First Sentence: We all make mistakes, all of the time.
In 1997, Brighton was on the hunt for a serial, stranger rapist. The perpetrator was never caught but the rapes suddenly stopped. Twelve years later, stranger rapes are happening again. The common thread is shoes; the victims all share a love for expensive, designer shoes which are used in their rape and taken from them. DS Roy Grace leads the team hunting down “The Shoe Man,” while awaiting the birth of his first child and still trying to solve the disappearance ten years ago of his first wife, Sandy.
What has happened to Peter James? I very much liked his first four books but suddenly, with his last book, found myself skimming through it, being bored. I had so hoped this sixth entry would return me to the author I originally enjoyed. It didn’t.
Hook/Tension: The book starts off very well. One skill Mr. James has not lost is the ability to create tension and suspense and convey fear. That did hold true throughout the book.
Setting/Sense of Place/Dialogue: Where was this book set? I had to keep reminding myself that James is a British author as the sense of place was so weak. The story could have been set in any city. While I wasn't looking for characters speaking in Cockney, only the occasionally British expression kept me on track. The dialogue, however, was not bad as it flowed well.
Characters/Character Development: There were a lot of characters. This would be natural for a major police investigation. We are told who they are and, perhaps, their attribute or failing, but we never get to know most of them. The majority of characters are one-dimensional. Even Grace; aside from repeated reminders of how much in love he is with his new wife, we see very little depth to his character. For all of Grace’s declarations of love for Cleo, women are not well treated by the author. None of them, including Cleo, are very interesting or intellectually appealing as characters although one of the victims was wonderfully gutsy. For the suspects, however, we are shown what has caused them to be as they are; I did find that a strong point of the book. It is not an easy thing for an author to turn a suspect of a vile and violent crime into a somewhat sympathetic character.
Plot/Flow/Quality of Writing/Originality: Considering stranger rape is very rare in itself, the odds of more than one man with the same fetish operating at the same time are incredibly low. While it did add to the suspense and made for an interesting ending, it also raised the implausibility level to a point which diminished the plot. A device I’m seeing more frequently is that of dual time periods. There is a time when that works. In this case, I felt it more bloated the story to the point where I nearly stopped reading. It’s enough to read about numerous rapes during one time period; doubling that number became repetitive rather than suspenseful. The same is true of the secondary story line regarding the disappeared first wife. It doesn’t go anywhere or enhance the story in any way. Rather, it’s the massive imperfection on someone’s face at which you can’t help but look but it serves no purpose. The chapters are short, the time changes frequently as does the point of view, all of which leads to a choppy, fragmented read with no flow.
Originality: This is a story which has been told before. There was no real originality to the plot, but there were some interesting bits. I did appreciate the good detail of procedural investigation and the handling of rape victims and appreciated Grace’s awareness of the impact of rape on its victims.
The opening sentence begins with “We all make mistakes…” This book, in my view, was one of them. It wasn’t a complete disaster. I did finish it, albeit with difficulty, and there were some good points to it. Unfortunately these were overwhelmed by its weaknesses. Had the book been at least 200 pages shorter, focused only on the present with references to the events of the past, had fewer and better developed characters and a strong sense of place it might have stood with James earlier books. However, this being the second of his books I’ve found very disappointing, it will probably be the last of his I read.
DEAD LIKE YOU (Pol Proc-DS Roy Grace-England-Cont) – Poor
James, Peter – 6th in series
Minotaur Books, ©2010, ARC – Hardcover ISBN: 9780312642822