What do you think?
Rate this book
A Noble Companion
Raid a dragon's hoard for her dowry? It seemed like a good idea at the time...
Madelena isn't in love with her friend Armando, but his marriage proposal offers the security she needs. She sympathizes with him—his father insists Armando must either find a bride or join the army. Armando would rather become a husband than a soldier, but his ugly face has scared away all other eligible ladies despite his family's wealth. Although she harbors only friendship for Armando, Madelena agrees to marry him on one condition: she insists on acquiring a dowry worthy of his family's noble standing in the land of Costa Nueva. But as a humble stablemaid, Madelena has no idea how to find such wealth. That's when the talking burro Terco mentions he's heard how to find a dragon’s treasure.
Javier, Armando’s younger brother, has loved Madelena in silence for years. When he learns of their impending marriage, he offers to help her find the treasure, even though succeeding may cost him the chance to spend his future with her. Together, they face a dangerous wilderness, a charming bandit, and a dragon’s lair, forcing Javier to confront his feelings and Madelena to re-evaluate her heart.
Madelena isn't in love with her friend Armando, but his marriage proposal offers the security she needs. She sympathizes with him—his father insists Armando must either find a bride or join the army. Armando would rather become a husband than a soldier, but his ugly face has scared away all other eligible ladies despite his family's wealth. Although she harbors only friendship for Armando, Madelena agrees to marry him on one condition: she insists on acquiring a dowry worthy of his family's noble standing in the land of Costa Nueva. But as a humble stablemaid, Madelena has no idea how to find such wealth. That's when the talking burro Terco mentions he's heard how to find a dragon’s treasure.
Javier, Armando’s younger brother, has loved Madelena in silence for years. When he learns of their impending marriage, he offers to help her find the treasure, even though succeeding may cost him the chance to spend his future with her. Together, they face a dangerous wilderness, a charming bandit, and a dragon’s lair, forcing Javier to confront his feelings and Madelena to re-evaluate her heart.
218 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 19, 2024
7 people are currently reading
182 people want to read
About the author
Rachel Kovaciny
26 books206 followersBorn only a few miles from where Jesse James robbed his first train, Rachel Kovaciny has loved the Old West all her life. She spends her days telling stories to her husband and their three homeschooled children. In her free time, Rachel writes a column on Old West history for the Prairie Times, reads, blogs, watches movies, and daydreams.
Visit www.rachelkovaciny.com to sign up for Rachel Kovaciny’s newsletter and receive a FREE copy of her Sleeping Beauty retelling, the novella The Man on the Buckskin Horse.
Visit www.rachelkovaciny.com to sign up for Rachel Kovaciny’s newsletter and receive a FREE copy of her Sleeping Beauty retelling, the novella The Man on the Buckskin Horse.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
November 23, 2024
When I first read this novella, I assumed it would be a straightforward, no magic, no fantasy, Western retelling. The type i most like. I have much difficulty getting into stories that throw a fantastical element in, because to me the Wild West is one of those places and times that don't really mesh well with magic. It already has a treasure trove of elements that make magic unnecessary to the plot.
Unless it's Native American. As it's indigenous to the land (and part of the treasure trove of elements I mentioned even when readers mightn't be conscious about it), it blends in well.
But European type of fantasy and magic? It's not something I appreciate seeing in Westerns. So, to me, the fantasy parts were the weak parts of this story.
Fortunately, they aren't overwhelming but toned down. But it's ever-present and not as contained by rules or explained as it should have. Of course, with a story this short, there wouldn't have been much room for worldbuilding, as the plot is narrow in terms of scope. The overall feel is like that of those native stories that just accept magic as is and don't bother to explain it; it simply exists.
Following Kovaciny's penchant for including peoples other than the usual WASP pioneers, this story has protagonists from an ethnicity rarely seen in Westerns: the Spanish. No, not Latinos. No, not Hispanics. S-p-a-n-i-s-h. Many people forget that large chunks of the US were colonies of Spain, and the descendants of those colonists exist, and are as Spanish-speaking and Catholic as your average Mexican. But they are white and don't like to be thrown in the same amorphous pile as Latinos for convenience. There were pockets of these Spanish that survived in isolated parts all over Latin America after independence from Spain, that didn't mix with the native population, so it's not a US-specific phenomenon at all.
Anyway, on to the story itself. It's about Magdalena's plight in search of a fabled dragon treasure she wants in order to be worthy of her rich intended, Armando. To this search she's accompanied by Armando's attractive brother, so you can already guess what happens, no? It's a very mainstream romance, with no surprises or unexpected turns. Maybe the only thing that will keep you trying to figure out is what exactly the "Ugly Duckling" resolution will be.
To be honest, I didn't see it. I am aware that the inspiration is very loose, so loose that you won't know it's supposed to be a retelling unless you are told, but there isn't a thematic coherence that would make you go "Ah! So this is how the ugly duckling becomes a swan." Because that moment is very on-the-nose and seems to be there because there needs to be something of the tale for this to be a retelling. Personally, I think a thematic retelling that didn't care about the tale's elements would've been better, because Javier is a much better candidate for an "ugly duckling" than Armando. Figuratively, because the "Ugly Duckling" fairy tale is a metaphor that goes both ways, physical and mental, and Armando is a hammered-in "ugly duckling" that goes for the physical fulfillment of the tale's requirements. Javier fulfills the requirements in the metaphorical sense much better, screw it that he's handsome. Even Magdalena is more of an "ugly duckling" figure than Armando, if you ask me.
It's all in the themes. With fairy tales, the Devil isn't in the details but in the themes.
By this point, you might be asking yourself if I liked this story. The answer is both yes and no, and that's not a cheat answer! I liked the characters of Magdalena and Javier, Rachel has always been excellent with characterisation, it's her gift as a writer and I love her stories because of that. I love that she's careful to be as accurate as possible about the language (she got the Spanish checked for accuracy) and about the historical facts. She is also good at inserting low-key humour, which for me is perfect because I have a bad track record with written humour. But I wasn't enthusiastic about the magical parts, didn't care about the burro and the dragon, I think they spoiled the fun for me and that there were ways to keep the plot mostly intact without those fantastical tidbits.
So, 3.5 stars it is, for Magdalena and Javier. Oh, all right, all right, and also for that smiling masked bandit that reminds me so much of Duncan Regehr's Don Diego de la Vega/Zorro. Growing up, I and my sisters used to pester our cousin by introducing her as "[coz's name] de la Vega" to people because she had a crush on Zorro. Good times, good times!
I received a free copy from the author with no obligation to review. This review is of my own volition.
Unless it's Native American. As it's indigenous to the land (and part of the treasure trove of elements I mentioned even when readers mightn't be conscious about it), it blends in well.
But European type of fantasy and magic? It's not something I appreciate seeing in Westerns. So, to me, the fantasy parts were the weak parts of this story.
