3.0 out of 5 stars
Plateaus Halfway Through -- Downhill from There
August 3, 2007
This is the sequel to Giller's "Hammerjack." I was fairly impressed with that book and had high hopes for this one. As I read through it, it looked like my hopes were being met. Then I got to about the middle of the book. Up until then, the book had been moving along very similarly to "Hammerjack." Actually, it was a bit better. The characterizations were more consistent than in the earlier work. But, suddenly, the characters on the space ship (the second locale in the book) start doing the SciFi equivalent of splitting up and walking backwards in the dark in a horror movie. From that point on, the characters seem to have a lot of "dumb" moments. I also kept noticing inconsistencies in the settings. For instance, on page 295, one character has to climb a cliff after exiting from her ship:
"Dangling there, she looked back down in time to see even bigger fragments plunging into the water -- a drop far enough to dash her to pieces if she fell."
Giller makes a big production of her climbing that cliff -- implying it's a long way up. Yet, on the way back, she jumps down to the ship.
Worst of all, there's an awful lot of scientific ignorance on display. Some of the worst is on page 346 where a character is approaching Earth (from beyond the Moon's orbit) in a space ship:
"He stomped on the rudder pedals, banking left and right as Ghostrider lurched from side to side, bouncing him around violently. Nathan's attention darted between his instruments and the horizon.... Nathan punched it -- opening the engines wide, gradually taking control of his roll and pitch. The altitude indicators on his panel slowly leveled out, the gravity spiral releasing him from its grip. Nathan relaxed as he became weightless...."
This is a ship in space. Yet, Giller has it banking, rolling, and pitching with an horizon nearby. Also, what altitude and why is it leveling out? It's in space. It's also under acceleration. Yet, he's weightless. And, that acceleration brings up another problem. Earlier, these ships are spotted beyond the moon's orbit. Giller mentions that they will take 90 minutes to get to Earth. He also mentions that Nathan's ship breaks away and will get to Earth in 6 minutes. With my handy-dandy calculator, I figure that means he accelerated that ship at (at least) 565Gs with no ill affects. They have artificial gravity in the main ship, but there's no mention of it in this ship and the prose indicates it's not available. Plus, they seem to have some kind of FTL drive, but there's no mention of extra-solar travel. Plus plus, if they have artificial gravity, why are they using reaction jets? Plus plus plus, Nathan hasn't flown anything before. Yet, here he is flying a space-going, and atmospheric-capable, plane manually.
These kinds of things continue all the way through to the end. In fact, on the very last page, Giller drops a huge implausibility as a means of tying some stuff up. By this point, the book has degenerated into pulp fiction status. If the whole book had been this way, I would have given it a mere 2 stars out of 5. But, since the first half is very good, I'm raising my rating to an OK 3 stars out of 5. It's an interesting, action-packed, easy read. Just don't expect too much out of it.