This book caught my eye at a local bookstore and I decided to get it on a whim since I’ve been wanting to read more history and was intrigued by the time frame, in which my grandmother would be been approximately my age and my mom was young. It was the longest it’s taken me to read a book in a while but I found it very interesting and informative. It was also made a longer read since I was flipping to the back to read about the Cast of Characters as they arise throughout to get additional biographical information. I also tried at first to write a short blurb next to the names of these people as they appeared until I realized there were too many to do so. It’s a very comprehensive list, which I appreciated because I feel like a lot of integral figures during this movement have been forgotten.
What sets this book apart from many other historical nonfiction books is that the author Clara Bingham chose to include very little narration. Instead, she chose to structure the book almost exclusively on firsthand accounts conducted by a series of interviews she did, as well as compiling other sources from the time such as newspaper articles, television quotes, legal documents, and more. The sheer volume of material would’ve been so much work to gather and organize into this book and Bingham did a great job of doing so both chronologically and by topic. She covered so many related to feminism at the time- the legal system, sports (tennis specifically), art, academics, journalism, politics, health (mostly abortion), racism, homophobia, literature, the history of feminism, and general cultural shifts.
The second wave of feminism can often be dismissed as overly focusing on the plight of married, white, middle-class women with families. And certainly, a large portion of the movement consisted of these women, especially in the movement's infancy. However, this book adds more nuance to the conversation, giving voice to those often forgotten. We simply couldn’t have had more progressive third-wave (and fourth-wave, etc.) feminism if it weren’t for the enormous shifts during the second wave, which Bingham classifies largely between 1963- 1973.
Bingham begins by introducing Betty Friedan’s epochal The Feminine Mystique and ends with the National Black Feminist Organization convening in early 1974. This highlights the transition from a more homogenous movement to one that branched and split until there was a place within it for so many more people. The contributions of nonwhite (primarily Black) women and queer should not be understated. I was so glad to learn more about women who were integral to the movement, like Shirley Chisholm, Pauli Murray, Florynce Kennedy, Margaret Sloan, Faith Ringgold, Margo Jefferson, Eleanor Holmes Norton, and others. I’d heard of some Black feminists at the time but this made me much more familiar with their work. Their plight was particularly difficult in the second wave's early years. Black women often toed the line between collaborating with white women who better understood the struggles of women but were ignorant to their racism, and allying with Black men, who understood race but often excluded women in their fight for civil rights. Eventually, many Black women formed their own groups so they could feel a stronger kinship with those who understood their intersectional identities.
Similarly, I learned a lot about queer feminists too. Many are overshadowed now, despite the accusations at the time by many who tried to dismiss the women’s movement as just a bunch of lesbians because they felt it easier to reject it by leaning on society's homophobia. Aligning oneself with lesbians risked adding yet another oppressed group to your identity. However, women like Billie Jean King, Rita Mae Brown, Karla Jay, and Ivy Bottini were able to embrace their queer identities and thus inspire others to do the same during a time when it was seen as unacceptable. Many queer women came out and found a place, if not in the broader feminist movement, then in one of the smaller groups that formed, as many Black women did.
There were so many groups that emerged from the second wave, but many had their own more specific issues they understandably wanted to focus on, divided by levels of extremity, race, sexual orientation, occupation, cause, region, etc. Some include NOW, NFBO, Radicalesbains, FAP, and the NWPC. While many different groups formed due to division among people within the same broader organization, many ultimately moved progress further down the road for so many people who didn’t (or still don’t) realize how much they’ve benefited from their tireless work. Myself included sometimes, especially before reading this book.
I had some cursory knowledge of this time but gained so much more knowledge about pivotal historical events, such as Chisholm's run for president, the Battle of the Sexes, RBG's bringing sex discrimination cases to the Supreme Court, the Janes abortion network, and the slow death of the ERA. And I learned so much about important events and shifts I had no idea about. I feel much better educated on the work of the women who came before me, giving me a newfound appreciation for the opportunities I have today. We have a long way to go in terms of gender equality but we've come so much further than some women in this period may have ever dreamed. Simply learning about and acknowledging these efforts is a great step to finding a path forward.
I could write so much more about The Movement but I'd end up writing a whole essay. I did, however, underline a lot of quotes that stood out to me throughout. I think part of why this book resonated with me so much is that I find it oddly comforting and validating to be reminded how messy history can be. What we are living through today may, in some ways, feel new but it often reflects the past in some way. And there are lessons to be learned there. And many things to be grateful for.
I probably won't be rereading this book anytime soon but I would like to someday to refresh my knowledge, or even just dip into it as a resource. It was a long (and not a light read) but I really enjoyed it.