this as soon as I read the synopsis. I was really excited when Simon and Schuster approved my request on NetGalley. Elisabeth and her sister Marthe are driven from their village in Normandy due to a scandal. They board a bride ship to Canada in hopes to start over. Things take a turn from there and Elisabeth ends up accusing a neighbour of being a witch. It was scarily easy to turn the village against her. If any of this is of interest to you go read The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier.
February 22, 2026
Élizabeth…girl…I think we need to hear just one more time how broad his chest is please
February 23, 2026
Maybe my book of the year and it's only the beginning of 2026! Publishers have a lot of work to do if they want to stand up to this one.
Key components> Canadian history, including Indigenous treatment, filles du roi (brides sent to New France), female hardships, early science vs witch lore and false accusations
Key components> Canadian history, including Indigenous treatment, filles du roi (brides sent to New France), female hardships, early science vs witch lore and false accusations
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I am so grateful my request was approved to read this early. I saw the author speak of her inspiration via social media and I was convinced I needed to read this immediately.
What unfolds is an intriguing, layered story about superstition, belief and the dynamics of power. The book beautifully, skillfully paints an image of life in the early colonies. How they were a rough place of hardship, loneliness…and way too many men. The way Ms Chevalier describes this setting is utterly believable.
I felt I was given insight into the minds and hearts of the women of that time. Their limited options for living out their lives as poor women with no family. I could feel the various yokes of oppression, their limitations for expressing themselves or even understanding the world around them. All the invisible lines drawn for them to stay within to be considered a “proper, devout” woman were so tangible you could feel their strangling presence.
There is a dual POV between two sisters, Marthe and Lili who could not be more different. I felt like I was gazing directly out of their eyes, feeling everything they felt. I was bereft, despairing one minute then utterly furious the next. They were complex, multi-layer girls forced to be women so young. They had experienced so much pain and sorrow but still knew so little of the world. Which, to be honest, most people of their status were trapped within their ignorance and had it leveraged against them. Rumours and suspicions became deadly sentences at the hands of fearful, miserable neighbors and townspeople. Humans have the capacity to be the greatest monsters.
However, this book showed that humans also have the capacity to be the greatest champions of what is right. It had a wonderful twist, moments of light and hope and women seizing what little power they had through intelligence and daring. I won’t spoil it but it was SO empowering and satisfying. I was so fearful and worried the first portion of the book that when the climax came I raced through to the end. I feel I need to go back and properly revel in the turn of events.
What unfolds is an intriguing, layered story about superstition, belief and the dynamics of power. The book beautifully, skillfully paints an image of life in the early colonies. How they were a rough place of hardship, loneliness…and way too many men. The way Ms Chevalier describes this setting is utterly believable.
I felt I was given insight into the minds and hearts of the women of that time. Their limited options for living out their lives as poor women with no family. I could feel the various yokes of oppression, their limitations for expressing themselves or even understanding the world around them. All the invisible lines drawn for them to stay within to be considered a “proper, devout” woman were so tangible you could feel their strangling presence.
There is a dual POV between two sisters, Marthe and Lili who could not be more different. I felt like I was gazing directly out of their eyes, feeling everything they felt. I was bereft, despairing one minute then utterly furious the next. They were complex, multi-layer girls forced to be women so young. They had experienced so much pain and sorrow but still knew so little of the world. Which, to be honest, most people of their status were trapped within their ignorance and had it leveraged against them. Rumours and suspicions became deadly sentences at the hands of fearful, miserable neighbors and townspeople. Humans have the capacity to be the greatest monsters.
However, this book showed that humans also have the capacity to be the greatest champions of what is right. It had a wonderful twist, moments of light and hope and women seizing what little power they had through intelligence and daring. I won’t spoil it but it was SO empowering and satisfying. I was so fearful and worried the first portion of the book that when the climax came I raced through to the end. I feel I need to go back and properly revel in the turn of events.
February 2, 2026
The Winter Witch is an engaging historical fiction novel that follows the journey of sisters Marthe and Élisabeth, who travel from France in 1670 with other Filles du Roi to find husbands in the remote village of Ville-Marie (Montréal, Quebec, Canada). While Marthe is determined to create a prosperous new life for herself, Élisabeth hasn't been able to leave her fears or secrets behind. She has been cursed by the winter witch.
From the cramped hold of the brideship to the vast wilderness of New France, Jennifer Chevalier creates a vivid and atmospheric setting filled with rich historical detail. I enjoyed this window into the lives of Canada's indigenous people and the early settlers of Quebec.
This period of history was a tumultuous time when religion and science were butting heads, and superstition warred with reason. Many people still feared witches, almost as much as they feared women's power and success. These conflicting beliefs and prejudices were brilliantly played out by the characters in the story, showing us how difficult it can be to acknowledge perspectives different than one's own.
I felt so many emotions as I eagerly followed the fates of Marthe, Élisabeth and their friends, from disgust and incredulity to frustration and compassion. This is ultimately a compelling story of female friendship and empowerment, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for providing me with an ARC of this book. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
From the cramped hold of the brideship to the vast wilderness of New France, Jennifer Chevalier creates a vivid and atmospheric setting filled with rich historical detail. I enjoyed this window into the lives of Canada's indigenous people and the early settlers of Quebec.
This period of history was a tumultuous time when religion and science were butting heads, and superstition warred with reason. Many people still feared witches, almost as much as they feared women's power and success. These conflicting beliefs and prejudices were brilliantly played out by the characters in the story, showing us how difficult it can be to acknowledge perspectives different than one's own.
I felt so many emotions as I eagerly followed the fates of Marthe, Élisabeth and their friends, from disgust and incredulity to frustration and compassion. This is ultimately a compelling story of female friendship and empowerment, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for providing me with an ARC of this book. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 12, 2026
3.5 stars.
Élisabeth and Marthe are forced to board a ship to New France from Normandy to start a new life after a village scandal. Élisabeth is harboring a dark secret and hopes that Montreal – the holiest place in the world – will lift the curse that plagues her. When her prayers go unanswered, Marthe encourages her to seek help from a powerful witch.
THE WINTER WITCH is a book I was really excited about reading in 2026. It is an incredible debut that is inspired by Canada’s Filles du Roi. The story is set primarily in New France within the village of Ville-Marie (aka Montreal, QC) in 1670.
The storytelling alternates between Élisabeth and Marthe’s POVs whom are two girls-for-marrying fleeing Normandy, France for a fresh start. I enjoyed both sisters as the narrators for this novel. Élisabeth and Marthe are well-written and interesting, though I did find Élisabeth to be a bit tiresome. It is clear from early on that she is suffering from mental illness, making her irrational and not open to other’s thoughts or directives.
The marriages these two women embark upon are not love matches, but there is a certain romance that develops between the two couples that is sweet and heartwarming.
I was hoping for a bit more witchiness within these pages, but I did love the attention the author gives to how easy lies and ignorance can lead to witch hunts.
I would like to thank Netgalley and the publisher, Simon & Schuster Canada, for the opportunity to read this advanced digital copy in exchange for an honest review! All opinions expressed are my own.
Élisabeth and Marthe are forced to board a ship to New France from Normandy to start a new life after a village scandal. Élisabeth is harboring a dark secret and hopes that Montreal – the holiest place in the world – will lift the curse that plagues her. When her prayers go unanswered, Marthe encourages her to seek help from a powerful witch.
THE WINTER WITCH is a book I was really excited about reading in 2026. It is an incredible debut that is inspired by Canada’s Filles du Roi. The story is set primarily in New France within the village of Ville-Marie (aka Montreal, QC) in 1670.
The storytelling alternates between Élisabeth and Marthe’s POVs whom are two girls-for-marrying fleeing Normandy, France for a fresh start. I enjoyed both sisters as the narrators for this novel. Élisabeth and Marthe are well-written and interesting, though I did find Élisabeth to be a bit tiresome. It is clear from early on that she is suffering from mental illness, making her irrational and not open to other’s thoughts or directives.
The marriages these two women embark upon are not love matches, but there is a certain romance that develops between the two couples that is sweet and heartwarming.
I was hoping for a bit more witchiness within these pages, but I did love the attention the author gives to how easy lies and ignorance can lead to witch hunts.
I would like to thank Netgalley and the publisher, Simon & Schuster Canada, for the opportunity to read this advanced digital copy in exchange for an honest review! All opinions expressed are my own.
January 28, 2026
Readers who loved The Midwife of Venice will devour The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier. Chevalier is an award-winning journalist who has utilized her talents as a researcher and storyteller to weave an incredible work of historical fiction. Carefully drawn from historical accounts, we meet sisters Elisabeth and Marthe who board a bride ship in seventeenth-century Normandy, bound for New France (Quebec) to marry the men helping to establish a new colony. On board the ship with them is a Catholic Priest who is considered to be an expert on witches, demonology and the fanatical destruction of anyone he believes is possessed by the devil. The sisters bond with the other women on the ship and form deep friendships which stand them in good stead as they navigate the trials of their new country. While Marthe is sensible and pragmatic, Elisabeth is a pious and fanciful girl with a dangerous secret, whose foolish beliefs about curses and witchcraft place a woman’s life in peril. Beautifully written, this is a compelling story of superstition and fear but also one of female agency. Highly recommended.
January 12, 2026
The history of the French colonies in Québec, specifically the Filles du Roi braving the unknown to join them, is a part of Canadian history that I am drawn to as it is fascinating and an important part of my own family’s history. I hadn’t read a work of fiction about the Filles du Roi since Anne Hébert’s Premier Jardin and when this period and its people are brought to life through fiction it is particularly engaging and moving.
The Winter Witch is a fantastic work historical fiction based on real events and people of this chapter of Canadian history. It is touching and empowering with complex characters and a gripping storyline with a hint of magic. I do wish that we had delved a bit deeper into life on the colonies and Indigenous culture and history. However this was overall a great read and I am excited to see what Chevalier writes next!
Thank you NetGalley and Simon and Schuster for the ARC!
January 2, 2026
Winter Witch follows sisters Elisabeth and Marthe as they leave France aboard a bride ship bound for Quebec after a scandal between Elisabeth and a local boy forces them to leave home. Along with other women sent to populate the New World, they face harsh conditions, strict religious rules, and the ever-present fear of witchcraft. Elisabeth believes the journey will lift a witch’s curse that has left her barren, allowing her to return to France to be with the man she loves
Jeanne Roy becomes a key figure in their lives, offering knowledge outside the Church’s rules and showing how quickly suspicion can spread. The story moves at a slower pace, but it lets the characters and their world come alive and kept me engaged throughout.
Overall, Winter Witch was a great read and I think anyone who enjoys historical women’s fiction with rich detail and well-drawn characters will really enjoy it as well.
Jeanne Roy becomes a key figure in their lives, offering knowledge outside the Church’s rules and showing how quickly suspicion can spread. The story moves at a slower pace, but it lets the characters and their world come alive and kept me engaged throughout.
Overall, Winter Witch was a great read and I think anyone who enjoys historical women’s fiction with rich detail and well-drawn characters will really enjoy it as well.
February 19, 2026
4.5 stars - loses 1/2 point for the main character being such an "ignorant peasant" and making me furious for so much of this book.
However, as a lover of historical fiction, I was swept away by this tale of witches, and the power of women.
However, as a lover of historical fiction, I was swept away by this tale of witches, and the power of women.
February 8, 2026
10 stars. What a story.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I received a complimentary ARC copy of The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier from Net Galley and Simon & Schuster Canada in order to read and give an honest review.
History and folklore come together so beautifully in Jennifer Chevalier’s debut, The Winter Witch. As someone who absolutely loves a good historical narrative, especially those that showcase the sheer grit and resilience of the women who came before us, I was definitely thrilled to get my hands on this one. I loved the intimate glimpse into the lives of the “Filles du Roi”, or “King’s Daughters,” who braved the unknown to build a legacy in the New World.
Inspired by the approximately 800 French women sponsored by King Louis XIV in the 17th century, the story follows sisters Marthe and Élisabeth (Lili) as they leave their home in Normandy behind. Searching for a life outside the shadow of a village scandal, they board the Saint-Jean-Baptiste to accept the King’s dowry, promising to marry settlers in New France. Their destination is Ville-Marie (now Montreal), which at the time was a tiny missionary village on the edge of the wilderness. While some of the other girls on board are looking for adventure or an escape from becoming spinsters, the sisters are running from a past that refuses to stay buried.
The story wanders between Marthe and Lili’s points of view, and I really enjoyed having both as narrators. Marthe is down-to-earth and protective, definitely the grounding force of the duo, and watching her reclaim her power through her own intelligence and daring was so empowering. Lili, on the other hand, was a bit more of a “difficult” character whose personality is ruled by fear, and she’s overwhelmed, convinced she’s cursed, hoping Montreal’s reputation as a “holy” place will drive the demon from her. I struggled with her at times with her irrationality and refusal to listen; it was a sad reminder about the history of mental illness, a condition that the 17th-century world was tragically unable to handle.
Although their marriages start out as matters of necessity rather than love matches, the romance that develops for both couples is surprisingly heartwarming. It was such a beautiful counterpoint to the harsher realities of the colonial life depicted. I also really appreciated the point the author makes about how easily lies, ignorance, and societal constraints can spiral into a witch hunt. It’s a chilling reminder of how humans have the capacity to be the greatest monsters when they’re fueled by fear.
I loved the fact that the book champions the human spirit. There’s a fantastic twist and some wonderful moments of light where these women seized what little power they had through sheer intelligence.
The Winter Witch is a well-written piece of historical fiction that manages to anchor a sliver of folklore in a very real, very gritty past. While the atmosphere and character development were dynamic, I did find myself wishing we’d delved just a bit deeper into the daily life of the colonies and Indigenous history. Regardless, this is a gripping, moving read that brings a vital chapter of Canadian history to the forefront. If you love stories about complex women fighting for their place in a world that fears them, you won’t want to miss this one. I highly recommend.
History and folklore come together so beautifully in Jennifer Chevalier’s debut, The Winter Witch. As someone who absolutely loves a good historical narrative, especially those that showcase the sheer grit and resilience of the women who came before us, I was definitely thrilled to get my hands on this one. I loved the intimate glimpse into the lives of the “Filles du Roi”, or “King’s Daughters,” who braved the unknown to build a legacy in the New World.
Inspired by the approximately 800 French women sponsored by King Louis XIV in the 17th century, the story follows sisters Marthe and Élisabeth (Lili) as they leave their home in Normandy behind. Searching for a life outside the shadow of a village scandal, they board the Saint-Jean-Baptiste to accept the King’s dowry, promising to marry settlers in New France. Their destination is Ville-Marie (now Montreal), which at the time was a tiny missionary village on the edge of the wilderness. While some of the other girls on board are looking for adventure or an escape from becoming spinsters, the sisters are running from a past that refuses to stay buried.
The story wanders between Marthe and Lili’s points of view, and I really enjoyed having both as narrators. Marthe is down-to-earth and protective, definitely the grounding force of the duo, and watching her reclaim her power through her own intelligence and daring was so empowering. Lili, on the other hand, was a bit more of a “difficult” character whose personality is ruled by fear, and she’s overwhelmed, convinced she’s cursed, hoping Montreal’s reputation as a “holy” place will drive the demon from her. I struggled with her at times with her irrationality and refusal to listen; it was a sad reminder about the history of mental illness, a condition that the 17th-century world was tragically unable to handle.
Although their marriages start out as matters of necessity rather than love matches, the romance that develops for both couples is surprisingly heartwarming. It was such a beautiful counterpoint to the harsher realities of the colonial life depicted. I also really appreciated the point the author makes about how easily lies, ignorance, and societal constraints can spiral into a witch hunt. It’s a chilling reminder of how humans have the capacity to be the greatest monsters when they’re fueled by fear.
I loved the fact that the book champions the human spirit. There’s a fantastic twist and some wonderful moments of light where these women seized what little power they had through sheer intelligence.
The Winter Witch is a well-written piece of historical fiction that manages to anchor a sliver of folklore in a very real, very gritty past. While the atmosphere and character development were dynamic, I did find myself wishing we’d delved just a bit deeper into the daily life of the colonies and Indigenous history. Regardless, this is a gripping, moving read that brings a vital chapter of Canadian history to the forefront. If you love stories about complex women fighting for their place in a world that fears them, you won’t want to miss this one. I highly recommend.
February 5, 2026
Book review: 3.5/5 ⭐️
Genre: historical fiction
Themes: superstitions, witch-hunt, child brides, colonies
📖 Read if you like: Weyward, The Book of Witching
“It is stupidity more than anything else that I cannot abide. Malice is comprehensible. One need only read the Bible to know that men are greedy and hateful. It’s the ignorance - the wilful, lazy ignorance! - that is so…so reprehensible.”
It is curious to have this raging sense of anger at the cruelty of ignorance and to dig further into a story of one. One of the central characters in this story is obsessed with her own demons that she has manifested them into madness. What can be construed as grief turns into depression and when layered with superstitious false piety it becomes dangerous. Élizabeth is an ignorant country girl, uneducated and easily enthralled by the idea of witches and curses. Her naivity and the cause of her affliction would be lamentable if she were not so blind to evidence laid forth before her and hell bent on the ideas of witchcraft. If she were not so indifferent to the very real suffering of others and if her ravings did not condemn an innocent woman to death she would merely be foolish, but as it were Lili was very hard to like. Her revelations came too late in the day, and I thought the switch was too drastic. She was too easily offered forgiveness for her cruelty. I found her change of heart and happy ending too neat for such a tale of misgivings and ignorance.
The other half of this story is told through the eyes of younger sister Marthe. Sharp tongued and with an iron will, Marthe marries young to escape her sister and forge her own path. Ambitious and determined, she is thwarted by the widow who lives with her husband and her own youth. When a very real threat presents itself, Marthe will do what she must to shackle the wolves, the monsters that hurt women simply because they can. She is the compelling and admirable half to Lili’s self obsessions.
Together they formed a tale steeped in beliefs that rings with accuracy for the times. This story made me livid and yet it wouldn’t let me go. It stirred such deep emotions to see how easily superstitions supersede all sense. This is in no small part due to the beautiful writing and ensnaring story. It was well researched and compelling. Naivety pays a heavy toll, one which is proven by historical witch-hunts against women that are different, those that are learned and not afraid to be bold. For there really is a certain magic to knowledge.
Synopsis: Two sisters set sell as brides for the colonies. One is escaping a sordid secret and the other following in her shame. They may leave Normandy behind, but they will bring with them the superstitious tales and beliefs of the winter witch. As they search for better lives in 17th-century Quebec, they will be forced to confront the truth about magic and their pasts.
Thank you to Simon and Schuster and Netgalley for an eARC of this book.
Genre: historical fiction
Themes: superstitions, witch-hunt, child brides, colonies
📖 Read if you like: Weyward, The Book of Witching
“It is stupidity more than anything else that I cannot abide. Malice is comprehensible. One need only read the Bible to know that men are greedy and hateful. It’s the ignorance - the wilful, lazy ignorance! - that is so…so reprehensible.”
It is curious to have this raging sense of anger at the cruelty of ignorance and to dig further into a story of one. One of the central characters in this story is obsessed with her own demons that she has manifested them into madness. What can be construed as grief turns into depression and when layered with superstitious false piety it becomes dangerous. Élizabeth is an ignorant country girl, uneducated and easily enthralled by the idea of witches and curses. Her naivity and the cause of her affliction would be lamentable if she were not so blind to evidence laid forth before her and hell bent on the ideas of witchcraft. If she were not so indifferent to the very real suffering of others and if her ravings did not condemn an innocent woman to death she would merely be foolish, but as it were Lili was very hard to like. Her revelations came too late in the day, and I thought the switch was too drastic. She was too easily offered forgiveness for her cruelty. I found her change of heart and happy ending too neat for such a tale of misgivings and ignorance.
The other half of this story is told through the eyes of younger sister Marthe. Sharp tongued and with an iron will, Marthe marries young to escape her sister and forge her own path. Ambitious and determined, she is thwarted by the widow who lives with her husband and her own youth. When a very real threat presents itself, Marthe will do what she must to shackle the wolves, the monsters that hurt women simply because they can. She is the compelling and admirable half to Lili’s self obsessions.
Together they formed a tale steeped in beliefs that rings with accuracy for the times. This story made me livid and yet it wouldn’t let me go. It stirred such deep emotions to see how easily superstitions supersede all sense. This is in no small part due to the beautiful writing and ensnaring story. It was well researched and compelling. Naivety pays a heavy toll, one which is proven by historical witch-hunts against women that are different, those that are learned and not afraid to be bold. For there really is a certain magic to knowledge.
Synopsis: Two sisters set sell as brides for the colonies. One is escaping a sordid secret and the other following in her shame. They may leave Normandy behind, but they will bring with them the superstitious tales and beliefs of the winter witch. As they search for better lives in 17th-century Quebec, they will be forced to confront the truth about magic and their pasts.
Thank you to Simon and Schuster and Netgalley for an eARC of this book.
January 28, 2026
ARC Review: The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier
Set against the starkness and unforgiving cold of 17th‑century New France, The Winter Witch follows sisters Élisabeth and Marthe Jossard as they flee a scandal in Normandy aboard a bride ship, hoping to outrun a curse and find safety in a land they’ve been told is holy. What they encounter instead is a world shaped by superstition, hardship, and the dangerous power of stories.
One of the elements I enjoyed most was the historical grounding. The novel brings to life the real journeys of the Filles du Roi, hundreds of women who left France to settle in Quebec and Montreal. Given how modern and bustling these cities are today, it was fascinating, and sobering, to be reminded of their origins as precarious, isolated settlements shaped by faith, fear, and survival.
The alternating POVs between Élisabeth and Marthe worked well, especially in highlighting how their limited education and differing temperaments shape their understanding of the world around them. Their fears, suspicions, and the collective anxieties of the women aboard the ship sometimes felt overwhelming, but also believable given the clergy’s manipulative influence. The way folklore, sin, and the threat of witchcraft were used to control female behaviour is handled with nuance and historical resonance.
The pacing in the first half is on the slower side, with Élisabeth’s internal turmoil repeating itself at times, but the story gains momentum once the sisters reach New France. From that point onward, the tension and emotional stakes held my interest through to the end. I also appreciated the men who become the sisters’ husbands—their backstories add warmth and humanity, and the fact that both couples ultimately find a form of happiness was satisfying, even if the resolution felt a bit rushed after the slower build‑up.
Overall, The Winter Witch is an atmospheric and thoughtful blend of historical fiction and subtle magical realism. It will appeal to readers who enjoy stories about strong women navigating harsh worlds, the dangers of superstition, and the fragile line between faith and fear. And truly, we could use more Canadiana in historical fiction.
P.S. I am grateful to the author, publisher and NetGalley for giving me an advanced reader’s copy of this story for which I am voluntarily writing this honest review.
P.S. 2: If you liked this, then please check out my other book reviews of stories about strong women and their handsome sidekicks!
Set against the starkness and unforgiving cold of 17th‑century New France, The Winter Witch follows sisters Élisabeth and Marthe Jossard as they flee a scandal in Normandy aboard a bride ship, hoping to outrun a curse and find safety in a land they’ve been told is holy. What they encounter instead is a world shaped by superstition, hardship, and the dangerous power of stories.
One of the elements I enjoyed most was the historical grounding. The novel brings to life the real journeys of the Filles du Roi, hundreds of women who left France to settle in Quebec and Montreal. Given how modern and bustling these cities are today, it was fascinating, and sobering, to be reminded of their origins as precarious, isolated settlements shaped by faith, fear, and survival.
The alternating POVs between Élisabeth and Marthe worked well, especially in highlighting how their limited education and differing temperaments shape their understanding of the world around them. Their fears, suspicions, and the collective anxieties of the women aboard the ship sometimes felt overwhelming, but also believable given the clergy’s manipulative influence. The way folklore, sin, and the threat of witchcraft were used to control female behaviour is handled with nuance and historical resonance.
The pacing in the first half is on the slower side, with Élisabeth’s internal turmoil repeating itself at times, but the story gains momentum once the sisters reach New France. From that point onward, the tension and emotional stakes held my interest through to the end. I also appreciated the men who become the sisters’ husbands—their backstories add warmth and humanity, and the fact that both couples ultimately find a form of happiness was satisfying, even if the resolution felt a bit rushed after the slower build‑up.
Overall, The Winter Witch is an atmospheric and thoughtful blend of historical fiction and subtle magical realism. It will appeal to readers who enjoy stories about strong women navigating harsh worlds, the dangers of superstition, and the fragile line between faith and fear. And truly, we could use more Canadiana in historical fiction.
P.S. I am grateful to the author, publisher and NetGalley for giving me an advanced reader’s copy of this story for which I am voluntarily writing this honest review.
P.S. 2: If you liked this, then please check out my other book reviews of stories about strong women and their handsome sidekicks!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Winter Witch follows the story of sisters Élisabeth and Marthe Jossard, who set sail for New France, hoping to find a new life. In Élisabeth's case however, the journey is more than seeking a fresh start: she hopes to find a cure to her curse.
The story opens strong, plunging you directly into the intrigue as the ship departs for the New World. The hook is instant. You begin to learn who these women are, their beliefs, and what they hope their future holds.
Once arriving in Montreal, the pacing does slow down, but never gets boring. The depiction of life in the early colonies was immersive and the imagery described was on point. The historical details were fascinating and really enriched the setting and atmosphere. I will also say that as a French person who immigrated to Québec (albeit under way more favorable circumstances), the girls' discovery of early Montreal (and its winter) was truly another experience.
I have to admit I struggled with Élisabeth's character: she was often frustrating, and yet I could understand why she acted the way she did. The insight into her life helped me grasp why she clung so desperately to her beliefs, which made her journey all the more rewarding. Of all the characters, you will love some (Jeanne and Wari were, of course, my absolute favourites), and you will hate some, but you will definitely care for all these girls, forced to become women far too young. I couldn't help but root for all of them, hoping that they will all find happiness in a time where they simply weren't allowed or given the chance to grow.
Ultimately, The Winter Witch is a cautionary tale on how innocence and ignorance can be taken advantage of, and how superstition and beliefs can easily be manipulated by people of power; but it is also a beautiful tale on how women coming together are a force to be reckoned with. The ending was as chaotic as it was satisfying, and I simply could not put the book down once I hit the last third. There was far less magical realism or witchcraft than I expected, but I can't say I was disappointed with how the topic was handled.
If you like a good historical fiction, this is the book for you. The Winter Witch is a strong debut novel, and I will be looking forward to the stories Jennifer Chevalier will write next.
I would like to sincerely thank Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for the ARC of this book! All opinions are my own.
The story opens strong, plunging you directly into the intrigue as the ship departs for the New World. The hook is instant. You begin to learn who these women are, their beliefs, and what they hope their future holds.
Once arriving in Montreal, the pacing does slow down, but never gets boring. The depiction of life in the early colonies was immersive and the imagery described was on point. The historical details were fascinating and really enriched the setting and atmosphere. I will also say that as a French person who immigrated to Québec (albeit under way more favorable circumstances), the girls' discovery of early Montreal (and its winter) was truly another experience.
I have to admit I struggled with Élisabeth's character: she was often frustrating, and yet I could understand why she acted the way she did. The insight into her life helped me grasp why she clung so desperately to her beliefs, which made her journey all the more rewarding. Of all the characters, you will love some (Jeanne and Wari were, of course, my absolute favourites), and you will hate some, but you will definitely care for all these girls, forced to become women far too young. I couldn't help but root for all of them, hoping that they will all find happiness in a time where they simply weren't allowed or given the chance to grow.
Ultimately, The Winter Witch is a cautionary tale on how innocence and ignorance can be taken advantage of, and how superstition and beliefs can easily be manipulated by people of power; but it is also a beautiful tale on how women coming together are a force to be reckoned with. The ending was as chaotic as it was satisfying, and I simply could not put the book down once I hit the last third. There was far less magical realism or witchcraft than I expected, but I can't say I was disappointed with how the topic was handled.
If you like a good historical fiction, this is the book for you. The Winter Witch is a strong debut novel, and I will be looking forward to the stories Jennifer Chevalier will write next.
I would like to sincerely thank Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for the ARC of this book! All opinions are my own.
December 4, 2025
The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier is a historical fiction novel set in 17th century Quebec, about witches, curses, and the magic of courage.
Elisabeth and Marthe set sail to New France from Normandy after a scandal banishes them to the cold wild lands of Quebec. Elisabeth believes she is cursed and clings tightly onto her faith hoping she will be saved by her religion. Once the sisters arrive in New France, Elisabeth's secret becomes harder and harder to contain, especially when whispers of witchcraft and demonic activity begin to unravel her tightly kept curse. Marthe recommends Jeanne Roy, a witchy woman to help rid Elisabeth of her secret, but when Jeanne's mysterious past threatens the lives and safety of the village, Elisabeth will need to decide if it's safer to keep her own secret while exposing another.
I always enjoy reading stories about New France as I studied this period of Canadian history quite a lot when I was in school. The tension of a pioneer village witch craze made this story a page turner with suspicion and mystery creating a dramatic atmosphere. I liked how this was not a typical witch hunt story, with science and medicine playing a larger role. It's always interesting to read about the fears, folklore, and ignorance of the early settlers without a fantasy element as it can sometimes overshadow the real traumas innocent women experienced. While there is nothing fantastical about this story, I couldn't help but wonder if there was indeed something witchy going on with Elisabeth, as there were suggestions and hints that perhaps she was bewitched? The details and depictions of life in seventeenth century Montreal were very well researched, and I thought the author's inspiration for this story was original.
Overall if you are a fan of historical fiction, I would recommend The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier.
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with a free arc via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The opinions expressed are my own.
Elisabeth and Marthe set sail to New France from Normandy after a scandal banishes them to the cold wild lands of Quebec. Elisabeth believes she is cursed and clings tightly onto her faith hoping she will be saved by her religion. Once the sisters arrive in New France, Elisabeth's secret becomes harder and harder to contain, especially when whispers of witchcraft and demonic activity begin to unravel her tightly kept curse. Marthe recommends Jeanne Roy, a witchy woman to help rid Elisabeth of her secret, but when Jeanne's mysterious past threatens the lives and safety of the village, Elisabeth will need to decide if it's safer to keep her own secret while exposing another.
I always enjoy reading stories about New France as I studied this period of Canadian history quite a lot when I was in school. The tension of a pioneer village witch craze made this story a page turner with suspicion and mystery creating a dramatic atmosphere. I liked how this was not a typical witch hunt story, with science and medicine playing a larger role. It's always interesting to read about the fears, folklore, and ignorance of the early settlers without a fantasy element as it can sometimes overshadow the real traumas innocent women experienced. While there is nothing fantastical about this story, I couldn't help but wonder if there was indeed something witchy going on with Elisabeth, as there were suggestions and hints that perhaps she was bewitched? The details and depictions of life in seventeenth century Montreal were very well researched, and I thought the author's inspiration for this story was original.
Overall if you are a fan of historical fiction, I would recommend The Winter Witch by Jennifer Chevalier.
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with a free arc via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I love learning more about women's experiences and their impact on history. The Winter Witch caught my eye with its beautiful cover, its promise of witchy things and its connection to Canadian history. This story was inspired by the experiences of Les Filles du Roi (King's Daughters) in the late 17th century. These 768 young women immigrated to New France (Quebec), sponsored by King Louis XIV to marry male colonists and promote settlement in Quebec.
The story follows two sisters, Marthe and Elisabeth, who come to New France fleeing a scandal and hoping to find peace and a new life in the new world. The story begins with their treacherous and tension-filled journey across the sea as the sisters make connections with other women on the ship. Through the sisters' dual perspectives, readers better understand the ruthless power of the Church; how it used fearmongering and threats of witchcraft to manipulate the general population, and in particular women, whose lives were already limited by societal expectations.
This book had great intentions and premise but fell flat on its delivery for me. It was a slow-moving story whose plot was a little too simplistic. The era and historical aspects were interesting and I enjoyed the complicated bond between the sisters, but Elisabeth's obsession with her old life soon became tiresome. I wanted more depth to the characters, including the 'witch'.
J'adore Montreal et Quebec! I absolutely love those cities and visit as often as I can, and I enjoyed recognizing street names in Old Montreal within this story. What I take away from this story is the power of sisterhood and female friendship and another interesting nugget of lesser-known Canadian and Women's history.
Disclaimer: My sincere thanks to Simon and Schuster Canada for the complimentary digital and trade paperback copies of this book which were given in exchange for my honest review.
The story follows two sisters, Marthe and Elisabeth, who come to New France fleeing a scandal and hoping to find peace and a new life in the new world. The story begins with their treacherous and tension-filled journey across the sea as the sisters make connections with other women on the ship. Through the sisters' dual perspectives, readers better understand the ruthless power of the Church; how it used fearmongering and threats of witchcraft to manipulate the general population, and in particular women, whose lives were already limited by societal expectations.
This book had great intentions and premise but fell flat on its delivery for me. It was a slow-moving story whose plot was a little too simplistic. The era and historical aspects were interesting and I enjoyed the complicated bond between the sisters, but Elisabeth's obsession with her old life soon became tiresome. I wanted more depth to the characters, including the 'witch'.
J'adore Montreal et Quebec! I absolutely love those cities and visit as often as I can, and I enjoyed recognizing street names in Old Montreal within this story. What I take away from this story is the power of sisterhood and female friendship and another interesting nugget of lesser-known Canadian and Women's history.
Disclaimer: My sincere thanks to Simon and Schuster Canada for the complimentary digital and trade paperback copies of this book which were given in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I want to thank Simon & Schuster Canada and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of The Winter Witch. However, all opinions expressed here are solely mine.
3.75 rounded up to 4
I truly wanted to love The Winter Witch. What historical fiction reader wouldn’t want to read a book set in the 17th century that features a possible witch? While Chevalier did extensive research for her novel, some parts felt forced. I enjoyed reading about the relationship between the brides, especially the sisters. But one was so wrapped in her misery that she refused to share, and often regretted the joy the other tried to find in life. And I understand that’s how sisters can be, but when you’re in your late teens and have no other family to turn to, are you really going to shut out the one you have?
I struggled to read this book for the first 60% or so. I’m not sure if it was the book or me, and life was getting in the way of my devoting the time to reading. That said, when I was approaching the last 30% or so, I didn’t want to stop reading. It seemed that’s where the majority of the action was. And the daring rescue was quite possibly the best part of it all.
I do think that The Winter Witch highlights what can happen when you let others have absolute power and control over every facet of life. There is a scene where Élisabeth is called a dumb peasant for her beliefs. While it may be true that she did not have sophisticated beliefs, she was not necessarily dumb or ignorant. This is brought up later in the story, and the character explains what they meant in a more meaningful way.
Overall, The Winter Witch is a great look at women’s lives in 17th-century Montreal. If you enjoy reading well-researched books, where there is character growth on all sides, then you should give The Winter Witch a read.
3.75 rounded up to 4
I truly wanted to love The Winter Witch. What historical fiction reader wouldn’t want to read a book set in the 17th century that features a possible witch? While Chevalier did extensive research for her novel, some parts felt forced. I enjoyed reading about the relationship between the brides, especially the sisters. But one was so wrapped in her misery that she refused to share, and often regretted the joy the other tried to find in life. And I understand that’s how sisters can be, but when you’re in your late teens and have no other family to turn to, are you really going to shut out the one you have?
I struggled to read this book for the first 60% or so. I’m not sure if it was the book or me, and life was getting in the way of my devoting the time to reading. That said, when I was approaching the last 30% or so, I didn’t want to stop reading. It seemed that’s where the majority of the action was. And the daring rescue was quite possibly the best part of it all.
I do think that The Winter Witch highlights what can happen when you let others have absolute power and control over every facet of life. There is a scene where Élisabeth is called a dumb peasant for her beliefs. While it may be true that she did not have sophisticated beliefs, she was not necessarily dumb or ignorant. This is brought up later in the story, and the character explains what they meant in a more meaningful way.
Overall, The Winter Witch is a great look at women’s lives in 17th-century Montreal. If you enjoy reading well-researched books, where there is character growth on all sides, then you should give The Winter Witch a read.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Elizabeth (Lili) and Marthe Jossard, who set sail from Normandy on a "bride ship" bound for New France hoping to leave a scandal behind. As part of a group of young women known as "girls for marrying", they have been provided with a dowry by the king in exchange for a promise to marry a settler in New France and populate the French colony. Lili, however, believes she has been cursed and hopes it can be lifted in the settlement of Ville Marie/Montreal which she has heard is the holiest place on earth. When her prayers aren't answered, Lili turns to Jeanne Roy, a stowaway midwife from their ship who Lili is convinced is a witch who could use her powers to lift the curse.
This was quite an enjoyable historical fiction read. I particularly enjoyed the Canadian setting, the insight into the experience of the young "Filles du Roi" and the depiction of life in 17th century Quebec with its harsh conditions in the settlement and powerful religious authorities controlling the community. The aspect of the plot revolving around the belief in witchcraft was also quite interesting and kept me turning the pages as this would have been around the same time as the Salem witch trials and there was an element of suspense to how it would all turn out. Lili can be quite a frustrating character but representative of her time when outlandish beliefs resulting from naivete and ignorance/lack of education too often led to tragic witch hunts. Overall a compelling debut novel!
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for providing a digital ARC of this book for review purposes. All opinions are my own.
This was quite an enjoyable historical fiction read. I particularly enjoyed the Canadian setting, the insight into the experience of the young "Filles du Roi" and the depiction of life in 17th century Quebec with its harsh conditions in the settlement and powerful religious authorities controlling the community. The aspect of the plot revolving around the belief in witchcraft was also quite interesting and kept me turning the pages as this would have been around the same time as the Salem witch trials and there was an element of suspense to how it would all turn out. Lili can be quite a frustrating character but representative of her time when outlandish beliefs resulting from naivete and ignorance/lack of education too often led to tragic witch hunts. Overall a compelling debut novel!
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for providing a digital ARC of this book for review purposes. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I guess I’m in the (early) minority on this one.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This was just not good. The title and blurb is very misleading IMO.
I didn’t enjoy any of the characters. Elisabeth was incredibly annoying and ignorant to the point of being dumb. None of her actions/reactions made sense and I hate characters deliberately withholding information as a plot device. Marthe had a bit more sense (not much though) but was boring once she was married. The widow was a ridiculous caricature of a MIL. All the husbands are just sort of there and although Francouer plays a more important role in the story, he is just the cliche farmer/solider with a heart of gold and very 21st century ideas about marriage *eye roll*.
Elisabeth’s past was not a shock or surprise but somehow took half the book to be revealed (to a single person and the reader).
Nothing in the story was about the girls’ struggles in New France or even witchcraft; which you would assume would be central since the book is literally called Winter Witch. All the witch stuff, of which there is very little, just pops up occasionally when it’s convenient for the story. It’s not the focus. There is no “witch hunt” or even magical realism. It’s just about one ignorant, naive, stupid annoying girl who is obsessed with the idea that she’s cursed and possessed and how she ruins the lives of those around her.
The ending made zero sense. Everyone is acting out of character and yet Elisabeth is somehow able to make everything better and everyone forgive her within a couple hours.
This book started with a lot of promise but quickly fell apart.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This was just not good. The title and blurb is very misleading IMO.
I didn’t enjoy any of the characters. Elisabeth was incredibly annoying and ignorant to the point of being dumb. None of her actions/reactions made sense and I hate characters deliberately withholding information as a plot device. Marthe had a bit more sense (not much though) but was boring once she was married. The widow was a ridiculous caricature of a MIL. All the husbands are just sort of there and although Francouer plays a more important role in the story, he is just the cliche farmer/solider with a heart of gold and very 21st century ideas about marriage *eye roll*.
Elisabeth’s past was not a shock or surprise but somehow took half the book to be revealed (to a single person and the reader).
Nothing in the story was about the girls’ struggles in New France or even witchcraft; which you would assume would be central since the book is literally called Winter Witch. All the witch stuff, of which there is very little, just pops up occasionally when it’s convenient for the story. It’s not the focus. There is no “witch hunt” or even magical realism. It’s just about one ignorant, naive, stupid annoying girl who is obsessed with the idea that she’s cursed and possessed and how she ruins the lives of those around her.
The ending made zero sense. Everyone is acting out of character and yet Elisabeth is somehow able to make everything better and everyone forgive her within a couple hours.
This book started with a lot of promise but quickly fell apart.
January 28, 2026
PUBLISHED TODAY
This is a debut novel written by an award winning Canadian journalist 🇨🇦 It's about a forgotten time in Canadian history that's beautifully woven into a fictional story.
A fascinating piece of my country's history that I only vaguely recall from grade school history class. In fact some of it I didn't even know about at all! It brings to light the experiences of women in an era that was steeped in religion, fear and superstition.
It's the 17th century in Normandy, France. Two sisters named Elisabeth and Marthe Jossard need to leave France because of scandal and shame. They board a ship to "New France" and are headed to Montreal, Quebec (then called Ville-Marie.) The ship is filled with all young women (sent by King Louis XIV as a ship of brides) but in French called, "Filles du Roi.” They are all hoping to make a new life and marry and settle in the New World. On the ship is a Priest who is travelling with them and checking for any "Witches" aboard who have been prosecuted and trying to escape. The sisters meet one lady who they fear is a witch. Marthe encourages Elisabeth who has had some troubles in the past to try to get the witch to help her. Once they reach Montreal some harsh realities settle in but the sisters eventually will marry.
In the end the women will all band together and help the sisters in their time of need. I thoroughly enjoyed this captivating story.
Publishes January 27, 2026
Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for the Advance Reader's Copy.
This is a debut novel written by an award winning Canadian journalist 🇨🇦 It's about a forgotten time in Canadian history that's beautifully woven into a fictional story.
A fascinating piece of my country's history that I only vaguely recall from grade school history class. In fact some of it I didn't even know about at all! It brings to light the experiences of women in an era that was steeped in religion, fear and superstition.
It's the 17th century in Normandy, France. Two sisters named Elisabeth and Marthe Jossard need to leave France because of scandal and shame. They board a ship to "New France" and are headed to Montreal, Quebec (then called Ville-Marie.) The ship is filled with all young women (sent by King Louis XIV as a ship of brides) but in French called, "Filles du Roi.” They are all hoping to make a new life and marry and settle in the New World. On the ship is a Priest who is travelling with them and checking for any "Witches" aboard who have been prosecuted and trying to escape. The sisters meet one lady who they fear is a witch. Marthe encourages Elisabeth who has had some troubles in the past to try to get the witch to help her. Once they reach Montreal some harsh realities settle in but the sisters eventually will marry.
In the end the women will all band together and help the sisters in their time of need. I thoroughly enjoyed this captivating story.
Publishes January 27, 2026
Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for the Advance Reader's Copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
2.5 stars rounded up. The Winter Witch is a debut historical fiction novel inspired by Canada’s Filles du Roi and set in Ville-Marie (present-day Montreal) in 1670. Based on the experiences of the King’s Daughters, the young women sent by Louis XIV to help colonize "New France", the premise is immediately compelling and rich with promise.
The dual perspectives of two sisters work well in showing the power of the Church and how fear, superstition, and accusations of witchcraft were used to control women whose lives were already tightly constrained. This exploration of manipulation and social control is where the novel is at its strongest.
Unfortunately, the book never fully delivers on what its title and premise suggest. Despite being called The Winter Witch, there is very little actual witchcraft, and what does appear is brief and underdeveloped. There is also surprisingly little focus on the women’s real struggles in New France, which feels like a missed opportunity given the historical foundation. The pacing is slow for much of the novel, and while the ending moves quickly, it wraps everything up a little too neatly.
Overall, this is a book with an intriguing concept and flashes of insight, but the execution doesn’t quite match the potential. Worth a look if the setting appeals to you, but it ultimately left me wanting more.
2.5 stars rounded up. The Winter Witch is a debut historical fiction novel inspired by Canada’s Filles du Roi and set in Ville-Marie (present-day Montreal) in 1670. Based on the experiences of the King’s Daughters, the young women sent by Louis XIV to help colonize "New France", the premise is immediately compelling and rich with promise.
The dual perspectives of two sisters work well in showing the power of the Church and how fear, superstition, and accusations of witchcraft were used to control women whose lives were already tightly constrained. This exploration of manipulation and social control is where the novel is at its strongest.
Unfortunately, the book never fully delivers on what its title and premise suggest. Despite being called The Winter Witch, there is very little actual witchcraft, and what does appear is brief and underdeveloped. There is also surprisingly little focus on the women’s real struggles in New France, which feels like a missed opportunity given the historical foundation. The pacing is slow for much of the novel, and while the ending moves quickly, it wraps everything up a little too neatly.
Overall, this is a book with an intriguing concept and flashes of insight, but the execution doesn’t quite match the potential. Worth a look if the setting appeals to you, but it ultimately left me wanting more.
February 20, 2026
4.5 rounded up
Different from my usual romantasy novels/series, but this read definitely resonated with me.
As predicted, "The Winter Witch" shares similarities with "Jeanne, fille du Roy" by Suzanne Martel, with its own characters, focuses and twists. The author did such a good job of describing the rough journey of women known as Les Filles du roi, from the perilous sea voyage from France to Canada, to marrying perfect strangers in harsh conditions with a single purpose, reproduce. Throw in the ever-looming presence of the Church, and you've got a pretty accurate picture of how ignorance kept entire nations in a state of fear that would lead to countless tragedies, such as the persecution of "witches" and Indigenous people.
Be prepared, Élizabeth's naïveté is so infuriating. I felt bad for Marthe and later on for Jeanne when Élizabeth chose to remain ignorant rather than consider what other possibilities could explain her troubles, in part because the “truth” might have meant she'd been played a fool. The characters of Barbe Poulin and Father de Sancy are perfect examples of the power of words and how, when wielded by the wrong tongues, can be incredibly destructive.
"The Winter Witch" gives you a glimpse of the past, whilst also offering insight on today's societies, where the same problematic mentalities still occur, under different labels and maintained through other institutions and methods.
Different from my usual romantasy novels/series, but this read definitely resonated with me.
As predicted, "The Winter Witch" shares similarities with "Jeanne, fille du Roy" by Suzanne Martel, with its own characters, focuses and twists. The author did such a good job of describing the rough journey of women known as Les Filles du roi, from the perilous sea voyage from France to Canada, to marrying perfect strangers in harsh conditions with a single purpose, reproduce. Throw in the ever-looming presence of the Church, and you've got a pretty accurate picture of how ignorance kept entire nations in a state of fear that would lead to countless tragedies, such as the persecution of "witches" and Indigenous people.
Be prepared, Élizabeth's naïveté is so infuriating. I felt bad for Marthe and later on for Jeanne when Élizabeth chose to remain ignorant rather than consider what other possibilities could explain her troubles, in part because the “truth” might have meant she'd been played a fool. The characters of Barbe Poulin and Father de Sancy are perfect examples of the power of words and how, when wielded by the wrong tongues, can be incredibly destructive.
"The Winter Witch" gives you a glimpse of the past, whilst also offering insight on today's societies, where the same problematic mentalities still occur, under different labels and maintained through other institutions and methods.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I requested an ARC of The Winter Witch based on the fact that it is historical fiction based on true events, set in Canada and the stunning cover.
I was wholly and very quickly drawn into the lives of sisters Elisabeth and Marthe as they were about to set out on a journey that was thrust upon them due to scandal and the loss of their family.
They are to embark on a treacherous journey from Normandy, France to New France; Ville-Marie (Montréal), Quebec on a bride ship. Oldest sister Elisabeth has a dark secret. She hopes that by going to the holiest place on earth she will be cured of her curse.
Soon Marthe encourages her sister to seek the aid of the Witch Jeanne Roy to help banish the spirit that reside in her.
When she is met with resistance to help cure her she cannot be reasoned with and soon makes decisions that will end badly for all involved.
This story provides the reader with so much intrigue and such beautiful story telling that you will not be able to put it down.
I was completely obsessed with this book and when I wasn't reading it I was thinking about it.
A very evocative story that will linger in your memory long after you close the last page.
** Received ARC through NetGalley. Thanks to Simon and Schuster Canada for the eArc. Voluntarily reviewed.**
I was wholly and very quickly drawn into the lives of sisters Elisabeth and Marthe as they were about to set out on a journey that was thrust upon them due to scandal and the loss of their family.
They are to embark on a treacherous journey from Normandy, France to New France; Ville-Marie (Montréal), Quebec on a bride ship. Oldest sister Elisabeth has a dark secret. She hopes that by going to the holiest place on earth she will be cured of her curse.
Soon Marthe encourages her sister to seek the aid of the Witch Jeanne Roy to help banish the spirit that reside in her.
When she is met with resistance to help cure her she cannot be reasoned with and soon makes decisions that will end badly for all involved.
This story provides the reader with so much intrigue and such beautiful story telling that you will not be able to put it down.
I was completely obsessed with this book and when I wasn't reading it I was thinking about it.
A very evocative story that will linger in your memory long after you close the last page.
** Received ARC through NetGalley. Thanks to Simon and Schuster Canada for the eArc. Voluntarily reviewed.**
February 15, 2026
I throughly enjoyed this historical fiction set in approximately 1670, about young women from Normandy France sent to New France (Montreal, Quebec) as young brides to be - to basically help grow the population. And many had been accused of witchcraft and were exiled by the King of France instead of being executed.
There’s a slow-building sense of mystery around the girls and the accusations against them that keeps you turning pages. I loved how each chapter alternated between the sisters, Elisabeth and Marthe—one fearful and feeling cursed, the other surprisingly clear-headed. The contrast made the story heartbreaking, fascinating and thought provoking.
The author does a great job showing just how young, naïve, and vulnerable these girls were. Growing up in a world full of superstition, many unable to read or write, truly believed misfortune was caused by witches or demons. Reading their perspective can be frustrating, but it really puts into perspective what it was like to be a young woman in that time—and makes their resilience even more impressive.
I truly enjoyed being taken back to this time. The author does an amazing job of showing the harsh realities of what life was like for young women back then—it felt real and raw.
A beautiful emotional read about fear, misinformation, and the strength of young women trying to survive in an unforgiving world.
There’s a slow-building sense of mystery around the girls and the accusations against them that keeps you turning pages. I loved how each chapter alternated between the sisters, Elisabeth and Marthe—one fearful and feeling cursed, the other surprisingly clear-headed. The contrast made the story heartbreaking, fascinating and thought provoking.
The author does a great job showing just how young, naïve, and vulnerable these girls were. Growing up in a world full of superstition, many unable to read or write, truly believed misfortune was caused by witches or demons. Reading their perspective can be frustrating, but it really puts into perspective what it was like to be a young woman in that time—and makes their resilience even more impressive.
I truly enjoyed being taken back to this time. The author does an amazing job of showing the harsh realities of what life was like for young women back then—it felt real and raw.
A beautiful emotional read about fear, misinformation, and the strength of young women trying to survive in an unforgiving world.
January 28, 2026
The Winter Witch is an intriguing and layered historical novel that explores superstition, belief, and power through the lives of women with painfully limited choices. Set against the backdrop of seventeenth century Quebec, the story follows sisters Élisabeth and Marthe Jossard as they board a bride ship from Normandy, hoping to escape scandal and a perceived curse by starting anew in what they have been told is the holiest place in the world.
The novel offers striking insight into the inner lives of poor, uneducated women who had no family support and little control over their futures. The pressure to be obedient, devout, and grateful is conveyed with such emotional clarity that it was impossible not to feel overwhelmed by their suffering. At times, the weight of expectation and fear brought me to tears. Yet despite the darkness, the story also holds space for hope and empowerment.
Although I initially expected more overt magic or magical realism, I was not disappointed. The strength of the novel lies in its immersive historical realism and its examination of how fear, ignorance, and gossip can spiral into dangerous accusations of witchcraft. Élisabeth’s struggle, particularly her untreated mental illness, is handled with compassion and underscores how easily vulnerable women could be labeled and condemned.
The author’s storytelling is especially impressive for a debut. The descriptions are vivid and atmospheric, from the harrowing, filthy voyage across the Atlantic to the lush but threatening wilderness of New France. The characters feel fully realized and emotionally accessible, and I grew deeply attached to these young women, many of them still teenagers, forced into marriages with unfamiliar men in a harsh land.
I did wish for more detail about daily pioneer life and a deeper exploration of the prejudice and cruelty faced by First Nations people at the hands of settlers. While this felt like a missed opportunity, the novel still succeeds in portraying the brutal realities endured by the brides themselves.
Overall, The Winter Witch is a compelling and emotionally resonant historical fiction novel that sheds light on a haunting chapter of women’s history. It is a strong and confident debut that will appeal to readers who appreciate character driven stories about resilience, injustice, and the devastating consequences of fear. Four stars.
Thank you NetGalley, Simon and Schuster, and Jennifer Chevalier for this ARC to review. All opinions are my own.
The novel offers striking insight into the inner lives of poor, uneducated women who had no family support and little control over their futures. The pressure to be obedient, devout, and grateful is conveyed with such emotional clarity that it was impossible not to feel overwhelmed by their suffering. At times, the weight of expectation and fear brought me to tears. Yet despite the darkness, the story also holds space for hope and empowerment.
Although I initially expected more overt magic or magical realism, I was not disappointed. The strength of the novel lies in its immersive historical realism and its examination of how fear, ignorance, and gossip can spiral into dangerous accusations of witchcraft. Élisabeth’s struggle, particularly her untreated mental illness, is handled with compassion and underscores how easily vulnerable women could be labeled and condemned.
The author’s storytelling is especially impressive for a debut. The descriptions are vivid and atmospheric, from the harrowing, filthy voyage across the Atlantic to the lush but threatening wilderness of New France. The characters feel fully realized and emotionally accessible, and I grew deeply attached to these young women, many of them still teenagers, forced into marriages with unfamiliar men in a harsh land.
I did wish for more detail about daily pioneer life and a deeper exploration of the prejudice and cruelty faced by First Nations people at the hands of settlers. While this felt like a missed opportunity, the novel still succeeds in portraying the brutal realities endured by the brides themselves.
Overall, The Winter Witch is a compelling and emotionally resonant historical fiction novel that sheds light on a haunting chapter of women’s history. It is a strong and confident debut that will appeal to readers who appreciate character driven stories about resilience, injustice, and the devastating consequences of fear. Four stars.
Thank you NetGalley, Simon and Schuster, and Jennifer Chevalier for this ARC to review. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I really enjoyed this read! I was very excited when I read the synopsis and was so excited to get this on NetGalley to read and review, so thank you to Simon and Schuster Canada!
I expected this to be more of a historical fantasy, but I was pleasantly surprised that, although it wasn’t, it was still fast-paced and exciting. The characters were all nuanced and had great depth, and I especially liked seeing the differences between the two sisters. Lili’s inside thoughts were so interesting and while I didn’t always like her character as much as Marthe, I still wanted to keep reading whenever we were inside her head.
I think the author did a wonderful job of setting the scene and I could so clearly imagine the setting. Truthfully, I sometimes struggle a bit with Canadian historical fiction because it can be a bit bland, but this had me hooked from the beginning.
My only real critique with this one would be the ending. It felt rushed and I wished we could have had a conclusion that had a bit more room to wrap things up. I did really enjoy the epilogue though, and it was a nice touch.
Overall, I would highly recommend this one! I gave it 4 stars and am eager to read more from the author!
I expected this to be more of a historical fantasy, but I was pleasantly surprised that, although it wasn’t, it was still fast-paced and exciting. The characters were all nuanced and had great depth, and I especially liked seeing the differences between the two sisters. Lili’s inside thoughts were so interesting and while I didn’t always like her character as much as Marthe, I still wanted to keep reading whenever we were inside her head.
I think the author did a wonderful job of setting the scene and I could so clearly imagine the setting. Truthfully, I sometimes struggle a bit with Canadian historical fiction because it can be a bit bland, but this had me hooked from the beginning.
My only real critique with this one would be the ending. It felt rushed and I wished we could have had a conclusion that had a bit more room to wrap things up. I did really enjoy the epilogue though, and it was a nice touch.
Overall, I would highly recommend this one! I gave it 4 stars and am eager to read more from the author!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews