I was surprised at how bad this book turned out to be. The last two books I've read by this author I gave 4-5 stars. She'd done a great job of portraying both a hero and heroine I could like and depicting a positive, equal relationship between them, while also keeping the external mystery interesting. Unfortunately, none of that talent is on display in this book. The romance was awful, with the hero an ice sculpture and the heroine a spineless little girl, and the villain was never in question so there was absolutely no mystery. Not to mention that the final climax was, in a word, anticlimactic.
As other reviewers have said, this book starts with Cordie's father dying and leaving her millions of dollars and the surprise that her mother actually isn't dead but rather alive and in Australia. Cordie was far from the best heroine. She's this drop-dead gorgeous woman who allegedly has no idea that she's even remotely attractive. Yeah that sound you hear is me gagging and rolling my eyes. This simply isn't believable. Virtually everywhere she goes in this book she gets hit on by some random guy. You do not spend a lifetime getting hit on without recognizing that you're attractive. And there wasn't even a plausible reason given for her insecurities. It would be one thing if she'd grown up in an abusive home where she'd always been told she was ugly, but she wasn't. She was raised by a loving father who doted on her and she has had the same 2 best gal pals since childhood who never miss an opportunity to compliment her. She's an allegedly normal, well-adjusted young woman, and she's got her PhD so she's supposedly smart as well, and yet we're supposed to swallow the idea that she's totally blind to her own level of attractiveness? GTFOOH!
In addition, Cordie was just plain weak. She complained and threw tantrums a lot, but never actually took action. She spent her entire life in love with Aiden and basically following him around like a puppy dog, but never made a move on him. And when their relationship finally crossed over into the bedroom, she firmly believed that it was meaningless for him and was totally fine with that. She was completely passive in the relationship, content to provide sex whenever Aiden found a few minutes for her, but never stepping up to take an active role. She kept going on and on in her mind about how she had this big plan to move to Boston so she could somehow try to move on from her infatuation with him like she was some kind of martyr instead of standing up for herself and demanding to be treated better.
Aiden, meanwhile, was equally bad in different ways. He's a good 10 years older than Cordie and acted as a big brother when she was young because she was his little sister's friend and unfortunately their relationship never feels like it evolves past that point. He orders Cordie around and forces his will on her under the guise of protecting her because "he knows best." When she protests at his high-handed tactics, he actually laughs at her in a very "pat you on the head and send you on your way" kind of way. It made it very obvious that he didn't respect her as an adult woman, and certainly not someone he viewed as an equal partner in their relationship. Which made the fact that they were having sex together feel pretty squicky.
And the portrayal of him in the aftermath of those sex scenes was the opposite of romance. Garwood made it a point to say that Aiden never cuddled Cordie or whispered any sweet words to her afterward. He simply got his rocks off and then headed into the bathroom. That's pretty much the definition of a booty call. Meanwhile, he continues to hold Cordie prisoner in his penthouse (literally under guard) while going about his business with no explanations to her. Many times he'd be out late or would come home and change into something that suggested he was going on a date, and would leave again without saying a word to her. Then he'd come into her bedroom in the middle of the night and have sex with her as if he had every right to. And Cordie was okay with that. So he's basically holding her captive and using her as his personal sex slave whenever he feels like it, but never talks to her or takes her feelings or desires into consideration. How is this a romance?
I'm not sure if Garwood thought their lifelong connection through previous books would somehow justify this or what, but that's not how it comes off. Of the books in this series I've read (which is only a few) none of them showed the relationship between Cordie and Aiden so I didn't have that foundation in my mind. And honestly, them having this lifelong connection just makes Aiden's treatment of her even worse. He acts like she's a cross between a child and a blowup doll. Not like she's his sister's best friend, whom he's known for decades and respects. The romance was just all wrong.
I had trouble believing the friendship between Regan, Sophie and Cordie as well. It's completely unbelievable that Cordie had been in love with Aiden since childhood, but her two inseparable best friends had NO idea. Especially when Regan's husband, Alec, could see it plain as day. What kind of best friends are this blind to each other? And neither of these friends was the least bit concerned by the fact that Aiden was holding Cordie against her will. Are these people nuts? Yes, someone was trying to kill her, but keeping her a prisoner is not the only way to protect her. She's a millionaire, she could hire bodyguards. She could go stay in some exclusive rehab facility where she'd be safe and have the best of care while she recuperated from her injuries. She's an adult and she made it perfectly clear she wanted to leave, her best friends should have agreed that she had that right, not participated in her incarceration.
As for the "mystery," as I said, it was anticlimactic. You know from the very beginning who the villains are because Garwood came straight out and told us. It wasn't something you even had to deduce logically, it was just stated. So there's no mystery at all. And the final scene where they catch the bad guys was basically a non-scene. There's no tense showdown where Cordie is in danger and Aiden has to rescue her, etc. Nope, they get the tip-off that the guy is on the plane and Alec and Jack arrest him at the airport. Done and done. It was a total letdown. And, as an aside, it's not very believable that Cordie would live happily ever after at the end. She's single-handedly destroyed the lives of some very, very powerful people who very much liked being rich and powerful. They would NOT just roll over and live with the insult. One of them went to jail, but there were still at least 4 other people who were free and pissed at her. She'd need to spend the rest of her life dodging assassination attempts.
Oh and I listened to this in audiobook format and while the narrator did a fine job on all the main characters, it should be noted that her range does NOT extend to depicting a believable Australian accent.