HONESTLY is as informative as anything I could have hoped for, though there are certain aspects of Stryper (the jealousy, the infighting) of which I'd almost prefer to remain ignorant. Michael Sweet bares his soul here almost to a fault, even when he knows the unvarnished truth might make him look petty, vain, and/or hypocritical. It's not every day a Christian singer starts off a book by admitting to drinking, swearing too much, and enjoying the occasional smoke--all within the very first paragraph!
There are two different angles by which to judge this book. The first relates to its overall entertainment value and quality. From that angle, HONESTLY is everything you could ask for in a Christian rock memoir, and I don't expect to come across its like anytime soon. As a pioneering Christian metal band that was signed to a secular label and played alongside such groups as Anthrax and White Lion, their position within the annals of rock history is particularly unique. As Michael Sweet points out, Stryper was attacked by the secular community for their overt Christian lyrics, and attacked by the Christian community for their glam metal fashion and musical sensibilities. Michael Sweet also managed to embark on a fairly successful solo career, and, in recent years, toured as lead singer for the legendary band Boston. The book also deals with some weighty issues, such as the band's spiritual backsliding, and Michael's struggle to hold onto his faith in the wake of his wife's death from cancer.
The second angle by which to judge this book has to do with Michael Sweet himself and how trustworthy you find his perspective. Personally, Michael strikes me as being both a bit of a control freak and a highly sensitive individual who is constantly feeling betrayed or slighted by the people in his life. He reminds me of a roommate I once had, a guy who once roused me out of bed at three in the morning because he was annoyed I left my Nintendo out on the floor in front of the TV. A few days later, he sat me down for a very serious discussion about the proper way to load the dishwasher. Needless to say, that relationship didn't end well. Not because we argued about anything important, but because he blew everything way out of proportion.
Maybe Michael Sweet really isn't really like that at all. That's just the impression I got from this book. Michael has very little positive to say about his band mates and often belittles their contributions. Michael seemingly implies that his band mates hold him back, and that he must remain ever-vigilant in protecting Stryper from their lousy ideas, poor business sense, and sub-par songwriting contributions. There is no doubt that Stryper is mostly Michael's brainchild and that he is by far the most accomplished musician in the group, yet he's also the kind of guy who insists on doing everything himself and then complains about the extra work. According to HONESTLY, there is no trust in this band and very little camaraderie--which is sad considering all they've been through together. If any of Michael's band mates ever read this book, it will likely make their already-strained relationship even worse!
The reasons Michael gives for being bitter toward Stryper just don't seem that earth-shattering to me. Again, that's just my opinion, and other people will disagree. Hopefully, one of the other band members will write a book so we can get a different perspective. It's clear that Michael doesn't always know (or even care, sometimes) what their side of the story is. Musically, I feel the other guys must be bringing something important to the table, because I've loved the last couple of Stryper albums but haven't cared for any of Michael's solo work apart from TRUTH. (This is despite Michael's claims that the differences between a Stryper album and his own solo work is "subtle.")
If you are a big Stryper fan, parts of HONESTLY may be unpleasant to read. As they say, the truth sometimes hurts. In terms of being an entertaining rock memoir, however, the book succeeds on almost every count. My only real criticism is that the band's most recent three albums--which are far and away my favorite--go largely ignored for whatever reason. MURDER BY PRIDE and THE COVERING barely get a mention, and NO MORE HELL TO PAY doesn't even get that. Man, I would have liked to hear more about the making of those albums, especially since I'm not a fan of Stryper's early stuff apart from AGAINST THE LAW, which was their least successful record. All in all, though, HONESTLY is an amazing memoir from one of the most impressive musicians I've ever seen in concert. Even if he is a pain in the neck to work with.
(If you're unfamiliar with Stryper, I especially recommend you check out their songs "Murder by Pride," "God," and "Legacy.")