What do you think?
Rate this book
Loveless Brothers #4
The Hookup Equation: A Professor / Student Romance
Thalia Lopez always follows the rules. Being a life-long good girl has its she’s got a full scholarship to college and her choice of graduate programs, and she never has to worry about getting into trouble. It also means she’s a twenty-two-year-old virgin, but it’s not like that matters.
Of course, the one time she steps out of line, she winds up locked in a bar bathroom. The men’s bathroom. With a total stranger.
When Caleb Loveless entered the men’s room, he wasn’t expecting to have to leave through the window. He really wasn’t expecting to be doing it with one of the prettiest girls he’s ever met. And when he asks her out on an impromptu date and she says yes? It’s the best night he can remember, with the best kiss at the end. Of course he can’t wait to see her again, and the sooner the better.
They exchange numbers. They make plans. They see each other the next morning, in Calculus 101. Turns out that Caleb is Professor Loveless, which makes college senior Thalia extremely off-limits. But Thalia can’t forget the way that one heated kiss felt. And Caleb can’t pretend he’s not letting his fingers linger just a second too long when she turns in her homework. What’s a girl to do when the one person she wants is the one she can’t have?
The Hookup Equation is the fourth book in the Loveless Brothers series, and can be listened to as a total standalone. It's for fans of high-heat, low-angst romantic comedies and anyone who's ever been hot for teacher. This one's got tons of forbidden steam, a high-stakes secret relationship, sibling banter, a heroine who really enjoys her first time, and a college setting that will make you feel like you're back on campus. There's an HEA, of course. (And yes, it bangs).
Of course, the one time she steps out of line, she winds up locked in a bar bathroom. The men’s bathroom. With a total stranger.
When Caleb Loveless entered the men’s room, he wasn’t expecting to have to leave through the window. He really wasn’t expecting to be doing it with one of the prettiest girls he’s ever met. And when he asks her out on an impromptu date and she says yes? It’s the best night he can remember, with the best kiss at the end. Of course he can’t wait to see her again, and the sooner the better.
They exchange numbers. They make plans. They see each other the next morning, in Calculus 101. Turns out that Caleb is Professor Loveless, which makes college senior Thalia extremely off-limits. But Thalia can’t forget the way that one heated kiss felt. And Caleb can’t pretend he’s not letting his fingers linger just a second too long when she turns in her homework. What’s a girl to do when the one person she wants is the one she can’t have?
The Hookup Equation is the fourth book in the Loveless Brothers series, and can be listened to as a total standalone. It's for fans of high-heat, low-angst romantic comedies and anyone who's ever been hot for teacher. This one's got tons of forbidden steam, a high-stakes secret relationship, sibling banter, a heroine who really enjoys her first time, and a college setting that will make you feel like you're back on campus. There's an HEA, of course. (And yes, it bangs).
Audible Audio
First published February 26, 2020
1946 people are currently reading
7976 people want to read
About the author
Roxie Noir
44 books3,509 followersRoxie is a romance author by day, and also a romance author by night. She lives in Los Angeles with one husband, two cats, far too many books, and a truly alarming pile of used notebooks that she refuses to throw away.
She's the author of the Loveless Brothers series, the upcoming Wildwood Society series, and a bunch of other books that are also delightful.
If you need updates or free stories, you can sign up for her newsletter: http://roxienoir.com/newsletter
She's the author of the Loveless Brothers series, the upcoming Wildwood Society series, and a bunch of other books that are also delightful.
If you need updates or free stories, you can sign up for her newsletter: http://roxienoir.com/newsletter
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 789 reviews
June 5, 2021
“I want to be next to you too,” she says, simply. “That’s all. This is once-in-a-lifetime, and I know it, and you know it, and I don’t want it to be me and you. I want it to be us. Always.”
“Always,” I echo. “Whatever we face, we face together.”
Have I mentioned that I hate student-teacher romances? I don’t even have a shelf dedicated for them because I honestly can’t stand them (you have 3 guesses why) BUUUUUT I was not about to skip Caleb's book... hence why you’re seeing this review. At this point I’m convinced Roxie Noir can do no wrong. If you guys aren’t up to speed yet, basically each of her books follows a distinct trope but what makes them so damn good, is her ability to weave it into something more.
♡ Plot: ♡
After a disastrous and somewhat funny meet-cute in a public restroom, Thalia Lopez (22) and Caleb Loveless (28) develop and instant connection. They go on dates and things are perfect until the first day of the semester rolls around, when they see each other from across the classroom. It turns out Caleb is an Assistant Professor and Thalia is his student…
♡ Characters ♡
Thalia was the perfect amount of sassy and sweet. She’s also extremely dorky and bad at flirting. I really liked her because she had a lot of heart. And as everyone else has pointed out, she’s the first POC character of the series (which is just plain sad if you ask me, but let’s not go there…).
“And I like that being with you feels like the solution to a problem I didn’t know I had,” I say, “You’re strangely like coming home, Thalia. Truth is, I just like you.”
Caleb is the youngest of the Loveless brothers and he was such sweetheart! For some reason, he kind of reminded me of a golden retriever. He could be very one track minded and incredibly stubborn. When he wanted something he would stop at nothing to get it. I loved that he didn’t play games and I think he's probably the most straightforward of the Loveless brothers.
Again, I know I’ve said this in every review so far, but I LOVE THE LOVELESS FAMILY. I FREAKING ADORE EACH AND EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM. I love their whole dynamic SO SO MUCH. It was hard not to feel a sense of nostalgia seeing previous characters return. Some have gotten married, and some have started their own families. And Rusty is nine years old in this book! My heart! I’m sorry, but I’m not okay with that.
♡ The Romance ♡
I still don’t believe in magic. But this, I know, is magical.
In the beginning I did feel like their relationship was mainly just lust. It felt too physical and shallow for my liking but over the course of the book, the author really developed the emotional/mental/intellectual bond they had. And the connection between Thalia and Caleb became effortless and natural, and it became clear that they were soulmates.
I can’t help myself. I never could, not with her, and now I want to fall not this girl, drown in her and never come up for air.
You’d think this book would be angstier given the nature of their relationship, but it really wasn’t. For the most part, Caleb and Thalia had a relatively low-drama type of relationship. There was no back and forth we should – we shouldn’t – we should debate which was rather refreshing.
Also, I can’t get over how SWEET Caleb was when they got intimate with each other. Especially with Thalia being a virgin... it was just really cute!
♡ Other thoughts ♡
Like I said, I’m not a fan of student-teacher romances but Thalia was in her senior year of college and with the age gap being so small, it just wasn’t really that big of a deal. At the end of the day, Thalia and Caleb were two consenting adults. Both incredibly intelligent and mature. I really appreciated that the author took some time to explore the power dynamics between the two and the morality of their situation.
I also really appreciated the fact that there were many characters (including family and friends) that were actually against the relationship. Thalia’s friend, Margaret, for example was incredibly annoying but she had many valid points and as a friend, she was rightfully concerned. I feel like this is something we don't often see in student-teacher romances. I also think the author handled the trope well because she was able to portray and articulate nuances poignantly.
Overall, The Hookup Equation was another great read! It’s sad to think that this series is coming to an end, I’m not willing to part ways yet! WHY ARE THERE ONLY 5 BROTHERS??
Rating: 4/5
***********************************************
The Loveless familyyyyy 😭💖💖💖 rtc
February 23, 2020
What a fun read, filled with a bit of angst, humor that had me grinning throughout the whole thing, and plenty of smexy times.
Talk about your meet-cute!!! This one surely wins the title. The fact that it doesn’t just end there until they meet again, or that it’s a one night stand etc, but that it’s the beginning of something with a foundation was refreshing. This couple instantly make an emotional connection as they share the same quirky sense of humor and, gasp, go on an actual date! I loved it!
Thalia was always the good Catholic girl and the fact that her horizons are expanded (thank you Caleb) she never really loses that characteristic. With humor and wit, she kept Caleb on his toes even if there were times her jokes fell a little flat. I really enjoyed getting to know her, as well as the burden she carried on her shoulders.
Caleb was perfect for Thalia, well except for the fact it ends up being taboo that he’s with her. Their banter was so much fun and it only made him fall even more for her. I really respected him and the way he lived his life. He’s not an overly possessive hero, but he has a few minutes of jealousy here and there.
I found this couple to be mostly fun, very hot, and wonderful when it came to friends and family. While the shadow of angst follows throughout most of this story, it isn’t until near the end that it lands pretty hard. With a longer length, this really gave me a chance to get to know these characters individually and as a couple and I loved them both.
The secondary characters helped add charm and I found myself smiling more times than not. This really highlights relationships with both friends and family. These relationships are not always perfect but they always felt authentic.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I can’t wait to find out what Silas is up to!
Dual POV
Safe
Triggers
Talk about your meet-cute!!! This one surely wins the title. The fact that it doesn’t just end there until they meet again, or that it’s a one night stand etc, but that it’s the beginning of something with a foundation was refreshing. This couple instantly make an emotional connection as they share the same quirky sense of humor and, gasp, go on an actual date! I loved it!
Thalia was always the good Catholic girl and the fact that her horizons are expanded (thank you Caleb) she never really loses that characteristic. With humor and wit, she kept Caleb on his toes even if there were times her jokes fell a little flat. I really enjoyed getting to know her, as well as the burden she carried on her shoulders.
Caleb was perfect for Thalia, well except for the fact it ends up being taboo that he’s with her. Their banter was so much fun and it only made him fall even more for her. I really respected him and the way he lived his life. He’s not an overly possessive hero, but he has a few minutes of jealousy here and there.
I found this couple to be mostly fun, very hot, and wonderful when it came to friends and family. While the shadow of angst follows throughout most of this story, it isn’t until near the end that it lands pretty hard. With a longer length, this really gave me a chance to get to know these characters individually and as a couple and I loved them both.
The secondary characters helped add charm and I found myself smiling more times than not. This really highlights relationships with both friends and family. These relationships are not always perfect but they always felt authentic.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I can’t wait to find out what Silas is up to!
Dual POV
Safe
Triggers
November 16, 2020
Favorite Quotes:
I’m a total lightweight, and it only takes a couple of drinks before I’m that embarrassing girl who’s vomiting in someone’s bushes while sobbing that squirrels are too precious for this world.
Every single time I find a guy attractive or interesting, I wind up sticking my foot in my mouth so hard I leave teeth marks on my knee.
You know, once upon a time I thought that if I kept the five of you alive until you hit eighteen I’d be done with parenting? I was an idiot.
Some people believe sharing your secrets cleanses the heart and mends the soul… I think that white lies are the only thing standing between polite society and utter barbarism.
My Review:
Roxie Noir is a recent find for me and I enjoy indulging in her special brand of irreverent humor and super-steamy delights. In both of her books I’ve read so far, she has also provided several entertaining and unpredictable storylines populated with uniquely endearing and oddly appealing characters and armed them with clever banter, profound insightfulness, and compelling issues. I started in the middle but have definitely been grooving on this series while kicking myself for being late to the party. I have some catching up to do.
I’m a total lightweight, and it only takes a couple of drinks before I’m that embarrassing girl who’s vomiting in someone’s bushes while sobbing that squirrels are too precious for this world.
Every single time I find a guy attractive or interesting, I wind up sticking my foot in my mouth so hard I leave teeth marks on my knee.
You know, once upon a time I thought that if I kept the five of you alive until you hit eighteen I’d be done with parenting? I was an idiot.
Some people believe sharing your secrets cleanses the heart and mends the soul… I think that white lies are the only thing standing between polite society and utter barbarism.
My Review:
Roxie Noir is a recent find for me and I enjoy indulging in her special brand of irreverent humor and super-steamy delights. In both of her books I’ve read so far, she has also provided several entertaining and unpredictable storylines populated with uniquely endearing and oddly appealing characters and armed them with clever banter, profound insightfulness, and compelling issues. I started in the middle but have definitely been grooving on this series while kicking myself for being late to the party. I have some catching up to do.
November 13, 2023
I don't tend to seek out forbidden romances for the sake of the forbidden element, but I've enjoyed the Loveless Brothers books I've read and I wanted to see how she'd tackle the student/teacher trope. I thought this captured the angst very well of finding your person and then realizing that your person shouldn't be yours for an ethical/moral reason. Then what do you do when you can't stay away from said person? Caleb (H) and Thalia (h) meet in a bar bathroom, in a unique meet-cute, and then go on to have a unique first date with all the sparks and magic and sexual chemistry. Then the next day, Caleb begins his first semester teaching math at the local college and sees Thalia in his class...which means they're not getting that second date they'd already planned.
The angst was at times lighter and others heavier. In addition to fighting their attraction and the moral dilemma of dating your professor/student, Thalia is also going through challenging family times, which Caleb steps up to support her with. I appreciated that when Caleb and Thalia gave in and pursued a relationship in earnest, they did so with their eyes wide open and acknowledging the issues inherent within their choices. The romance itself is sweet and fun, Caleb is a wonderful book boyfriend (he's not a pervy old man taking advantage of a student) and Thalia was awkwardly adorable and resilient (she in turn is not being taken advantage of). Written in first person, dual POV. No ow/om drama, H not a virgin (and not a manho) and h was a virgin.
I liked Caleb and Thalia together. He had a more relaxed feel to his character and she felt more mature. And oh the tension and chemistry between them was fire. Even though the steamy factor plays a big role (once they start getting down to it), the emotional intimacy, the vulnerabilities, and the connection were all highlighted throughout the story. This is not just forbidden sex and fear of getting caught. This is a true romance between fully developed characters who continue to develop on page with each other. Plenty of cute scenes of bonding and meeting each other's families and being together in general, both before and after the shit hits the fan, solidify their relationship in a lovely way.
When the big conflict comes, I was not fully prepared for how it all played out, and bravo to the author for hitting me in the feels. Caleb makes choices that aren't fully wrong, but aren't right either and Thalia holds him accountable. There is a brief separation and then when they're reunited, there's communication and not just "I'm sorry, let's hop on into bed", although there is a quick return to bedroom activities lol.
Side characters in this book were complicated! Both Thalia's family and Caleb's had interesting dynamics and backstories. I will forever love the brother relationships in this series though and wish for more and more. Thalia's friends were hilarious and wonderful, but then also crossed some lines themselves in their concern over the situation brewing. There was a lot happening around the main characters in a realistic way. There's no romance happening in a mystical vacuum where their choices don't have repercussions or affect other relationships.
The ending is HFN and the bonus scene that can be downloaded via the author's newsletter actually happens before the epilogue. Now, am I sure that these two stay together forever in love? Yeah, I am, they are the right person for each other and just happened to meet at a less ideal time. But the epilogue is several months down the road with them moving in together and with updates on where they are and peeks at their families interacting. The bonus scene is also great for this. This author's endings don't usually end with marriage and babies, but you still get that satisfaction of knowing they're gonna make it when you close the book. I find this author's writing to be wonderful and return to her books again and again, so I recommend giving her a try if you haven't before!
The angst was at times lighter and others heavier. In addition to fighting their attraction and the moral dilemma of dating your professor/student, Thalia is also going through challenging family times, which Caleb steps up to support her with. I appreciated that when Caleb and Thalia gave in and pursued a relationship in earnest, they did so with their eyes wide open and acknowledging the issues inherent within their choices. The romance itself is sweet and fun, Caleb is a wonderful book boyfriend (he's not a pervy old man taking advantage of a student) and Thalia was awkwardly adorable and resilient (she in turn is not being taken advantage of). Written in first person, dual POV. No ow/om drama, H not a virgin (and not a manho) and h was a virgin.
I liked Caleb and Thalia together. He had a more relaxed feel to his character and she felt more mature. And oh the tension and chemistry between them was fire. Even though the steamy factor plays a big role (once they start getting down to it), the emotional intimacy, the vulnerabilities, and the connection were all highlighted throughout the story. This is not just forbidden sex and fear of getting caught. This is a true romance between fully developed characters who continue to develop on page with each other. Plenty of cute scenes of bonding and meeting each other's families and being together in general, both before and after the shit hits the fan, solidify their relationship in a lovely way.
When the big conflict comes, I was not fully prepared for how it all played out, and bravo to the author for hitting me in the feels. Caleb makes choices that aren't fully wrong, but aren't right either and Thalia holds him accountable. There is a brief separation and then when they're reunited, there's communication and not just "I'm sorry, let's hop on into bed", although there is a quick return to bedroom activities lol.
Side characters in this book were complicated! Both Thalia's family and Caleb's had interesting dynamics and backstories. I will forever love the brother relationships in this series though and wish for more and more. Thalia's friends were hilarious and wonderful, but then also crossed some lines themselves in their concern over the situation brewing. There was a lot happening around the main characters in a realistic way. There's no romance happening in a mystical vacuum where their choices don't have repercussions or affect other relationships.
The ending is HFN and the bonus scene that can be downloaded via the author's newsletter actually happens before the epilogue. Now, am I sure that these two stay together forever in love? Yeah, I am, they are the right person for each other and just happened to meet at a less ideal time. But the epilogue is several months down the road with them moving in together and with updates on where they are and peeks at their families interacting. The bonus scene is also great for this. This author's endings don't usually end with marriage and babies, but you still get that satisfaction of knowing they're gonna make it when you close the book. I find this author's writing to be wonderful and return to her books again and again, so I recommend giving her a try if you haven't before!
February 20, 2020
This book! The hookup equation had the perfect mathematics for me. Swoon-worthy forbidden lead male, funny dialect and a back story which had me glued to every page.
The meet. A night of fun can end perfectly but the night day is a different story. Imagine you find the man of your dream only to realise he's your university professor. The connection you shared is already embedded in your brain. It's hard to just forget about it, but that's exactly what Thalia needs to do.
Caleb has never felt a strong connection to another person like he did Thalia. Even though their date didn't get too far he is struggling to pretend it didn't happen. Now she sat in the back of his class and his mind isn't on the maths.
This has adult content but it's not a sexy seductive teacher book. Both characters have a life outside the university. Their connection is deeper than physical.
I really enjoyed this book. 5 out of 5.
*ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The meet. A night of fun can end perfectly but the night day is a different story. Imagine you find the man of your dream only to realise he's your university professor. The connection you shared is already embedded in your brain. It's hard to just forget about it, but that's exactly what Thalia needs to do.
Caleb has never felt a strong connection to another person like he did Thalia. Even though their date didn't get too far he is struggling to pretend it didn't happen. Now she sat in the back of his class and his mind isn't on the maths.
This has adult content but it's not a sexy seductive teacher book. Both characters have a life outside the university. Their connection is deeper than physical.
I really enjoyed this book. 5 out of 5.
*ARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 26, 2020
What I really like about this author is that she can take a typical trope and turn it into so much more. In Hookup Equation we get the teacher/student trope and the virgin heroine trope.
I’m pretty leery of the virgin trope because it just never seems realistic in current times, but like I said, the author just made this story so much more than that. It didn’t even feel like a big deal based off how this couple progresses in their relationship. What we get is a slow burn romance that lets us get to know these two as individuals, and as a new couple.
Having this as a student teacher trope also allowed for Caleb and Thalia to recognize and admit early on what their attraction meant and could be if they explored it. It took an explosive first encounter and forced them to slow down and evaluate. I really enjoyed seeing them work through these obstacles.
These Loveless brothers have been a fun family to get to know. They are all so different in personality but the same in the core of their values. I genuinely like them and love to see them fall in love. I’m so glad we have another brother’s story to come. I not only recommend this book, but I also recommend all the standalone books in this series. These Loveless men are delicious!
I’m pretty leery of the virgin trope because it just never seems realistic in current times, but like I said, the author just made this story so much more than that. It didn’t even feel like a big deal based off how this couple progresses in their relationship. What we get is a slow burn romance that lets us get to know these two as individuals, and as a new couple.
Having this as a student teacher trope also allowed for Caleb and Thalia to recognize and admit early on what their attraction meant and could be if they explored it. It took an explosive first encounter and forced them to slow down and evaluate. I really enjoyed seeing them work through these obstacles.
These Loveless brothers have been a fun family to get to know. They are all so different in personality but the same in the core of their values. I genuinely like them and love to see them fall in love. I’m so glad we have another brother’s story to come. I not only recommend this book, but I also recommend all the standalone books in this series. These Loveless men are delicious!
January 30, 2025
3,5 stars
I don’t mind a forbidden romance, but there was too much power imbalance and the age gap didn’t help either. It’s not that it was that big of a gap, if the heroine were 28 and the hero 34, I wouldn’t even consider it an age gap. However, if he is 28 and she’s 22, and he’s her professor… 😬😬😬*
I still enjoyed the book, loved the cameos and the Loveless family dynamic, but the romance was a little too forbidden for my taste.
*and he’s not a hot vampire, which would make the whole thing acceptable obviously
I don’t mind a forbidden romance, but there was too much power imbalance and the age gap didn’t help either. It’s not that it was that big of a gap, if the heroine were 28 and the hero 34, I wouldn’t even consider it an age gap. However, if he is 28 and she’s 22, and he’s her professor… 😬😬😬*
I still enjoyed the book, loved the cameos and the Loveless family dynamic, but the romance was a little too forbidden for my taste.
*and he’s not a hot vampire, which would make the whole thing acceptable obviously
February 23, 2020
This book is a work of sheer beauty... filled to the brim with intense emotion.
You will find a love that is so deep and pure that it would do anything to protect the loved one from any harm ... A love so blazing hot that it threatens to scorch you from head to toe ...
You will find tragedy in many forms ... past and present ...
You will find laughter ... carefree, uncontrolled and exuberant ... The banter between Caleb and Thalia and Caleb and his brothers ... hilarious and priceless ...
And you will find heartbreak ...
... the full range of human emotions ... skilfully unfolded, masterfully created ...
Words fail me.
I think this book is one of the best I'll read this year.
You will find a love that is so deep and pure that it would do anything to protect the loved one from any harm ... A love so blazing hot that it threatens to scorch you from head to toe ...
You will find tragedy in many forms ... past and present ...
You will find laughter ... carefree, uncontrolled and exuberant ... The banter between Caleb and Thalia and Caleb and his brothers ... hilarious and priceless ...
And you will find heartbreak ...
... the full range of human emotions ... skilfully unfolded, masterfully created ...
Words fail me.
I think this book is one of the best I'll read this year.
March 11, 2020
I enjoyed all of the Lawless brothers books except this one. For Caleb being so smart, it did not carry over in this book. The book felt thrown together and as another reviewer mentioned, there was no research done on the area where the story took place. I realize this is a work of fiction but if you’re going to write about a real place, some research needs to be done to make it believable. If not, use a fictional location. I was disappointed in this book.
July 4, 2023
this was my least favorite of the series so far. idk it just felt like it was lacking some of the charm of the others - and thalia and caleb just felt a little flat compared to the other stories. still enjoyed though!
May 21, 2020
may i just say, that summary is a crime. "but i'm a virgin" GIRL IF U DONT-
it's very frustrating cause the synopsis exudes intense Wattpad energy that doesn't reflect the book at all?? it focuses so much on Thalia being a miss-goody-two-shoes and being a viRGiN and yet the book doesn't really make it seem like the biggest of deals?? so why does the summary do that.
anyways.
overall, solid romance novel. it has one of my least favourite tropes and yes, i'm still a bit iffy about Thalia and Caleb and their romeo and juliet escapades but whatever. i'm not gonna take it too seriously.
actually -- you cannot convince me that these two were so in looOOoOOve they couldn't wait half a year to bang. ffs. and Thalia's speeches on "she can decide for herself" were valid, but misplaced in this kind of scenario. being in love doesn't change that it is v ethically murky to sleep with your students. what's with horny people... keep it in your pants i promise you won't die.
what i did like -- is that there were higher stakes in this than the last two successors. like the anxiety of being found out was real with this. and i liked the ending too --
i like the diversity too -- Thalia is Latina and the representations feels realistic as always, v v welcome : )
and: as always, i really fucking loved the writing. and the humour. and the dialogue, y'all. the conversation the characters have amongst each other (as opposed to with me?? lmao) is always so entertaining to read. i like reading about the Loveless family and i love that secondary characters feel a whole lot more explored and not just there for the ~girl gang aesthetic~. OH AND -- i mentioned this in another review for one of the other books -- the 'foundation?' of the following novel is established and it gets you hype! to read the next book. (SETH LETS GOOO )
basically -- even with all the flaws and weird marketing, i really loved this series and i'm happy i found it. and its author :)
on that note tho -- i hope i never fall in love if it's gonna make me this short-sighted gOD.
it's very frustrating cause the synopsis exudes intense Wattpad energy that doesn't reflect the book at all?? it focuses so much on Thalia being a miss-goody-two-shoes and being a viRGiN and yet the book doesn't really make it seem like the biggest of deals?? so why does the summary do that.
anyways.
overall, solid romance novel. it has one of my least favourite tropes and yes, i'm still a bit iffy about Thalia and Caleb and their romeo and juliet escapades but whatever. i'm not gonna take it too seriously.
actually -- you cannot convince me that these two were so in looOOoOOve they couldn't wait half a year to bang. ffs. and Thalia's speeches on "she can decide for herself" were valid, but misplaced in this kind of scenario. being in love doesn't change that it is v ethically murky to sleep with your students. what's with horny people... keep it in your pants i promise you won't die.
what i did like -- is that there were higher stakes in this than the last two successors. like the anxiety of being found out was real with this. and i liked the ending too --
i like the diversity too -- Thalia is Latina and the representations feels realistic as always, v v welcome : )
and: as always, i really fucking loved the writing. and the humour. and the dialogue, y'all. the conversation the characters have amongst each other (as opposed to with me?? lmao) is always so entertaining to read. i like reading about the Loveless family and i love that secondary characters feel a whole lot more explored and not just there for the ~girl gang aesthetic~. OH AND -- i mentioned this in another review for one of the other books -- the 'foundation?' of the following novel is established and it gets you hype! to read the next book. (SETH LETS GOOO )
basically -- even with all the flaws and weird marketing, i really loved this series and i'm happy i found it. and its author :)
on that note tho -- i hope i never fall in love if it's gonna make me this short-sighted gOD.
February 25, 2020
Forbidden love is smutnip for me. I know it’s wrong, I know they shouldn’t but I also can’t stop reading, hoping they do. That’s the feeling I had reading this. I also can’t tell you the number of times I found myself humming The Police’s Don’t Stand So Close to Me while reading this. I’m an 80s kid, and I still smile when I think of Sting all shirtless punk scholar-like. I guarantee I didn’t have a teacher like that when I was in school. Sprinkle some forbidden student-teacher love into a romance, and I want to just rub all over it and purr. I wasn’t disappointed.
Caleb is an calculus assistant professor at a university, Thalia is a senior, getting ready to graduate. To avoid any more spoilers, suffice to say that lines are crossed all over the place. The story uses that special sexual tension that only the forbidden can give you, and how many times can I say forbidden? Yum. Anyhoodle...while that aspect of the story is important, Ms. Noir doesn’t ignore the inherent power imbalance but actually addresses it, and consequences are real. I LOVED that, because it really digs into those gray areas, and it gave depth to the overall tale.
I always say the first meet/kiss/love scene is so, so, so important. It’s the proof in the pudding - the character’s sexual attraction, emotional connection is key for me. If that leaps off the page, I can and have forgiven so many sins. Here, Thalia and Caleb’s chemistry is *chef’s kiss* good, with the right amount of sweet and sexy to sweep a reader up in those scenes.
Now, I’ve enjoyed the earlier Loveless books in varying degrees, but it’s been a pretty monochromatic ‘verse. So, color me pleasantly surprised to see some POC make it into this ‘verse. Is it a consequence of being set in university? Possibly and I’m here for it. Thalia is Latina, and as a Latina I wasn’t offended by the representation. I think it was fine - is it incredibly detailed? No, but it works for this story and it is handled in a respectful manner.
The main attraction for me with this series has always been the relationships between the Loveless brothers, and this didn’t disappoint. The banter was good, the love was apparent, and they served their purpose as supporting players without taking over the narrative - the light shines bright on Caleb and Thalia.
All in all, I think it’s my favorite book so far. If you’re a fan of this series and/or love the forbidden student-teacher romance trope, you may enjoy this because I definitely did.
**ARC provided via SocialButterflyPR for review**
For more reviews, visit
December 31, 2023
Loved this. So fun getting to "live out" the hot professor scenario.
🤫 forbidden romance
🎓 professor / student
🧠 woman in STEM
🤍 age gap (6 years)
dual POV
5/5 stars ⭐️
2.5/5 spice level 🌶️
🤫 forbidden romance
🎓 professor / student
🧠 woman in STEM
🤍 age gap (6 years)
dual POV
5/5 stars ⭐️
2.5/5 spice level 🌶️
Read
June 22, 2024
DNF @ 23%.
Before I start this review, just know I’ve never read anything by this author before, or any of the previous books in this series. I got this book for free on Amazon, and it sounded interesting, so I gave it a shot. 🤷🏾♀️
Here’s a little list of the stuff I didn’t like that led me to DNF. I bailed pretty early on, and based on other reviews, it sounds like that was a good call because it only gets more frustrating.
1. The writing was a huge issue. It was super cringey and felt like reading a Wattpad fanfic. The humor was just bland and forced. I was already confused a couple of pages in. It was overwhelming and just not my style.
2. The FMC was really annoying. I was only 20% in, and she was already getting on my nerves. She’s super cringey and keeps going on about being a virgin and a “good girl”. Like, okay, we get it. You want a cookie or something? And that scene where she was making out with the MMC and reacted to his boner like this:
Girl, what 😭😭😭😭
3. Lastly, I was just bored. This book is 400+ pages, and I wasn’t going to force myself through all that when nothing was keeping me interested or entertained.
So yeah, those are my reasons for DNFing. But I guess my barf might be another’s yum, right?
Before I start this review, just know I’ve never read anything by this author before, or any of the previous books in this series. I got this book for free on Amazon, and it sounded interesting, so I gave it a shot. 🤷🏾♀️
Here’s a little list of the stuff I didn’t like that led me to DNF. I bailed pretty early on, and based on other reviews, it sounds like that was a good call because it only gets more frustrating.
1. The writing was a huge issue. It was super cringey and felt like reading a Wattpad fanfic. The humor was just bland and forced. I was already confused a couple of pages in. It was overwhelming and just not my style.
2. The FMC was really annoying. I was only 20% in, and she was already getting on my nerves. She’s super cringey and keeps going on about being a virgin and a “good girl”. Like, okay, we get it. You want a cookie or something? And that scene where she was making out with the MMC and reacted to his boner like this:
Should I pretend I don’t notice? Grab it? Grab it and say, hey, big boy, is that a cucumber in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?
Girl, what 😭😭😭😭
3. Lastly, I was just bored. This book is 400+ pages, and I wasn’t going to force myself through all that when nothing was keeping me interested or entertained.
So yeah, those are my reasons for DNFing. But I guess my barf might be another’s yum, right?
February 1, 2021
This book was every bit as good as I hoped. I was worried after not enjoying books 2 and 3 as much as I did the first book in the series. I'm a sucker for this trope, forbidden love and the student teacher relationship (college, of course).
Thalia is a senior in college and Caleb is her mathematics professor. They didn't know when they first met and they tried to stay away from each other but just couldn't stay apart. They were just drawn to each other.
Their love making was sexy and steamy. Caleb was sweet and Thalia was a sweetheart.
Very much enjoyed this story. Definitely recommend. I enjoy this author and have downloaded a couple of other books of hers. Here is hoping I like them just as well as Enemies with Benefits and this one.
Thalia is a senior in college and Caleb is her mathematics professor. They didn't know when they first met and they tried to stay away from each other but just couldn't stay apart. They were just drawn to each other.
Their love making was sexy and steamy. Caleb was sweet and Thalia was a sweetheart.
Very much enjoyed this story. Definitely recommend. I enjoy this author and have downloaded a couple of other books of hers. Here is hoping I like them just as well as Enemies with Benefits and this one.
February 26, 2020
After a chance meeting Thalia and Caleb have some serious chemistry only to later find out he’s her professor. He can’t risk his career and she can’t risk her scholarship but these two can’t deny the intensity they feel around each other. I love humorous banter in stories and this fit perfectly!!
June 30, 2021
Least favorite of the series so far - I'm sad that my sweet, nerdy Caleb got a forbidden romance and I couldn't get on board. Still good writing but professor/student is not for me.
January 23, 2024
One star isn’t low enough, this book deserves negative stars
February 28, 2020
A forbidden college professor/student romance that begins with a cute-meet-greet . . . if you're into men's bathrooms. I swear this is the third book - yes 3! - that I've read since the first of the year with this same scenario. Do author's get a list of mandated themes to include in new books during a particular time cycle? And while we're on the subject, these have all included nods to "poop" and "barf" because, of course, the poor female character is drunk and upset and the women's restroom is out of order or the line is too long and she can't wait. And there's always our hunky hero who waltzes in and finds said inebriated girl. Hey! I'll go with it, but it seems be getting overworked in my opinion. I'm all for cutesy meet-ups. And I'm thinking there must be other avenues available, too!
Thalia and Caleb know they're wrong, they know the consequences can be devastating to both of them, but even though they give it the old college try, they fail. Of course, without giving it a second thought, you know they're going to get caught, and things go all sorts of crazy. The Prof gets major kudos for his stance on protecting Thalia. He's the knight-in-shining-armor. Thalia whined and cried a lot - yet she wasn't a bad character. Both of them carried angsty baggage.
All in all, I finished it not too disappointed. It won't be re-read, but it worked for an afternoon distraction.
There are a lot of extras involved in this story, and some of it really could have been left out. Maybe the author is planning on another book that will feature one of the dangling ends.
Thalia and Caleb know they're wrong, they know the consequences can be devastating to both of them, but even though they give it the old college try, they fail. Of course, without giving it a second thought, you know they're going to get caught, and things go all sorts of crazy. The Prof gets major kudos for his stance on protecting Thalia. He's the knight-in-shining-armor. Thalia whined and cried a lot - yet she wasn't a bad character. Both of them carried angsty baggage.
All in all, I finished it not too disappointed. It won't be re-read, but it worked for an afternoon distraction.
There are a lot of extras involved in this story, and some of it really could have been left out. Maybe the author is planning on another book that will feature one of the dangling ends.
January 16, 2025
“it feels like I’ve met someone who lights up every room she walks into and makes me want to believe in magic, that’s the cold hard truth.”
four stars!
i knew from their first encounter with their banter that i was going to enjoy this book and i did! they were cute and funny.
even without reading the other books in this series, i loved seeing caleb’s brothers and their overall dynamic. i always enjoy an interconnected series of brothers or best friends, so i can see myself reading the other books in this series to get more of them.
my only complaint is i think there could have been a littttttttle more of a resolution with caleb and a new job & thalia and her parents.
four stars!
i knew from their first encounter with their banter that i was going to enjoy this book and i did! they were cute and funny.
even without reading the other books in this series, i loved seeing caleb’s brothers and their overall dynamic. i always enjoy an interconnected series of brothers or best friends, so i can see myself reading the other books in this series to get more of them.
my only complaint is i think there could have been a littttttttle more of a resolution with caleb and a new job & thalia and her parents.
April 1, 2020
Thalia and Caleb have such an immediate connection, brought together in one of the cutest, funniest meet cutes, ever, and it's all good. Too bad she walks into class later and finds out he's her new professor. Yeah...
I freaking love professor romances, all the forbiddenness of it, the delicious naughtiness of it, but when you add in the cute factor of a rom com, it's even better. Caleb and Thalia are such a great couple, I loved their chemistry, their sweet moments, and his large family and circle of friends. About the only thing that could have made this one better is if Caleb's ending were a bit more definitive. I wanted to know the direction his life was heading, but it might appear in the next story, if there is one. The Loveless Brothers have been amazing so far, I can't wait for Seth's story, I hope it's next!
ARC via Social Butterfly PR for an honest review.
Review & Blog Tour: Live Through Books Blog.
Blog | Instagram | Facebook | Twitter
December 6, 2020
Too many characters
Felt that the story line didn’t focus enough on Thalia and Caleb. Spent too much time talking about the characters family, which created some lulls and felt like no value added to the story line. Because it didn’t focus on the main characters, it was hard to get behind their reason to be together and to feel the risk of their relationship. I didn’t read the other books in the series so maybe that’s why.
Felt that the story line didn’t focus enough on Thalia and Caleb. Spent too much time talking about the characters family, which created some lulls and felt like no value added to the story line. Because it didn’t focus on the main characters, it was hard to get behind their reason to be together and to feel the risk of their relationship. I didn’t read the other books in the series so maybe that’s why.
March 5, 2024
The only line you need in this book is “I shouldn’t be getting blowjobs from the girl whose papers I grade.” 🤮 I love this author’s writing, but this plot was so much ick. I don’t care if the characters are technically consenting adults; the power imbalance and real world consequences portrayed were not cute or romantic. This was so not it.
June 23, 2021
suddenly i love math
November 7, 2023
3.7 ⭐️
Esperaba con tantas ansias saber la historia de Caleb... y siento que la autora le salió a deber a este personaje... y a muchos lectores como yo... el trope de cuasi amor a primer vista, combinado con chica virgen, con romance prohibido profesor/estudiante, no son de mis afectos en lo absoluto, pero esperaba que funcionara bien por el bien de mi nerd favorito...
Caleb es super romántico y tiernito, y Thalia es una chica inteligente y divertida... la historia de ellos se desarrolla bien, entiendo las razones de ambos... pero, pasa tanto que quedan algunas cosas inconclusas y además la forma en que se "solucionó" la situación principal me deja un sabor bastante amargo, siento que no es justo.
Amo que toda la familia Loveless sale en el libro y puedo ver como siguen las historias de todos y divertirme y enamorarme más con cada intervención, pero aún así, siento que Roxie le falló a Caleb, le dió demasiado drama, DEMASIADO, al más peque y tranquilo de todos...
Eso sí, me hizo querer aún más saber que pasará con Seth... y por ahora, estoy de acuerdo con Caleb y no quiero a Delilah... pero esperaré a saber qué ocurre...
Esperaba con tantas ansias saber la historia de Caleb... y siento que la autora le salió a deber a este personaje... y a muchos lectores como yo... el trope de cuasi amor a primer vista, combinado con chica virgen, con romance prohibido profesor/estudiante, no son de mis afectos en lo absoluto, pero esperaba que funcionara bien por el bien de mi nerd favorito...
Caleb es super romántico y tiernito, y Thalia es una chica inteligente y divertida... la historia de ellos se desarrolla bien, entiendo las razones de ambos... pero, pasa tanto que quedan algunas cosas inconclusas y además la forma en que se "solucionó" la situación principal me deja un sabor bastante amargo, siento que no es justo.
Amo que toda la familia Loveless sale en el libro y puedo ver como siguen las historias de todos y divertirme y enamorarme más con cada intervención, pero aún así, siento que Roxie le falló a Caleb, le dió demasiado drama, DEMASIADO, al más peque y tranquilo de todos...
Eso sí, me hizo querer aún más saber que pasará con Seth... y por ahora, estoy de acuerdo con Caleb y no quiero a Delilah... pero esperaré a saber qué ocurre...
June 14, 2024
I know I’m old when I’m panicking over the thought of anyone not having a job in this economy. 😂 From the time he lost his job until the epilogue (and admittedly, even after that because what even is that job) I was like “but how will they SURVIVE!?”
Ugh, I’m ancient and apparently value financial security more than hot man sexy times. 🥲
Ugh, I’m ancient and apparently value financial security more than hot man sexy times. 🥲
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
August 31, 2024Soft DNF at 34% | might come back to this someday but it’s not holding my interest right now.
February 24, 2020
Before I even start this review, I have to say, how HOT is this cover? It's perfect! I LOVE the glasses. It's EVERYTHING!!! Now on to the review! (P.s. It's also now my lovk screen picture on my phone. (If that's ok)
I absolutely adored Caleb and Thalia. I loved Caleb and his glasses, lol. I don't think it would have been complete without them. I mean, c'mon, look how sexy he is. Not everyone can get away with wearing glasses but Caleb Loveless pulls it off, big time. Ok, ok. I've finished gushing about his glasses.
Caleb is the youngest Loveless brother at 28. He's a maths wizard and is about to embark on his first year at teaching.
Thalia is smart, beautiful and adorably awkward and things just don't filter from her mouth before she says them.
The both meet while stuck in the men's toilet. Caleb helps Thalia escape and from there they go on a date. A fantastic date, one I'd like myself. But neither one knows what the other does job wise or each others ages.
The next day they both get a shock when Thalia turns up in Caleb's lecture. They try to stay away as they know it's "wrong" but they both know the consequences for their actions. And so they start to date, secretly.
Thalia has terrible parents (grew up catholic, everything she does seems like a sin?) Anyway she just wants to be free of the restraints that have been put upon her and she breaks free of them shackles by doing something for herself. Loving Caleb. But not everyone is happy about that and sets out to destroy it.
Caleb is hiding something from his brother's and it's weighing heavy on his shoulders. He finally unburdens himself to Thalia, the only other person besides his mother that knows the secret.
I loved these two and couldn't get enough. I'm just happy that there is at least one more book (Silas- honorary Loveless 😉), which is Seth's. I just hope it's not with the one who broke his heart because I don't know if I can forgive her. And we haven't even gotten the full story on that, yet! So looking forward to Seth's book and more appearances from the Loveless clan.
I absolutely adored Caleb and Thalia. I loved Caleb and his glasses, lol. I don't think it would have been complete without them. I mean, c'mon, look how sexy he is. Not everyone can get away with wearing glasses but Caleb Loveless pulls it off, big time. Ok, ok. I've finished gushing about his glasses.
Caleb is the youngest Loveless brother at 28. He's a maths wizard and is about to embark on his first year at teaching.
Thalia is smart, beautiful and adorably awkward and things just don't filter from her mouth before she says them.
The both meet while stuck in the men's toilet. Caleb helps Thalia escape and from there they go on a date. A fantastic date, one I'd like myself. But neither one knows what the other does job wise or each others ages.
The next day they both get a shock when Thalia turns up in Caleb's lecture. They try to stay away as they know it's "wrong" but they both know the consequences for their actions. And so they start to date, secretly.
Thalia has terrible parents (grew up catholic, everything she does seems like a sin?) Anyway she just wants to be free of the restraints that have been put upon her and she breaks free of them shackles by doing something for herself. Loving Caleb. But not everyone is happy about that and sets out to destroy it.
Caleb is hiding something from his brother's and it's weighing heavy on his shoulders. He finally unburdens himself to Thalia, the only other person besides his mother that knows the secret.
I loved these two and couldn't get enough. I'm just happy that there is at least one more book (Silas- honorary Loveless 😉), which is Seth's. I just hope it's not with the one who broke his heart because I don't know if I can forgive her. And we haven't even gotten the full story on that, yet! So looking forward to Seth's book and more appearances from the Loveless clan.
February 26, 2020
Magical. Probably the best way to describe Caleb and Thalia's story. Magical versus magic is a running theme throughout the book, and once you've completed it you will understand why. Not because they were perfect. Not because they did everything right, or were always kind to one another, or always said or did just the right things. No, they didn't. Magical, because they were perfect in their imperfections; flawed, but delightful just the same. Caleb, the youngest of the Loveless brothers, is just starting his career and timing and/or fate being the tricky thing that it is, meets the right girl at the wrong time. Ms. Noir does such a wonderful job of making the day-to-day interactions between these characters so engaging. The simplest of scenes cause your pulse to race and your chest to clench, and a feeling of dread or excitement to creep up your spine...for Caleb and Thalia are indeed magical together. They make poor choices, but for all the right reasons and we root for them all the way. We see less of the rest of the Loveless clan in book #4 than the prior installments, probably due to a bulk the story taking place in Caleb's college town rather than Sprucedale, but the time we do get to spend with Levi, Seth, Eli and the family are sweet and endearing, and serve as a great reminder for why I enjoy this series so very much. Levi's still my favorite Loveless brother, but Caleb is probably in a tie now with Eli for second place. I may have to re-read book #1 now to refresh my memory and to see if Caleb had pulled ahead of Eli in my standing for favorite Loveless. I'm sure Seth's story will indubitably be next in the series and I'm intrigued to see how it all plays out based upon the trickle of Seth's story line sprinkled into Caleb's book. We soon shall see...I voluntarily read and reviewed this book for the author.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 789 reviews