What do you think?
Rate this book
Forged in Battle
After decades of war, the Union was starting to rebuild. But our allies betrayed us without warning, striking every ship in the system in a cowardly surprise attack. One destroyer remains—trapped far behind enemy lines, with no support and no way home.
Captain Jaxon Steele never expected his first command to throw him into the heart of a raging storm…
On a routine diplomatic mission, Steele’s ship is orbiting a war-torn planet when the entire system erupts in rebellion. Missiles smash into Ranger’s shields. Communications are jammed. Enemy warships are closing in fast…
Ranger is an advanced destroyer—fast, stealthy, and armed to the teeth—but she wasn’t built for heavy fighting and a rebel battleship would tear her to shreds. Steele will need all his trickery and tactical genius to survive the first strike.
But survival is not enough… A vast enemy fleet is lurking somewhere in the system. Only Ranger can locate it and prevent a catastrophic defeat.
Steele knows his duty… He begins a deadly game of hunter and hunted across the rebel system, knowing that any mistake will be his last. Can his leadership, daring, and resolve turn the tide of the war?
Packed with high-stakes space combat, breathtaking tension, and jaw-dropping twists, Forged in Battle is a military science fiction adventure perfect for fans of David Weber’s Honor Harrington series and James S.A. Corey’s The Expanse.
Captain Jaxon Steele never expected his first command to throw him into the heart of a raging storm…
On a routine diplomatic mission, Steele’s ship is orbiting a war-torn planet when the entire system erupts in rebellion. Missiles smash into Ranger’s shields. Communications are jammed. Enemy warships are closing in fast…
Ranger is an advanced destroyer—fast, stealthy, and armed to the teeth—but she wasn’t built for heavy fighting and a rebel battleship would tear her to shreds. Steele will need all his trickery and tactical genius to survive the first strike.
But survival is not enough… A vast enemy fleet is lurking somewhere in the system. Only Ranger can locate it and prevent a catastrophic defeat.
Steele knows his duty… He begins a deadly game of hunter and hunted across the rebel system, knowing that any mistake will be his last. Can his leadership, daring, and resolve turn the tide of the war?
Packed with high-stakes space combat, breathtaking tension, and jaw-dropping twists, Forged in Battle is a military science fiction adventure perfect for fans of David Weber’s Honor Harrington series and James S.A. Corey’s The Expanse.
- GenresScience Fiction
334 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 25, 2025
338 people are currently reading
36 people want to read
About the author
Marc Alan Edelheit
41 books849 followersBestselling author Marc Edelheit has traveled the world, from Asia to Europe, at one point crossing the border at Check Point Charlie in Berlin toward the end of the Cold War.
Marc is the ultimate history fan and incorporates much of that passion into his work to bring greater realism to his fans. He is also an avid reader, devouring several books per week, ranging from history to science fiction and fantasy.
Marc is the ultimate history fan and incorporates much of that passion into his work to bring greater realism to his fans. He is also an avid reader, devouring several books per week, ranging from history to science fiction and fantasy.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
July 16, 2025
Forged in Battle
by Marc Alan Edelheit is a spellbinding and gripping military science fiction thriller. It’s the first book in the Command Decision series and it moves at a lightning pace. Captain Jaxon Stelle is on a routine diplomatic mission on his first command. The Ranger is an advanced destroyer, fast, stealthy, and fully armed. However, she wasn’t built for heavy fighting. While orbiting the war-torn planet, Tenebris, the entire star system erupts in rebellion. Missiles hit the Ranger’s shields, communications are jammed, and enemy warships are approaching. Survival is going to be tough, and they learn they need to confirm reports of a large enemy fleet in the star system before heading for home.
Steele enjoys strategy, history, and reading. He tends to leverage that knowledge in clutch situations. Clutter is a distraction to him and waiting tests his patience. He’s also thoughtful of the well-being of his crew and ship and projects an air of calm and quiet confidence that steadies the crew during stressful times. He listens to their advice despite not always following it and expresses his appreciation for their work and he is willing to accept the consequences of his actions knowing he will have to explain them when they return home. The other main bridge characters are introduced and readers learn some of their background and how they react under pressure, but I wanted a little more depth.
The world-building is fantastic in this novel. Much of it is set on the bridge of the Ranger and it was easy to feel like I was there as events unfolded. While there are hours of waiting that the crew experiences, it didn’t feel like it as I was reading. The tension was palpable throughout the story. The plot has several twists and turns that keep readers engaged and rapidly turning the pages. The heart-pounding space combat was easy to visualize and made me grateful I wasn’t on the vessel. Themes include political tension, rebellion, war, intelligence and its failures, desire for autonomy, trust, and command decisions that affect lives.
The author added an extremely helpful appendix at the back of the book. It includes a detailed explanation of both intra-star-system and interstellar travel, as well as information on the Union of Free Stars, the Protectorate Star Systems, the Valkorian Hegemony, the Illidran Star System, and the Union naval ship Ranger.
Overall, this is a fast-paced, action-packed novel with compelling characters, fantastic world-building, exceptional action scenes, and a great plot. The novel should appeal to those who enjoy science fiction military action thrillers. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series.
--------------------------------------
My 4.23 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
Steele enjoys strategy, history, and reading. He tends to leverage that knowledge in clutch situations. Clutter is a distraction to him and waiting tests his patience. He’s also thoughtful of the well-being of his crew and ship and projects an air of calm and quiet confidence that steadies the crew during stressful times. He listens to their advice despite not always following it and expresses his appreciation for their work and he is willing to accept the consequences of his actions knowing he will have to explain them when they return home. The other main bridge characters are introduced and readers learn some of their background and how they react under pressure, but I wanted a little more depth.
