I really enjoyed this book when it released in 2008, and I enjoyed it again. Mia is a funny, likable character with a strong narrative voice, and I really appreciate the focus on her family dynamics and the relationships she has with her parents and older brothers. Just like the first book, this one also weaves in relatable elements to Mia's family's financial situation. The story resolves her skating-related financial dilemmas in a realistic and hopeful way while also honoring the very real constraints that working class families face when trying to help their kids follow their dreams.
The story also delves more into Mia's relationship with her coach, tensions related to a mean girl from the skating club, and the challenges of her first major competition. The book is very realistic, and I appreciate how it provides a more nuanced view of the mean girl and why she behaves the way that she does, without excusing her behavior. The book provides positive modeling for a variety of issues without being preachy, and the descriptions of skating are wonderful. The author defines technical language clearly, describes the competition in a suspenseful way, and gives a deep sense of why Mia finds so much joy on the ice.
I really enjoyed this book, and I'm glad that American Girl designed and released this character. Even though a lot of the Girl of the Year books are pretty shallow, this was one of the standout years with a character I will always appreciate and remember. I would definitely recommend both Mia books to people choosing which out-of-print American Girl titles to pursue for themselves or their child.