What do you think?
Rate this book
The Forbidden List #1
The Stone Road
Magic and Martial Arts meet head on in a war that will change the world. "This is fantasy in a very different setting - as traditional sword and sorcery meets the House of Flying Daggers." - Amazon Review
Zhou is a diplomat, on a mission to bring peace between his city and the city of Yaart. A mission that will, if successful, end the war that has lasted thirty years. But, not everyone on his team wants peace at any cost. There are scores to be settled that could jeopardise the treaty and plunge the two cities into another thirty years of bloody conflict.
Haung has no family but the army that raised him. Peace could prevent him from reaching the heights of glory he desires. But then comes an offer from an unexpected source and Haung must train to be a Jiin-Wei; a master swordsman, magician and spy. He will find that life as a spy is a lot more complicated than that of a soldier, and his loyalties will be tested to the full.
Deception is a weapon that all sides wield with skill. Behind it all, an Emperor is readying the land for a war against a new enemy. One that he knows too little about.
Zhou is a diplomat, on a mission to bring peace between his city and the city of Yaart. A mission that will, if successful, end the war that has lasted thirty years. But, not everyone on his team wants peace at any cost. There are scores to be settled that could jeopardise the treaty and plunge the two cities into another thirty years of bloody conflict.
Haung has no family but the army that raised him. Peace could prevent him from reaching the heights of glory he desires. But then comes an offer from an unexpected source and Haung must train to be a Jiin-Wei; a master swordsman, magician and spy. He will find that life as a spy is a lot more complicated than that of a soldier, and his loyalties will be tested to the full.
Deception is a weapon that all sides wield with skill. Behind it all, an Emperor is readying the land for a war against a new enemy. One that he knows too little about.
344 pages, Paperback
First published November 7, 2013
23 people are currently reading
768 people want to read
About the author
G.R. Matthews
19 books248 followersG. R. Matthews is a British fantasy and science fiction author best known for Seven Deaths of an Empire (Solaris, 2021), a grimdark epic praised for its visceral combat, dual perspectives, and rich world-building inspired by Roman and Celtic history.
Born in Wiltshire, surrounded by chalk hills, white horses, and ancient stone circles, he grew up immersed in landscapes steeped in ancient myth. Matthews began his publishing journey with self-published works including The Stone Road—the first of The Forbidden List trilogy drawing on ancient China—and the Corin Hayes underwater sci-fi thrillers, before breaking into traditional publishing with Seven Deaths of an Empire.
A passionate gamer as well as a self-taught guitarist, Matthews brings discipline, imagination, and resilience to his storytelling, crafting tales of loyalty, honour, and political intrigue. He continues to expand his fictional worlds with upcoming projects such as The Silencing of the North, while engaging readers with his blend of history, myth, and character-driven drama.
www.grmatthews.com
Born in Wiltshire, surrounded by chalk hills, white horses, and ancient stone circles, he grew up immersed in landscapes steeped in ancient myth. Matthews began his publishing journey with self-published works including The Stone Road—the first of The Forbidden List trilogy drawing on ancient China—and the Corin Hayes underwater sci-fi thrillers, before breaking into traditional publishing with Seven Deaths of an Empire.
A passionate gamer as well as a self-taught guitarist, Matthews brings discipline, imagination, and resilience to his storytelling, crafting tales of loyalty, honour, and political intrigue. He continues to expand his fictional worlds with upcoming projects such as The Silencing of the North, while engaging readers with his blend of history, myth, and character-driven drama.
www.grmatthews.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
September 16, 2015
I would like to start by saying this is the first 'self published' book I have read. I'm not sure that is relevant but regardless it is unexplored territory for me.
Reading other peoples comments on this book, I noticed the focus being on the different world setting. I didn't spend any time making comparisons or stopping to try and picture the scene. This, I believe is a sign of how well Mr Matthews builds and develops his world.
The story starts slow (but when I think about it, most of my favourite books do) and steadily gains momentum until by the end you really are riding the avalanche!
A particular scene in the book (two actually) wherein both Haung and Zhou are involved (though they just miss each other) created some of the finest atmosphere I have ever read. That really impressed me.
While ordinarily I would find myself in Haung's fan camp (I usually back the warrior type) I was drawn in by Zhou from the beginning and though I enjoyed following each character's journey, I think I found Zhou's trials and actions more gripping. But that is like saying 9 is of a higher value than 8. Yes it is, but only just!
The magic system is user-friendly and interesting at the same time. Various factions keep things fresh and some of the twists (or perhaps developments) are not obvious. Certainly not to me.
This story was written with emotion, of that there is no doubt. As you read you empathise with the characters and find yourself urging them along. The times when our two characters cross paths are always interesting and I hope to see more of that in the coming trilogy.
My favourite thing in this story can be summed up in two letters: Wu
Intrigue, deception, swords and magic are the recipe and the meal is deadly. But it leaves you craving a second course. I'm really excited about seeing how the story unfolds.
Highly recommended
Reading other peoples comments on this book, I noticed the focus being on the different world setting. I didn't spend any time making comparisons or stopping to try and picture the scene. This, I believe is a sign of how well Mr Matthews builds and develops his world.
The story starts slow (but when I think about it, most of my favourite books do) and steadily gains momentum until by the end you really are riding the avalanche!
A particular scene in the book (two actually) wherein both Haung and Zhou are involved (though they just miss each other) created some of the finest atmosphere I have ever read. That really impressed me.
While ordinarily I would find myself in Haung's fan camp (I usually back the warrior type) I was drawn in by Zhou from the beginning and though I enjoyed following each character's journey, I think I found Zhou's trials and actions more gripping. But that is like saying 9 is of a higher value than 8. Yes it is, but only just!
The magic system is user-friendly and interesting at the same time. Various factions keep things fresh and some of the twists (or perhaps developments) are not obvious. Certainly not to me.
This story was written with emotion, of that there is no doubt. As you read you empathise with the characters and find yourself urging them along. The times when our two characters cross paths are always interesting and I hope to see more of that in the coming trilogy.
My favourite thing in this story can be summed up in two letters: Wu
Intrigue, deception, swords and magic are the recipe and the meal is deadly. But it leaves you craving a second course. I'm really excited about seeing how the story unfolds.
Highly recommended
April 15, 2015
This was part of Mark Lawrence's Great Self-Published Fantasy Blog Off challenge.
Set in a world with a very Far East feel, The Stone Road is an interesting personal journey, as well as a rather surprising political one. War is coming, and no one seems to know what they need to know to prepare for it. Matthews does a great job really delving into the psychology of his characters. He keeps the cast small enough for them to be memorable and intimate, yet large enough to allow readers to really explore this world he’s created, as well as the intricacies of it. There are a lot of surprising twists and turns, and is left open enough for Matthews to really get down and dirty with the world and characters in the next book.
While I highly enjoyed this one, the world might put people off due to the fact that it might feel a little “borrowed” from our own world (if that makes sense at all). However, that’s really what I enjoyed the most. It’s not a western setting. There aren’t kings and queens and lots of floofy dresses. This is very unique, and incredibly brave. There’s a lot of exploration that Matthews can do. I did lament the fact that the magic system didn’t seem to get more of a background or buildup in this novel, but I think Matthews will continue to build on it in the next book.
http://www.bookwormblues.net/2015/04/...
Set in a world with a very Far East feel, The Stone Road is an interesting personal journey, as well as a rather surprising political one. War is coming, and no one seems to know what they need to know to prepare for it. Matthews does a great job really delving into the psychology of his characters. He keeps the cast small enough for them to be memorable and intimate, yet large enough to allow readers to really explore this world he’s created, as well as the intricacies of it. There are a lot of surprising twists and turns, and is left open enough for Matthews to really get down and dirty with the world and characters in the next book.
While I highly enjoyed this one, the world might put people off due to the fact that it might feel a little “borrowed” from our own world (if that makes sense at all). However, that’s really what I enjoyed the most. It’s not a western setting. There aren’t kings and queens and lots of floofy dresses. This is very unique, and incredibly brave. There’s a lot of exploration that Matthews can do. I did lament the fact that the magic system didn’t seem to get more of a background or buildup in this novel, but I think Matthews will continue to build on it in the next book.
http://www.bookwormblues.net/2015/04/...
January 25, 2016
I liked the book and am looking forward to reading the next - the blue mountain! I enjoyed the plot twists and the fact that I couldn't predict where the story was going.
June 25, 2017
Well what a fantastical ride...
The Stone Road isn't set in your usual medieval Europe style world. Instead, it's set in an ancient China inspired land. The author has clearly done his research, because this comes across throughout the book, whether through dress, buildings, culture or magic, yes magic!!
The books starts well with an intriguing prologue. Magic is apparent here, but not in any way I've seen before.
From there the story takes on a political feel of intrigue and mystery, but little action... until all hell breaks loose. Once it starts, the two main characters, whose paths intertwine very well, are dragged and pushed along, follow and pursue, paths that you would not expect.
The magic feels far eastern, and where there felt (to me) a lack of it to start with (after prologue), it is more than made up for later on. Very cinematic, the magic takes you on a colourful tour away from the 'norm' and into realms of magical wonderment.
There is tragedy and love, brutally swift combat and raging battles. Everything wanted In a fantasy novel. All of that comes with the refreshing far eastern setting GR has created.
The ending leaves you wanting more (in a good way), and I'm pleased to say there's more to come! I can't wait to get stuck into the following novel, to see where the build up and coming war will take me.
Try something different, take a step away from the 'norm' and check this out!
The Stone Road isn't set in your usual medieval Europe style world. Instead, it's set in an ancient China inspired land. The author has clearly done his research, because this comes across throughout the book, whether through dress, buildings, culture or magic, yes magic!!
The books starts well with an intriguing prologue. Magic is apparent here, but not in any way I've seen before.
From there the story takes on a political feel of intrigue and mystery, but little action... until all hell breaks loose. Once it starts, the two main characters, whose paths intertwine very well, are dragged and pushed along, follow and pursue, paths that you would not expect.
The magic feels far eastern, and where there felt (to me) a lack of it to start with (after prologue), it is more than made up for later on. Very cinematic, the magic takes you on a colourful tour away from the 'norm' and into realms of magical wonderment.
There is tragedy and love, brutally swift combat and raging battles. Everything wanted In a fantasy novel. All of that comes with the refreshing far eastern setting GR has created.
The ending leaves you wanting more (in a good way), and I'm pleased to say there's more to come! I can't wait to get stuck into the following novel, to see where the build up and coming war will take me.
Try something different, take a step away from the 'norm' and check this out!
November 6, 2015
Both excellent and entertaining. I enjoyed reading a fantasy novel with a far eastern setting, (as opposed to the more traditional alternate European setting). I haven't encountered many and was pleased with all the attention to detail contained within the novel without the story becoming bogged down by it. The author definitely is a skilled storyteller and I appreciated the balance he found in showing us the tales of these two very different men. Furthermore, I was intrigued by the magical elements of the novel and I look forward to learning more about them in the next book.
May 14, 2017
Two rival provinces Wubei and Yaart in a kingdom far far away at war. Peace talks have continued for a long time but diplomatic loopholes have stalled that until the current time.
Zhou is pushed by his influential father-in-law to join the diplomats in the peace talks on behalf of Wubei.
Haung is a young trainee freshly recruited into the legendary group of spies who infiltrated and watched every move of their own kingdoms and more. They are the Jiin-Wei; master swordsmen, magicians, and spies.
Both the young men show promise, though in different ways, pretty early in the book. Through the course of the narrative, they deal with greedy, shrewd, and manipulative superiors, loss or fear of loss of loving family, and horrors of war before they meet a mysterious new master.
We experience the chain of events through eyes of the two leads, Zhou and Haung's. The chapters are well constructed with a smooth transition of POV.
The scenes are done with precision and care. A particular one where Huang finds a woman in the village they have just plundered is one of the most haunting and memorable ones. Did he do the right thing? I can't say. I haven't been there. But he decided he would rather accept the burden of guilt than let the young mother who has just lost her children suffer from further pain and suffering by becoming the spoils of war. Such is the strength in that man.
A tender scene where Huang finds out his wife is pregnant is so simple in emotion yet so touching.
Mr. Matthews has taken two central characters, Haung and Zhou, men from different backgrounds taking two different journeys and finally converging into an intersection. Will their life be connected in the future? Will they play a bigger role in the political drama directed by the mysterious Dragon Emperor? I have to read the next two books to be able to tell you. Why don't you do that too?
The Stone Road doesn't glorify Huang and Zhou. We see them suffer as much as any common people. Haung and Zhou's daily struggle with the decisions they have to take or orders they have to follow show us that neither of them was born under a lucky star. Haung sees too much and Zhou suffers a great loss to reach the point where their fates merge.
The others like commanders, diplomats, a dragon emperor, all play their role perfectly. We understand the base nature driving the ones who let the war happen and appreciate the visible compassion of the lead characters even in such times.
The author uses predictability as a tool and crafts his story with emotions justifying each known course of action. And no, he doesn't offer pages of explanation as that justification. He lets us see for ourselves. Take the example of Haung and Zhou's scene at Hsin's house. Read the book if you want to know what I mean.
We know a good man would do a similar thing given the opportunity but are we sure?
G.R. has studied the techniques of Chinese martial arts (see his bio), magic system, and mythology well enough to make us non-native ones who may or may not have a thing for Kung-fuey goodness believe in his world and people.
The characters are few and receive the complete focus of the writer.
G.R. Matthews has taken his inspiration from the land and lore of eastern Asia and created his own unique tale of fantasy. The charmingly western ('mommy','bugger') terms used in dialogs don't really stand out in the tale that is built on a base of oriental names, places, and magic system.
The writing style is quite uniform. Some say the pace isn't fast in the beginning but I appreciate the gentle start. The prolog giving us a taste of the unique magic system and the first few chapters introducing characters and places were necessary. In my opinion, once the war had started, the fast pace of narrative had no place for all that.
So, it was a good thing we knew which factions and provinces stood where. G.R.'s simple and beautiful prose helps us connect to the story. His strong visualization gives a life to the brutal post-war scenes. A fine example would be a man blinded by rage and lust for revenge imagines red snakes coming out of crossbows or slit throats while he can only see things in black and white as an after effect of the emotional trauma.
I believe we can expect an expanse of world building and character development in the other books. A heads up: I am reading the second book and already have some of my curiosities satisfied.
For this review and more: http://bohomind.com/the-stone-road-th...
Zhou is pushed by his influential father-in-law to join the diplomats in the peace talks on behalf of Wubei.
Haung is a young trainee freshly recruited into the legendary group of spies who infiltrated and watched every move of their own kingdoms and more. They are the Jiin-Wei; master swordsmen, magicians, and spies.
Both the young men show promise, though in different ways, pretty early in the book. Through the course of the narrative, they deal with greedy, shrewd, and manipulative superiors, loss or fear of loss of loving family, and horrors of war before they meet a mysterious new master.
We experience the chain of events through eyes of the two leads, Zhou and Haung's. The chapters are well constructed with a smooth transition of POV.
The scenes are done with precision and care. A particular one where Huang finds a woman in the village they have just plundered is one of the most haunting and memorable ones. Did he do the right thing? I can't say. I haven't been there. But he decided he would rather accept the burden of guilt than let the young mother who has just lost her children suffer from further pain and suffering by becoming the spoils of war. Such is the strength in that man.
A tender scene where Huang finds out his wife is pregnant is so simple in emotion yet so touching.
Mr. Matthews has taken two central characters, Haung and Zhou, men from different backgrounds taking two different journeys and finally converging into an intersection. Will their life be connected in the future? Will they play a bigger role in the political drama directed by the mysterious Dragon Emperor? I have to read the next two books to be able to tell you. Why don't you do that too?
The Stone Road doesn't glorify Huang and Zhou. We see them suffer as much as any common people. Haung and Zhou's daily struggle with the decisions they have to take or orders they have to follow show us that neither of them was born under a lucky star. Haung sees too much and Zhou suffers a great loss to reach the point where their fates merge.
The others like commanders, diplomats, a dragon emperor, all play their role perfectly. We understand the base nature driving the ones who let the war happen and appreciate the visible compassion of the lead characters even in such times.
The author uses predictability as a tool and crafts his story with emotions justifying each known course of action. And no, he doesn't offer pages of explanation as that justification. He lets us see for ourselves. Take the example of Haung and Zhou's scene at Hsin's house. Read the book if you want to know what I mean.
We know a good man would do a similar thing given the opportunity but are we sure?
G.R. has studied the techniques of Chinese martial arts (see his bio), magic system, and mythology well enough to make us non-native ones who may or may not have a thing for Kung-fuey goodness believe in his world and people.
The characters are few and receive the complete focus of the writer.
G.R. Matthews has taken his inspiration from the land and lore of eastern Asia and created his own unique tale of fantasy. The charmingly western ('mommy','bugger') terms used in dialogs don't really stand out in the tale that is built on a base of oriental names, places, and magic system.
The writing style is quite uniform. Some say the pace isn't fast in the beginning but I appreciate the gentle start. The prolog giving us a taste of the unique magic system and the first few chapters introducing characters and places were necessary. In my opinion, once the war had started, the fast pace of narrative had no place for all that.
So, it was a good thing we knew which factions and provinces stood where. G.R.'s simple and beautiful prose helps us connect to the story. His strong visualization gives a life to the brutal post-war scenes. A fine example would be a man blinded by rage and lust for revenge imagines red snakes coming out of crossbows or slit throats while he can only see things in black and white as an after effect of the emotional trauma.
I believe we can expect an expanse of world building and character development in the other books. A heads up: I am reading the second book and already have some of my curiosities satisfied.
For this review and more: http://bohomind.com/the-stone-road-th...
September 25, 2018
Definitely a series that I would like to keep an eye on. The characters are well-written, with some pleasing parallels that I imagine will be expanded on in later editions. The plot is full of intrigue and a lot more scope than I was expecting. The only thing that bothers me at the moment is the two different, equally vague magic systems that don't get as much time devoted to them as I would like. Still worth a moment of your time, especially if you're fed up with Medieval Europe as a fantasy backdrop.
January 2, 2018
I read this book very quickly because I was absolutely unable to put it down. Quite simply, this is epic fantasy in a Far East type setting with an excellent and easy to grasp magic system and a great deal of political intrigue.
What sets this book apart from others that I've read recently is Geoff Matthews' beautiful flowing prose. His words (much like Rothfuss and Robin Hobb) flow so beautifully and his pacing, even during the novel's subtler moments is so perfect that the book always feels exciting. His characters are flawed and 3 dimensional with excellent interaction and the romantic subplots are handled well.
I'm looking forward to the next two parts of The Forbidden List and to checking out more from this great writer.
What sets this book apart from others that I've read recently is Geoff Matthews' beautiful flowing prose. His words (much like Rothfuss and Robin Hobb) flow so beautifully and his pacing, even during the novel's subtler moments is so perfect that the book always feels exciting. His characters are flawed and 3 dimensional with excellent interaction and the romantic subplots are handled well.
I'm looking forward to the next two parts of The Forbidden List and to checking out more from this great writer.
March 28, 2016
This is actually a damned good read. Set in an ancient Chinese-style culture, this is the kung-fu movie you wished you'd read instead of watched. No bad dubbing, good pacing and an intriguing magic system.
February 23, 2021
I picked up this book when I heard the words "Asian" and "fantasy" in one sentence. I've always loved Asian culture, and how very different it is from ours, so I couldn't resist. And I really love how he caught the soul of the culture so well, without the story becoming stale, or feeling like non fiction.
I really liked the two main characters - as they are on opposing sites, and Matthews manages to make you cheer for both of them. Depending on what part of the story you're in you will change your opinion of who's the bad guy, or if there really is a bad and a good guy at all. I really enjoyed that, as I hate "all black or white" stories. This one has a lot of grey areas and it did all the characters justice.
The writing style was fluid, though there were quite some typos now gone I hope). It is a really easy read, perfect as a little breather between the big tomes! There were some very wise quotes I marked down right away.
The plot was interesting, and kept me reading all the way through without long delays. It is a good mixture of quite grim and bloody in some parts, but hopeful and positive in others.
I would have wished for a bit more depth and complexity - and especially a bit more info about the magic used in the book. Though I hope that'll follow in the later books :)
All in all a good four star book that kept me entertained throughout the story!
-----------------------
Edit: By now I have read the whole trilogy and can say that they get better and better. Matthews is quickly learning and has by now advanced to become one of my favorite authors!
I really liked the two main characters - as they are on opposing sites, and Matthews manages to make you cheer for both of them. Depending on what part of the story you're in you will change your opinion of who's the bad guy, or if there really is a bad and a good guy at all. I really enjoyed that, as I hate "all black or white" stories. This one has a lot of grey areas and it did all the characters justice.
The writing style was fluid, though there were quite some typos now gone I hope). It is a really easy read, perfect as a little breather between the big tomes! There were some very wise quotes I marked down right away.
The plot was interesting, and kept me reading all the way through without long delays. It is a good mixture of quite grim and bloody in some parts, but hopeful and positive in others.
I would have wished for a bit more depth and complexity - and especially a bit more info about the magic used in the book. Though I hope that'll follow in the later books :)
All in all a good four star book that kept me entertained throughout the story!
-----------------------
Edit: By now I have read the whole trilogy and can say that they get better and better. Matthews is quickly learning and has by now advanced to become one of my favorite authors!
April 4, 2016
Not that anyone needs to know this stuff but I first saw this book on the goodreads giveaway list and then I read about it on Mark Lawrence's SPBO, so when I saw it come up on the giveaway again I entered but didn't win.
The cover art is what got my attention. Subtle colors with a hint of the setting. The bookmark styled emblem with the dragon is a nice touch.
Anyway, this story follows Zhou and Haung. Two men whose lives start out on different paths but end up intersecting at times, until they both end up on similiar journeys.
I liked both the main characters, but particularly liked Zhou, whom I didn't care for much at all at the beginning of the book but grew to like him more as their stories progressed.
As the other reviwers say, the world of The Stone Road, feels like an eastern style world(with a smidge of European thrown in). I enjoyed that it didn't drown us in culture but let us pick it up as the story progressed.
I liked the magic in that it felt very fresh, but also familiar. It was a seamless part of the story and world, that felt like it belonged, without feeling shoehorned in just so the story can have magic. If that makes sense. For me, this was one of the stronger parts of the story.
There wasn't a lot of explaining how it worked, but to be honest I didn't really care and it didn't feel like it needed it, especially if it's going to drag the story down. I assume we will get more about the magic as the books progress anyway.
I like that the story had some nice twists in it and wasn't too predictable. This book did feel a little like it could have been a prologue book, but I say that not having read the second one yet, my view will no doubt change when I see how everything plays out over the next book.
There were also a few places that felt like I could use more information, like things got jumped through to speed the story along but it was mostly minor things, and not always needed for the main story itself. For me though, that was a few of the weaker spots of the book. Luckily they were few.
The editing/formatting was great! Any mistakes were so few that I barely noticed or can't remember them. I really appreciate when the SP authors put that extra effort into the editing and it's one of the reasons I do try to mention it when I review.
So- nicely paced, great characters, and a mystical setting combined to make a very enjoyable read. I am excited for the next book!
The cover art is what got my attention. Subtle colors with a hint of the setting. The bookmark styled emblem with the dragon is a nice touch.
Anyway, this story follows Zhou and Haung. Two men whose lives start out on different paths but end up intersecting at times, until they both end up on similiar journeys.
I liked both the main characters, but particularly liked Zhou, whom I didn't care for much at all at the beginning of the book but grew to like him more as their stories progressed.
As the other reviwers say, the world of The Stone Road, feels like an eastern style world(with a smidge of European thrown in). I enjoyed that it didn't drown us in culture but let us pick it up as the story progressed.
I liked the magic in that it felt very fresh, but also familiar. It was a seamless part of the story and world, that felt like it belonged, without feeling shoehorned in just so the story can have magic. If that makes sense. For me, this was one of the stronger parts of the story.
There wasn't a lot of explaining how it worked, but to be honest I didn't really care and it didn't feel like it needed it, especially if it's going to drag the story down. I assume we will get more about the magic as the books progress anyway.
I like that the story had some nice twists in it and wasn't too predictable. This book did feel a little like it could have been a prologue book, but I say that not having read the second one yet, my view will no doubt change when I see how everything plays out over the next book.
There were also a few places that felt like I could use more information, like things got jumped through to speed the story along but it was mostly minor things, and not always needed for the main story itself. For me though, that was a few of the weaker spots of the book. Luckily they were few.
The editing/formatting was great! Any mistakes were so few that I barely noticed or can't remember them. I really appreciate when the SP authors put that extra effort into the editing and it's one of the reasons I do try to mention it when I review.
So- nicely paced, great characters, and a mystical setting combined to make a very enjoyable read. I am excited for the next book!
June 9, 2016
This was read in Fantasy-Faction's Book Club and I really enjoyed it.
The story is told from two characters, each one hailing from a different province that are at war for decades. This worked really well, actually better than I expected and both characters were pretty good and had some great moments.
The pace of the book is really fast. The initial chapters and a long prologue may give the opposite reaction but this goes roller-coaster mode after that and only real life stuff that couldn't wait prevented me of plowing through the book in two days.
There's also interesting magic involving spirits and Ki and although both characters are only beginning to grasp at it, there are really cool moments involving the world and some other characters, like an hermit in a mountain village and a certain serving girl.
Sometimes you will find some typos, some very contemporary wording now and then (the story is based on ancient China) and some parts, mostly in the beginning, the writing may feel a bit rough, but the story kept me engaged enough that I really didn't care much for this as I kept flipping pages, something I certainly couldn't say about most of other self-published material I came across.
It certainly got me curious to know what the heck happens next and since the author is active in the community, so for me these two factors counterbalances the little thing above.
The story is told from two characters, each one hailing from a different province that are at war for decades. This worked really well, actually better than I expected and both characters were pretty good and had some great moments.
The pace of the book is really fast. The initial chapters and a long prologue may give the opposite reaction but this goes roller-coaster mode after that and only real life stuff that couldn't wait prevented me of plowing through the book in two days.
There's also interesting magic involving spirits and Ki and although both characters are only beginning to grasp at it, there are really cool moments involving the world and some other characters, like an hermit in a mountain village and a certain serving girl.
Sometimes you will find some typos, some very contemporary wording now and then (the story is based on ancient China) and some parts, mostly in the beginning, the writing may feel a bit rough, but the story kept me engaged enough that I really didn't care much for this as I kept flipping pages, something I certainly couldn't say about most of other self-published material I came across.
It certainly got me curious to know what the heck happens next and since the author is active in the community, so for me these two factors counterbalances the little thing above.
June 4, 2020
This is fantasy in a very different setting - as traditional sword and sorcery meets the House of Flying Daggers. Eschewing the dominant medieval European backdrop to so much fantasy fiction, GR Matthews takes us further East to a world where two men are transformed by their experience of peace and war, life and death, love and loneliness.
There is a mythology that underpins this story, but it is not one I was familiar with before. This makes the systems of magic and the kinds of characters a new challenge to get to grips with, but I particularly liked how the author immersed the reader in this very foreign world. Like learning a different language through living in a country, we learn the ways of this place by osmosis as we journey through the story.
The two central characters are an intriguing contrast, in their personalities, their challenges and the changes they experience as a bigger picture plays out around them and their families.
In a story I always want to see characters who are changed and developed by their experiences, and these two certainly have been.
There is a mythology that underpins this story, but it is not one I was familiar with before. This makes the systems of magic and the kinds of characters a new challenge to get to grips with, but I particularly liked how the author immersed the reader in this very foreign world. Like learning a different language through living in a country, we learn the ways of this place by osmosis as we journey through the story.
The two central characters are an intriguing contrast, in their personalities, their challenges and the changes they experience as a bigger picture plays out around them and their families.
In a story I always want to see characters who are changed and developed by their experiences, and these two certainly have been.
January 26, 2016
This is a fantastic begining to what could be a great series I am really looking forward to reading the blue mountain
February 22, 2021
I picked this up after reading some Wuxia books and hearing a recommendation that this was a good example. It's Asian inspired but for me it doesn't really capture the fun or the outlandishness or the fantasy of other Wuxia I've read. The powers are bland and are all bestowed between chapters so there is no training or sacrifice or character growth moments. One second a character is in the army and asked to join the mysterious magical spy clan and the in the next chapter it's years later and he is tracing spells on doors so he can listen in. I'm more interested in the Wuxia where one guy has spent ten years doing one finger push ups and now has a super finger that can cut straight though a person.
DNF
DNF
September 4, 2016
My first experience of fantasy with a far eastern setting, ws a slow start (for me) but once characters/settings established this story rattles along a a good pace. Some fresh ideas, I like the magic system and how it requires practical/physical application rather than vaguely waving your hand and the spell happens. The otherworldly aspect is interesting and I can see it leading to some interesting battles in the other two books.
A great debut and well worth a read.
A great debut and well worth a read.
November 25, 2015
Amazing book ! Well what more to say ? We have a Asian setting and magic
I read another book silent city from gr and was hooked go buy that too
The detail and skill put in to deliver this work is outstanding . To start a peace envoy to end a war that seals the peace to city's burning and assassination attempts !
Breath taking first book I will look out for more
I read another book silent city from gr and was hooked go buy that too
The detail and skill put in to deliver this work is outstanding . To start a peace envoy to end a war that seals the peace to city's burning and assassination attempts !
Breath taking first book I will look out for more
December 17, 2016
I loved The Stone Road. The plot was well written and the characters were clearly defined. As I read, I could easily imagine what the settings looked like, in my head. I will definitely be reading more of Matthews work. True brilliance.
January 3, 2019
First off, I would like to publicly apologize to Mr. Matthews. Mr. Matthews gave me his book to review 3 months ago and the quote “time fills itself up” has never been more appropriate in this case. My procrastination is truly a sight to behold. I am so sorry Mr. Matthews for being a slow intolerable snub :)
Now let’s talk about this amazing book! The stone road is set in a magical world in ancient China. Reading the book makes you truly appreciate the Chinese culture; be it the graphically described clothing or the beautifully illustrated monuments.
The book begins by showing us a territorial dispute between two kingdoms inside the Chinese empire; Wubei and Yaart. However these kingdoms have finally decided to start holding peace talks. Simultaneously, we are introduced to our two protagonists; Zhou, a diplomat of Wubei and Haung, an apprentice from Yaart training to become a master spy.
The initial quarter of the book is filled with insane diplomatic exchanges. Through the double narrative, we see how both sides are trying to stay one step ahead of the other. The amount of backstabbing and lying going on is absolutely insane! (how did you come up with that Mr. Matthews?!). Here is one of the nicest quotes, during those negotiations; “Most of it will be lies. You should be astonished how often people lie to those that they should trust” — A character to Haung.
Speaking of other characters, the supporting characters in the story are awesome. They truly develop alongside the protagonist and of course help the protagonists develop immensely.
The contrast in personality between the two protagonists is also outstandingly well written. This is further enhanced when each character is presented with similar existential dilemmas. The choice taken by these characters in these situations are well depicted and the pretext prior to the dilemma is perfectly written.
Coming back to our story, after the negotiations between the two kingdoms, us readers are made to believe that all is well… But is that really the case? Read the book to find out!
What I loved: I loved the vulnerability of both these characters. Unlike many other books, where I know the protagonist will never die, in the stone road, I often feel as if the protagonists may die.
What can be improved: The transitions between the narratives is as smooth as a baby’s buttock. However, I felt that sometimes the transitions were a bit too smooth and I got lost as to whose story I was reading
Rating: 4.5/5
Purchase the stone read from amazon.com; https://www.amazon.com/Stone-Road-For...
Now let’s talk about this amazing book! The stone road is set in a magical world in ancient China. Reading the book makes you truly appreciate the Chinese culture; be it the graphically described clothing or the beautifully illustrated monuments.
The book begins by showing us a territorial dispute between two kingdoms inside the Chinese empire; Wubei and Yaart. However these kingdoms have finally decided to start holding peace talks. Simultaneously, we are introduced to our two protagonists; Zhou, a diplomat of Wubei and Haung, an apprentice from Yaart training to become a master spy.
The initial quarter of the book is filled with insane diplomatic exchanges. Through the double narrative, we see how both sides are trying to stay one step ahead of the other. The amount of backstabbing and lying going on is absolutely insane! (how did you come up with that Mr. Matthews?!). Here is one of the nicest quotes, during those negotiations; “Most of it will be lies. You should be astonished how often people lie to those that they should trust” — A character to Haung.
Speaking of other characters, the supporting characters in the story are awesome. They truly develop alongside the protagonist and of course help the protagonists develop immensely.
The contrast in personality between the two protagonists is also outstandingly well written. This is further enhanced when each character is presented with similar existential dilemmas. The choice taken by these characters in these situations are well depicted and the pretext prior to the dilemma is perfectly written.
Coming back to our story, after the negotiations between the two kingdoms, us readers are made to believe that all is well… But is that really the case? Read the book to find out!
What I loved: I loved the vulnerability of both these characters. Unlike many other books, where I know the protagonist will never die, in the stone road, I often feel as if the protagonists may die.
What can be improved: The transitions between the narratives is as smooth as a baby’s buttock. However, I felt that sometimes the transitions were a bit too smooth and I got lost as to whose story I was reading
Rating: 4.5/5
Purchase the stone read from amazon.com; https://www.amazon.com/Stone-Road-For...
May 23, 2014
I loved the subtle detail that Mr. Matthews uses in the smaller nuances of human behavior that is exhibited in the book. Some of the larger displays of action I thought could have had more detail but I noticed that it was consistent throughout the book and better explanations were waiting for the events that unfolded. I have always been a huge fan of a small and trickling reveal. Not too much here and not too much there has always piqued my interest and allowed me to play a game of what if and see if it shapes up that way later on in the book. I rarely ever came close to predicting all of the elements that Mr. Matthews brings out in the story but that made me want to turn the page that much more.
Getting details correct when you are looking at the behavior of a character are subjective to the writer and no one knows the characters better than the writer does which goes without saying. Mr. Matthews vividly shows this in the reveal of his characters behaviors and psychological elements. Most of which is played close to the vest but in the few interactions I have had with the author I think this is a personal character trait as well. I have always been one that notices the small nuances of humans when I am out and about. My Grandfather taught me how to people watch as a young lad and have kept up the game ever since. It shows in The Stone Road. It is not necessary to pick up on them for the story but adds a depth to the book that I enjoyed. It also leaves the reader guessing on motivations of the characters and which path they will pick but by the end of the road (pun intended, couldn’t resist) it shores up the characters to have solid foundations and leaves plenty of room for the reader to hunger for more about Zhou and Haung in the next book.
The story of Zhou and Haung start at almost polar opposites from one another but through trials and circumstance they end up on a similar path both of mind and direction. The magical subsets of the book are unique to me. I have not encountered them before in other paradigms of magic in SF. In a collection of short stories about The Stone Road world available on Mr. Matthews website, http://http://www.grmatthews.com/ you will get to delve further into this magical construct a bit deeper with Shu and learn more about some of the other characters.
I was hoping for more detail into Haung's training and the basis for his magic versus the Wu. I am sure that will be coming in book two and the two main characters progress on similar paths to face an unknown evil that is pressing down on them. The differences between Haung and Zhou led to a conclusion that deep in the recesses of each character’s soul there is similar motivation and burning desire fueling them both to their fate. It is a complex relationship that I am looking forward to exploring in more detail.
I would recommend this book to everyone that enjoys SF. It is not off the path but a new look at the path to be taken in its story telling and plot. There is a lot to be explored and some unanswered questions that hopefully will be forthcoming in the future installments by Mr. Matthews.
Getting details correct when you are looking at the behavior of a character are subjective to the writer and no one knows the characters better than the writer does which goes without saying. Mr. Matthews vividly shows this in the reveal of his characters behaviors and psychological elements. Most of which is played close to the vest but in the few interactions I have had with the author I think this is a personal character trait as well. I have always been one that notices the small nuances of humans when I am out and about. My Grandfather taught me how to people watch as a young lad and have kept up the game ever since. It shows in The Stone Road. It is not necessary to pick up on them for the story but adds a depth to the book that I enjoyed. It also leaves the reader guessing on motivations of the characters and which path they will pick but by the end of the road (pun intended, couldn’t resist) it shores up the characters to have solid foundations and leaves plenty of room for the reader to hunger for more about Zhou and Haung in the next book.
The story of Zhou and Haung start at almost polar opposites from one another but through trials and circumstance they end up on a similar path both of mind and direction. The magical subsets of the book are unique to me. I have not encountered them before in other paradigms of magic in SF. In a collection of short stories about The Stone Road world available on Mr. Matthews website, http://http://www.grmatthews.com/ you will get to delve further into this magical construct a bit deeper with Shu and learn more about some of the other characters.
I was hoping for more detail into Haung's training and the basis for his magic versus the Wu. I am sure that will be coming in book two and the two main characters progress on similar paths to face an unknown evil that is pressing down on them. The differences between Haung and Zhou led to a conclusion that deep in the recesses of each character’s soul there is similar motivation and burning desire fueling them both to their fate. It is a complex relationship that I am looking forward to exploring in more detail.
I would recommend this book to everyone that enjoys SF. It is not off the path but a new look at the path to be taken in its story telling and plot. There is a lot to be explored and some unanswered questions that hopefully will be forthcoming in the future installments by Mr. Matthews.
August 21, 2015
The beginning of the book does absolutely nothing to sell me, and I almost dropped it like a hot rock then and there. Prologues don't do anything for me, especially when they're intentionally vague and just serve to make you go "Oh, there are bad guys in this book. Okay." On top of that, there were a few things that seemed... off in the first chapter. And I kept noticing anachronistic words and phrases, things that seemed modern and Western, rather than medieval and Chinese. But, I decided that I was going to give this book a really solid try, rather than just drop it.
And then the book got totally friggin' awesome. The characters went from nothing to people you legitimately care about, although I will say that I never got a good mental image of one of them. The plot was really enjoyable, the emotion was really well written, the characterization was very well done. There were a few plot developments that were ultra predictable, but that's because predictable often means "This is gonna be the thing you want to have happen." Then, when it happens, Matthews does it super-satisfyingly.
Everything pays off well and sets up for the next book, without making it so painful that it is obviously leading into a next book. Like, this adventure stands on its own, without needing to drag on every single plot thread into whatever will come next. I'm definitely going to be looking forward to the next of Matthews' books, whether it's in this series or the next.
And then the book got totally friggin' awesome. The characters went from nothing to people you legitimately care about, although I will say that I never got a good mental image of one of them. The plot was really enjoyable, the emotion was really well written, the characterization was very well done. There were a few plot developments that were ultra predictable, but that's because predictable often means "This is gonna be the thing you want to have happen." Then, when it happens, Matthews does it super-satisfyingly.
Everything pays off well and sets up for the next book, without making it so painful that it is obviously leading into a next book. Like, this adventure stands on its own, without needing to drag on every single plot thread into whatever will come next. I'm definitely going to be looking forward to the next of Matthews' books, whether it's in this series or the next.
August 21, 2015
I discovered this book after asking for recommendations on Fantasy Faction.
The author threw his hat into the ring and suggested his books!
I loved every part of the book.
The chapters switch between the 2 protagonists and you quickly become attached to each but in a different way. There is a balanced mix of political intrigue, action and subterfuge. I would like to have read more on Haung's training but that's only a minor criticism because I like him so much.
I finished the book in a day and then devoured the second, the day after and loved that one even more!
The author threw his hat into the ring and suggested his books!
I loved every part of the book.
The chapters switch between the 2 protagonists and you quickly become attached to each but in a different way. There is a balanced mix of political intrigue, action and subterfuge. I would like to have read more on Haung's training but that's only a minor criticism because I like him so much.
I finished the book in a day and then devoured the second, the day after and loved that one even more!
March 9, 2017
Great new world. It's been awhile since I read it. But the characters are still vivid.
A great mixture of Shamanistic/ Oriental magic systems. Highly recommend.
A great mixture of Shamanistic/ Oriental magic systems. Highly recommend.
January 17, 2019
An enjoyable debut novel that started as a slow burn for me but built up so that by the end, I was left excited to learn more about the world and the characters. It's based in a secondary world with Chinese influences, and we're shown two characters on opposite sides of a war. Neither is the "good" or "evil" one, as life is more complex than that and so are these characters. In addition, they are unaware of a larger tapestry being woven and as you get more peeks at it, you'll want to learn more about what is really going on and how our two protagonists fit into it. I recommend reading it!
December 31, 2022
Give this a try
My friends first novel which has taken me a very long time to finally pick up and read. I'm glad I did! Starting with a pretext of peace between warring nations, this soon turns into a tale of deceit, mysticism and a larger scale plot. I am a huge fantasy fan but have never read a book that is grounded in a world based on the Far East. This comes with a large slab of magic that I think is only going to grow through the series and good old action packed sequences. I will be returning for book 2, albeit, 8 years late!
My friends first novel which has taken me a very long time to finally pick up and read. I'm glad I did! Starting with a pretext of peace between warring nations, this soon turns into a tale of deceit, mysticism and a larger scale plot. I am a huge fantasy fan but have never read a book that is grounded in a world based on the Far East. This comes with a large slab of magic that I think is only going to grow through the series and good old action packed sequences. I will be returning for book 2, albeit, 8 years late!
June 12, 2016
This tale is set in a world with a strong oriental flavour which is quite unusual as most fantasy stories tend to have a medieval setting. If I'm being completely honest that did put me off a bit but when I began to read it worked really well. There's no boring info dumping in this book, it's pure story and action.
The premise is that there are two provinces, Yaart and Wubei, who have been at war for thirty long years. Both sides are exhausted and when the Duke of Yaart calls for a peace treaty both sides are eager to achieve peace.
We watch these events unfolding through Zhou a junior diplomat from Wubei trying to secure peace and Haung a secretive member of the Jiin-Wei in Yaart. Both these characters face many problems which test their loyalties and strengths to breaking point and what's really intersting is how they both deal with their difficulties.
Initially there is a slow build up as we are introduced to the characters but soon it all kicks off.
The plot was really interested and was impossible to predict what was going to happen next which made it an exciting read.
In this cleverly crafted book you'll come across moments both funny and heart wrenching but beware nothing is what it seems either. There's no obvious good guy/bad guy and you'll find yourself sympathising with ll the characters through their good and bad actions.
All in all this is a very fast paced book where fate keeps the characters spinning wildly out of control.
The premise is that there are two provinces, Yaart and Wubei, who have been at war for thirty long years. Both sides are exhausted and when the Duke of Yaart calls for a peace treaty both sides are eager to achieve peace.
We watch these events unfolding through Zhou a junior diplomat from Wubei trying to secure peace and Haung a secretive member of the Jiin-Wei in Yaart. Both these characters face many problems which test their loyalties and strengths to breaking point and what's really intersting is how they both deal with their difficulties.
Initially there is a slow build up as we are introduced to the characters but soon it all kicks off.
The plot was really interested and was impossible to predict what was going to happen next which made it an exciting read.
In this cleverly crafted book you'll come across moments both funny and heart wrenching but beware nothing is what it seems either. There's no obvious good guy/bad guy and you'll find yourself sympathising with ll the characters through their good and bad actions.
All in all this is a very fast paced book where fate keeps the characters spinning wildly out of control.
July 11, 2016
A great self published fantasy novel. The setting is not your typical western fantasy which gives it something different and a sense of the magical in itself. Apart from that there are some fantastic fight scenes and some interesting magic systems. Well worth the read!
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews