I'm from one of the sparsely populated areas of Canada, the province of Saskatchewan. An interesting thing - I can almost always tell if a person is a local or not, simply by hearing their pronounciation of the word.
I'm generalizing of course, as there will always be exceptions, but it's fairly consistent. And it reminds me of my favorite genre of book. I can usually tell an "insider" whom I'd consider a true science fiction fan just by hearing him speak. Does he say "science fiction", or does he say "sci-fi".
I admit I'm generalizing, but I've found that there are two main categories of science fiction fans. There are those that focus on the movies and television shows, and those that focus on the novels and short stories. The "sci-fi" folk are the mass media group, who may read 5-10 novels per year, but get the vast majority of their SF fix through movies and TV. And I, perhaps a bit of an SF snob, belong to the other group - I enjoy some of the movies and a rare bit of TV, but by far the majority of my time spent with SF is through reading books.
You'd think the two groups would be more closely linked. And yet I find a big difference. When you read a lot of SF (an awful lot), you start to get familiar with some of the conventions of the genre. And the movies are just not consistent with those norms. They get the science wrong, they get the aliens wrong (too human), they get the cultures wrong (too uniform within a planet), etc.
I have rarely found a movie that does what I'd call "true" science fiction right. I can usually find it in the books that I read.
I presume that if I were in the other group, I'd find that after watching tons of sci-fi movies, I'd be a bit disappointed in the books being so staid, and in their need to make things so complicated. Why can't we just blow things up (with nice bright explosions in space) and solve things that way? (Sorry, a bit of sarcasm there.)
So... now to this book. And to the reason why I rate this so highly. One of the authors is actually an actor who appeared regularly on Babylon 5 (a show I've never watched even once... sorry). So I expected a sci-fi romp, similar to a movie or television show. In fact, reading the blurb on the back made me think of the movie Galaxy Quest (which I loved, by the way), so the book seemed like it would not be my standard fare of SF reading material.
But I was overseas, shopping in Davao City Philippines (at Gaisano Mall, in case anybody knows the spot), and this was one of the few books in the entire used book shop that looked like it had any appeal. So I debated... and bought it for 80 pesos.
And started to read it on a whim as I flew back to Canada.
And wow.... I was immediately captivated. My first impression was that this book was VERY similar to Galaxy Quest. But this book came first.... Hmm...
And then the book got better, and better, and better. And more impressively: this book does science fiction right! The authors took the time to make sure that the science works within the accepted norms of the written science fiction genre. When the book discusses zero gravity, the authors find ways to describe it that make it so real - unlike the scenes I recall from most movies I've seen. The book even discusses some physics concepts as the background for its basic conflict between alien species (involving a famous cat who may or may not be dead), and gets the physics right. The book also uses nanotech in ways consistent with other big hard-SF writers such as Bear or Benford might employ. And the book goes to great lengths to explain that alien species should not be humanoid. More examples are possible, but you get the point.
But the book also seamlessly analyzes movie and television sci-fi as well. I learned a lot, and have a new respect for some of the story lines and titles discussed. Being produced for the masses (most of whom don't care about the nitpicking details with which I've concerned myself), they still nonetheless have something to say about our society and our times. And this book brings this out, again and again.
Wow... I really didn't expect a book that could be such an exciting read, and yet can sit so comfortably in any canonical realm of the science fiction genre.
As a novel - top marks once again. The characters were engaging. The plot was detailed and fast-moving. There was a twist at the end that I was maybe a bit disappointed with initially (thinking perhaps that it was a bit too neat), but then another twist was thrown in the last 8 pages that knocked me flat. So I had to re-evaluate, and admit that it was as satisfying and exciting an ending as I've read in a long while. Not too "Hollywood" at all...
I will definitely seek out more by the author William Keith, but apparently this is all that Peter Jurasik has produced.
Highly recommended!
(Genre fans will obviously get the most of this book - both SF and sci-fi fans! But new readers will also find this enlightening, so I encourage anybody who has any curiosity in science fiction to check this out, as it will educate you on Hollywood sci-fi while keeping you firmly within respectable confines of the written SF genre.)