Fortunately, they aren't overwhelming but toned down. But it's ever-present and not as contained by rules or explained as it should have. Of course, with a story this short, there wouldn't have been much room for worldbuilding, as the plot is narrow in terms of scope. The overall feel is like that of those native stories that just accept magic as is and don't bother to explain it; it simply exists.
Following Kovaciny's penchant for including peoples other than the usual WASP pioneers, this story has protagonists from an ethnicity rarely seen in Westerns: the Spanish. No, not Latinos. No, not Hispanics. S-p-a-n-i-s-h. Many people forget that large chunks of the US were colonies of Spain, and the descendants of those colonists exist, and are as Spanish-speaking and Catholic as your average Mexican. But they are white and don't like to be thrown in the same amorphous pile as Latinos for convenience. There were pockets of these Spanish that survived in isolated parts all over Latin America after independence from Spain, that didn't mix with the native population, so it's not a US-specific phenomenon at all.
Anyway, on to the story itself. It's about Magdalena's plight in search of a fabled dragon treasure she wants in order to be worthy of her rich intended, Armando. To this search she's accompanied by Armando's attractive brother, so you can already guess what happens, no? It's a very mainstream romance, with no surprises or unexpected turns. Maybe the only thing that will keep you trying to figure out is what exactly the "Ugly Duckling" resolution will be.
To be honest, I didn't see it. I am aware that the inspiration is very loose, so loose that you won't know it's supposed to be a retelling unless you are told, but there isn't a thematic coherence that would make you go "Ah! So this is how the ugly duckling becomes a swan." Because that moment is very on-the-nose and seems to be there because there needs to be something of the tale for this to be a retelling. Personally, I think a thematic retelling that didn't care about the tale's elements would've been better, because Javier is a much better candidate for an "ugly duckling" than Armando. Figuratively, because the "Ugly Duckling" fairy tale is a metaphor that goes both ways, physical and mental, and Armando is a hammered-in "ugly duckling" that goes for the physical fulfillment of the tale's requirements. Javier fulfills the requirements in the metaphorical sense much better, screw it that he's handsome. Even Magdalena is more of an "ugly duckling" figure than Armando, if you ask me.
It's all in the themes. With fairy tales, the Devil isn't in the details but in the themes.
By this point, you might be asking yourself if I liked this story. The answer is both yes and no, and that's not a cheat answer! I liked the characters of Magdalena and Javier, Rachel has always been excellent with characterisation, it's her gift as a writer and I love her stories because of that. I love that she's careful to be as accurate as possible about the language (she got the Spanish checked for accuracy) and about the historical facts. She is also good at inserting low-key humour, which for me is perfect because I have a bad track record with written humour. But I wasn't enthusiastic about the magical parts, didn't care about the burro and the dragon, I think they spoiled the fun for me and that there were ways to keep the plot mostly intact without those fantastical tidbits.
So, 3.5 stars it is, for Magdalena and Javier. Oh, all right, all right, and also for that smiling masked bandit that reminds me so much of Duncan Regehr's Don Diego de la Vega/Zorro. Growing up, I and my sisters used to pester our cousin by introducing her as "[coz's name] de la Vega" to people because she had a crush on Zorro. Good times, good times!
I received a free copy from the author with no obligation to review. This review is of my own volition.
January 17, 2025
4 stars, personally ✨ Christian Fiction - Fairytale Retelling
About this book:
“Raid a dragon's hoard for her dowry? It seemed like a good idea at the time...
Madelena isn't in love with her friend Armando, but his marriage proposal offers the security she needs. She sympathizes with him—his father insists Armando must either find a bride or join the army. Armando would rather become a husband than a soldier, but his ugly face has scared away all other eligible ladies despite his family's wealth. Although she harbors only friendship for Armando, Madelena agrees to marry him on one condition: she insists on acquiring a dowry worthy of his family's noble standing in the land of Costa Nueva. But as a humble stablemaid, Madelena has no idea how to find such wealth. That's when the talking burro Terco mentions he's heard how to find a dragon’s treasure.
Javier, Armando’s younger brother, has loved Madelena in silence for years. When he learns of their impending marriage, he offers to help her find the treasure, even though succeeding may cost him the chance to spend his future with her. Together, they face a dangerous wilderness, a charming bandit, and a dragon’s lair, forcing Javier to confront his feelings and Madelena to re-evaluate her heart.”
Series: Book #6 in the multi-author series, “Cornerstone”. It does not seem to be connected to any other books, however. A stand-alone novel. Click on the books to be taken to that review: Book #1, Book #2, and Book #3, Book #4!, and Book #5!
Spiritual Content- A few Scriptures are mentioned, remembered, & quoted; Many Prayers & Thanking God; God is called by the Spanish word ‘Dios’ in this book; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Mentions of Dios; Mentions of prayers, praying, blessings over food, & thanking God; Mentions of going to church/Mass, mission churches, Mass, & priests; A couple mentions of a cross necklace; A mention of Heaven; A mention of someone being a godsend; A mention of someone not being “conscientious enough” to become a priest; A mention of blessings;
*Note: When thanking Dios for a meal with meat in it, Madelena particularly thanks Him for creating animals “that did not speak or think, all of which He permitted to be eaten” and it’s added that “those were much different from the talking kinds of animals, the burros, horses, dogs, cats, and birds of prey which He had created as helpers to work for and with humans, not to be eaten by them.”; Madelena has a talking burro and he is with her on this journey to a dragon’s lair, plus two talking horses; A man talks to a bird in a language that Madelena and Javier don’t understand; Madelena talks to a dragon.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘dumb’, a ‘shut up’, and three ‘stupid’s; A mention of a curse (said, not written); Some sarcasm & eye rolling; Both Madelena and Javier eavesdrop on conversations; Madelena considers lying about not finding the treasure, but knows she couldn’t live with herself if she lied about it; Talking horses are unable to lie, but burros can bend or ignore the truth (which is why most duplicitous people use burros); Fighting, Being hit, Facing bandits, Being held at gun-point, Gunshots, & a Duel where someone could die and concern for the person (including imagining the person hurt or dead, up to semi-detailed); Seeing someone shot, a bad injury, pain, blood/bleeding, & giving someone stitches (up to semi-detailed); Seeing a burro attacked by a wildcat, the blood/injury, & shooting the wildcat (and later the dead body of the wildcat, up to semi-detailed); Killing a tick (up to semi-detailed); Javier has a bit of a temper and wishes to punch a man for his comments towards Madelena; Javier gives Madelena a cup of brandy to drink when she’s injured (she’s never had brandy before so he says she’s in a for “a real treat” and his parents enjoy sharing a brandy after supper every evening); A dragon threatens to eat Madelena and Javier or her burro (the dragon adds about the taste of the burro, but Madelena won’t give him her talking burro adding that she would never sell a talking creature to anyone who meant to eat it, barely-above-not-detailed); Many mentions of bandits, criminals, thieves, stealing, stolen items, being robbed, kidnappings, ransoms, being shot, & weapons; Mentions of deaths, grief, & fevers (Madelena’s parents); Mentions of a duel & the possibility of being killed (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of shooting, being shot at, & gunshots; Mentions of injuries, pain, stitches, & blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of alcohol (wine and brandy) & drinking (See comment above for a positive comment about parents drinking brady after supper); Mentions of ticks stuck on animals & the animal being harmed or dying because of it (up to semi-detailed); A few mentions of a bully; A few mentions of lies, lying, & liars; A few mentions of a dead wildcat’s body (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of the possibility of being drugged or poisoned; A couple mentions of a story about a bear attack and a wife having to sew her husband’s hair back on; A couple mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of hunting; A mention of a dead rodent; A mention of manure; A mention of vomit;
*Note: Madelena assumes a couple of times that people think less of her because of her being a stablemaid and that not being typical work for a woman; Javier says his oldest brother is selfish and spoiled.
Sexual Content- An almost kiss (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed), a barely-above-not-detailed kiss, and two semi-detailed kisses; Remembering a kiss & an almost kiss (barely-above-not-detailed); Wanting to kiss (barely-above-not-detailed); Glancing at another’s lips; Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Remembering Touches & Dancing (barely-above-not-detailed); Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); A bit of flirting; Madelena plans to marry Javier’s brother because of circumstances (marriage of convenience) even though they don’t love each other (she had come to expect that they would one day wed, so she had fed and nourished her affections for him, but still does not love him); A man flirts with Madelena which makes Javier jealous; Another man wants Javier to trade Madelena for a horse (which he doesn’t do); Mentions of kisses, hand kisses, possible kisses, & kissing; Mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of chaperones; Love, falling/being in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Madelena looks away from a shirtless man, but notices Javier tugging his shirt back on (barely-above-not-detailed); Madelena is “what others generally called “a solid girl”” and that “her shoulders and arms boasted the kinds of firm and useful muscles many young men would be proud to have. The kind that would drive most young women of Costa Nueva to wearing long sleeves or a shawl to hide them. But not Madelena Vela. She had gained her strength through honorable work, and she felt no need to hide it.”; Later, Madelena notes that she has “a woman’s curves” but they are “understated compared to her powerful shoulders”; Madelena wears a dress that “modestly covered her womanly curves while making sure they were shown off to their best advantage”; A few comments/thoughts from Madelena about decent women keeping their hair up as only a husband should be allowed the intimacy of seeing a woman’s hair down.
-Madelena Vela, age 22
-Javier Moncada, age 20
P.O.V. switches between them
188 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{ Those squeamish to blood/injuries might not enjoy scenes from this book, lower up to a full star for such readers. }
I have a new pitch for this book: Josefina American Girl Books + a little bit of Dora the Explorer with the quest for a dragon’s lair + the cutest unrequited love 🥹 + talking animals (which I typically don’t like, but it worked so well for this book?) + a little Love Comes Softly for the Western setting and a scene towards the end = I was pretty flabbergasted about this one. Which is so funny to me because out of those elements, if someone tried to sell that pitch to me, only the unrequited love and smitten MMC (he’s been reading books and learning all he can about establishing a successful business so he can build a home with her one day—my heart!) would have attracted me to this story. But it worked so well despite it being so different for me, oddly enough.
I will say that I didn’t quite get The Ugly Duckling story? Javier’s brother is known to not be good-looking, but he was mostly mentioned, and we didn’t see him much so I thought it was strange that he would be the ugly duckling.
There were a few parts that made me squirm that had to do with blood and injuries and animals, just as a heads up for those sensitive to that element. I’m usually not in books, but there were more details that I was expecting in this one about all of that.
When I first started reading this book and saw the talking animals, I thought it was interesting, but not really my normal read. Which it wasn’t. At all. But it ended up being such a fun wild card, if you will, and one I will be thinking of fondly!
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
About this book:
“Raid a dragon's hoard for her dowry? It seemed like a good idea at the time...
Madelena isn't in love with her friend Armando, but his marriage proposal offers the security she needs. She sympathizes with him—his father insists Armando must either find a bride or join the army. Armando would rather become a husband than a soldier, but his ugly face has scared away all other eligible ladies despite his family's wealth. Although she harbors only friendship for Armando, Madelena agrees to marry him on one condition: she insists on acquiring a dowry worthy of his family's noble standing in the land of Costa Nueva. But as a humble stablemaid, Madelena has no idea how to find such wealth. That's when the talking burro Terco mentions he's heard how to find a dragon’s treasure.
Javier, Armando’s younger brother, has loved Madelena in silence for years. When he learns of their impending marriage, he offers to help her find the treasure, even though succeeding may cost him the chance to spend his future with her. Together, they face a dangerous wilderness, a charming bandit, and a dragon’s lair, forcing Javier to confront his feelings and Madelena to re-evaluate her heart.”
Series: Book #6 in the multi-author series, “Cornerstone”. It does not seem to be connected to any other books, however. A stand-alone novel. Click on the books to be taken to that review: Book #1, Book #2, and Book #3, Book #4!, and Book #5!
Spiritual Content- A few Scriptures are mentioned, remembered, & quoted; Many Prayers & Thanking God; God is called by the Spanish word ‘Dios’ in this book; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Mentions of Dios; Mentions of prayers, praying, blessings over food, & thanking God; Mentions of going to church/Mass, mission churches, Mass, & priests; A couple mentions of a cross necklace; A mention of Heaven; A mention of someone being a godsend; A mention of someone not being “conscientious enough” to become a priest; A mention of blessings;
*Note: When thanking Dios for a meal with meat in it, Madelena particularly thanks Him for creating animals “that did not speak or think, all of which He permitted to be eaten” and it’s added that “those were much different from the talking kinds of animals, the burros, horses, dogs, cats, and birds of prey which He had created as helpers to work for and with humans, not to be eaten by them.”; Madelena has a talking burro and he is with her on this journey to a dragon’s lair, plus two talking horses; A man talks to a bird in a language that Madelena and Javier don’t understand; Madelena talks to a dragon.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘dumb’, a ‘shut up’, and three ‘stupid’s; A mention of a curse (said, not written); Some sarcasm & eye rolling; Both Madelena and Javier eavesdrop on conversations; Madelena considers lying about not finding the treasure, but knows she couldn’t live with herself if she lied about it; Talking horses are unable to lie, but burros can bend or ignore the truth (which is why most duplicitous people use burros); Fighting, Being hit, Facing bandits, Being held at gun-point, Gunshots, & a Duel where someone could die and concern for the person (including imagining the person hurt or dead, up to semi-detailed); Seeing someone shot, a bad injury, pain, blood/bleeding, & giving someone stitches (up to semi-detailed); Seeing a burro attacked by a wildcat, the blood/injury, & shooting the wildcat (and later the dead body of the wildcat, up to semi-detailed); Killing a tick (up to semi-detailed); Javier has a bit of a temper and wishes to punch a man for his comments towards Madelena; Javier gives Madelena a cup of brandy to drink when she’s injured (she’s never had brandy before so he says she’s in a for “a real treat” and his parents enjoy sharing a brandy after supper every evening); A dragon threatens to eat Madelena and Javier or her burro (the dragon adds about the taste of the burro, but Madelena won’t give him her talking burro adding that she would never sell a talking creature to anyone who meant to eat it, barely-above-not-detailed); Many mentions of bandits, criminals, thieves, stealing, stolen items, being robbed, kidnappings, ransoms, being shot, & weapons; Mentions of deaths, grief, & fevers (Madelena’s parents); Mentions of a duel & the possibility of being killed (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of shooting, being shot at, & gunshots; Mentions of injuries, pain, stitches, & blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of alcohol (wine and brandy) & drinking (See comment above for a positive comment about parents drinking brady after supper); Mentions of ticks stuck on animals & the animal being harmed or dying because of it (up to semi-detailed); A few mentions of a bully; A few mentions of lies, lying, & liars; A few mentions of a dead wildcat’s body (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of the possibility of being drugged or poisoned; A couple mentions of a story about a bear attack and a wife having to sew her husband’s hair back on; A couple mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of hunting; A mention of a dead rodent; A mention of manure; A mention of vomit;
*Note: Madelena assumes a couple of times that people think less of her because of her being a stablemaid and that not being typical work for a woman; Javier says his oldest brother is selfish and spoiled.
Sexual Content- An almost kiss (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed), a barely-above-not-detailed kiss, and two semi-detailed kisses; Remembering a kiss & an almost kiss (barely-above-not-detailed); Wanting to kiss (barely-above-not-detailed); Glancing at another’s lips; Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Remembering Touches & Dancing (barely-above-not-detailed); Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); A bit of flirting; Madelena plans to marry Javier’s brother because of circumstances (marriage of convenience) even though they don’t love each other (she had come to expect that they would one day wed, so she had fed and nourished her affections for him, but still does not love him); A man flirts with Madelena which makes Javier jealous; Another man wants Javier to trade Madelena for a horse (which he doesn’t do); Mentions of kisses, hand kisses, possible kisses, & kissing; Mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of chaperones; Love, falling/being in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Madelena looks away from a shirtless man, but notices Javier tugging his shirt back on (barely-above-not-detailed); Madelena is “what others generally called “a solid girl”” and that “her shoulders and arms boasted the kinds of firm and useful muscles many young men would be proud to have. The kind that would drive most young women of Costa Nueva to wearing long sleeves or a shawl to hide them. But not Madelena Vela. She had gained her strength through honorable work, and she felt no need to hide it.”; Later, Madelena notes that she has “a woman’s curves” but they are “understated compared to her powerful shoulders”; Madelena wears a dress that “modestly covered her womanly curves while making sure they were shown off to their best advantage”; A few comments/thoughts from Madelena about decent women keeping their hair up as only a husband should be allowed the intimacy of seeing a woman’s hair down.
-Madelena Vela, age 22
-Javier Moncada, age 20
P.O.V. switches between them
188 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{ Those squeamish to blood/injuries might not enjoy scenes from this book, lower up to a full star for such readers. }
I have a new pitch for this book: Josefina American Girl Books + a little bit of Dora the Explorer with the quest for a dragon’s lair + the cutest unrequited love 🥹 + talking animals (which I typically don’t like, but it worked so well for this book?) + a little Love Comes Softly for the Western setting and a scene towards the end = I was pretty flabbergasted about this one. Which is so funny to me because out of those elements, if someone tried to sell that pitch to me, only the unrequited love and smitten MMC (he’s been reading books and learning all he can about establishing a successful business so he can build a home with her one day—my heart!) would have attracted me to this story. But it worked so well despite it being so different for me, oddly enough.
I will say that I didn’t quite get The Ugly Duckling story? Javier’s brother is known to not be good-looking, but he was mostly mentioned, and we didn’t see him much so I thought it was strange that he would be the ugly duckling.
There were a few parts that made me squirm that had to do with blood and injuries and animals, just as a heads up for those sensitive to that element. I’m usually not in books, but there were more details that I was expecting in this one about all of that.
When I first started reading this book and saw the talking animals, I thought it was interesting, but not really my normal read. Which it wasn’t. At all. But it ended up being such a fun wild card, if you will, and one I will be thinking of fondly!
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
October 14, 2025
5 stars. First, I have to mention the cover. This series has great covers, but this one is definitely my favourite. It's SO pretty!!
Next, I have to mention the creativity of the plot. A sort of New Spain, aka Spanish California, with talking donkeys and dragons guarding hoards of treasure? Sign me up.
Magdalena & Javier were really enjoyable MCs. I loved her unusual background and her solid common sense as well as her sense of responsibility and devotion, and her friendliness to everyone. Javier was just as self-sacrificing and upright and he completed her so well. I really liked Armando as well... and his storyline was great. But my favourite character was definitely El Lobo. He was basically a "villain Zorro" and I found him both fascinating and hilarious.
I was very impressed by how well the Ugly Duckling retelling was woven into the story, and the title too. There were a couple layers to each! The plot was exciting and original, and I loved watching M & J work things out as they battled wildcats, dragons, outlaws, and other obstacles...
It's a solid, wholesome story and another great addition to the series! I raise my hat to Rachel Kovaciny.
Fantasy Level: 4/5 (higher). The dragon, horses, and burras can talk; and horses act as chaperones since they're unable to lie. No magic; everything's perfectly normal in this world.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
Next, I have to mention the creativity of the plot. A sort of New Spain, aka Spanish California, with talking donkeys and dragons guarding hoards of treasure? Sign me up.
Magdalena & Javier were really enjoyable MCs. I loved her unusual background and her solid common sense as well as her sense of responsibility and devotion, and her friendliness to everyone. Javier was just as self-sacrificing and upright and he completed her so well. I really liked Armando as well... and his storyline was great. But my favourite character was definitely El Lobo. He was basically a "villain Zorro" and I found him both fascinating and hilarious.
I was very impressed by how well the Ugly Duckling retelling was woven into the story, and the title too. There were a couple layers to each! The plot was exciting and original, and I loved watching M & J work things out as they battled wildcats, dragons, outlaws, and other obstacles...
It's a solid, wholesome story and another great addition to the series! I raise my hat to Rachel Kovaciny.
Fantasy Level: 4/5 (higher). The dragon, horses, and burras can talk; and horses act as chaperones since they're unable to lie. No magic; everything's perfectly normal in this world.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
October 28, 2024
This was a really fun read with engaging characters and a Spanish flair that I don’t see often in fantasy novels. It was well paced with a really fun setting. Not to mention a whimsical world with well woven faith elements, a chivalrous bandit king, a talking burro, and a lonely dragon. It’s not often I appreciate the antagonist but our bandit king, El Lobo, really made this book that much better.
A Noble Companion was a really creative twist to this fairytale retelling.
*I received an ARC from the author. I was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
A Noble Companion was a really creative twist to this fairytale retelling.
*I received an ARC from the author. I was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 14, 2024
Full review on the way. This is such a fun one!
FULL REVIEW:
This book is so unlike my usual reads, but I love it so much! I've read this story twice now, and both times it was fun, easy to read, cute, unique, humorous, and engaging. I love the Spanish/historical flair the author put on this fairy tale, while still keeping it non-magically fantasy enough (dragons, talking animals, etc.). I've honestly never read a book quite like it!
The setting was, I think, the strongest point of the book. The author created a world that feels so real, with nuance, detailed landscapes, and clever names. The "Spanish" feeling lore of the world was also so well-done. All of the tiny details she wove in, such as facts like horses can't lie, and that different people call their land by different names were such great tidbits of info. Since it's a short book, it wasn't anything complicated, but I definitely felt like I'd been dropped into a real world with real people going about their lives, and I stayed immersed the entire time.
The characters were also so fun! I enjoyed Madelena's character, witnessing her strength and consideration for those around her. She felt very realistic and pragmatic, and I respected her determination to do what was ultimately best. Her faith and trust in Dios was also very appreciated. Javier was also a stellar character. Though he might be hot-headed, his care for Madelena, and resolve to keep her safe no matter what was so sweet. I'm so glad that they reached an understanding in the end, because they are SO cute.
The supporting characters too...ah! So good. I absolutely LOVE the charming mountain bandit king (in fact, I believe he is my favorite character in the book). I would read an entire book about him, haha. The talking burros and horses were also such a fun and unique element to the story, adding yet another fantasy layer. The talking dragon as well - what a well-developed little guy! Even Armando was sympathetic and likable, despite his flaws. Everyone felt so well-rounded and interesting.
The plot is slower and the writing style is introspective and flowy, but I enjoyed it! If you're expecting a fast-paced, thrilling tale, this won't be that book. But if you enjoy witty, charming journeys with interesting and likable characters, sweet slow-burn romance, and meaningful themes, you will love this one! It leaves me smiling each time, and I'm so glad to have given it a chance ("historical/western" books are not usually my thing, but this is an exception!).
The Ugly Duckling references were subtle but woven in well, creating the backdrop to this masterfully crafted tale. And that ending...perfect way to tie up all of the loose ends. I actually laughed at the little twist. Definitely recommend this one!
Content to mention: Mild peril, fighting (with knives and guns), kidnapping by bandit, the FMC cuts her thumb and the injury is mildly described (blood is mentioned, as are phrases such as "flap of skin" and brief descriptions of stiches being put in and removed), mention that the protagonist "emptied her stomach", attack by wild animal, FMC is given brandy to drink while getting stitches, several non-described kisses. No explicit romantic scenes, gore, coarse language, or excessive violence.
** I received an ARC copy of this book, but was not required to leave a review - much less a positive one. All thoughts expressed are my own. **
FULL REVIEW:
This book is so unlike my usual reads, but I love it so much! I've read this story twice now, and both times it was fun, easy to read, cute, unique, humorous, and engaging. I love the Spanish/historical flair the author put on this fairy tale, while still keeping it non-magically fantasy enough (dragons, talking animals, etc.). I've honestly never read a book quite like it!
The setting was, I think, the strongest point of the book. The author created a world that feels so real, with nuance, detailed landscapes, and clever names. The "Spanish" feeling lore of the world was also so well-done. All of the tiny details she wove in, such as facts like horses can't lie, and that different people call their land by different names were such great tidbits of info. Since it's a short book, it wasn't anything complicated, but I definitely felt like I'd been dropped into a real world with real people going about their lives, and I stayed immersed the entire time.
The characters were also so fun! I enjoyed Madelena's character, witnessing her strength and consideration for those around her. She felt very realistic and pragmatic, and I respected her determination to do what was ultimately best. Her faith and trust in Dios was also very appreciated. Javier was also a stellar character. Though he might be hot-headed, his care for Madelena, and resolve to keep her safe no matter what was so sweet. I'm so glad that they reached an understanding in the end, because they are SO cute.
The supporting characters too...ah! So good. I absolutely LOVE the charming mountain bandit king (in fact, I believe he is my favorite character in the book). I would read an entire book about him, haha. The talking burros and horses were also such a fun and unique element to the story, adding yet another fantasy layer. The talking dragon as well - what a well-developed little guy! Even Armando was sympathetic and likable, despite his flaws. Everyone felt so well-rounded and interesting.
The plot is slower and the writing style is introspective and flowy, but I enjoyed it! If you're expecting a fast-paced, thrilling tale, this won't be that book. But if you enjoy witty, charming journeys with interesting and likable characters, sweet slow-burn romance, and meaningful themes, you will love this one! It leaves me smiling each time, and I'm so glad to have given it a chance ("historical/western" books are not usually my thing, but this is an exception!).
The Ugly Duckling references were subtle but woven in well, creating the backdrop to this masterfully crafted tale. And that ending...perfect way to tie up all of the loose ends. I actually laughed at the little twist. Definitely recommend this one!
Content to mention: Mild peril, fighting (with knives and guns), kidnapping by bandit, the FMC cuts her thumb and the injury is mildly described (blood is mentioned, as are phrases such as "flap of skin" and brief descriptions of stiches being put in and removed), mention that the protagonist "emptied her stomach", attack by wild animal, FMC is given brandy to drink while getting stitches, several non-described kisses. No explicit romantic scenes, gore, coarse language, or excessive violence.
** I received an ARC copy of this book, but was not required to leave a review - much less a positive one. All thoughts expressed are my own. **
November 22, 2024
A Noble Companion is a delightful fantasy adventure, rich with details reminiscent of old Spanish California and featuring my favorite romantic couple Rachel Kovaciny has written yet! Madalena is so firm and sensible, Javier is so loyal, and together, they're just so perfect. Highly recommended to anyone who loves sweet romance with historical vibes and a sprinkling of magic.
Read
November 24, 2024petition for all dragon treasure hunt stories from here on out to include a sweet lil backstory about how the dragon was once befriended by a knight who kept him company and told him stories 🫶
November 21, 2024
This is my first of the author’s work and I loved this action packed quest, that also held sweet moments!
The mission and descriptions of the setting bring you right in!
There were a few scenes that didn’t seem to mesh well and a couple that were written in a style/way I don’t usually read. I also wonder if there could’ve been character arc moments that could’ve been tied together more strongly.
For the former, as this is an ARC there may just be a few instances the author has to tidy still, but for the latter things that is just personal preference.
I love how Madelena sees in the end the kind of man she does really want to be with and that Javier appreciates her for who she is. The themes were lovely, as well as Madelena’s faith and trust in the Lord inspiring!
This is such an adventure, the elements along the quest pieced together so well—bandits, a dragon and his treasure, and more!
I loved the era mixed with fantastical elements so much!
I will look forward to more from the author!
I was given an ARC by the author, a positive review was not required, these thoughts are all my own!
The mission and descriptions of the setting bring you right in!
There were a few scenes that didn’t seem to mesh well and a couple that were written in a style/way I don’t usually read. I also wonder if there could’ve been character arc moments that could’ve been tied together more strongly.
For the former, as this is an ARC there may just be a few instances the author has to tidy still, but for the latter things that is just personal preference.
I love how Madelena sees in the end the kind of man she does really want to be with and that Javier appreciates her for who she is. The themes were lovely, as well as Madelena’s faith and trust in the Lord inspiring!
This is such an adventure, the elements along the quest pieced together so well—bandits, a dragon and his treasure, and more!
I loved the era mixed with fantastical elements so much!
I will look forward to more from the author!
I was given an ARC by the author, a positive review was not required, these thoughts are all my own!
November 24, 2024
This was such a fun adventure. I love the idea of side characters in fairytales having their own adventures! This one is full of danger, duels, bandits, talking animals, and a quest. I was on the edge of my seat and biting my nails!
The characters and their banter was A+! Especially El Lobo! 👏 A villain you’ll love to love. Lena and Javi are the cutest. Friends on a quest to find a dowery for Lena while Javi secretly harbors a long standing love for her. He’s sweet, smart, brave, and willing to do anything to take care of Lena. Lena is strong, determined, bold, and kind.
The plot of this story is full of danger, twists, surprises, and revelations. I love the underlying theme of God leading them through the whole process. Beautifully written. I also love the meaning of the color red that is spread throughout the book and revealed at the end.
Definitely worth the read asap. There’s so many fun and clever details. I giggled, gasped, and held my breath. If Shrek were a donkey, he’d probably be Terco!
Perfect for you if you like:
✨quests
✨friends-to-(in-laws or lovers?)
✨dragons
✨talking animals (especially mouthy donkeys)
✨extravagant bandits
✨fairytales
✨finding treasure
✨he falls first
✨wound tending
Strong language: none
Spice: none
Violence: very mild: a mishap while cutting food, a unique dual - nothing gory or super descriptive
The characters and their banter was A+! Especially El Lobo! 👏 A villain you’ll love to love. Lena and Javi are the cutest. Friends on a quest to find a dowery for Lena while Javi secretly harbors a long standing love for her. He’s sweet, smart, brave, and willing to do anything to take care of Lena. Lena is strong, determined, bold, and kind.
The plot of this story is full of danger, twists, surprises, and revelations. I love the underlying theme of God leading them through the whole process. Beautifully written. I also love the meaning of the color red that is spread throughout the book and revealed at the end.
Definitely worth the read asap. There’s so many fun and clever details. I giggled, gasped, and held my breath. If Shrek were a donkey, he’d probably be Terco!
Perfect for you if you like:
✨quests
✨friends-to-(in-laws or lovers?)
✨dragons
✨talking animals (especially mouthy donkeys)
✨extravagant bandits
✨fairytales
✨finding treasure
✨he falls first
✨wound tending
Strong language: none
Spice: none
Violence: very mild: a mishap while cutting food, a unique dual - nothing gory or super descriptive
June 29, 2025
The breath of fresh air I needed in my reading slump! It was a little slow at first, but I really grew to love the characters as the story progressed.
December 6, 2024
✨ I loved this story! 🥰 It was sweet and beautiful and heartwarming! The talking horses and donkeys! Recommend it to anyone with a desire to read Hispanic history and fairytale retellings or both mixed together in one!
January 23, 2025
I couldn't help loving both Madalena and Javi--they were both so sweet! Madalena's willingness to reach out and befriend the least of those around her was inspiring, and Javi's quiet, unselfish care for her... *melts* I loved the Spanish flavor of the setting as well. The talking animal bit took me a while to get used to--it's just not something I read a lot--but their personalities were rather fun, especially Terco. And I loved the way things worked out in the end. <3
December 18, 2024
Loved the dragon and talking animals. Didn’t really see the Ugly Duckling connection but it didn’t really bother me. Enjoyed this sweet somewhat-western-vibed romance.
November 10, 2024
This was a really fun book.
Good plot, active heroine and manly hero, comedic talking-animal sidekick, clean read... oh, and a dragon and a charming bandit king.
Our heroine, Madalena, goes out to acquire a dowry so that she can marry a childhood friend, one Armando, the son of a wealthy landowner. Even though she doesn't really want to marry him (she's always hoped for a love match), she agrees because he's a friend, and she can stay in the home she's always known if this works out. Her intended's brother, Javier, who's really in love with her, accompanies her to ensure her safety, at his brother's request. And he's super-honorable about it, too, so don't y'all get any ideas!
The banter made me laugh aloud several times, the worldbuilding was pretty cool (I now have a severe desire to read more Spanish/South American cowboy stories), the romance was sweet and the forced-proximity trope is always nice. And did I mention there was a dragon (💗💗💗) and a charming bandit king (!!!)? but I'm gonna be honest with you here. I forgot what story they were retelling partway through the book. So as a retelling, not my favorite.
It's a GREAT book, it really is, but... a bit of a stretch as an Ugly Duckling retelling. That's why I only gave it four stars.
That said, I liked the little details that Ms. Kovaciny put in there. That horses can't lie, that different areas have different fauna and flora (like a real place), that there are different names the island goes by, depending on who it is who's referring to it (again, like a real place. 10 points for convincing me this book takes place in the real world! I just need to find Costa Nueva and acquire myself a talking hawk friend...), the food, the awesome map at the front... all wonderfully done.
While I was not required to leave a review of this book, I wanted to share it. A good read, though not my favorite retelling. However, within the parameters of the series (nonmagical and from a side character), very well-done.
Good plot, active heroine and manly hero, comedic talking-animal sidekick, clean read... oh, and a dragon and a charming bandit king.
Our heroine, Madalena, goes out to acquire a dowry so that she can marry a childhood friend, one Armando, the son of a wealthy landowner. Even though she doesn't really want to marry him (she's always hoped for a love match), she agrees because he's a friend, and she can stay in the home she's always known if this works out. Her intended's brother, Javier, who's really in love with her, accompanies her to ensure her safety, at his brother's request. And he's super-honorable about it, too, so don't y'all get any ideas!
The banter made me laugh aloud several times, the worldbuilding was pretty cool (I now have a severe desire to read more Spanish/South American cowboy stories), the romance was sweet and the forced-proximity trope is always nice. And did I mention there was a dragon (💗💗💗) and a charming bandit king (!!!)? but I'm gonna be honest with you here. I forgot what story they were retelling partway through the book. So as a retelling, not my favorite.
It's a GREAT book, it really is, but... a bit of a stretch as an Ugly Duckling retelling. That's why I only gave it four stars.
That said, I liked the little details that Ms. Kovaciny put in there. That horses can't lie, that different areas have different fauna and flora (like a real place), that there are different names the island goes by, depending on who it is who's referring to it (again, like a real place. 10 points for convincing me this book takes place in the real world! I just need to find Costa Nueva and acquire myself a talking hawk friend...), the food, the awesome map at the front... all wonderfully done.
While I was not required to leave a review of this book, I wanted to share it. A good read, though not my favorite retelling. However, within the parameters of the series (nonmagical and from a side character), very well-done.
March 5, 2025
2.5/5 stars (rounded up to 3) - not for me
I was excited to get an ARC copy of A Noble Companion because the premise was so intriguing. A quest to raid a dragon's hoard? Count me in!
Unfortunately, as I got reading, I found it very difficult to get invested. The conflict was resolved too smoothly for my taste, and the characters had a habit of being wholly good people. The story is filled with objectively good lessons about kindness and forgiveness. However, because there was so much goodness in the story, I struggled to get sucked in. Things fell flat for me.
This is not an indication of "error" on the part of the book or author. The simple fact is that this book was not for me. I was looking for an epic tale of dangerous quests and battles against fire-breathing dragons. That isn't what A Noble Companion is about. If you're someone who likes sweet stories of forgiveness and love, you'd probably enjoy this book. But if you're a dragon slayer, this one probably isn't for you.
Thank you so much, Rachel Kovaciny, for providing me with an advanced copy of A Noble Companion in exchange for an honest review. My sincerest apologies for taking so long to finish reading.
I was excited to get an ARC copy of A Noble Companion because the premise was so intriguing. A quest to raid a dragon's hoard? Count me in!
Unfortunately, as I got reading, I found it very difficult to get invested. The conflict was resolved too smoothly for my taste, and the characters had a habit of being wholly good people. The story is filled with objectively good lessons about kindness and forgiveness. However, because there was so much goodness in the story, I struggled to get sucked in. Things fell flat for me.
This is not an indication of "error" on the part of the book or author. The simple fact is that this book was not for me. I was looking for an epic tale of dangerous quests and battles against fire-breathing dragons. That isn't what A Noble Companion is about. If you're someone who likes sweet stories of forgiveness and love, you'd probably enjoy this book. But if you're a dragon slayer, this one probably isn't for you.
Thank you so much, Rachel Kovaciny, for providing me with an advanced copy of A Noble Companion in exchange for an honest review. My sincerest apologies for taking so long to finish reading.
October 18, 2024
Clever. An easy to read and engaging fairytale retelling for those who appreciate a well-written clean read with elements of a Christian worldview.
Madelena finds herself in a tough spot after her parents die and she loses her family, her financial security, and social standing all in one fell swoop. She is relegated to working in the stables and her hopes of marrying her childhood sweetheart evaporate. By the time she’s given a second chance to marry him after all, she realizes she doesn’t love him anymore, but what choice does she have? Enter….you guessed it, the guy who secretly loves her and has for some time.
I was a little worried at the beginning, in the best way, that Madelena might make the wrong choice! This was a fun, engaging read with memorable characters and an ending that satisfied my romantic side.
Adventuresome Dangerous Quest for a Treasure. Friends to Lovers. Fairytale Retelling. Great Storytelling.
Bandits. Talking animals.
Recommended for preteens and above.
Madelena finds herself in a tough spot after her parents die and she loses her family, her financial security, and social standing all in one fell swoop. She is relegated to working in the stables and her hopes of marrying her childhood sweetheart evaporate. By the time she’s given a second chance to marry him after all, she realizes she doesn’t love him anymore, but what choice does she have? Enter….you guessed it, the guy who secretly loves her and has for some time.
I was a little worried at the beginning, in the best way, that Madelena might make the wrong choice! This was a fun, engaging read with memorable characters and an ending that satisfied my romantic side.
Adventuresome Dangerous Quest for a Treasure. Friends to Lovers. Fairytale Retelling. Great Storytelling.
Bandits. Talking animals.
Recommended for preteens and above.
December 18, 2024
This was a fun read. I enjoyed the characters and the world. It was a real twist on the Ugly Duckling story that I wasn't quite expecting (). I honestly think that it would have been better without the ugly duckling element. I really enjoyed having the dual POVs and thought it made the story richer. I was confused by the talking animals at first, but wonder if that's part of the larger world of this series or if each one is set in a different world as I know they can all be read as standalones. This is the only one I've read, so I can't answer that. But it was a fun fantastical element that made it different than your standard western-setting romance.
March 21, 2025
Interesting Setting, Meh Retelling
I liked the setting and Zorro-esque vibes. El Lobo was a vibrant side character, and I liked the animal companions. Javier was a fine mmc, though a bit more passive than I prefer. Madalena was... Eh. I didn't connect with her. I didn't actively dislike her per se, but she just wasn't very interesting to me. She was stubborn about things that seemed unnecessary, unfairly judgemental at times, and yet talked about as if a paragon by some other characters. Armando, who was barely in this, received the brunt of judgemental thoughts/comments, which seemed unfair from what was shown and made Madalena seem like a bit of a hypocrite.
This supposedly was an Ugly Duckling retelling, but I don't think it was a good one or at least not incorporated to a degree to really be called that.
I think the religious themes/faith were well depicted in the first half of the book, but got more heavy handed toward the end.
I liked the setting and Zorro-esque vibes. El Lobo was a vibrant side character, and I liked the animal companions. Javier was a fine mmc, though a bit more passive than I prefer. Madalena was... Eh. I didn't connect with her. I didn't actively dislike her per se, but she just wasn't very interesting to me. She was stubborn about things that seemed unnecessary, unfairly judgemental at times, and yet talked about as if a paragon by some other characters. Armando, who was barely in this, received the brunt of judgemental thoughts/comments, which seemed unfair from what was shown and made Madalena seem like a bit of a hypocrite.
This supposedly was an Ugly Duckling retelling, but I don't think it was a good one or at least not incorporated to a degree to really be called that.
I think the religious themes/faith were well depicted in the first half of the book, but got more heavy handed toward the end.
December 17, 2024
A Noble Companion by Rachel Kovaciny
What I loved about this book:
🧭 Talking donkeys
🧭 The dragon and his hoard
🧭 A marriage proposal of convenience
🧭 Action and adventure!
🧭 Sweet and swoony romance, just kisses
Thoroughly enjoyed this Wild West fairytale from the Cornerstone series! Very unqiue and exciting. This one is an Ugly Duckling retelling but the duckling is a side character so if I hadn't known it was a retelling I wouldn't have recognized it as one. But the story stands perfectly well on its own!
Part of the Cornerstone series, a multi author series of Christian fairytales
Favorite quote: "An outlaw I may be, and a rogue, and a thief. Even, sometimes, a liar. But I am always a man of decency." (The bandit king!)
Favorite scene: The second waterfall
Favorite character: Madelena (our main female character)
What I loved about this book:
🧭 Talking donkeys
🧭 The dragon and his hoard
🧭 A marriage proposal of convenience
🧭 Action and adventure!
🧭 Sweet and swoony romance, just kisses
Thoroughly enjoyed this Wild West fairytale from the Cornerstone series! Very unqiue and exciting. This one is an Ugly Duckling retelling but the duckling is a side character so if I hadn't known it was a retelling I wouldn't have recognized it as one. But the story stands perfectly well on its own!
Part of the Cornerstone series, a multi author series of Christian fairytales
Favorite quote: "An outlaw I may be, and a rogue, and a thief. Even, sometimes, a liar. But I am always a man of decency." (The bandit king!)
Favorite scene: The second waterfall
Favorite character: Madelena (our main female character)
November 18, 2024
I was utterly smitten! I've read all of Rachel Kovaciny's Westerns (Prairie Tales) - fairytale retellings set in the Wild West, so I was anxious to read A Noble Companion, and it did not disappoint!!
With gentleman villains, surprise plot twists, a feisty heroine and a donkey whose very name has a hilarious meaning from the Spanish, this delightful story was filled with wit, wisdom and traditional Western with a twist!
There are soooo many plot points and witticisms, comparisons to favorite books and even films, that I'd like to mention - but as that would involve spoilers, I'll just invite you to read it for yourself and be completely charmed!
With gentleman villains, surprise plot twists, a feisty heroine and a donkey whose very name has a hilarious meaning from the Spanish, this delightful story was filled with wit, wisdom and traditional Western with a twist!
There are soooo many plot points and witticisms, comparisons to favorite books and even films, that I'd like to mention - but as that would involve spoilers, I'll just invite you to read it for yourself and be completely charmed!
November 14, 2024
This book has so much in it, it's great! Princess Bride cozy feelings, spanish influences, robber kings, dragons, and talking animals! It really was such a fun story that I greatly enjoyed with them embarking on an adventure to find the dragon's treasure and along the way, Madelena learns to stand up for herself and the true value of kindness as it gives her simpler solutions to problems than had she used her temper like Javi. I also love the contrast between the two with their attitudes in a few scrapes, including both PoVs showing up in the chapters. Really, I greatly enjoyed this story and I love the Christian influence throughout, it felt very natural and not overwhelming.
December 9, 2024
I've long been afraid to read a story written by a friend for this very moment: reviewing it.
Let's me say that this book is well written and fun. Had it been a middle grade, I think I could have really enjoyed it. But talking animals and a self-imposed treasure-finding quest and a heroine who makes friends with bandits... just didn't quite work for me. I couldn't quite immerse myself. I also couldn't find the ugly duckling parallel, although that didn't particularly bother me as I wasn't reading for the retelling aspect. 2.5 stars
Let's me say that this book is well written and fun. Had it been a middle grade, I think I could have really enjoyed it. But talking animals and a self-imposed treasure-finding quest and a heroine who makes friends with bandits... just didn't quite work for me. I couldn't quite immerse myself. I also couldn't find the ugly duckling parallel, although that didn't particularly bother me as I wasn't reading for the retelling aspect. 2.5 stars
April 26, 2025
I can honestly say I've never read such a unique novella. I loved everything about this Ugly Duckling retelling.
Not only were the lore, culture, and Christian messages paired perfectly with the adventure the Main Characters go on, but it was simply just fun to read.
Talking animals.
A bandit.
A misunderstood dragon.
Secret pining.
And best friends on an epic quest.
I can't recommend this one enough. Great for YA+ readers. :)
Not only were the lore, culture, and Christian messages paired perfectly with the adventure the Main Characters go on, but it was simply just fun to read.
Talking animals.
A bandit.
A misunderstood dragon.
Secret pining.
And best friends on an epic quest.
I can't recommend this one enough. Great for YA+ readers. :)
November 3, 2024
I love this book! Part Princess Bride, part Mask of Zorro and 100% delightful. I can't wait to share it with my daughters. It has all the pieces we have come to expect from one of the author's stories, but in completely different setting. I loved all of the characters; even the villains leave you wanting more of their stories!
November 20, 2024
A Noble Companion by Rachel Kovaciny was fun to read, it was cool to see the “ugly duckling” as a man instead of a woman. I also really enjoyed the fun journey that the main characters embarked on. While reading I was definitely imagining Madelena as “Luisa” from Encanto. It was a truly enjoyable book to read! I did receive an advanced copy of this book and was asked but not required to provide a review. All opinions and words are my own and a positive review was not required.
November 18, 2024
This sweet retelling of The Ugly Duckling was a new story in itself! I saw pieces of the original tale, but they were more of a hint in the way things happened than actually what did happen in the story. It was well crafted and kept me guessing, and I fully enjoyed the way everything led to a happy ending!
December 4, 2024
Seeing people with new eyes
Madalena was orphaned and left with debts not a dowry. Instead of trusting God, she considers marrying Armand for security, little realizing Javi loved her. I loved how she saw the best in people -and fierce dragons and wanted to befriend them. Their journey was troubled but what they learnt about each other was priceless.
Madalena was orphaned and left with debts not a dowry. Instead of trusting God, she considers marrying Armand for security, little realizing Javi loved her. I loved how she saw the best in people -and fierce dragons and wanted to befriend them. Their journey was troubled but what they learnt about each other was priceless.
August 30, 2025
Read this in one day. What a delightful, unique book! I always love how Rachel puts such wholesome, wonderful, never-boring characters in her books. They're so nice to spend time with. 💜 My favorite was El Lobo for sure, but each one has a special place in my heart now.
This is a book about a treasure hunt, a dragon, unrequited love, and a lot more too. I highly recommend!!!
This is a book about a treasure hunt, a dragon, unrequited love, and a lot more too. I highly recommend!!!
December 15, 2024
This was so good! One of the best heroines ever, and one of the coolest bad guys ever. There were also talking horses, burros and dragons. And treasure! And red butterflies… ❤️ A very fun read, one I flew through because I really couldn’t wait to see what was going to happen next!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews