This was about 3.5 stars for me, but in a way that was a great reminder to consider target audience. I finished this and immediately knew that it had to be a Christmas present for my dad-- it was a huge hit with him and my sister.
This is going to land better if you're an urban fantasy fan, someone who enjoys progression fantasy and/ or shounen anime, or a fan of scrappy underdogs in general. I casually enjoy all of that rather than loving it, so this was fun without being memorable. For all that I normally love details in a setting like this, I don't care much about magic systems or power levels specifically, so I found my attention wandering during some of the details about the levels of power in different magical wells and what flavor of Pokemon/element magic does what. That's all delivered gradually and not in massive infodumps, but I like a little more soft-edged mystery in my magic.
I'm not much of an action scene fan, but I think that the ones in this book are creative and don't wear out their welcome. Stephen doesn't have a lot of raw power, so he's building little sigls through trial and error and has to work out what's actually practical to carry into a fight. You can tell that he'll be doing plenty of arsenal upgrades in the future, which is always nice to prevent combat scenes from getting stale over the course of a series. I also appreciated that his self-taught methods result in plenty of failures and even sometimes injure him when something doesn't work as expected. Those moments of coming up short add a great touch of realism to the whole process. If you liked the early Dresden Files books, when Harry is using a handful of trusty spells and always feels like he's outclassed, this might be your cup of tea.
There's some deeper infrastructure exploration (commentary on how being a gig worker is awful even in a magical society, class issues, and so on) at times: if that had been in the spotlight, I'd be absolutely fixated on the sequels. Instead, it's good background content, and I think something that will affect the rest of the series. In another type of story, Stephen would just get to the top of the heap, reversing his fortune, but I suspect that this one will involve a deeper questioning of the system's failures and Stephen doing something like declining a comfortable position in the current hierarchy to push for major change. The question of whether to reject the system or change it from within is always interesting, and I'd love to see future books explore those paths.
Overall, an interesting read and a great gift pick, just not the best fit for my current reading tastes (except for Hobbes the cat, who seems delightful).
//
Somewhere around 3.5 stars for this one. In the beginning, it felt a little flat for me: there's a lot of explaining the magic system and establishing Stephen as a scrappy underdog who's fighting uphill, and that's all fine but not memorable. Somewhere around the half to two-thirds mark, though, the story takes a thoughtful turn into talking about how precarious it is to be a freelance gig worker, even in the magical community. Urban fantasy leads often wear being slightly broke as part of the outfit, just something to coax them into risky jobs, but you can really feel the way Stephen is watching his bank balance, or how he's so tired from dead-end jobs that it's hard to think about anything else. I enjoyed the surprise digressions into him having to theology reading in exchange for help on drucraft problems. Overall, an interesting time, and I do love Hobbes the cat. RTC.
(Audiobook people, help me out: how do you say "sigl"? Is it kind of like "sigil," or more like "sile" with a long i? More like the German way, which veers toward "seagull"? The word looks odd and I never settled on a mental pronunciation.)