What do you think?
Rate this book
Camp Prodigy
Perfect for fans of Victoria Jamieson and Raina Telgemeier, this heartwarming middle grade graphic novel follows two nonbinary kids who navigate anxiety and identity while having fun and forming friendships at their summer orchestra camp.After attending an incredible concert, Tate Seong is inspired to become a professional violist. There’s just one they’re the worst musician at their school. Tate doesn’t even have enough confidence to assert themself with their friends or come out as nonbinary to their family, let alone attempt a solo anytime soon. Things start to look up when Tate attends a summer orchestra camp—Camp Prodigy—and runs into Eli, the remarkable violist who inspired Tate to play in the first place. But Eli has been hiding their skills ever since their time in the spotlight gave them a nervous breakdown. Together, can they figure out how to turn Tate into a star and have Eli overcome their performance anxieties? Or will the pressure take them both down?
256 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 11, 2024
37 people are currently reading
622 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
December 30, 2024
This was such a cute and fun graphic novel that approached several different topics in very thoughtful and relatable ways. While I thought that it was solely going to focus on the main characters experiences at an orchestra camp, it delved into different things related to the stress about being successful. Quite often middle grade books focus on characters attempting to attain success, yet this is one of the few that addresses the burn out and stress that can often accompany success. While this isn't the case when readers initially encounter Tate, it is through their own interactions with Eli and their rising success that Tate learns that leaning on the shoulders of friends is better than trying to rise to the top alone. This was well developed with a fun range of characters and wonderful queer representation. The artwork was immaculate. This is my first experience with Carolina Palmer, but I'm definitely looking forward to any more works they put out in the future.
April 7, 2024
So wholesome plus wonderful nonbinary rep!
December 16, 2023
“That’s the point of opening up to people. When you’re sacred, or struggling they’ll want to help. And you won’t be alone.”
I'd like to thank Simon & Schuster for sending me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
I've also posted this review on Instagram and my blog.
Instagram Post
Blog Post
Camp Prodigy was such a fun read! The artwork was really cute and captured my attention right away. The main characters Tate and Eli were relatable and intriguing. I especially liked following how Tate and Eli's friendship developed as they each grew on their own. Both the musical and camp elements were interesting to read about. I had never read a book about a musical camp before! While there are a lot of fun aspects I also appreciated how this book talks about more serious topics like burnout and the pressure of trying to live up to expectations. Overall I had a great time reading it!
I'd like to thank Simon & Schuster for sending me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
I've also posted this review on Instagram and my blog.
Instagram Post
Blog Post
Camp Prodigy was such a fun read! The artwork was really cute and captured my attention right away. The main characters Tate and Eli were relatable and intriguing. I especially liked following how Tate and Eli's friendship developed as they each grew on their own. Both the musical and camp elements were interesting to read about. I had never read a book about a musical camp before! While there are a lot of fun aspects I also appreciated how this book talks about more serious topics like burnout and the pressure of trying to live up to expectations. Overall I had a great time reading it!
March 9, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!!
This was such a cute graphic novel. I loved it. The art was amazing and one of my favorite styles so far. All these summer camp middle grade graphic novels are so fun and I’m adoring them all.
Eli and Tate were awesome and the friendships with everyone was so refreshing. I also love to see books where everyone is accepting. Tate coming out to their friends & parents about being nonbinary was inspiring. Also the lessons about being under pressure and enjoying what you love instead of trying to be the best and hating it. People of all ages can learn from that lesson. This was great and I’m looking forward more from this artist!!
This was such a cute graphic novel. I loved it. The art was amazing and one of my favorite styles so far. All these summer camp middle grade graphic novels are so fun and I’m adoring them all.
Eli and Tate were awesome and the friendships with everyone was so refreshing. I also love to see books where everyone is accepting. Tate coming out to their friends & parents about being nonbinary was inspiring. Also the lessons about being under pressure and enjoying what you love instead of trying to be the best and hating it. People of all ages can learn from that lesson. This was great and I’m looking forward more from this artist!!
March 10, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!!
This was such a cute graphic novel. I loved it. The art was amazing and one of my favorite styles so far. All these summer camp middle grade graphic novels are so fun and I’m adoring them all.
Eli and Tate were awesome and the friendships with everyone was so refreshing. I also love to see books where everyone is accepting. Tate coming out to their friends & parents about being nonbinary was inspiring. Also the lessons about being under pressure and enjoying what you love instead of trying to be the best and hating it. People of all ages can learn from that lesson. This was great and I’m looking forward more from this artist!!
This was such a cute graphic novel. I loved it. The art was amazing and one of my favorite styles so far. All these summer camp middle grade graphic novels are so fun and I’m adoring them all.
Eli and Tate were awesome and the friendships with everyone was so refreshing. I also love to see books where everyone is accepting. Tate coming out to their friends & parents about being nonbinary was inspiring. Also the lessons about being under pressure and enjoying what you love instead of trying to be the best and hating it. People of all ages can learn from that lesson. This was great and I’m looking forward more from this artist!!
May 11, 2025
2.5 stars rounded up to 3. I enjoyed the camaraderie of the campers and the idea of music camp. I think this could be the right person
August 1, 2024
Well, this book really grabbed my eldest sister perfectionism trauma and shook it like a rag doll, yelling, TAKE BREAKS, DO THINGS FOR FUN, DO THINGS FOR YOU. And I think I'm still crying about it.
May 9, 2024
This is a cute and relatable middle grade graphic novel about a string music camp. Tate Seong has recently taken up viola after hearing the young prodigy Eli Violet backstage. Eli struggles with anxiety and was unable to perform that day, but their music struck a chord with Tate, and Tate's supportive parents surprise them with the summer camp.
Tate is surprised to find Eli is attending the camp as well. Eli and Tate become friends, and Eli tutors Tate in viola. Meanwhile, Tate, who also has anxiety, is feeling more like themself and comes out as nonbinary—like Eli—to their fellow viola players.
Lots of things are relatable here: anxiety, the competitiveness of music. Auditions always gave me more anxiety than solos. I attended quite a few week or weekend long music camps as a teen, and none of them resembled this in the least, but the author is a viola player, and I imagine they're writing from experience even if it's dissimilar from my own experiences. I really loved Tate's parents.
The art style didn't speak to me, but I imagine most tweens would enjoy it. Overall, a great read for musical tweens.
Tate is surprised to find Eli is attending the camp as well. Eli and Tate become friends, and Eli tutors Tate in viola. Meanwhile, Tate, who also has anxiety, is feeling more like themself and comes out as nonbinary—like Eli—to their fellow viola players.
Lots of things are relatable here: anxiety, the competitiveness of music. Auditions always gave me more anxiety than solos. I attended quite a few week or weekend long music camps as a teen, and none of them resembled this in the least, but the author is a viola player, and I imagine they're writing from experience even if it's dissimilar from my own experiences. I really loved Tate's parents.
The art style didn't speak to me, but I imagine most tweens would enjoy it. Overall, a great read for musical tweens.
March 16, 2024
I received an advance copy from the publisher via Netgalley for review purposes; this in no way influences my review.
This is so adorable and gave me all the warm hug feelings! I love the friendships Tate and Eli develop with each other as well as other campers. I adored Eli framing coming out as a gift you’re offering to others, and if they don’t accept it/you, that’s on them and not you. The art is super cute and I just really loved this story. So cute and warm!
This is so adorable and gave me all the warm hug feelings! I love the friendships Tate and Eli develop with each other as well as other campers. I adored Eli framing coming out as a gift you’re offering to others, and if they don’t accept it/you, that’s on them and not you. The art is super cute and I just really loved this story. So cute and warm!
June 9, 2024
Camp Prodigy was a fun read! The artwork was done really well and caught my eye right away! I really enjoyed seeing Tate and Eli's friendship develop as they each grew on their own. Reading about Tate coming out to their friends & parents about being nonbinary was inspiring. It was refreshing to see how accepting and supportive everyone was of each other! Overall it's a great summer read for the middle grade book lovers that enjoy graphic novels and music!
December 28, 2024
A heartwarming graphic novel about nonbinary teenagers navigating gender, relationships, anxiety, and improving their mental health. Tate is a closeted teen who started playing viola after being inspired by Eli, a talented violist who shut down before their first solo concert. The two teens meet at a music camp and Tate asks Eli to help them improve their viola skills. Together, Tate and Eli learn about making friends, opening up to people, combating perfectionism, and enjoying the little things in life in the face of stress or great expectations. Highly recommend this for anyone who wants a quick and uplifting read.
April 28, 2024
This was so cute 😭 I loved it sm
Read
July 15, 2024Wow how stereotypical… all the queer kids playing viola 🙄🙄🙄
Read
August 17, 2025This book was adorable. I’m so happy whenever I see nonbinary characters and storylines in middle grade novels. I love Eli and Tate so much :)
August 29, 2024
I wasn’t my favorite art style but the characters and their struggles were handled so well. This is the perfect for middle school kids to read
September 3, 2025
It was really good to see some issues young people face and the art is fantastic.
August 1, 2024
My daughter plays the Viola so she was extremely excited that this book specifically featured Viola players in a Orchestra summer camp.
We both loved reading this, and thelt the art style was coloful and attractive, the story was interesting and well paced, the characters detailed and relatable. The references to music and in particular to the instrument practice were realistic and on spot woth the musical terms. It features 2 nonbinary MCs characters and the concepts are well explained for younger readers.
Overall it was a fun and entertaining read, with beautiful and attractive illustrations.
It’s the perfect pick for GN lovers, music lovers, for the summer camp book readers and for Pride month.
Thank you @storygramtours and @simonkids and @netgalley for sending me a physical copy for this tour, and to @netgalley for sending me an eARC!
All opinions are my own.
We both loved reading this, and thelt the art style was coloful and attractive, the story was interesting and well paced, the characters detailed and relatable. The references to music and in particular to the instrument practice were realistic and on spot woth the musical terms. It features 2 nonbinary MCs characters and the concepts are well explained for younger readers.
Overall it was a fun and entertaining read, with beautiful and attractive illustrations.
It’s the perfect pick for GN lovers, music lovers, for the summer camp book readers and for Pride month.
Thank you @storygramtours and @simonkids and @netgalley for sending me a physical copy for this tour, and to @netgalley for sending me an eARC!
All opinions are my own.
June 18, 2024
6/17/2024 Violas! Full review tk at TheFrumiousConsortium.net.
6/18/2024 A graphic novel about viola players, whaaaaaaat!
Haha, sorry, as an orchestra cellist, it's always fun for me to read about underrepresented instruments and their players. Perhaps more importantly, this Middle Grade comic is about two nonbinary teenagers who meet at the title summer camp, which has the no-pressure name of Camp Prodigy, lol. There they learn how to navigate and confront the challenges of putting way more pressure on themselves than necessary, whether it comes to music or pretending that everything is okay for the benefit of the people around them.
Our two main protagonists are Tate Seong and Eli Violet, who sorta meet backstage at a concert one day before meeting for real a year plus later at Camp Prodigy. Tate was actually inspired to take up the viola after hearing Eli play backstage that evening, but hasn't really progressed via school instruction since. After being discouraged from performing in the school concert, Tate is feeling pretty down about music -- not to mention their inability to come out about not being a boy to their family and friends -- so is thrilled when their parents suggest sending them away to a summer camp for music students of all abilities. They're not great at the viola but they're ready to learn, and they look forward to camp.
Eli, on the other hand, is an accomplished violist who was set to embark on a professional career when they unexpectedly backed out of their solo debut. Now they're trying to regain the joy of just playing, while perhaps rebuilding their confidence in their abilities. As Tate and Eli become friends, Eli tutors Tate on how to play properly as well as how to open up to the people around them. Tate, meanwhile, slowly encourages Eli to stop placing so much unnecessary pressure on themself to be extraordinary. They both learn a valuable lesson from their fellow campers about just hanging out and having fun instead of focusing on music 24/7.
I super loved the music camp scenes, with the diversity of students not only in appearance but also in temperament. Hannah might be my favorite because she's exactly the kind of overachiever I am, despite us focusing on completely different instruments. And I really loved how the beauty and joy of playing music is never allowed to be drowned out by the drama of musical rivalries, tho the latter are also very realistically depicted.
But the best thing about this book was the wonderful representation it gives to non-binary kids, showing both how they're different from other kids but also very much the same. The musical backdrop underscores the fact that non-binary people exist everywhere, in every field. The choice to have both protagonists be non-binary was also excellent. There may be fewer non-binary kids in the world than other genders, but that doesn't mean that having just one in a story is enough. Having both take center stage makes it clear that their stories are just as important and diverse as anybody else's.
I also wanted to say that I really liked the interior art, especially the color selections, textures and musical depictions. I do think it's a weird trend in a lot of recent graphic novels aimed at younger audiences to have very awkward-looking covers that only barely hint at the expressiveness inside. The presentation otherwise of this book is great, making it a nice solid volume to hand to my eldest kid as he complains about being bored already on summer vacation.
Camp Prodigy by Caroline Palmer was published June 11 2024 by Atheneum Books For Young Readers and is available from all good booksellers, including
6/18/2024 A graphic novel about viola players, whaaaaaaat!
Haha, sorry, as an orchestra cellist, it's always fun for me to read about underrepresented instruments and their players. Perhaps more importantly, this Middle Grade comic is about two nonbinary teenagers who meet at the title summer camp, which has the no-pressure name of Camp Prodigy, lol. There they learn how to navigate and confront the challenges of putting way more pressure on themselves than necessary, whether it comes to music or pretending that everything is okay for the benefit of the people around them.
Our two main protagonists are Tate Seong and Eli Violet, who sorta meet backstage at a concert one day before meeting for real a year plus later at Camp Prodigy. Tate was actually inspired to take up the viola after hearing Eli play backstage that evening, but hasn't really progressed via school instruction since. After being discouraged from performing in the school concert, Tate is feeling pretty down about music -- not to mention their inability to come out about not being a boy to their family and friends -- so is thrilled when their parents suggest sending them away to a summer camp for music students of all abilities. They're not great at the viola but they're ready to learn, and they look forward to camp.
Eli, on the other hand, is an accomplished violist who was set to embark on a professional career when they unexpectedly backed out of their solo debut. Now they're trying to regain the joy of just playing, while perhaps rebuilding their confidence in their abilities. As Tate and Eli become friends, Eli tutors Tate on how to play properly as well as how to open up to the people around them. Tate, meanwhile, slowly encourages Eli to stop placing so much unnecessary pressure on themself to be extraordinary. They both learn a valuable lesson from their fellow campers about just hanging out and having fun instead of focusing on music 24/7.
I super loved the music camp scenes, with the diversity of students not only in appearance but also in temperament. Hannah might be my favorite because she's exactly the kind of overachiever I am, despite us focusing on completely different instruments. And I really loved how the beauty and joy of playing music is never allowed to be drowned out by the drama of musical rivalries, tho the latter are also very realistically depicted.
But the best thing about this book was the wonderful representation it gives to non-binary kids, showing both how they're different from other kids but also very much the same. The musical backdrop underscores the fact that non-binary people exist everywhere, in every field. The choice to have both protagonists be non-binary was also excellent. There may be fewer non-binary kids in the world than other genders, but that doesn't mean that having just one in a story is enough. Having both take center stage makes it clear that their stories are just as important and diverse as anybody else's.
I also wanted to say that I really liked the interior art, especially the color selections, textures and musical depictions. I do think it's a weird trend in a lot of recent graphic novels aimed at younger audiences to have very awkward-looking covers that only barely hint at the expressiveness inside. The presentation otherwise of this book is great, making it a nice solid volume to hand to my eldest kid as he complains about being bored already on summer vacation.
Camp Prodigy by Caroline Palmer was published June 11 2024 by Atheneum Books For Young Readers and is available from all good booksellers, including
August 13, 2025
A heartwarming middle grade graphic novel about a group of violists learning to forge friendships and conquer their anxieties at summer camp.
Tate Seong decides to pick up the viola after attending a life changing concert. Afraid that they'll never be good enough to perform, Tate decides that they're going to sit out of this year's concerts. Desperate to help them out, Tate's parents tell them about a summer camp called Camp Prodigy for young string players who desire to hone their skills. Once they arrive at camp, Tate meets the young violist who changed their life, Eli Violet. The two nonbinary youths soon strike a deal and find themselves working together to become the best musicians they can be.
This story was such a cute one. As a violist myself, this was truly a heartwarming read that reminded me heavily of many of my own memories. I may never have went to a summer camp, but I've participated in enough sectionals, ensembles, and other orchestral shenanigans to find this book very nostalgic. Pair that with the many church mission trips I went on in my teen years, this book was reminiscent of many of my own experiences.
Tate is struggling with their identity and telling their family that they are nonbinary. Not only does Eli help Tate hone their skills on the viola, Eli also helps them gain the confidence they need to tell others who they truly are. Middle grade stories that feature coming out in such a positive way are always great to see, so I am happy to add "Camp Prodigy" to my list of middle grade queer book recs.
I must say, it took me a hot second to get used to this art style, but it grew on me rather quickly. When I started this book I truly thought that the art was going to take away from the story immensely, but I ended up finding myself enjoying it before the story was through.
This book is a great reminder to enjoy the small things in life and to not be afraid to ask for help from your loved ones. Life gets stressful, so it's important to give yourself a break and not push yourself harder than you'd push anyone else. I truly adore the way that Tate and Eli's families treats them, and I think being comfortable enough to communicate one's needs to their family is an important thing for all children to have and to witness in media.
Overall, I really enjoyed the time I spent with "Camp Prodigy." It is such a sweet middle grade graphic novel that highlights so many unique different string players. It urges the reader to give themself grace and to ask for help when they need it. Tate and Eli's platonic relationship was so endearing and it was amazing to see the two of them bond with their fellow violists. Pair that with all of the diversity and queer rep, this book is a banger of a read. As a string player myself, I highly recommend checking this one out.
Tate Seong decides to pick up the viola after attending a life changing concert. Afraid that they'll never be good enough to perform, Tate decides that they're going to sit out of this year's concerts. Desperate to help them out, Tate's parents tell them about a summer camp called Camp Prodigy for young string players who desire to hone their skills. Once they arrive at camp, Tate meets the young violist who changed their life, Eli Violet. The two nonbinary youths soon strike a deal and find themselves working together to become the best musicians they can be.
This story was such a cute one. As a violist myself, this was truly a heartwarming read that reminded me heavily of many of my own memories. I may never have went to a summer camp, but I've participated in enough sectionals, ensembles, and other orchestral shenanigans to find this book very nostalgic. Pair that with the many church mission trips I went on in my teen years, this book was reminiscent of many of my own experiences.
Tate is struggling with their identity and telling their family that they are nonbinary. Not only does Eli help Tate hone their skills on the viola, Eli also helps them gain the confidence they need to tell others who they truly are. Middle grade stories that feature coming out in such a positive way are always great to see, so I am happy to add "Camp Prodigy" to my list of middle grade queer book recs.
I must say, it took me a hot second to get used to this art style, but it grew on me rather quickly. When I started this book I truly thought that the art was going to take away from the story immensely, but I ended up finding myself enjoying it before the story was through.
This book is a great reminder to enjoy the small things in life and to not be afraid to ask for help from your loved ones. Life gets stressful, so it's important to give yourself a break and not push yourself harder than you'd push anyone else. I truly adore the way that Tate and Eli's families treats them, and I think being comfortable enough to communicate one's needs to their family is an important thing for all children to have and to witness in media.
Overall, I really enjoyed the time I spent with "Camp Prodigy." It is such a sweet middle grade graphic novel that highlights so many unique different string players. It urges the reader to give themself grace and to ask for help when they need it. Tate and Eli's platonic relationship was so endearing and it was amazing to see the two of them bond with their fellow violists. Pair that with all of the diversity and queer rep, this book is a banger of a read. As a string player myself, I highly recommend checking this one out.
July 24, 2024
First and foremost, there's a bias for me. I grew up with Caroline Palmer and had the privilege of having lunch, various art classes, and many sleepovers with them during our pre-teen and high school years. I saw Palmer's art style in its "infancy" and was introduced to a variety of characters and comics as our friendship continued (and still does). Anyone who knows them personally understands that Palmer takes their craft, storytelling, and artwork seriously. All I'm going to say is, when I heard that they had secured a Big Five publisher, I was impressed but not surprised. 😜
Onto my review of the book... (Contains some spoilers):
Camp Prodigy is a solid debut. The story has elements of humor, nonconformity, and a message that most youth would be looking for: "Be yourself. Challenge your thoughts. Step out of your comfort zone once in a while." At the same time, Palmer's storytelling reflects real-life; there's parallels to Tate's coming out as non-binary that I'm sure reflects Palmer's own memories.
Some parents might be concerned with this novel, considering the intended demographic and the concept of someone being non-binary. I promise you: There's no "agenda," there's no "brainwashing," etc. This is storytelling. This is fiction, with elements of the author's own reflections growing up. It's okay to be somewhat uncomfortable with something you don't entirely understand. We're all human. And Camp Prodigy reflects on this.
My two biggest critiques? Length and backstory.
I would've loved for the novel to be longer. We're introduced to a plethora of characters and while they all had a chance to shine, I wanted to know them more. (Side note: I'm curious as to how much Palmer had to cut from the story overall, in terms of editing.) As for backstory, I'm curious to know how Eli and Tate both realized they were non-binary. There's implications here and there, but a few flashbacks for one or both characters would've been helpful in understanding their journey; especially as some well-meaning parents are attempting to understand their own child's coming out IRL.
My two biggest compliments? The realism and the art style.
At the end of Camp Prodigy , one character bows out, admitting to the pressure and expectations being too much for them. It's a happy ending for the most part, though the reader may have their own two cents about what should've happened. But you also understand that the author relates to being a prodigy, and how far one could crack due to performance anxiety. I've already applauded Palmer's art style, and I'll do it again: LOVE IT! 😊
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / 5
Onto my review of the book... (Contains some spoilers):
Camp Prodigy is a solid debut. The story has elements of humor, nonconformity, and a message that most youth would be looking for: "Be yourself. Challenge your thoughts. Step out of your comfort zone once in a while." At the same time, Palmer's storytelling reflects real-life; there's parallels to Tate's coming out as non-binary that I'm sure reflects Palmer's own memories.
Some parents might be concerned with this novel, considering the intended demographic and the concept of someone being non-binary. I promise you: There's no "agenda," there's no "brainwashing," etc. This is storytelling. This is fiction, with elements of the author's own reflections growing up. It's okay to be somewhat uncomfortable with something you don't entirely understand. We're all human. And Camp Prodigy reflects on this.
My two biggest critiques? Length and backstory.
I would've loved for the novel to be longer. We're introduced to a plethora of characters and while they all had a chance to shine, I wanted to know them more. (Side note: I'm curious as to how much Palmer had to cut from the story overall, in terms of editing.) As for backstory, I'm curious to know how Eli and Tate both realized they were non-binary. There's implications here and there, but a few flashbacks for one or both characters would've been helpful in understanding their journey; especially as some well-meaning parents are attempting to understand their own child's coming out IRL.
My two biggest compliments? The realism and the art style.
At the end of Camp Prodigy , one character bows out, admitting to the pressure and expectations being too much for them. It's a happy ending for the most part, though the reader may have their own two cents about what should've happened. But you also understand that the author relates to being a prodigy, and how far one could crack due to performance anxiety. I've already applauded Palmer's art style, and I'll do it again: LOVE IT! 😊
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / 5
January 4, 2024
ARC provided by Young Adult Books Central
In this graphic novel, we meet Tate Seong, who became enthralled with the idea of playing viola after hearing a prodigy his age, Eli Violet, backstage before a concert. Unfortunately, Eli (who uses they/them pronouns), was so anxious that they didn't go on stage, but Tate did pick up the viola. He isn't very good, but his parents are behind him 100%, but also want him to think about playing a sport, since that would make him a well rounded young man. Tate is uncomfortable identifying as male, but isn't sure how to go about telling anyone this. At Camp Prodigy, there are a lot of different campers, some of whom, like Xin, are very driven, and others who want to take advantage of typical camp activities like gimp bracelet making, hiking, and swimming. Tate meets Eli, who reluctantly agrees to help tutor Tate as long as he keeps their secret about erstwhile fame. Tate works hard, but struggles with not only the viola, but with a lot of anxiety about playing in public as well as a deep seated feeling of confusion about what to do about his nonbinary status. Eli is a good ally, and he seeks their advice about when they came out to their moms. When Tate gets a big solo and is unsure whether he can stand up in front of the audience, his new friends come to the rescue, reminding him that he doesn't have to do everything alone, and there are other people who can step in to help. At the end, Tate comes out to their parents, retaining their name, and the parents are very supportive.
Palmer's illustrations are solid, and often fall into the popular Manga style eye pops and dramatic emotions, which graphic novels tend to love but remind me of Speed Racer. The characters look different enough from each other that I was never confused, and it was very helpful when the new campers were introduced and appeared on the bottom of the page with their names. I'd love to see more books do that. There are notes on the evolution of the drawings at the end of the book.
Many middle grade readers have struggled with anxiety since the Pandemic, and Eli and Tate's journey toward understanding the underlying causes of their stress and fear are well portrayed. The other campers, counselors, and parents are all supportive, and even a character that is very competitive at the beginning, Xin, helps in the end.
Readers who are huge fans of Raina Telgemeier's Drama or Chmakova's Berrybrook Middle school will enjoy this look at a high pressure, elite musical camp.
In this graphic novel, we meet Tate Seong, who became enthralled with the idea of playing viola after hearing a prodigy his age, Eli Violet, backstage before a concert. Unfortunately, Eli (who uses they/them pronouns), was so anxious that they didn't go on stage, but Tate did pick up the viola. He isn't very good, but his parents are behind him 100%, but also want him to think about playing a sport, since that would make him a well rounded young man. Tate is uncomfortable identifying as male, but isn't sure how to go about telling anyone this. At Camp Prodigy, there are a lot of different campers, some of whom, like Xin, are very driven, and others who want to take advantage of typical camp activities like gimp bracelet making, hiking, and swimming. Tate meets Eli, who reluctantly agrees to help tutor Tate as long as he keeps their secret about erstwhile fame. Tate works hard, but struggles with not only the viola, but with a lot of anxiety about playing in public as well as a deep seated feeling of confusion about what to do about his nonbinary status. Eli is a good ally, and he seeks their advice about when they came out to their moms. When Tate gets a big solo and is unsure whether he can stand up in front of the audience, his new friends come to the rescue, reminding him that he doesn't have to do everything alone, and there are other people who can step in to help. At the end, Tate comes out to their parents, retaining their name, and the parents are very supportive.
Palmer's illustrations are solid, and often fall into the popular Manga style eye pops and dramatic emotions, which graphic novels tend to love but remind me of Speed Racer. The characters look different enough from each other that I was never confused, and it was very helpful when the new campers were introduced and appeared on the bottom of the page with their names. I'd love to see more books do that. There are notes on the evolution of the drawings at the end of the book.
Many middle grade readers have struggled with anxiety since the Pandemic, and Eli and Tate's journey toward understanding the underlying causes of their stress and fear are well portrayed. The other campers, counselors, and parents are all supportive, and even a character that is very competitive at the beginning, Xin, helps in the end.
Readers who are huge fans of Raina Telgemeier's Drama or Chmakova's Berrybrook Middle school will enjoy this look at a high pressure, elite musical camp.
May 28, 2024
"Camp Prodigy" is a delightful and heartwarming graphic novel that strikes all the right chords. Caroline Palmer masterfully crafts a story that is as rich in character as it is in emotion. The cast of odd and lovable characters makes this book a standout, each one bringing their unique personality to the forefront, ensuring that every middle grader will find someone to identify with.
Tate Seong is an inspiring protagonist, whose journey from self-doubt to self-acceptance is both relatable and moving. Their struggles with confidence, identity, and the pressure to perform are depicted with sensitivity and realism. Eli, on the other hand, presents a compelling narrative about the pressures of prodigious talent and the anxiety that often accompanies it. Their dynamic together is beautifully portrayed, showcasing a friendship that is supportive, understanding, and transformative.
One of the highlights of "Camp Prodigy" is its nonbinary representation. Both Tate and Eli's stories provide a much-needed perspective that is both specific to their experiences and universally relatable. Palmer handles these themes with grace, offering young readers a chance to see themselves in characters who are navigating similar challenges.
The setting of a summer orchestra camp is perfect for music lovers and band or orchestra nerds. Palmer's depiction of the camp is vibrant and full of life, making it a place readers will wish they could visit. The detailed and charming illustrations add an extra layer of engagement, bringing the story and its characters to life in a way that words alone could not.
"Camp Prodigy" also delves into the pressures of achieving excellence and the toll it can take on young minds. It's a powerful reminder that being "good" at something isn't the only path to fulfillment and that perseverance and passion are just as important.
In conclusion, "Camp Prodigy" by Caroline Palmer is a touching and inspiring graphic novel that will resonate with readers of all ages. Its heartwarming story, diverse cast of characters, and beautiful artwork make it a standout read. Don't miss your chance to enter our giveaway and win a copy of this fantastic book. Whether you're a music enthusiast, a middle grader looking for relatable characters or someone who loves a good summer camp adventure, "Camp Prodigy" is a book you'll want to add to your collection.
Thank you, Atheneum for Young Readers for the book and my honest review. For more reviews and book giveaways visit my blog https://www.kimsbookreviewsandwriting....
Tate Seong is an inspiring protagonist, whose journey from self-doubt to self-acceptance is both relatable and moving. Their struggles with confidence, identity, and the pressure to perform are depicted with sensitivity and realism. Eli, on the other hand, presents a compelling narrative about the pressures of prodigious talent and the anxiety that often accompanies it. Their dynamic together is beautifully portrayed, showcasing a friendship that is supportive, understanding, and transformative.
One of the highlights of "Camp Prodigy" is its nonbinary representation. Both Tate and Eli's stories provide a much-needed perspective that is both specific to their experiences and universally relatable. Palmer handles these themes with grace, offering young readers a chance to see themselves in characters who are navigating similar challenges.
The setting of a summer orchestra camp is perfect for music lovers and band or orchestra nerds. Palmer's depiction of the camp is vibrant and full of life, making it a place readers will wish they could visit. The detailed and charming illustrations add an extra layer of engagement, bringing the story and its characters to life in a way that words alone could not.
"Camp Prodigy" also delves into the pressures of achieving excellence and the toll it can take on young minds. It's a powerful reminder that being "good" at something isn't the only path to fulfillment and that perseverance and passion are just as important.
In conclusion, "Camp Prodigy" by Caroline Palmer is a touching and inspiring graphic novel that will resonate with readers of all ages. Its heartwarming story, diverse cast of characters, and beautiful artwork make it a standout read. Don't miss your chance to enter our giveaway and win a copy of this fantastic book. Whether you're a music enthusiast, a middle grader looking for relatable characters or someone who loves a good summer camp adventure, "Camp Prodigy" is a book you'll want to add to your collection.
Thank you, Atheneum for Young Readers for the book and my honest review. For more reviews and book giveaways visit my blog https://www.kimsbookreviewsandwriting....
May 31, 2024
ARC provided by publisher however all thoughts and opinions my own.
In Caroline Palmer’s Camp Prodigy readers meet Tate Seong, who after being deeply inspired by an electrifying concert, dreams of becoming a professional violist. However, there’s a tough hurdle to get across: they are the least skilled musician at their school. Tate struggles not only with musical confidence but also with asserting themselves among friends and coming out as non-binary to their family.
The turning point comes when Tate enrolls in a summer program at Camp Prodigy, an orchestra camp. There, they unexpectedly meet Eli, the exceptional violist whose performance originally helped boost Tate’s passion for music. Despite Eli’s extraordinary talent, they have been avoiding the spotlight due to a debilitating nervous breakdown from their past performances.
As Tate and Eli grow closer, they bond and help each other shine as a violist and overcome their stage fright. Camp Prodigy explores whether they can navigate their challenges and support each other in achieving their musical dreams, or if the mounting pressure will overwhelm them both.
The Camp Prodigy graphic novel stands out as a remarkable piece of nonbinary representation, making it an excellent choice for Pride Month reads or book lists. Tate Seong’s journey reflects the authentic struggles and triumphs of coming out and self-acceptance. The story delicately portrays the nuances of being nonbinary in a society that often fails to understand or accept gender diversity. Particularly poignant is when Tate finally does come out to their parents and their reaction. It’s not one of anger but it’s a quiet admittance that they don’t quite understand what non-binary means but they are very willing to learn. The book’s sensitive exploration of Tate’s identity and coming out experience makes it a perfect read for Pride Month.
Camp Prodigy also speaks directly to Type A personalities, particularly those who are hard on themselves when they fall short of perfection. Eli’s initial lack of confidence and subsequent growth to overcome anxiety surrounding stage fright is a great example that perfectionists often face. Eli’s journey at Camp Prodigy, alongside Tate, offers a compelling story about resilience, self-discovery, and the importance of accepting imperfection.
This graphic novel should resonate with tween and teen readers who struggle with high expectations and self-doubt, because it boils down to a sweet story of overcoming personal challenges.
In Caroline Palmer’s Camp Prodigy readers meet Tate Seong, who after being deeply inspired by an electrifying concert, dreams of becoming a professional violist. However, there’s a tough hurdle to get across: they are the least skilled musician at their school. Tate struggles not only with musical confidence but also with asserting themselves among friends and coming out as non-binary to their family.
The turning point comes when Tate enrolls in a summer program at Camp Prodigy, an orchestra camp. There, they unexpectedly meet Eli, the exceptional violist whose performance originally helped boost Tate’s passion for music. Despite Eli’s extraordinary talent, they have been avoiding the spotlight due to a debilitating nervous breakdown from their past performances.
As Tate and Eli grow closer, they bond and help each other shine as a violist and overcome their stage fright. Camp Prodigy explores whether they can navigate their challenges and support each other in achieving their musical dreams, or if the mounting pressure will overwhelm them both.
The Camp Prodigy graphic novel stands out as a remarkable piece of nonbinary representation, making it an excellent choice for Pride Month reads or book lists. Tate Seong’s journey reflects the authentic struggles and triumphs of coming out and self-acceptance. The story delicately portrays the nuances of being nonbinary in a society that often fails to understand or accept gender diversity. Particularly poignant is when Tate finally does come out to their parents and their reaction. It’s not one of anger but it’s a quiet admittance that they don’t quite understand what non-binary means but they are very willing to learn. The book’s sensitive exploration of Tate’s identity and coming out experience makes it a perfect read for Pride Month.
Camp Prodigy also speaks directly to Type A personalities, particularly those who are hard on themselves when they fall short of perfection. Eli’s initial lack of confidence and subsequent growth to overcome anxiety surrounding stage fright is a great example that perfectionists often face. Eli’s journey at Camp Prodigy, alongside Tate, offers a compelling story about resilience, self-discovery, and the importance of accepting imperfection.
This graphic novel should resonate with tween and teen readers who struggle with high expectations and self-doubt, because it boils down to a sweet story of overcoming personal challenges.
May 17, 2024
Before we dive in, I would like to start by thanking Simon & Schuster for providing me with an early copy of the novel in exchange for an honest review!
"Maybe it would sound pretty to you again if you focused less on technical skill and more on just enjoying the activity of making music itself?"
"Camp Prodigy" was a short yet engaging read, featuring a diverse cast of vibrant characters. It delved into themes that resonated not only with young adult readers but with everyone, exploring topics such as self-identity, burnout, imposter syndrome, and the importance of taking a well-needed break. The story centers around Tate, a nonbinary individual who finds inspiration in child prodigy Eli Violet. While searching for the bathroom, Tate witnesses Eli practicing for their upcoming performance; however, upon returning to their seat, Eli rushes off the stage, overwhelmed by the anxiety of needing to be perfect.
Despite Eli's stage fright, Tate is motivated to take on the violin after being amazed by Eli's practicing session. However, they struggle with feelings of inadequacy and believe they're making no progress, feeling unfit to perform in their school's concert. After opening up to their family about their struggles, they suggest Camp Prodigy—a place where Tate can immerse themselves in their passion for music and grow as a musician.
However, upon arriving at the camp, Tate is not only met with new faces but also greeted by a familiar one—none other than Eli themselves, now going by an alias, attempting to make a comeback after their disastrous night. There, over the next few weeks, the pair team up, tackling challenges like making new friends, mastering sheet music, chair tests, self-identity, overcoming imposter syndrome, feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and much more.
While I can understand that the art style might not be everyone's cup of tea (it was mine, due to how expressive and stylized it was!) and that some parts of the graphic novel have a bit of rocky pacing, I truly enjoyed reading this book! As a fellow queer band kid, I could relate to Tate's social anxieties and Eli's drive for perfection, especially regarding family expectations. I would read it again.
4/5
"Maybe it would sound pretty to you again if you focused less on technical skill and more on just enjoying the activity of making music itself?"
"Camp Prodigy" was a short yet engaging read, featuring a diverse cast of vibrant characters. It delved into themes that resonated not only with young adult readers but with everyone, exploring topics such as self-identity, burnout, imposter syndrome, and the importance of taking a well-needed break. The story centers around Tate, a nonbinary individual who finds inspiration in child prodigy Eli Violet. While searching for the bathroom, Tate witnesses Eli practicing for their upcoming performance; however, upon returning to their seat, Eli rushes off the stage, overwhelmed by the anxiety of needing to be perfect.
Despite Eli's stage fright, Tate is motivated to take on the violin after being amazed by Eli's practicing session. However, they struggle with feelings of inadequacy and believe they're making no progress, feeling unfit to perform in their school's concert. After opening up to their family about their struggles, they suggest Camp Prodigy—a place where Tate can immerse themselves in their passion for music and grow as a musician.
However, upon arriving at the camp, Tate is not only met with new faces but also greeted by a familiar one—none other than Eli themselves, now going by an alias, attempting to make a comeback after their disastrous night. There, over the next few weeks, the pair team up, tackling challenges like making new friends, mastering sheet music, chair tests, self-identity, overcoming imposter syndrome, feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and much more.
While I can understand that the art style might not be everyone's cup of tea (it was mine, due to how expressive and stylized it was!) and that some parts of the graphic novel have a bit of rocky pacing, I truly enjoyed reading this book! As a fellow queer band kid, I could relate to Tate's social anxieties and Eli's drive for perfection, especially regarding family expectations. I would read it again.
4/5
May 27, 2024
Tate isn’t sure what extra curricular activity fits but when Eli Violet, a child prodigy, is heard playing their viola, a new string instrument player is born! A summer camp designed to improve orchestra members’ abilities while also participating in the usual arts & crafts, swimming and sports activities is offered, Tate snaps at the chance to improve. Surprisingly, Eli Violet is there, too, but under an assumed name as they try to overcome a severe case of burnout coupled with intense anxiety. The two become friends and begin to share thoughts and feelings with one another and soon realize that they have similarities well beyond simply playing the viola—both are non-binary and both are struggling with anxiety. Tate and Eli make a deal to help one another leading Tate to not only earn section leader status and the big solo during the end of summer concert but to come out to friends and family.
The subtle advice to tweens and early teens about seeking out help for emotional struggles in a variety of places begins right away and may be of real benefit to readers whether to help them find relief for their own panic or to gain some understanding of others. A message of working hard, goal setting and determination to improve skills comes through loud and clear without seeming “preachy.” The coming out aspect of Camp Prodigy did seem rather contrived with Eli Violet coming from a two mom family and finding it easy to announce their pronouns of they/them to everyone and Tate only needing one month to gain the courage to come out to new friends and his family. The responses from all was easy acceptance and understanding which is fairly unrealistic. The action of a camp counselor asking each camper to share their name and pronouns during the first meet and greet may be common in some areas, but would not be typical in others.
Text is free of profanity, violence and sexual content. Representation: Black and Caucasian characters, several non-binary characters and Eli Violet has two moms, campers’ body shapes, clothing choices and hairstyles demonstrate a great variety, one camper is on the spectrum. Target age group: grades 5-8.
Thanks for the print arc, Simon & Schuster/Atheneum Publishing.
The subtle advice to tweens and early teens about seeking out help for emotional struggles in a variety of places begins right away and may be of real benefit to readers whether to help them find relief for their own panic or to gain some understanding of others. A message of working hard, goal setting and determination to improve skills comes through loud and clear without seeming “preachy.” The coming out aspect of Camp Prodigy did seem rather contrived with Eli Violet coming from a two mom family and finding it easy to announce their pronouns of they/them to everyone and Tate only needing one month to gain the courage to come out to new friends and his family. The responses from all was easy acceptance and understanding which is fairly unrealistic. The action of a camp counselor asking each camper to share their name and pronouns during the first meet and greet may be common in some areas, but would not be typical in others.
Text is free of profanity, violence and sexual content. Representation: Black and Caucasian characters, several non-binary characters and Eli Violet has two moms, campers’ body shapes, clothing choices and hairstyles demonstrate a great variety, one camper is on the spectrum. Target age group: grades 5-8.
Thanks for the print arc, Simon & Schuster/Atheneum Publishing.
June 6, 2024
Camp Prodigy was a fun and wholesome summer camp story!
I absolutely loved the color palette and expressive art style in this graphic novel. I liked the cool backmatter showing the author/artist’s concept art, writing and drawing process, and other preparations that went into creating Camp Prodigy.
Tate and Eli were wonderful main characters who are nonbinary and love playing the viola. Through ups and downs they supported each other’s progress to be better as violists and individuals. It was interesting how what they worried about at the beginning of camp starts to reverse as time goes on. What they see happening to the other helps them come to terms with their anxieties about performing.
Tate’s enthusiasm for the viola was so cute and inspiring to see. Although dreadful at first, I admired that they kept trying to improve and that their family and music teacher still supported them.
Eli was determined to regain their confidence and go pro by attending Camp Prodigy anonymously. Many will relate to the burden that is perfectionism that Eli has carried on their shoulders for so long. Tate and the rest of the delightful campers were the perfect antithesis for them, encouraging Eli to take a break and enjoy the camp experience.
I loved Camp Prodigy from start to finish. It was funny, nostalgic, and relatable. Through their beautiful friendship with Eli, Tate finds the courage to happily be his authentic self as an openly nonbinary person. In turn, Eli learns to de-stress and that mistakes are okay to make. Camp Prodigy is a great read for the summer!
Thanks again Atheneum Books for Young Readers and NetGalley for the e-arc to read in exchange for an honest review!
I absolutely loved the color palette and expressive art style in this graphic novel. I liked the cool backmatter showing the author/artist’s concept art, writing and drawing process, and other preparations that went into creating Camp Prodigy.
Tate and Eli were wonderful main characters who are nonbinary and love playing the viola. Through ups and downs they supported each other’s progress to be better as violists and individuals. It was interesting how what they worried about at the beginning of camp starts to reverse as time goes on. What they see happening to the other helps them come to terms with their anxieties about performing.
Tate’s enthusiasm for the viola was so cute and inspiring to see. Although dreadful at first, I admired that they kept trying to improve and that their family and music teacher still supported them.
Eli was determined to regain their confidence and go pro by attending Camp Prodigy anonymously. Many will relate to the burden that is perfectionism that Eli has carried on their shoulders for so long. Tate and the rest of the delightful campers were the perfect antithesis for them, encouraging Eli to take a break and enjoy the camp experience.
I loved Camp Prodigy from start to finish. It was funny, nostalgic, and relatable. Through their beautiful friendship with Eli, Tate finds the courage to happily be his authentic self as an openly nonbinary person. In turn, Eli learns to de-stress and that mistakes are okay to make. Camp Prodigy is a great read for the summer!
Thanks again Atheneum Books for Young Readers and NetGalley for the e-arc to read in exchange for an honest review!
January 2, 2024
Tate Seong is inspired to take up the viola after hearing about Eli Violet, a kid their age who is a virtuoso. When Tate goes to a month long music camp, Camp Prodigy, Eli is there! Tate is so psyched to meet Eli, and soon the two kids are practicing together. Tate becomes obsessed with reaching first chair in the orchestra, but Eli is aiming for it too, as well as the super serious Xin. Will the young musicians be able to reach their musical potential without trampling on one another’s feelings? As Tate gets more and more pumped with his musical progress, Eli helps them take on another challenge: telling their family and friends that they are non binary.
I loved this fast paced novel of friendship, music and owning your true self. Tate (biracial) and Eli (Black with two Moms)’ friendship grows believably, and they each have something to learn from one another. The other kids at camp are fun and diverse, with gender pronoun reveals supported and part of normal camp life. It was fun seeing a kid grow in musical ability and to connect that with the new courage to come out. All adults are kind, and it was so satisfying to see Tate’s family lovingly support their coming out. Although most of the ARC is in black and white, the manga-like art’s final colors appear at the beginning and are vibrant and appealing, with lots of purple and magenta.
This is perfect for fans of realistic graphic novels such as those by Raina Telgemeier and Victoria Jamieson. Kids into music will enjoy lots about this book as well.
I loved this fast paced novel of friendship, music and owning your true self. Tate (biracial) and Eli (Black with two Moms)’ friendship grows believably, and they each have something to learn from one another. The other kids at camp are fun and diverse, with gender pronoun reveals supported and part of normal camp life. It was fun seeing a kid grow in musical ability and to connect that with the new courage to come out. All adults are kind, and it was so satisfying to see Tate’s family lovingly support their coming out. Although most of the ARC is in black and white, the manga-like art’s final colors appear at the beginning and are vibrant and appealing, with lots of purple and magenta.
This is perfect for fans of realistic graphic novels such as those by Raina Telgemeier and Victoria Jamieson. Kids into music will enjoy lots about this book as well.
October 30, 2025
When Tate heard Eli rehearsing for a major professional concert, Tate fell in love with the viola and decided to learn to play--even though Eli had a nervous breakdown and couldn't play at the concert. Tate loves the viola...but is pretty bad at playing it. His parents suggest a month at Camp Prodigy, a music camp that also offers the typical camp activities, and mixed-gender cabins. Music isn't the only thing Tate is struggling with, though--they know Eli is nonbinary, and wish they had the courage to come out as nonbinary themselves. At camp, Tate actually runs into Eli, and they become besties. Eli agrees to help Tate with the viola, and Tate helps Eli find some balance and do some other fun camp activities. Eli is struggling with expectations for their prowess, and Tate, though improving every day as a violist, is struggling with their gender identity and coming out. Can they help each other live their best lives--whatever that may encompass?
I love a good camp story, and was so happy this was a camp with all the activities in addition to music. I thought the main characters' trials and tribulations were well-represented, and that the message is more about finding the goals that will make you happy, rather than any one path leading to happiness and fulfillment. The art style worked well, though there were some characters I did have trouble differentiating, and most of the background characters didn't stand out to me as much as I would have wished. Anyway, an enjoyable camp story!
I love a good camp story, and was so happy this was a camp with all the activities in addition to music. I thought the main characters' trials and tribulations were well-represented, and that the message is more about finding the goals that will make you happy, rather than any one path leading to happiness and fulfillment. The art style worked well, though there were some characters I did have trouble differentiating, and most of the background characters didn't stand out to me as much as I would have wished. Anyway, an enjoyable camp story!
June 17, 2024
I liked a few things about this book overall, one it is a graphic novel. I LOVE graphic novels. I love Tate's family, they are very nice overall as they are trying to help Tate with the music and being a violist. I also like the characters were written well in this book overall of Tate and also Eli. Eli was a great character and the violist who inspired Tate to become one!
One thing I am not a huge fan of is the nonbinary thing, I can read stories with nonbinary material in them, however I do not like that it is a children's book. Nonbinary is a very serious thing and you need to be a person who can think fully before you refer to yourself as that or change genders or anything else. I can not condone this part of the book as a mom, it could change kids minds on things.
However, the story itself is good overall. I enjoy the relationship between Eli and Tate. They made me want to finish the book and find out if Eli plays in front of people or if Tate gets any better as a violist. I have never been to summer camp and I liked the pictures and the descriptions of what it is like. Also I loved meeting the other campers. That was such a great part of the book. There is so much they do in the camp all summer long! And lastly I do like the fact that Tate has friends with all the kids from camp at the end. That is the best part of being young, making friends with kids at summer camps!
One thing I am not a huge fan of is the nonbinary thing, I can read stories with nonbinary material in them, however I do not like that it is a children's book. Nonbinary is a very serious thing and you need to be a person who can think fully before you refer to yourself as that or change genders or anything else. I can not condone this part of the book as a mom, it could change kids minds on things.
However, the story itself is good overall. I enjoy the relationship between Eli and Tate. They made me want to finish the book and find out if Eli plays in front of people or if Tate gets any better as a violist. I have never been to summer camp and I liked the pictures and the descriptions of what it is like. Also I loved meeting the other campers. That was such a great part of the book. There is so much they do in the camp all summer long! And lastly I do like the fact that Tate has friends with all the kids from camp at the end. That is the best part of being young, making friends with kids at summer camps!
February 7, 2025
I'm not quite sure what to make of this one.
This is a middle grade graphic novel about a kid named Tate who goes to a music camp over the summer in hopes of being a great musician. It's also a story about coming out for the first time as a nonbinary person.
My main struggle is the age group this is marketed for, 8-12 year old's. A lot of kids will have trouble understanding the full scope of the nonbinary topic. Some may not be able to handle it maturely, either. It should be approached with caution and care when recommending this book to young readers.
Personal enjoyment wise, I thought this was a little on the boring side for a graphic novel. The music plot I found drawn out and predictable (even for a kids book). Maybe another plot line in the story was needed or this part of the story needed to be elaborated on.
I thought the art style was okay, nothing remarkable and nothing to dreary. There's a lot of kids who will be drawn to this art style as it looks similar to a lot of current popular kids graphic novels.
The best part of this book was friendship. Tate seems to struggle with friendship at the start of the book just slightly. They are at this new camp, and starting out in a new place and meeting people can sometimes be a little scary. They are also struggling with their identity. They make good friendships where it seems like they're understood and feel comfortable.
This is a middle grade graphic novel about a kid named Tate who goes to a music camp over the summer in hopes of being a great musician. It's also a story about coming out for the first time as a nonbinary person.
My main struggle is the age group this is marketed for, 8-12 year old's. A lot of kids will have trouble understanding the full scope of the nonbinary topic. Some may not be able to handle it maturely, either. It should be approached with caution and care when recommending this book to young readers.
Personal enjoyment wise, I thought this was a little on the boring side for a graphic novel. The music plot I found drawn out and predictable (even for a kids book). Maybe another plot line in the story was needed or this part of the story needed to be elaborated on.
I thought the art style was okay, nothing remarkable and nothing to dreary. There's a lot of kids who will be drawn to this art style as it looks similar to a lot of current popular kids graphic novels.
The best part of this book was friendship. Tate seems to struggle with friendship at the start of the book just slightly. They are at this new camp, and starting out in a new place and meeting people can sometimes be a little scary. They are also struggling with their identity. They make good friendships where it seems like they're understood and feel comfortable.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews