3.5⭐s
A perfect summer read! As long as you don’t mind frenemies. Holy moly this book smacked Fire Island upside the head. Not sure if this book has nationwide appeal with it’s insight into the inner workings of summers on Long Island but it certainly piqued this reader’s interest. I read it in one day!
Let me admit to having experience with spending summers on Fire Island during my youth, and this probably added to my enjoyment of the exaggerated characters and gossipy vibe. Although some serious points were thrown into the mix too. The story of Theo marrying into the group hints at Fire Island's real dirty little secret. Anyone with money can rent/buy a house in Southampton; Fire Island however, was a kingdom unto itself - ultra exclusive. It is extremely hard to buy a house on Fire Island. They stay within families for generations. No joke. Which builds a very insular and unique society made up of families anointing themselves local royalty, mixing with the uber wealthy, along with plenty of pretty young men & women who flock there for the summer. And here is where our story begins…
Sam and Jason are the main characters - one being raised by wealthy parents in a volatile marriage and very insecure, and the other kid becoming jealous of his friend’s wealth and privilege. We meet their eventual spouses - Jen and Lauren. Their friend network of two other acceptable couples (Brian & Lisa and Paul & Emily) along with singletons, bitter Rachel and tennis pro Robert. We also meet the local social network, consisting of the older generation (Susan and Larry), younger generation (Micah) and the rivals of our fun little backbiting crew (Beth, Jeannette, et al). It sounds like a lot to keep track of but it’s easy to follow along as each one gets to narrate and present their view of summer about the same people. It's a zippy read. The characters are stereotypes, but we all know a person who holds the power of gossip, a person who never got over their first love, one who is jealous of what others have, one who loves to call others out for trivial transgressions, and on and on. And yet, the story did not follow a formula. These little unexpected turns kept this over-the-top tale interesting instead of too much.
It would have been nice to have more “good” characters but that title warned us . . .
We learn about country club shenanigans, local pettiness, marriages imploding, affairs, and it veers into what I thought was going to be an eat-the-rich type story, but even with its reality tv type plot, this story manages to invoke some character introspection. Why do certain characters, in this awesome foursome of couples, have healthier marriages despite the same or worse issues? Is money the root of all evil? Is all cheating the same? I revised my opinion of the main four characters by the end. Also felt Micah was wasted as a character and should have been used to greater effect.
Think Bravo TV Reunion episode. Popcorn reading but with lots of half-popped kernels of truth in there too. You need to get to the end to appreciate them. Some readers might not make it, but keep going. It's worth it. The end changed everything . . . and nothing!
I recommend reading this sordid tale while poolside, with a drink. And then picking the characters apart afterward. I mean, the cover does show the characters are the target.