I have been on a James Caine kick since receiving an ARC that introduced me to his twisty thrillers a few months ago. After finishing one of his books, I’m always wanting more, so this box set with 4 thrillers was perfect!! I loved that each story was very different from one another, so it didn’t feel like I was reading the same / similar themes.
The In-Laws: After a whirlwind romance and marriage, Chelsea meets her in-laws for the first time at their incredibly remote house in the woods. Aside from their seclusion, this starts out as what seems like a stereotypical Monster-in-Law story. I also really thought this was going to take some sort of Norma-Norman Bates turn, but instead it had a few twists that I truly wasn’t expecting! This was a good paced book, and the unsettling feeling it gives makes you want to keep on reading. I also liked the ending of this one as it wrapped things up nicely and felt well-concluded with an ending as happy as it could be.
The Boss: there are little tidbits throughout this that point to something nefarious happening, and it’s just enough to keep your attention, even though I felt this was a little slower of a book. This didn’t really bother me though because Caine does a great job at steadily building tension. The Boss is written in a first person narrative, and I do like how it alternated POVs, which made it easier to truly understand what the characters were feeling and the reasons behind it. Both Nicole and Alice are successful, ambitious women. Nicole is quite confident, manipulative, and has diabolical schemes that are motivated by her own selfishness, while Alice is a ball of anxiety and it seems a lot of her motivation stems from her insecurities and the way her father treated her as a child. As someone with anxiety, I get how easy it is to make a mountain out of a molehill, but also felt that it was super repetitive. Alice also constantly talks about how her husband doesn’t have a job, how lazy he is, etc. and all I could think is “why don’t you do something about it or leave?” which I know is easier said than done, it just was crazy to me that a woman as driven as Alice would put up with a man like Evan. While thrillers aren’t always the most believable, parts of this one were so far-fetched, such as how Nicole’s plan pans out and the incompetence of the police, that it made it kind of frustrating and ehh for me. Overall a decent read that steps beyond a typical “bad boss” story which sets it apart from other books with similar storylines, but not my favorite by Caine.
The Girl Outside: like most of his books, this is a really short, fast-paced read that is easy to finish in one sitting. While I figured I would’ve enjoyed the plot, I felt that this one wasn’t fully developed and it seemed kind of rushed. At times the story wasn’t flowing very well, almost like some words were left out. There were also some errors with character names that would distract from the story at times; for example, he wrote “Mandy sighed” when it should’ve been “Callie sighed”. The ending was also kind of abrupt and did not leave me satisfied; I felt that the ending could’ve been longer, especially since the book was already so short. I think almost every (if not every) James Caine book I’ve read has had an epilogue, so it was odd that this one didn’t, even though it may have helped strengthen the book. Unfortunately, I think this is the first book by Caine that I didn’t really enjoy a ton, even though it had so much potential.
Mother and Daughter: **some light
spoilers ahead** this was another quick read, and is a solid story if you are looking for a morally grey vigilante character. Sarah and Roger are a married couple that have been experiencing difficulties in their marriage. They usually try to keep this away from their four-year-old daughter, Gracie, but recently she was caught in the middle of a fight between the two of them where she almost got injured. As we see later in the book, she has also witnessed her father getting physical with her mother. Lately, Gracie has been attending preschool in an attempt to socialize her with other children while Sarah plans to return to work. She adores her teacher, Annie, and her teacher adores her right back…but maybe a little too much. Putting together hints that Gracie has shown in her art, the way she seems uncomfortable around her father, etc. Annie takes drastic measures to help Gracie. This storyline shows that you can’t always trust the people that you should be able to, due to the many secrets and actions of the characters. One thing I liked about this book is how clearly I was able to feel the characters emotions, from Sarah’s frustrations when others doubt her suspicions, Roger’s attempts to serve justice to a local pedophile that he believes took Gracie, and to Annie’s turmoil of the choices she makes. Of course, it was heart-wrenching to see Gracie’s parents go through her abduction, even though the reader knows where Gracie is. And you can’t help but feel bad for Annie. The ending was so good too, mainly with Sarah, and I liked the last little turn of events with Annie!! But, it did leave me wanting more unfortunately. Overall, I really enjoyed this book and thought it was an original plot that highlights the complexities of trauma, abuse, and definitely of the morally-grey area.
Thank you to James Caine and Book Sirens for this free ARC. I am leaving my review voluntarily.