What do you think?
Rate this book
Chateau of Secrets
Gis le Duchant guards a secret that could cost her her life. Tunnels snake through the hill under her family's medieval chateau in Normandy. Now, with Hitler's army bearing down, her brother and several friends are hiding in the tunnels, resisting the German occupation of France.
463 pages, Library Binding
First published May 13, 2014
262 people are currently reading
8872 people want to read
About the author
Melanie Dobson
50 books1,767 followersWriting fiction is a fun excuse for Melanie to explore ghost towns and old houses, travel to unusual places, and spend hours reading dusty books and journals. She writes both contemporary and historical fiction with threads of romance and suspense.
Melanie is the award-winning author of almost thirty time-slip, historical romance, suspense, and contemporary novels including Catching the Wind, The Winter Rose, and The Wings of Poppy Pendleton. Five of her novels including Chateau of Secrets have won Carol Awards, Catching the Wind won the Audie 2018 Inspirational Fiction award, and Love Finds You in Liberty, Indiana won Best Novel of Indiana. Catching the Wind and Memories of Glass were both finalists for Christy Awards in historical fiction.
Melanie and her husband, Jon, have two daughters. After moving numerous times with Jon's work, the Dobsons have finally settled near Portland, Oregon, and they love to travel and hike in both the mountains and the cliffs above the Pacific. When Melanie isn't writing or researching, she enjoys line dancing, biking, and making up stories with her kids.
More information about her and her books is available on her website at www.melaniedobson.com. You can also connect with Melanie at www.facebook.com/melaniedobsonfiction.
Melanie is the award-winning author of almost thirty time-slip, historical romance, suspense, and contemporary novels including Catching the Wind, The Winter Rose, and The Wings of Poppy Pendleton. Five of her novels including Chateau of Secrets have won Carol Awards, Catching the Wind won the Audie 2018 Inspirational Fiction award, and Love Finds You in Liberty, Indiana won Best Novel of Indiana. Catching the Wind and Memories of Glass were both finalists for Christy Awards in historical fiction.
Melanie and her husband, Jon, have two daughters. After moving numerous times with Jon's work, the Dobsons have finally settled near Portland, Oregon, and they love to travel and hike in both the mountains and the cliffs above the Pacific. When Melanie isn't writing or researching, she enjoys line dancing, biking, and making up stories with her kids.
More information about her and her books is available on her website at www.melaniedobson.com. You can also connect with Melanie at www.facebook.com/melaniedobsonfiction.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 464 reviews
January 1, 2016
Quickie review! This was my first novel by Melanie Dobson, and now I'm eager to get my hands on her previous books and her upcoming release. Rarely when I read a dual-time narrative do I find both sides of the story equaling compelling. Typically, in the face of the historical aspect, the contemporary storyline comes across as trite and anti-climactic, but here I thought the blend was terrific.
November 20, 2014
Other readers with similar tastes have read and enjoyed this. I recently read a book that was categorized as Christian Fiction and thought it was very enjoyable. I found the Christian in this fiction heavy handed and inconsistent throughout the story.
The story itself was compelling, unfortunately I found myself wishing a more experienced author had written the narrative. The characters in both the contemporary and historical settings came across as flat and one dimensional. The dialogue was very often stilted with the characters in the 1940s frequently avoiding the use of contractions, saying "I will search for her"; "I will get water for the children"; "What has happened to you?" Which didn't have a very authentic feel.
I think the suspense of discovering what happened in the past was minimized by the heavy foreshadowing in the contemporary storyline. Some of the revelations of what happened in the 1940s were obvious by the time they were revealed to the reader. Tying the reveals together more tightly would have made for a more exciting story.
I didn't find any of the romantic relationships realistic, nor did I find the characters' emotional progression toward those feeling or away from them, portrayed authentically. There was also a lot of innocence, ignorance and naiveté that I found difficult to believe. At one point the protagonist makes a declaration about what she cannot allow the Nazis to do (really?)and later realizes the Allied Powers might have to use force to remove the Nazis from her home. It seemed like she might have caught on to the way things worked after four years of war and occupation.
The narrator tells us about Gisele's fear of the Germans but I never felt her fear as I was reading her story. I felt the same about the other emotions the characters felt, there was more telling than showing.
I also didn't care for the storyline that included a near abortion and a father's remorse that led to his estrangement from the child. That felt like unnecessary melodrama and would have been better left out.
I was interested to learn there was a woman whose actions inspired this story and that an estimated 150,000 'Mischling' Jews who fought in the German Army after being "reclassified" as sufficiently Aryan or as having enough "German Blood".
This story was rich with potential, unfortunately there were many times when something exciting would happen and instead of fleshing out the conflict or the complex emotions that the characters would be feeling the focus was shifted to telling about the next event that occurred. This could have been a great story but the writing gets in the way.
The story itself was compelling, unfortunately I found myself wishing a more experienced author had written the narrative. The characters in both the contemporary and historical settings came across as flat and one dimensional. The dialogue was very often stilted with the characters in the 1940s frequently avoiding the use of contractions, saying "I will search for her"; "I will get water for the children"; "What has happened to you?" Which didn't have a very authentic feel.
I think the suspense of discovering what happened in the past was minimized by the heavy foreshadowing in the contemporary storyline. Some of the revelations of what happened in the 1940s were obvious by the time they were revealed to the reader. Tying the reveals together more tightly would have made for a more exciting story.
I didn't find any of the romantic relationships realistic, nor did I find the characters' emotional progression toward those feeling or away from them, portrayed authentically. There was also a lot of innocence, ignorance and naiveté that I found difficult to believe. At one point the protagonist makes a declaration about what she cannot allow the Nazis to do (really?)and later realizes the Allied Powers might have to use force to remove the Nazis from her home. It seemed like she might have caught on to the way things worked after four years of war and occupation.
The narrator tells us about Gisele's fear of the Germans but I never felt her fear as I was reading her story. I felt the same about the other emotions the characters felt, there was more telling than showing.
I also didn't care for the storyline that included a near abortion and a father's remorse that led to his estrangement from the child. That felt like unnecessary melodrama and would have been better left out.
I was interested to learn there was a woman whose actions inspired this story and that an estimated 150,000 'Mischling' Jews who fought in the German Army after being "reclassified" as sufficiently Aryan or as having enough "German Blood".
This story was rich with potential, unfortunately there were many times when something exciting would happen and instead of fleshing out the conflict or the complex emotions that the characters would be feeling the focus was shifted to telling about the next event that occurred. This could have been a great story but the writing gets in the way.
February 20, 2015
Fabulous marriage of current day and 1940s. This novel was based largely in France. It is so satisfying to read a novel that has an engaging storyline (I was equally drawn to Chloe's current day story as I was to Gisele's 1940s story) and educates me as well. I do not want to give anything away so will not share what I learned from reading this novel.
I highly recommend Chateau of Secrets for those who enjoyed The Butterfly and Violin by Kristy Cambron and Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay.
I highly recommend Chateau of Secrets for those who enjoyed The Butterfly and Violin by Kristy Cambron and Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay.
September 30, 2019
Another really good Melanie Dobson book.
Because of the bouncing back and forth between current day and 1940s Nazi occupied France, I got a bit muddled. But after backtracking a few times to get a better handle on who was who and how they fit into the picture, I began to really love the book.
It was sad to see how the Nazis took over people's homes, turning homeowners into servants, who were watched and even abused. But it was reality, and not something I’d fault the author for in her writing. She painted an authentic picture of what France endured, what the Jewish families suffered, and of loving people who took them in, including orphans, always with the hope the war would be over soon and life wouldn’t be so harsh.
It’s a story of Gisele, a woman whose father had just been killed, and whose brother hid in tunnels below their beloved chateau with a resistance group, foiling the Nazis at every chance, who had taken over the chateau as their headquarters. It’s a story of French who were conscripted into service or forced to aid the Nazis, all hoping the allies would soon rescue them from this sad life.
One such soldier, Josef, was half Jewish, but few knew it. To stay alive and care for his mother he had to work as a Nazi officer for the "leader" he hated. But in his mind his life was not in service to the Nazis, he was in service to God, praying to be of assistance where he could. He was there to stop Gisele from being raped by another German officer (which nearly turned out a bit too realistic). He saved her and helped her with false papers for herself and others on several occasions.
Never would she believe she'd fall in love with a German officer, but his good heart and helpful ways of saving people, including orphans, warmed her heart toward him...and, greatest of all... she trusted him. A German soldier!
Current day story is of Chloe, a woman whose family owned the chateau occupied by Nazis 70 years before. A journalist contacted her parents about an article on this area of France. Chloe accompanied him begrudgingly, but as they researched, and tromped all over the grounds and spoke with people who knew her grandmother, she found out so much more than she could ever believe.
Pieces were being put together for both Chloe and for the journalist, Riley Holtz. New, hard to believe information brought Chloe a new way to trust God to bring them through it.
Very well done book! I’d like to get the audiobook and go through it slowly next time.
Because of the bouncing back and forth between current day and 1940s Nazi occupied France, I got a bit muddled. But after backtracking a few times to get a better handle on who was who and how they fit into the picture, I began to really love the book.
It was sad to see how the Nazis took over people's homes, turning homeowners into servants, who were watched and even abused. But it was reality, and not something I’d fault the author for in her writing. She painted an authentic picture of what France endured, what the Jewish families suffered, and of loving people who took them in, including orphans, always with the hope the war would be over soon and life wouldn’t be so harsh.
It’s a story of Gisele, a woman whose father had just been killed, and whose brother hid in tunnels below their beloved chateau with a resistance group, foiling the Nazis at every chance, who had taken over the chateau as their headquarters. It’s a story of French who were conscripted into service or forced to aid the Nazis, all hoping the allies would soon rescue them from this sad life.
One such soldier, Josef, was half Jewish, but few knew it. To stay alive and care for his mother he had to work as a Nazi officer for the "leader" he hated. But in his mind his life was not in service to the Nazis, he was in service to God, praying to be of assistance where he could. He was there to stop Gisele from being raped by another German officer (which nearly turned out a bit too realistic). He saved her and helped her with false papers for herself and others on several occasions.
Never would she believe she'd fall in love with a German officer, but his good heart and helpful ways of saving people, including orphans, warmed her heart toward him...and, greatest of all... she trusted him. A German soldier!
Current day story is of Chloe, a woman whose family owned the chateau occupied by Nazis 70 years before. A journalist contacted her parents about an article on this area of France. Chloe accompanied him begrudgingly, but as they researched, and tromped all over the grounds and spoke with people who knew her grandmother, she found out so much more than she could ever believe.
Pieces were being put together for both Chloe and for the journalist, Riley Holtz. New, hard to believe information brought Chloe a new way to trust God to bring them through it.
Very well done book! I’d like to get the audiobook and go through it slowly next time.
July 8, 2021
Oh my goodness! This book deserves all the stars!! I might of had some tears in my eyes at the end. Highly recommend!
June 16, 2015
I loved this book!!! The story moves back and forth between Normandy, France during WWII and Normandy in the present day as the secrets of one family's involvement in the war are revealed and developed. I don't often cry at the end of a book but this one brought me to tears. I highly recommend this book!!!
September 7, 2023
I really absolutely loved this read - longstanding on my TBR. If I am telling the truth, the plot, the construction, the set up - nothing new or novel here. Exactly the same as all the WWII books. Dual timeline with aging dying grandparents with secrets, rescued children likely adopted, germans over-taking a castle, brave resistance fighters. Secret hideaways. Present day heroines with broken love affairs who seek to solve the truth of their grandparents histories and are intercontinentally whisked away to the setting. I mean we have all read this plenty of times, have we not?
And still I loved it. I couldn't put it down. I dropped everything to keep going. I even wept as the usual plot turned exactly as it always did. Maybe in a week it will take its place alongside the others, but for today, it has charmed me and gone straight to my heart. I think I liked the writing and the characters. I enjoyed the bravery, the spirit, and the story. And then the ending you know is coming, was no less sweet due to it being expected. It still touched my heart. I would be interested to see how long the feeling lasts. But for today, I am charmed.
And still I loved it. I couldn't put it down. I dropped everything to keep going. I even wept as the usual plot turned exactly as it always did. Maybe in a week it will take its place alongside the others, but for today, it has charmed me and gone straight to my heart. I think I liked the writing and the characters. I enjoyed the bravery, the spirit, and the story. And then the ending you know is coming, was no less sweet due to it being expected. It still touched my heart. I would be interested to see how long the feeling lasts. But for today, I am charmed.
July 19, 2023
Wow. 5 huge, glowing, sparkling stars!!!
Where do I begin?? Let's start with the cover... gorgeous, historical, gorgeous, and you want to go there immediately, and did I mention gorgeous?
This author and her writing.... she has a gift. I'm so glad she's using it and sharing it with us. You instantly feel like you're in that place and time. Plus, she is a master of the dual timeline and how the stories relate to each other. Wonderful writing!!
History....wowzer... I learned so much about World War 2 in this story. It's full of historical information. Reading about this part of history hurts my heart for all the unnecessary violence and killings that were done by a madman in charge. I'm so thankful for the people who stood up and resisted and fought for freedom from the evil that was there.
I don't want to accidentally give away any spoilers, so please read this for yourself. Highly recommend!!
Where do I begin?? Let's start with the cover... gorgeous, historical, gorgeous, and you want to go there immediately, and did I mention gorgeous?
This author and her writing.... she has a gift. I'm so glad she's using it and sharing it with us. You instantly feel like you're in that place and time. Plus, she is a master of the dual timeline and how the stories relate to each other. Wonderful writing!!
History....wowzer... I learned so much about World War 2 in this story. It's full of historical information. Reading about this part of history hurts my heart for all the unnecessary violence and killings that were done by a madman in charge. I'm so thankful for the people who stood up and resisted and fought for freedom from the evil that was there.
I don't want to accidentally give away any spoilers, so please read this for yourself. Highly recommend!!
August 14, 2021
“Chateau of Secrets” is a novel about the French Resistance and loosely based on the life of Genevieve de Saint Pern Menke, who risked her life to save downed Allied airmen during World War 2. There truly *was* a chateau in France, with tunnels underneath where Resistance fighters hid along with the airmen. You can see photos of the chateau on Melanie’s blog here: http://melaniedobson.com/research/res....
"Chateau of Secrets" is a dual story. Chloe, engaged to a up-and-coming gubernatorial candidate, plans a trip to France to uncover her grandmother’s story during the war. She finds a lot more than she bargained for! Discovering just prior to her trip that her fiance is not who she thought he was, Chloe is fleeing both her disillusionment and her own confusing personal motivations. Somewhat predictably (as far as the romantic element goes), she meets someone who helps her to not only regain trust, but also with sorting out her questions. And Chloe has lots of questions; questions about where God is in the hard times, and Who He really is. Can one truly begin over again, even after a history of failure and wrong decisions? Can we judge those who make choices that we would find unacceptable?
However, this is really not the main thrust of the novel. The novel focuses more on the questions Chloe struggles with in her search for the truth to her family’s secrets, why they felt they had to keep silent, and what motivates people in such times of stress and hardship to either resist, take courageous action, or to cooperate with a dangerous enemy.
There is plenty of suspense:
“A sound from one of the bins startled her, and she held her breath.
What if one of the entrances to the tunnel was in here? What if one of the members of France’s resistance stuck his head into a room filled with Germans? Surely none of them would be so stupid…
But they had no way of knowing the Nazis were here, on the other side of the wall.”
In reading reviews of “Chateau of Secrets”, I read that some readers took offence with the underlying message linked to Christianity in the book. I have to be honest here and say that I am not always happy with the overemphatic slant and all-too-predictable plots of contemporary Christian fiction. However, I was pleased to discover that this novel is anything but trite. The novel does include a Catholic convent, some courageous nuns and a chapel, all realistic parts of life in this village in France.
The author is not in the least offensive in her portrayals, but rather gives a picture to the reader of her characters both realistically in their beliefs and in their level of devotion. (This is wartime, remember? plenty of reason for some to, in desperation, turn to a God for help and solace in time of need.) There are also consequently questions Chloe has that, like in our day, simply go unanswered; the problem of good versus evil is a never-ending topic and one not solely explored in literature.
There is one scene in the book where the Christian faith is explained more fully, but it is not a chapter that to me should give the reader resentment, as it is simply a part of the story and Chloe’s inward searching.
After I wrote my own thoughts on this, I was pleased to find another review that seemed to affirm my own perspective:
'Religion plays a noticeable role in the story, but it flows naturally and is applied to the characters in very realistic ways. I abhor preachy fiction with a passion and was stunned at how effectively Dobson was able to utilize faith as a primary theme without pontificating. '
I enjoyed learning that there actually were Jewish soldiers that served in the Wehrmacht. That was eyeopening! I also like the way the courageous actions of Gisele and her brother Michel were written about. There is a somewhat slow build-up to this novel but it still kept me reading as I had to discover whether Adeline, the young Jewish baby, will be kept safe.
“What did your grandfather say about the resistance?” Riley asked.
My own questions resurfaced. I wished Grandpa had told me his stories before he passed away.
But I didn’t have to prove anything to Riley or the reporter in Richmond or to anyone else. Meme was proud of Henri Sauver’s military and then resistance record, and so was I. “My grandfather didn’t like to talk about the war.”
“I wonder why not,” he said.”
"Chateau of Secrets" is a dual story. Chloe, engaged to a up-and-coming gubernatorial candidate, plans a trip to France to uncover her grandmother’s story during the war. She finds a lot more than she bargained for! Discovering just prior to her trip that her fiance is not who she thought he was, Chloe is fleeing both her disillusionment and her own confusing personal motivations. Somewhat predictably (as far as the romantic element goes), she meets someone who helps her to not only regain trust, but also with sorting out her questions. And Chloe has lots of questions; questions about where God is in the hard times, and Who He really is. Can one truly begin over again, even after a history of failure and wrong decisions? Can we judge those who make choices that we would find unacceptable?
However, this is really not the main thrust of the novel. The novel focuses more on the questions Chloe struggles with in her search for the truth to her family’s secrets, why they felt they had to keep silent, and what motivates people in such times of stress and hardship to either resist, take courageous action, or to cooperate with a dangerous enemy.
There is plenty of suspense:
“A sound from one of the bins startled her, and she held her breath.
What if one of the entrances to the tunnel was in here? What if one of the members of France’s resistance stuck his head into a room filled with Germans? Surely none of them would be so stupid…
But they had no way of knowing the Nazis were here, on the other side of the wall.”
In reading reviews of “Chateau of Secrets”, I read that some readers took offence with the underlying message linked to Christianity in the book. I have to be honest here and say that I am not always happy with the overemphatic slant and all-too-predictable plots of contemporary Christian fiction. However, I was pleased to discover that this novel is anything but trite. The novel does include a Catholic convent, some courageous nuns and a chapel, all realistic parts of life in this village in France.
The author is not in the least offensive in her portrayals, but rather gives a picture to the reader of her characters both realistically in their beliefs and in their level of devotion. (This is wartime, remember? plenty of reason for some to, in desperation, turn to a God for help and solace in time of need.) There are also consequently questions Chloe has that, like in our day, simply go unanswered; the problem of good versus evil is a never-ending topic and one not solely explored in literature.
There is one scene in the book where the Christian faith is explained more fully, but it is not a chapter that to me should give the reader resentment, as it is simply a part of the story and Chloe’s inward searching.
After I wrote my own thoughts on this, I was pleased to find another review that seemed to affirm my own perspective:
'Religion plays a noticeable role in the story, but it flows naturally and is applied to the characters in very realistic ways. I abhor preachy fiction with a passion and was stunned at how effectively Dobson was able to utilize faith as a primary theme without pontificating. '
I enjoyed learning that there actually were Jewish soldiers that served in the Wehrmacht. That was eyeopening! I also like the way the courageous actions of Gisele and her brother Michel were written about. There is a somewhat slow build-up to this novel but it still kept me reading as I had to discover whether Adeline, the young Jewish baby, will be kept safe.
“What did your grandfather say about the resistance?” Riley asked.
My own questions resurfaced. I wished Grandpa had told me his stories before he passed away.
But I didn’t have to prove anything to Riley or the reporter in Richmond or to anyone else. Meme was proud of Henri Sauver’s military and then resistance record, and so was I. “My grandfather didn’t like to talk about the war.”
“I wonder why not,” he said.”
October 5, 2020
I loved this book—the mystery, the history and intrigue, the tunnels full of secrets snaking beneath a beautiful old chateau. I loved the scent and flavor of France, the characters’ resistance to Nazi domination and their determination to save those most vulnerable. Chateau of Secrets contrasts the greed and ugliness of human nature with its ability to rise above self and sacrifice so that others might live. A compelling and beautiful book.
July 8, 2015
This was a very intriguing book. I wasn't expecting both the WWII story as well as the present day one. Still it was good.
August 23, 2015
I thought this would be a fun book about people having romantical problems at war times. But buyer beware: this is a secret Jesus book. Leave it on the shelf.
May 27, 2019
Apart from
, this was the best WW2 book I've read to date. The author took me back to a time era, where you know what happened, still hope for different outcomes, and was able to highlight some interesting facts that I never knew, without being left depressed after reading this.
This dual-time story was quite different to others I've read - the past was written in 3rd person, the present in 1st person. At first I found it weird, but then later found it actually helped me know which voice I'm reading now.
On top of great a great historical story, the author included some mystery threads which kept me guessing and reading (most I guessed correctly). Then she also included two characters in the present time, Chloe, who had to find herself again through this journey, and Riley, who experienced God's salvation and redemption, but still had his own healing to do as well due to past mistakes.
People who love Narnia would appreciate the Narnia reference included in this story as well.
Highly recommended to fans of Historical fiction.
*There was some more mature content included - attempted rape, murder and some questionable choices one character made.
, this was the best WW2 book I've read to date. The author took me back to a time era, where you know what happened, still hope for different outcomes, and was able to highlight some interesting facts that I never knew, without being left depressed after reading this.This dual-time story was quite different to others I've read - the past was written in 3rd person, the present in 1st person. At first I found it weird, but then later found it actually helped me know which voice I'm reading now.
On top of great a great historical story, the author included some mystery threads which kept me guessing and reading (most I guessed correctly). Then she also included two characters in the present time, Chloe, who had to find herself again through this journey, and Riley, who experienced God's salvation and redemption, but still had his own healing to do as well due to past mistakes.
People who love Narnia would appreciate the Narnia reference included in this story as well.
Highly recommended to fans of Historical fiction.
*There was some more mature content included - attempted rape, murder and some questionable choices one character made.
May 13, 2019
Chateau of Sectrets
“I have no desire to be in a relationship for the sake of being in one,” he said. “I’ve made mistakes in the past, terrible ones. The next time I date a woman, I hope it’s for keeps.”
When I went to the library to pick up my reservation I was drawn to the WW2 bookstand. Before I knew it I found myselfs browsing through the books on the shelf. I felt an inner urge to read a book that took place during the Second World War. With the 5th of may right around the corner, the timing feels right. Every year before our independance day I feel like reading a historical fiction set during the war. This year included. It was not the reason I came to the library, but I am glad I went. This book got my attention and (ofcourse) I HAD tot bring it home with me.
I loved the book a lot! The story is very interesting and well written. Gisele is such a powerful woman, a real inspiration. It was an honor to read her story.
“I have no desire to be in a relationship for the sake of being in one,” he said. “I’ve made mistakes in the past, terrible ones. The next time I date a woman, I hope it’s for keeps.”
When I went to the library to pick up my reservation I was drawn to the WW2 bookstand. Before I knew it I found myselfs browsing through the books on the shelf. I felt an inner urge to read a book that took place during the Second World War. With the 5th of may right around the corner, the timing feels right. Every year before our independance day I feel like reading a historical fiction set during the war. This year included. It was not the reason I came to the library, but I am glad I went. This book got my attention and (ofcourse) I HAD tot bring it home with me.
I loved the book a lot! The story is very interesting and well written. Gisele is such a powerful woman, a real inspiration. It was an honor to read her story.
May 13, 2014
I have changed the rating between 4 and 5 a number of times so I think it is a safe assumption that it is definitely more than a 4 star book but doesn't quite reach a 5 star for me. The push to a 5 star is simply that it didn't move me so completely on a literary level. It's strong, just not that the 5 star strong. But close.
The book is loosely based on a woman who lived near Normandy during the German occupation. She lived in a family chateau and some of the experiences described are true events. The chateau was built over hidden tunnels where she hid people and helped in the resistance effort.
See the rest of this review: http://amusingreviews.blogspot.com/20...
The book is loosely based on a woman who lived near Normandy during the German occupation. She lived in a family chateau and some of the experiences described are true events. The chateau was built over hidden tunnels where she hid people and helped in the resistance effort.
See the rest of this review: http://amusingreviews.blogspot.com/20...
July 4, 2014
What an amazing story--based in part on a real person and events--best book I've read for awhile! It will keep you up late just to see what happens and how the mystery unfolds. This is a must-read for anyone interested in WW2 especially, or who just enjoys a good adventure with human interest, and a small side of romance. Once you've read it, check out the author's blog for photos and more info on the person who inspired the book. 5+ stars!
http://melaniedobson.blogspot.com/201...
http://melaniedobson.blogspot.com/201...
November 15, 2015
I was just looking for a good, quick historical fiction to get my mind off work stress. I should have taken a proper look at the tags for this one. Little did I know, it's historical/christian fiction. My oh my, is this ever dripping with Conservative bile. But quite frankly, I could've handled the Christian nonsense if the book was well written. Sadly, it it not. Shame.
April 28, 2016
Beautiful. Can't recommend enough.
November 16, 2014
I enjoyed the WWII story line more than the modern story, which was very predictable. The religious aspect was too heavy handed for me.
February 17, 2018
Life was a challenge for Gisele during World War Two when the German Nazis invaded her country and moved into her chateau. Since her brother was fighting with the French Resistance, and her own concern for the Jewish children in her community, it was essential she keeps her secrets undercover.
Years later, Gisele's granddaughter, Chloe, returned to France to investigate her heritage. She discovers that her grandmother's secrets were more surprising than Chloe had expected. I loved the combined stories of Gisele and Chloe and was delighted when the book came to a satisfying conclusion.
Years later, Gisele's granddaughter, Chloe, returned to France to investigate her heritage. She discovers that her grandmother's secrets were more surprising than Chloe had expected. I loved the combined stories of Gisele and Chloe and was delighted when the book came to a satisfying conclusion.
January 18, 2015
Reviewed at The Power of Words: http://tinyurl.com/p32rnca
Chateau of Secrets by Melanie Dobson is an epic story, told by a masterful storyteller. Every essential element is present: rich characterization, historical detail, multilayered plots, lyrical writing that flows across the page, an emotional and gripping narrative. This is also a compelling and relevant story, with a message that calls out to us today. My attention was captured and held from the very first page. Whenever I come across a novel like this, my only problem is in writing a review that comes close to doing it justice.
Chateau of Secrets is set in the medieval Château d’Agneaux on jagged cliffs above the River Vire, close to the northern French town of Saint-Lo, and is loosely based on the courage and faith of a real life French noblewoman. Melanie has a gift for seamlessly weaving past and present together between Gisèle Duchant during the Nazi occupation of France, to her granddaughter, Chloe Sauver, in today's time. This is the second excellent story I've read recently that used this literary vehicle, and I loved how the contemporary storyline gave me a much-needed breather from the emotional depth and suspense of World War II.
Gisèle, a French war heroine, is a strong character that readers will love. With a devout faith, as well as passion and purpose that included helping her brother Michel and the resistance cell, I couldn't help but admire and be drawn to her. Gisèle was driven to rescue, even when the enemy was determined to destroy.
Chloe, Gisèle's granddaughter, found herself engaged to an ambitious political candidate, only to be used as a campaign pawn in order to get elected. Chloe "felt a bit like a broken gift hidden under pretty paper and a bow." Riley, with his WWII heritage, was intrigued as to what sacrifices people were willing to make in order to protect themselves and those they loved: "It tells a lot about a person when you find out what or who they're willing to die for."
At the heart of this story are its spiritual themes, relevancy, and even challenges for us today. God uses ordinary, often unexpected people to carry out His will. It's a book about secrets - secret tunnels, secret identities, secret motives. Gisèle questions as to how a secret could destroy, yet it could also shield a family. "When did a secret cross over the gray wasteland between protecting one you loved and destroying him?"
But the theme that hit the hardest is drawn from Jesus' words, "Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you." As she wrestles with this teaching, Gisèle reflects: "When was she supposed to love her enemy and when was she supposed to resist? And somehow, in the great mystery of faith, was it possible for her to do both?" Her conclusion - and maybe ours as well? Pray, but also fight against evil. I'd like to end with these touching thoughts from Gisèle:
"Was it possible to love your enemy even as you hated - as you battled - the wrong that drove them? Perhaps that was what Jesus did on the cross. He forgave those who killed Him and yet in his death, He defeated the sin that blinded them."
Chateau of Secrets is an extremely entertaining and moving story that earns my highest recommendation - and will be on my "best of the best" list for this year's reading.
Thank you to Howard Publishing for providing an electronic ARC of this book through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Chateau of Secrets by Melanie Dobson is an epic story, told by a masterful storyteller. Every essential element is present: rich characterization, historical detail, multilayered plots, lyrical writing that flows across the page, an emotional and gripping narrative. This is also a compelling and relevant story, with a message that calls out to us today. My attention was captured and held from the very first page. Whenever I come across a novel like this, my only problem is in writing a review that comes close to doing it justice.
Chateau of Secrets is set in the medieval Château d’Agneaux on jagged cliffs above the River Vire, close to the northern French town of Saint-Lo, and is loosely based on the courage and faith of a real life French noblewoman. Melanie has a gift for seamlessly weaving past and present together between Gisèle Duchant during the Nazi occupation of France, to her granddaughter, Chloe Sauver, in today's time. This is the second excellent story I've read recently that used this literary vehicle, and I loved how the contemporary storyline gave me a much-needed breather from the emotional depth and suspense of World War II.
Gisèle, a French war heroine, is a strong character that readers will love. With a devout faith, as well as passion and purpose that included helping her brother Michel and the resistance cell, I couldn't help but admire and be drawn to her. Gisèle was driven to rescue, even when the enemy was determined to destroy.
Chloe, Gisèle's granddaughter, found herself engaged to an ambitious political candidate, only to be used as a campaign pawn in order to get elected. Chloe "felt a bit like a broken gift hidden under pretty paper and a bow." Riley, with his WWII heritage, was intrigued as to what sacrifices people were willing to make in order to protect themselves and those they loved: "It tells a lot about a person when you find out what or who they're willing to die for."
At the heart of this story are its spiritual themes, relevancy, and even challenges for us today. God uses ordinary, often unexpected people to carry out His will. It's a book about secrets - secret tunnels, secret identities, secret motives. Gisèle questions as to how a secret could destroy, yet it could also shield a family. "When did a secret cross over the gray wasteland between protecting one you loved and destroying him?"
But the theme that hit the hardest is drawn from Jesus' words, "Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you." As she wrestles with this teaching, Gisèle reflects: "When was she supposed to love her enemy and when was she supposed to resist? And somehow, in the great mystery of faith, was it possible for her to do both?" Her conclusion - and maybe ours as well? Pray, but also fight against evil. I'd like to end with these touching thoughts from Gisèle:
"Was it possible to love your enemy even as you hated - as you battled - the wrong that drove them? Perhaps that was what Jesus did on the cross. He forgave those who killed Him and yet in his death, He defeated the sin that blinded them."
Chateau of Secrets is an extremely entertaining and moving story that earns my highest recommendation - and will be on my "best of the best" list for this year's reading.
Thank you to Howard Publishing for providing an electronic ARC of this book through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
May 17, 2016
Melanie Dobson weaves together two storylines in the Chateau of Secrets, the modern day and a tale of seventy-years ago. Our modern day tale is centered around Chloe Salvare, a school teacher that has just had her world tossed upside down and her hunt to figure out what happened at her families Château during WWII. Chloe wonders what transpired that has kept her grandmother's lips (Gisèle aka Mémé) sealed for so long and her father scared to go back.
I found the present day story of Chloe's life to be a bit predictable, and wished we could spend more time in Mémé's world during WWII. Both storylines stand on their own, just as they also complement each other. I, by the simple nature of enjoying history, am more compelled by the historical aspect of Gisèle's story. Gisèle is the star of the story, you will easily find yourself rooting for her and her efforts during the German occupation of not only her homeland but her home. Gisele highlights the stories of love, courage and sacrifice that faced those left behind to serve the Nazi's. She is forced to understand how and why someone might choose to march to Hitler's orders rather than stand and fight.
Dobson drew inspiration from the real life of Genevieve de Saint Pern Menke and her efforts during the war at the Château d’Agneaux. Visit Dobson's blog for a few pictures of Genevieve, the Château and a synopsis of the real inspiration. Gisèle is very strong and unwavering in her faith as she fights to live and lives to fight each day. Chloe on the other hand needs to find a balance in her life, what is her heart of hearts telling her about the new future she must choose.
FTC disclosure: I received an unedited advanced reader copy of this book to review from the publisher Howard Books a division of Simon & Schuster. I was not financially compensated by the publisher, Edelweiss or the author. (via Edelweiss).
Adapted from my original review posted at Plethora of Books Blog, see full review on blog.
I found the present day story of Chloe's life to be a bit predictable, and wished we could spend more time in Mémé's world during WWII. Both storylines stand on their own, just as they also complement each other. I, by the simple nature of enjoying history, am more compelled by the historical aspect of Gisèle's story. Gisèle is the star of the story, you will easily find yourself rooting for her and her efforts during the German occupation of not only her homeland but her home. Gisele highlights the stories of love, courage and sacrifice that faced those left behind to serve the Nazi's. She is forced to understand how and why someone might choose to march to Hitler's orders rather than stand and fight.
Dobson drew inspiration from the real life of Genevieve de Saint Pern Menke and her efforts during the war at the Château d’Agneaux. Visit Dobson's blog for a few pictures of Genevieve, the Château and a synopsis of the real inspiration. Gisèle is very strong and unwavering in her faith as she fights to live and lives to fight each day. Chloe on the other hand needs to find a balance in her life, what is her heart of hearts telling her about the new future she must choose.
FTC disclosure: I received an unedited advanced reader copy of this book to review from the publisher Howard Books a division of Simon & Schuster. I was not financially compensated by the publisher, Edelweiss or the author. (via Edelweiss).
Adapted from my original review posted at Plethora of Books Blog, see full review on blog.
June 30, 2014
A courageous young noblewoman risks her life to hide French resistance fighters; seventy years later, her granddaughter visits the family’s abandoned chateau and uncovers shocking secrets from the past.
Dobson seamlessly weaves two interconnecting narratives of the past and the present. Two wonderfully strong and independent female protagonists spotlighted, leaving the audience in awe of their courage, grace and poise.
Gisele exemplified courage amidst her fear and risked her life for her county, countrymen, allies, family and the innocent. Her faith and hope kept her going through the adversity she faced. Amazing woman with an impressive story to tell. As her story fell together piece by piece you appreciate her efforts along with Josef/Henri and countless others taking monumental risks as well as putting their lives in grave danger to spare others. Emotional story with a compelling character.
Chloe mirrors her grandmother in strength, courage and poise. Despite her story being a tad predictable, suspense was held as she unraveled the silken thread of her family's unanswered questions underneath the dark shadow of WWII.
Usually in the case of split narratives one story plays dominate to the audience, however, I found both stories equal. The past and the present merged together in such a complimentary way enhancing the entire narrative and characters. Numerous twists side by side with suspense and the emotional pull make this a page turner.
Dobson approached aspects of WWII not commonly addressed, masterfully blending faith, hope and religious interjections in all the correct locations without losing control. A fabulous story depicting WWII with messages of family, endless sacrifices and love. Highly recommend Chateau of Secrets, Dobson forged an emotional and memorable narrative along with endearing characters.
Dobson seamlessly weaves two interconnecting narratives of the past and the present. Two wonderfully strong and independent female protagonists spotlighted, leaving the audience in awe of their courage, grace and poise.
Gisele exemplified courage amidst her fear and risked her life for her county, countrymen, allies, family and the innocent. Her faith and hope kept her going through the adversity she faced. Amazing woman with an impressive story to tell. As her story fell together piece by piece you appreciate her efforts along with Josef/Henri and countless others taking monumental risks as well as putting their lives in grave danger to spare others. Emotional story with a compelling character.
Chloe mirrors her grandmother in strength, courage and poise. Despite her story being a tad predictable, suspense was held as she unraveled the silken thread of her family's unanswered questions underneath the dark shadow of WWII.
Usually in the case of split narratives one story plays dominate to the audience, however, I found both stories equal. The past and the present merged together in such a complimentary way enhancing the entire narrative and characters. Numerous twists side by side with suspense and the emotional pull make this a page turner.
Dobson approached aspects of WWII not commonly addressed, masterfully blending faith, hope and religious interjections in all the correct locations without losing control. A fabulous story depicting WWII with messages of family, endless sacrifices and love. Highly recommend Chateau of Secrets, Dobson forged an emotional and memorable narrative along with endearing characters.
May 5, 2014
This is my first book by Melanie Dobson and I have to say that I was very impressed. I love dual time period stories, this one alternated between World War II and present day. This story had me engaged right from the beginning, the authors writing style made it easy to get lost in this saga. There is a lot going on here, drama, mystery, suspense, romance, deception and secrets to name just a few.
Beginning when France is invaded by the Germans we meet Gisele Duchant, a brave and caring young woman who is forced into the role of host to the Germans when her home is taken over by them. As you can tell from the synopsis above she was keeper of secrets that once revealed had the power to destroy. Fast forward 70 years and her granddaughter, Chloe Salvare visits the chateau and uncovers pieces of her family's past that are shocking.
The transition between the two time periods was easy to follow and usually had me wanting to read more, love little cliffhangers. It was easy to get acquainted with Gisele and Chloe during this book and was a little glum to have to bid them farewell, in my opinion that means the author did her job in creating characters and a story to leave this kind of affect on her readers. Well done Melanie Dobson, I will be on the lookout for more of your books.
This book reminded me of Kate Morton, who is one of my favorite authors, and will appeal to those that like HF taking place in France and during WWII.
Beginning when France is invaded by the Germans we meet Gisele Duchant, a brave and caring young woman who is forced into the role of host to the Germans when her home is taken over by them. As you can tell from the synopsis above she was keeper of secrets that once revealed had the power to destroy. Fast forward 70 years and her granddaughter, Chloe Salvare visits the chateau and uncovers pieces of her family's past that are shocking.
The transition between the two time periods was easy to follow and usually had me wanting to read more, love little cliffhangers. It was easy to get acquainted with Gisele and Chloe during this book and was a little glum to have to bid them farewell, in my opinion that means the author did her job in creating characters and a story to leave this kind of affect on her readers. Well done Melanie Dobson, I will be on the lookout for more of your books.
This book reminded me of Kate Morton, who is one of my favorite authors, and will appeal to those that like HF taking place in France and during WWII.
September 18, 2016
When you buy a book and then get 2/3 of the way through it and realize it's "Christian historical fiction". Ugh. It wasn't even good at the end. The first two parts were fine. The 3rd the Christianity just seemed shoved in there and heavy handed where it hasn't been the first part. The conflict also resolved super quickly. So disappointing. If the plot had been better I could forgive it the Jesus. But, I have to say, this is the 2nd book of Christian fiction I've accidentally bought and both were terribly written. So perhaps Jesus should make his writers, you know, better at it? If they want me to read their books.
I give it 3 stars cause I did like the first two parts of it and I did finish it.
I give it 3 stars cause I did like the first two parts of it and I did finish it.
April 5, 2021
As always, author Melanie Dobson has written a beautiful WWII story showcasing the incredible bravery of ordinary men and women who made extraordinary differences in our world. Before this story, I knew little about the Jewish men who served in the Wehrmacht during the war. I found this to be a fascinating historical aspect.
The movement between a modern day story and the time of the war in France is smooth and brings this story alive as the details weave together to connect the past and present. This novel is very well done and offers vivid descriptions, deep emotions, romance, faith and historic significance. I highly recommend this novel to other readers who enjoy time slip novels and WWII fiction.
The movement between a modern day story and the time of the war in France is smooth and brings this story alive as the details weave together to connect the past and present. This novel is very well done and offers vivid descriptions, deep emotions, romance, faith and historic significance. I highly recommend this novel to other readers who enjoy time slip novels and WWII fiction.
February 27, 2017
For anyone intrigued by the bravery resistance fighters maintained during World War II, this book will prove highly satisfying. A rich, suspenseful story brings that time of tribulation to light, while romance touches it with emotion. Moving between contemporary and historical plots adds a great deal of perplexity and context. A recommended read.
May 20, 2014
Fabulous read! Review pending.
December 29, 2018
Way better than average Christian fiction. A real page-turner about a young French woman and her private battle against the Nazis during WWII.
July 28, 2021
Holy Hannah this audiobook was absolutely amazing! I enjoyed every moment of this WWII historical fiction.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 464 reviews