The world-building is fantastic in this novel. Much of it is set on the bridge of the Ranger and it was easy to feel like I was there as events unfolded. While there are hours of waiting that the crew experiences, it didn’t feel like it as I was reading. The tension was palpable throughout the story. The plot has several twists and turns that keep readers engaged and rapidly turning the pages. The heart-pounding space combat was easy to visualize and made me grateful I wasn’t on the vessel. Themes include political tension, rebellion, war, intelligence and its failures, desire for autonomy, trust, and command decisions that affect lives.
The author added an extremely helpful appendix at the back of the book. It includes a detailed explanation of both intra-star-system and interstellar travel, as well as information on the Union of Free Stars, the Protectorate Star Systems, the Valkorian Hegemony, the Illidran Star System, and the Union naval ship Ranger.
Overall, this is a fast-paced, action-packed novel with compelling characters, fantastic world-building, exceptional action scenes, and a great plot. The novel should appeal to those who enjoy science fiction military action thrillers. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series.
--------------------------------------
My 4.23 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
May 26, 2025
Forged in Battle (Command Decision Book 1) by Marc Alan Edelheit
Under a vast darkness of space, wondrous flecks of matter settle neatly on author Marc Alan Edelheit’s canvas. The Union’s finest ship, “Ranger,” is on a routine mission within its vortex. Firmly at the helm, Jaxon Steele, our main protagonist, deftly navigates the ship and crew through safe airspace, or is it? Our story is a juggernaut of one man’s ability to make preemptive decisions under a hailstorm of duress and civil unrest.
Space opera. A fantasy haven for human readers shackled by Earth’s gravity, rendering us unable to float weightlessly among the stars. Living vicariously, our body sensors have been scanned through book consumption, and we are granted access to the Ranger's airlocks. Escorted briskly, we approach the bridge where Jaxon Steele firmly offers a cup of coffee and bids us welcome. Witnessing a firsthand look at Steel’s immensely charismatic persona, we are privy to the newest technology the Union has to offer. This war was thought to be over, but an uprising has begun, pitting the Protectorate against the Union. LDF, Local Defense Force, backed by the villainous Hegemony, is on the attack, attempting to seize control again.
A contrasting swath of colors, an indication of threats, immobilizes those without knowledge of futuristic warfare. Steele’s crew is ready; their expertise is on full display. As the plot thickens, a wave of anger washes over my visor. How should one feel after such betrayal? How could the Union politicians have allowed this upheaval? Steele looks over to my position and tells me to hold on. An asteroid field of rock and debris lies ahead. The Ranger soldiers on, highlighting its capabilities in search of the truth that the Union’s intelligence agency has provided. Our ship stealthily dodges obstacles when needed and faces predatory ships in retaliation. We must return to warn our brethren what has happened here. Steele, nerves of steel, has become our foundational rock within this jet stream of turbulence. However, none of our mission has meaning if we don’t reach our destination.
Launched weaponry assaulted my senses. My mind kept returning to old Star Trek episodes on the bridge of the USS Enterprise. The tale had a familiar tone, one I loved as a youth. The twinkling of stars made luminous by the offsetting deepness of dark black hues. We are yet but a fly on the hull, witnessing daily operations upon a ship, viewing the officers' approach to handling mayhem as it arrives. The revolutions of habitable planets offer a look at futuristic societies with the same modern-day problems. Have we learned nothing? Edelheit has given readers a pathway to a world with complex social issues and done so in a lucid manner.
As Book 1 recedes in the distance, afterburners slowly churning, I slowly open my visor. Standing firmly on soil, I understand our task. That being said, I will be reading the next installment of the series. Jaxon Steele will undoubtedly need to provide an answer for his actions, and I will be front and center to hear his words. Forged in Battle is a fabulous introduction to a space opera series for newcomers to the genre. It’s straightforward, entertaining, and certain to keep one’s attention. I am giving this 4.25 out of 5 stars, rounding down to 4 stars. Recommended!
Many thanks to Second Sky for the ARC through NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion.
Under a vast darkness of space, wondrous flecks of matter settle neatly on author Marc Alan Edelheit’s canvas. The Union’s finest ship, “Ranger,” is on a routine mission within its vortex. Firmly at the helm, Jaxon Steele, our main protagonist, deftly navigates the ship and crew through safe airspace, or is it? Our story is a juggernaut of one man’s ability to make preemptive decisions under a hailstorm of duress and civil unrest.
Space opera. A fantasy haven for human readers shackled by Earth’s gravity, rendering us unable to float weightlessly among the stars. Living vicariously, our body sensors have been scanned through book consumption, and we are granted access to the Ranger's airlocks. Escorted briskly, we approach the bridge where Jaxon Steele firmly offers a cup of coffee and bids us welcome. Witnessing a firsthand look at Steel’s immensely charismatic persona, we are privy to the newest technology the Union has to offer. This war was thought to be over, but an uprising has begun, pitting the Protectorate against the Union. LDF, Local Defense Force, backed by the villainous Hegemony, is on the attack, attempting to seize control again.
A contrasting swath of colors, an indication of threats, immobilizes those without knowledge of futuristic warfare. Steele’s crew is ready; their expertise is on full display. As the plot thickens, a wave of anger washes over my visor. How should one feel after such betrayal? How could the Union politicians have allowed this upheaval? Steele looks over to my position and tells me to hold on. An asteroid field of rock and debris lies ahead. The Ranger soldiers on, highlighting its capabilities in search of the truth that the Union’s intelligence agency has provided. Our ship stealthily dodges obstacles when needed and faces predatory ships in retaliation. We must return to warn our brethren what has happened here. Steele, nerves of steel, has become our foundational rock within this jet stream of turbulence. However, none of our mission has meaning if we don’t reach our destination.
Launched weaponry assaulted my senses. My mind kept returning to old Star Trek episodes on the bridge of the USS Enterprise. The tale had a familiar tone, one I loved as a youth. The twinkling of stars made luminous by the offsetting deepness of dark black hues. We are yet but a fly on the hull, witnessing daily operations upon a ship, viewing the officers' approach to handling mayhem as it arrives. The revolutions of habitable planets offer a look at futuristic societies with the same modern-day problems. Have we learned nothing? Edelheit has given readers a pathway to a world with complex social issues and done so in a lucid manner.
As Book 1 recedes in the distance, afterburners slowly churning, I slowly open my visor. Standing firmly on soil, I understand our task. That being said, I will be reading the next installment of the series. Jaxon Steele will undoubtedly need to provide an answer for his actions, and I will be front and center to hear his words. Forged in Battle is a fabulous introduction to a space opera series for newcomers to the genre. It’s straightforward, entertaining, and certain to keep one’s attention. I am giving this 4.25 out of 5 stars, rounding down to 4 stars. Recommended!
Many thanks to Second Sky for the ARC through NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion.
July 27, 2025
I have read and enjoyed many of Mr. Edelheit's books which put a Roman-like empire and military in a fantasy setting (and solve the mystery of the missing ninth legion). I find that I do like them better than his new scifi but that is personal taste. If you like military scifi, I recommend trying this new series. It isn't David Drake or David Weber but is still very good.
May 21, 2025
Energetic and impossible to put down Forged in Battle is military sf at its best.
The book is tense as first there is the unease that something is not quite right and then when things go bad, there is almost non stop action interspersed with careful planning for the next action so to speak. There are a few surprises and of course the required climactic battle that is foreshadowed almost from the beginning.
The novel is told mostly through the pov of Captain Steele but with well defined secondary characters - the XO, various other bridge officers, the ship doctor, the intelligence officer who instigated the original mission of the modern destroyer Ranger in the Protectorate under the guise of a run of the mill diplomatic trip as well as a few others to be discovered by the reader.
The universe of the series is interesting - there is a lot of detail in the appendix both about the Union and Protectorate, but also about the mechanics of space travel, ftl and in system, as well as about ship capabilities, armament and tactics.
The storyline ends at a very good tbc point and the next novel in the series is a huge asap.
Top 25 of the year and highly recommended mil sf of the highest class
The book is tense as first there is the unease that something is not quite right and then when things go bad, there is almost non stop action interspersed with careful planning for the next action so to speak. There are a few surprises and of course the required climactic battle that is foreshadowed almost from the beginning.
The novel is told mostly through the pov of Captain Steele but with well defined secondary characters - the XO, various other bridge officers, the ship doctor, the intelligence officer who instigated the original mission of the modern destroyer Ranger in the Protectorate under the guise of a run of the mill diplomatic trip as well as a few others to be discovered by the reader.
The universe of the series is interesting - there is a lot of detail in the appendix both about the Union and Protectorate, but also about the mechanics of space travel, ftl and in system, as well as about ship capabilities, armament and tactics.
The storyline ends at a very good tbc point and the next novel in the series is a huge asap.
Top 25 of the year and highly recommended mil sf of the highest class
July 9, 2025
ARC provided by Second Sky and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Forged in Battle is a solid military sci-fi outing that will feel familiar (in a good way) to fans of Jack Campbell's Dauntless and the Lost Fleet series. With shades of Black Jack Geary, Captain Jaxon Steele leads the charge in this first book of what looks to be a promising series.
The universe Edelheit sets up—the Union, the Protectorate, the Hegemony—is intriguing and layered, and I’m definitely interested in exploring more of it. The story moves well, and while it never left me on the edge of my seat, it was a smooth, enjoyable ride.
That said, the book does suffer from some rough edges. Repetitive euphemisms (I counted “unzip my fly” four separate times) and an overreliance on characters nodding at each other pulled me out of the story at times. The stakes also felt a bit soft—I never truly believed Steele or his crew were in danger, even when the narrative wanted me to. The return of the Starfish was predictable, and the outcome felt a little too safe.
Character-wise, Steele is a compelling lead, but I wish more attention had been given to the supporting cast—especially Chase and the bridge crew, who had the potential to add depth and color to the narrative. Everything was told from Steele’s perspective, which limited our insight into the rest of the team.
One big thing I missed was seeing the aftermath of the mission—the consequences, the debrief, the recognition from the Union. Hopefully, that’s something we’ll get in book two, because the Ranger and her crew deserve their moment.
Despite its flaws, Forged in Battle is a good book and well worth reading for fans of military sci-fi. I’ll definitely be back for more—just like the Union.
Forged in Battle is a solid military sci-fi outing that will feel familiar (in a good way) to fans of Jack Campbell's Dauntless and the Lost Fleet series. With shades of Black Jack Geary, Captain Jaxon Steele leads the charge in this first book of what looks to be a promising series.
The universe Edelheit sets up—the Union, the Protectorate, the Hegemony—is intriguing and layered, and I’m definitely interested in exploring more of it. The story moves well, and while it never left me on the edge of my seat, it was a smooth, enjoyable ride.
That said, the book does suffer from some rough edges. Repetitive euphemisms (I counted “unzip my fly” four separate times) and an overreliance on characters nodding at each other pulled me out of the story at times. The stakes also felt a bit soft—I never truly believed Steele or his crew were in danger, even when the narrative wanted me to. The return of the Starfish was predictable, and the outcome felt a little too safe.
Character-wise, Steele is a compelling lead, but I wish more attention had been given to the supporting cast—especially Chase and the bridge crew, who had the potential to add depth and color to the narrative. Everything was told from Steele’s perspective, which limited our insight into the rest of the team.
One big thing I missed was seeing the aftermath of the mission—the consequences, the debrief, the recognition from the Union. Hopefully, that’s something we’ll get in book two, because the Ranger and her crew deserve their moment.
Despite its flaws, Forged in Battle is a good book and well worth reading for fans of military sci-fi. I’ll definitely be back for more—just like the Union.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 31, 2025
Marc Alan Edelheit writes a heck of a good sci-fi novel! In Forged in Battle, we meet Captain Jaxon Steele, recently given command of the Union’s newest destroyer, Ranger. He’s not sure why his ship was tagged for what seems to be a routine diplomatic mission. But when things go horribly awry and the diplomatic mission becomes a rescue and extraction, Steele realizes this is anything but routine, and Ranger‘s presence is entirely intentional.
An intelligence agent is one of the people rescued, and just as it looks like Ranger will make it safely out of harm’s way, he informs Steele of a new mission: determine whether the Protectorate has a fleet hidden in the Exclusion Zone, a wasteland of detritus from the final battle of the previous great war. Steele and his crew must navigate a multitude of hazards and avoid detection in hopes of helping Union forces prepare for what may be coming.
This is some good, old-school-style space opera, and I am here for it. Edelheit gives us a compelling protagonist in Jaxon Steele. He’s confident in his abilities and lets his very competent crew do the work they’ve trained and prepared for, but human enough that worries and concerns still seep through occasionally. He realizes he was given command of Ranger over others who thought they were better suited to the role, and he pushes to prove himself worthy of that command, knowing that this unexpected mission will subject him to questioning when they return safely home. And he perseveres.
We get a lot of jargon with the story, but Edelheit weaves it in so deftly that it’s pretty easy to figure out from context what things are. He also gives us a handy appendix at the end of the book that provides a lot of useful information on concepts and major players in the story.
A lot of time in the story is spent waiting – waiting as they travel slowly back into the heart of the Illidran system, waiting to see the outcome of probes launched, waiting to see if enemy forces pick them up on scans and blow their cover. But the story never dragged. We were waiting with tension, with bated breath, knowing something was going to happen any minute. And so it did. This was a hard book to put down, even knowing I had to get up and work the next morning.
There are more books to come, but this particular arc wraps up neatly, so there isn’t a huge cliffhanger even though you know there’s more to the story. I appreciate that! And the next book in the series is expected out early next year, so I won’t have too long to wait to see what happens next.
If you’re a fan of hard-hitting science fiction that makes you bite your nails and stay up past bedtime reading, pick up Forged in Battle. Happy reading!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book from Second Sky Books. I didn’t have to leave a review. All opinions here are mine, and I don’t say nice things about books I don’t actually like.
An intelligence agent is one of the people rescued, and just as it looks like Ranger will make it safely out of harm’s way, he informs Steele of a new mission: determine whether the Protectorate has a fleet hidden in the Exclusion Zone, a wasteland of detritus from the final battle of the previous great war. Steele and his crew must navigate a multitude of hazards and avoid detection in hopes of helping Union forces prepare for what may be coming.
This is some good, old-school-style space opera, and I am here for it. Edelheit gives us a compelling protagonist in Jaxon Steele. He’s confident in his abilities and lets his very competent crew do the work they’ve trained and prepared for, but human enough that worries and concerns still seep through occasionally. He realizes he was given command of Ranger over others who thought they were better suited to the role, and he pushes to prove himself worthy of that command, knowing that this unexpected mission will subject him to questioning when they return safely home. And he perseveres.
We get a lot of jargon with the story, but Edelheit weaves it in so deftly that it’s pretty easy to figure out from context what things are. He also gives us a handy appendix at the end of the book that provides a lot of useful information on concepts and major players in the story.
A lot of time in the story is spent waiting – waiting as they travel slowly back into the heart of the Illidran system, waiting to see the outcome of probes launched, waiting to see if enemy forces pick them up on scans and blow their cover. But the story never dragged. We were waiting with tension, with bated breath, knowing something was going to happen any minute. And so it did. This was a hard book to put down, even knowing I had to get up and work the next morning.
There are more books to come, but this particular arc wraps up neatly, so there isn’t a huge cliffhanger even though you know there’s more to the story. I appreciate that! And the next book in the series is expected out early next year, so I won’t have too long to wait to see what happens next.
If you’re a fan of hard-hitting science fiction that makes you bite your nails and stay up past bedtime reading, pick up Forged in Battle. Happy reading!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book from Second Sky Books. I didn’t have to leave a review. All opinions here are mine, and I don’t say nice things about books I don’t actually like.
July 28, 2025
Thank you to Second Sky Books and Netgalley for the eARC for review.
Forged in Battle is the first in a new military sci-fi series, Command Decision. The man in command and weighed down with the responsibility of life or death decisions is Captain Steele who is in charge of Ranger, a Destroyer Class starship designed for battle and stealth missions.
Captain Steele and his more than capable crew including a strong female character with his second in command, Executive Officer Chase, are going to need every bit of the cutting edge technology that Ranger offers if they are going to have a hope of survival.
Steele's first command mission should be peaceful and straightforward but his diplomatic task for the Union over a war-torn planet is thrown into chaos when a rebellion erupts. The Union had been rebuilding after decades of war and have withdrawn military to such an extent that they no longer have the control of the Illidran star system that they think they do.
Ranger soon find itself outgunned, and alone in hostile planetary space with communications cut. It's no longer about quelling rebellion but trying to survive and before they can try to escape the system and warn the Union there's intel that suggests that the uprising has had help and that a deadly fleet of spaceships is hiding and waiting to strike.
The plot and action are tense and suspenseful, the pages whipping past like the missiles and maser fire from the starship.
The world building is exceptional and the military tactics and starship science feels very real (there's a detailed appendix at the back giving details about the starship, scientific data about space travel, information about the star systems, etc).
Steele, despite all the clenching and rubbing of his jaw, is a more nuanced character than first appears and it's his interest in reading history and strategy that helps him come up with unconventional ideas that may just keep them alive. We all knew reading books was the best thing right?
If you like science fiction shows and books such as Star Trek and The Expanse then this is for you. And if you like thrillers with plot twists then this is one set in space and worthy of your time.
A strong and exciting start to a new series with a dramatic conclusion that also leaves things wide open for the next instalment.
Forged in Battle is the first in a new military sci-fi series, Command Decision. The man in command and weighed down with the responsibility of life or death decisions is Captain Steele who is in charge of Ranger, a Destroyer Class starship designed for battle and stealth missions.
Captain Steele and his more than capable crew including a strong female character with his second in command, Executive Officer Chase, are going to need every bit of the cutting edge technology that Ranger offers if they are going to have a hope of survival.
Steele's first command mission should be peaceful and straightforward but his diplomatic task for the Union over a war-torn planet is thrown into chaos when a rebellion erupts. The Union had been rebuilding after decades of war and have withdrawn military to such an extent that they no longer have the control of the Illidran star system that they think they do.
Ranger soon find itself outgunned, and alone in hostile planetary space with communications cut. It's no longer about quelling rebellion but trying to survive and before they can try to escape the system and warn the Union there's intel that suggests that the uprising has had help and that a deadly fleet of spaceships is hiding and waiting to strike.
The plot and action are tense and suspenseful, the pages whipping past like the missiles and maser fire from the starship.
The world building is exceptional and the military tactics and starship science feels very real (there's a detailed appendix at the back giving details about the starship, scientific data about space travel, information about the star systems, etc).
Steele, despite all the clenching and rubbing of his jaw, is a more nuanced character than first appears and it's his interest in reading history and strategy that helps him come up with unconventional ideas that may just keep them alive. We all knew reading books was the best thing right?
If you like science fiction shows and books such as Star Trek and The Expanse then this is for you. And if you like thrillers with plot twists then this is one set in space and worthy of your time.
A strong and exciting start to a new series with a dramatic conclusion that also leaves things wide open for the next instalment.
June 8, 2025
It felt as if I was reading a Star Trek novel (I love Star Trek) with the tension, the (military) decisions, the stakes, the battles and the outwitting the enemy. I could fully visualise the bridge and the officers working in their areas of expertise, and I love the diversity in characters. The main character was interesting, but nothing very special, but I did really like reading more about the side characters like the XO and the doctor.
The book starts of quickly with action and when I thought we'd hit a lull in the story, it started picking back up and I spent the rest of the story on the edge of my seat waiting for that inevitable climactic battle, which did not let me down at all! The battles are really well written and explained, so I could follow along easily. I did feel that Captain Steele explains decisions to his crew, that he wouldn't actually have to explain, but was mostly done for our benefit. I do appreciate being in the loop as a reader, but I don't think this amazing crew would have some basic space military decisions explained to them.
The worldbuilding was decent, but for me it wasn't very clear on why the Hegemony is só bad that their planets have to be conquered back by the Union (maybe also because I just felt a strong connection to Star Trek and conquering worlds is quite out of character for Star Trek). We are informed that the Hegemony killed an entire planet (objectively really really bad, not denying that), but if these rebellious planets rather have them, why try to conquer them back, again? Why go through the trouble of securing planets that rather have the Hegemony as a ruler (yes, even if they're 'bad neighbours').
This was my first real military sci-fi and I am very excited to continue this series!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!
The book starts of quickly with action and when I thought we'd hit a lull in the story, it started picking back up and I spent the rest of the story on the edge of my seat waiting for that inevitable climactic battle, which did not let me down at all! The battles are really well written and explained, so I could follow along easily. I did feel that Captain Steele explains decisions to his crew, that he wouldn't actually have to explain, but was mostly done for our benefit. I do appreciate being in the loop as a reader, but I don't think this amazing crew would have some basic space military decisions explained to them.
The worldbuilding was decent, but for me it wasn't very clear on why the Hegemony is só bad that their planets have to be conquered back by the Union (maybe also because I just felt a strong connection to Star Trek and conquering worlds is quite out of character for Star Trek). We are informed that the Hegemony killed an entire planet (objectively really really bad, not denying that), but if these rebellious planets rather have them, why try to conquer them back, again? Why go through the trouble of securing planets that rather have the Hegemony as a ruler (yes, even if they're 'bad neighbours').
This was my first real military sci-fi and I am very excited to continue this series!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!
July 12, 2025
I don’t read a huge amount of military science fiction (though I have read some!) and I think this book is up there for me with the Lost Fleet and the Honor Harrington books in how it manages to describe military combat between space ships, adding in all those small details that give it a sense of grounded reality. The ships needing time to maneuver, engines needing to get up to speed, and shields and weapon systems — how nothing is instant, everything takes time, and every action taken, every blow endured, every blow landed against the ship adds to the wear and tear.
And the waiting. The author uses the waiting very well to stretch out the tension, never overusing it to slow down the pace. And honestly, the pacing is the best part for me. The story moves along from point to point without any lethargic or meandering passages; the stakes are explained early on and then made worse through subsequent discoveries.
The writing is competent, and many scenes feel like they’ve been framed in a very cinematic way, heavy on the action and tense conversations over screens. The characters, though, are mostly … there. Honestly, even Steele, the main character, didn’t really have much personality for me beyond “authority figure”. Still, if you’re looking for clever military science fiction, I do recommend this book. It’s a fun, quick read, and the first book in a series.
Thank you so much to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC.
And the waiting. The author uses the waiting very well to stretch out the tension, never overusing it to slow down the pace. And honestly, the pacing is the best part for me. The story moves along from point to point without any lethargic or meandering passages; the stakes are explained early on and then made worse through subsequent discoveries.
The writing is competent, and many scenes feel like they’ve been framed in a very cinematic way, heavy on the action and tense conversations over screens. The characters, though, are mostly … there. Honestly, even Steele, the main character, didn’t really have much personality for me beyond “authority figure”. Still, if you’re looking for clever military science fiction, I do recommend this book. It’s a fun, quick read, and the first book in a series.
Thank you so much to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC.
July 30, 2025
Looking for a page turner? Look no further, I've got you covered! Recently I have read Forged in Battle, Marc Alan Edelheit's latest science fiction novel. It is the first of a new series, called Command Decision. I was hooked immediately, right from the first page.
Forged in Battle is set mostly inside of a spaceship, Ranger. Captain Steele seems to be out for some routine work, but things fall apart very rapidly, when suddenly the space station he is at starts firing at Ranger. And it's not only that, but apparently a rebellion is on the rise. Suddenly Steele finds himself surrounded by war ships and is forced to use every trick up his sleeve to keep himself and his crew alive.
Fighting off the enemy, he tries to escape, but then suddenly learns that his duty lies elsewhere. He is not supposed to leave the enemy's system, he's supposed to trick them into thinking Ranger has left. A ship like Ranger was built especially for this purpose: stealth. His mission is to find out more about this rebellion and the enemy fleet it might be hiding and at the same time keep his crew alive.
Believe me when I say that Edelheit kept me turning pages until the end. The very definition of a page turner!
Forged in Battle contains a lot of technical details. I do not have a clue when it comes to science, so do not ask me if these things were correct. I found them credible while reading. After finishing the novel, I noticed there's a whole section explaining all the technical details with impressive math, which I also do not know anything about. But if you like hard science fiction I guess this part will be heaven to you!
I really liked that all characters in this novel had some depth. It's easy to forget about these details, when there's a war going on and the pace of the novel is very high. All characters were incredibly 'human'. They were all definitely not prepared for battle, showed fear from time to time, but were also highly trained. They reacted and functioned like I expect a team of human beings to do. Edelheit did not turn his characters in some sort of godlike heroes. I like that!
I had never before read anything by Edelheit, so I was surprised to see the long list of sci-fi and fantasy novels he has written. Apparently he is not that known in the Netherlands? Studying his web page I learn that Edelheit has a Bachelor's degree in Science and a Master's degree in Education and Administration. He has written several successful book series. I, for one, am looking forward to the second book in the Command Decision series!
Forged in Battle is set mostly inside of a spaceship, Ranger. Captain Steele seems to be out for some routine work, but things fall apart very rapidly, when suddenly the space station he is at starts firing at Ranger. And it's not only that, but apparently a rebellion is on the rise. Suddenly Steele finds himself surrounded by war ships and is forced to use every trick up his sleeve to keep himself and his crew alive.
Fighting off the enemy, he tries to escape, but then suddenly learns that his duty lies elsewhere. He is not supposed to leave the enemy's system, he's supposed to trick them into thinking Ranger has left. A ship like Ranger was built especially for this purpose: stealth. His mission is to find out more about this rebellion and the enemy fleet it might be hiding and at the same time keep his crew alive.
Believe me when I say that Edelheit kept me turning pages until the end. The very definition of a page turner!
Forged in Battle contains a lot of technical details. I do not have a clue when it comes to science, so do not ask me if these things were correct. I found them credible while reading. After finishing the novel, I noticed there's a whole section explaining all the technical details with impressive math, which I also do not know anything about. But if you like hard science fiction I guess this part will be heaven to you!
I really liked that all characters in this novel had some depth. It's easy to forget about these details, when there's a war going on and the pace of the novel is very high. All characters were incredibly 'human'. They were all definitely not prepared for battle, showed fear from time to time, but were also highly trained. They reacted and functioned like I expect a team of human beings to do. Edelheit did not turn his characters in some sort of godlike heroes. I like that!
I had never before read anything by Edelheit, so I was surprised to see the long list of sci-fi and fantasy novels he has written. Apparently he is not that known in the Netherlands? Studying his web page I learn that Edelheit has a Bachelor's degree in Science and a Master's degree in Education and Administration. He has written several successful book series. I, for one, am looking forward to the second book in the Command Decision series!
June 21, 2025
A very intriguing first installment in the series - very excited to see where the story goes next. This book reads very similarly to Halo game adaptation novels, and as a fan of those this was enjoyable, fast-paced, and suspenseful as an introduction to the world of the Union, the Valkorian Hegemony, and the Protectorate.
The second and third acts shone, with the second really hooking me into the story as the protagonist, Captain Jaxon Steele, attempts to uncover the truth of the situation occurring in front of his eyes. The third act was a masterful conglomeration of military strategy, reveals, and overall suspense - the style of the combat sequences reminded me not only of the Halo novels, but also of the Expanse novels, with its detail to the physical realities of space and engineering/defense components of the spacecrafts engaged.
Personally, I think the book would have benefited from a bit more character work, as the reader spends a lot of time inside Captain Steele's head, and is shown the depth of the bonds he's developed with his crew, but we don't know a lot of details outside of that. However, I am excited to see if we get more of that kind of development in the next installments of the series.
I was thoroughly impressed with this as a series opener, and I eagerly await the second installment.
-Thank you to the publisher for providing me an ARC of this book.-
The second and third acts shone, with the second really hooking me into the story as the protagonist, Captain Jaxon Steele, attempts to uncover the truth of the situation occurring in front of his eyes. The third act was a masterful conglomeration of military strategy, reveals, and overall suspense - the style of the combat sequences reminded me not only of the Halo novels, but also of the Expanse novels, with its detail to the physical realities of space and engineering/defense components of the spacecrafts engaged.
Personally, I think the book would have benefited from a bit more character work, as the reader spends a lot of time inside Captain Steele's head, and is shown the depth of the bonds he's developed with his crew, but we don't know a lot of details outside of that. However, I am excited to see if we get more of that kind of development in the next installments of the series.
I was thoroughly impressed with this as a series opener, and I eagerly await the second installment.
-Thank you to the publisher for providing me an ARC of this book.-
July 26, 2025
Captain Jaxon Steele's first command is thrown into turmoil when the Union's allies betray them. His ship is built for stealth and not heavy battle. To survive the first strike, he'll need his wits, but the survival of the Union requires him to find the enemies lurking and waiting to destroy his ship.
We get a rapid infodump via background paragraphs and conversations, giving information on the bridge crew and the major players in space governments. It's essentially the Union vs the Hegemony, and a buffer zone with planets too harsh to survive without resources. The Protectorate declares independence from the Union at the end of chapter three, which then picks up the action in the story. There are efforts to save civilians and escape from the incoming attacks. The novel is full of these details and action, with tension escalating further after brief lulls.
The story is exactly what the title promises. There are battles, heavy sci-fi terms, and high stakes. I don't feel very connected to the characters as we move from one disaster to another. It's very heavy on tech and action, and quiet moments show characters in different lights. This will appeal to hard sci-fi fans who love space battles and technology.
We get a rapid infodump via background paragraphs and conversations, giving information on the bridge crew and the major players in space governments. It's essentially the Union vs the Hegemony, and a buffer zone with planets too harsh to survive without resources. The Protectorate declares independence from the Union at the end of chapter three, which then picks up the action in the story. There are efforts to save civilians and escape from the incoming attacks. The novel is full of these details and action, with tension escalating further after brief lulls.
The story is exactly what the title promises. There are battles, heavy sci-fi terms, and high stakes. I don't feel very connected to the characters as we move from one disaster to another. It's very heavy on tech and action, and quiet moments show characters in different lights. This will appeal to hard sci-fi fans who love space battles and technology.
July 27, 2025
Thank you to Second Sky and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was a fast-paced gripping sci-fi, following Captain Steele who is in his first command and finds he quickly gets thrown in the deep end.
The book is very plot driven and it was easy to get drawn into the game of cat and mouse as the story unfolded.
I also liked that at the end of the book there was a breakdown of the science of how these spaceships travel at such high speeds. As someone who is not at all scientific it was very helpful to me, and I appreciated that the author had really thought through how it would all work and explained it in an accessible way.
An enjoyable read that kept me interested.
This was a fast-paced gripping sci-fi, following Captain Steele who is in his first command and finds he quickly gets thrown in the deep end.
The book is very plot driven and it was easy to get drawn into the game of cat and mouse as the story unfolded.
I also liked that at the end of the book there was a breakdown of the science of how these spaceships travel at such high speeds. As someone who is not at all scientific it was very helpful to me, and I appreciated that the author had really thought through how it would all work and explained it in an accessible way.
An enjoyable read that kept me interested.
July 26, 2025
In a small “backwater” system in the buffer zone between two adversarial star nations, Captain Jaxon Steele and the crew of the destroyer Ranger find themselves in the middle of it all when things go pear shaped. I thought this book seemed shorter than it really is, because after the “hook” is set, I had to read it to the end with no breaks (if you know, you know). There is a palpable tension as Ranger has to sneak around enemy space gathering intel, then attempts to make a run for friendly territory.
Elements of the story remind me a little of Das Boot and a little of Enemy Below. Rest assured, if you are a fan of Military SciFi, you should feel quite at home aboard the Ranger.
Elements of the story remind me a little of Das Boot and a little of Enemy Below. Rest assured, if you are a fan of Military SciFi, you should feel quite at home aboard the Ranger.
July 27, 2025
Marc Alan Edelheit has done it again!!
Marc is a great storyteller of military intrigue. In his newest space adventure he chronicles the maiden mission of the Unions newest Starship Ranger, and her newly appointed Captain Jason Steele. Captain Steele finds himself in the middle of military coup, but he must make a Command Decision that will put his crew in harm's way that just might save the Unions fleet. For those of us that were raised on WWII movies Marc captures this new age submarine type of thriller. Fast paced and action packed from start to finish. Outstanding read!!!
Marc is a great storyteller of military intrigue. In his newest space adventure he chronicles the maiden mission of the Unions newest Starship Ranger, and her newly appointed Captain Jason Steele. Captain Steele finds himself in the middle of military coup, but he must make a Command Decision that will put his crew in harm's way that just might save the Unions fleet. For those of us that were raised on WWII movies Marc captures this new age submarine type of thriller. Fast paced and action packed from start to finish. Outstanding read!!!
August 4, 2025
Forged in Battle by Marc Alan Edelheit.
Command decision book 1.
I did love the cover. That's why I signed up. Although a slow starter, i did eventually enjoy this book. I liked the writing style and the story. I read this book in two sittings. This is a new author for me. I loved the world building. I felt like I was there, especially on the bridge in the Ranger. I'm looking forward to the next book in this series. I do recommend this book
Command decision book 1.
I did love the cover. That's why I signed up. Although a slow starter, i did eventually enjoy this book. I liked the writing style and the story. I read this book in two sittings. This is a new author for me. I loved the world building. I felt like I was there, especially on the bridge in the Ranger. I'm looking forward to the next book in this series. I do recommend this book
July 26, 2025
Action packed, great book.
As usual, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Anything written by Marc is joy to read. There was a lot of action and tension throughout the book. Captain Steele takes everything into account before making a decision on how to proceed. If you like sci-fi, you will love this one.
As usual, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Anything written by Marc is joy to read. There was a lot of action and tension throughout the book. Captain Steele takes everything into account before making a decision on how to proceed. If you like sci-fi, you will love this one.
July 29, 2025
Slow and plodding
I have read every one of Marc's books and enjoyed them all. However, this book was slow and just plodded along. It's obvious that he did little research in any kind of naval terminology or procedures which is sad since there are plenty of Naval Vets out there, myself included that would have been happy to contribute.
I have read every one of Marc's books and enjoyed them all. However, this book was slow and just plodded along. It's obvious that he did little research in any kind of naval terminology or procedures which is sad since there are plenty of Naval Vets out there, myself included that would have been happy to contribute.
July 30, 2025
It's okay
Nowhere as good as I had expected from one of my favorite authors. The story was the same as 100 others, lone ship has to save the day. Characters were OK but not great. Then the maneuvering propellant, just making up a problem to try to be more exciting. After all the hype, disappointing.
Nowhere as good as I had expected from one of my favorite authors. The story was the same as 100 others, lone ship has to save the day. Characters were OK but not great. Then the maneuvering propellant, just making up a problem to try to be more exciting. After all the hype, disappointing.
September 2, 2025
Excellent Story of Space Warfare
Great action and well thought out technical details. Thought author had made the basic mistake of acceleration vs velocity but he explains his approach in the afterwords. Good character development. Looking forward to next book in series and already preordered it!
Great action and well thought out technical details. Thought author had made the basic mistake of acceleration vs velocity but he explains his approach in the afterwords. Good character development. Looking forward to next book in series and already preordered it!
July 29, 2025
Forged in Battle
Excellent book! Marc Alan Edelheit ranks in my top favorite authors, along with David Weber, David Drake, Elizabeth Moon, Nathan Lowell, Robert Heinlein, and Lois McMaster Bujold.
Excellent book! Marc Alan Edelheit ranks in my top favorite authors, along with David Weber, David Drake, Elizabeth Moon, Nathan Lowell, Robert Heinlein, and Lois McMaster Bujold.
August 3, 2025
Fast paced intro to this series
Great read from the first page. Rich characters and evolving storyline. Action & suspense. Well done MAE! A other great series from your prodigious mind.
Great read from the first page. Rich characters and evolving storyline. Action & suspense. Well done MAE! A other great series from your prodigious mind.
July 28, 2025
Brilliant
Once.again Marc delivers, what a book to start a series Steele is on a one way mission like a wrecking ball roaming deep space
Once.again Marc delivers, what a book to start a series Steele is on a one way mission like a wrecking ball roaming deep space
July 31, 2025
new series from a favorite author
Not really a new concept in the sci fi world. First real foray by this author into a real sci-fi genre. Lots of action and a fun story.
Not really a new concept in the sci fi world. First real foray by this author into a real sci-fi genre. Lots of action and a fun story.
August 2, 2025
Awesome book !
As always Mr. Edelheit has written an excellent book. Great story and characters. Well developed story line can't wait for the next installment
As always Mr. Edelheit has written an excellent book. Great story and characters. Well developed story line can't wait for the next installment
August 3, 2025
Pure Gold
Marc is one of the best authors I have come across in recent memory. Every book he has written I have considered 5 stars. I hope he writes more and faster!
Marc is one of the best authors I have come across in recent memory. Every book he has written I have considered 5 stars. I hope he writes more and faster!
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews