It’s extremely rare that I think a book is bad. Even when I read books that I completely disagree with or books that have misinformation, I call them out on it, but they’re at least written well. With this book, it almost feels like the editors completely failed this author. And before anyone thinks I just didn’t like it for the subject matter, I’m someone who was canceled years ago and am very much against cancel culture.
This book is just a confused mess. The first question I always ask is, “Who is this book for?”, and I honestly couldn’t tell you with this one. The intro of this book makes it seem like it’ll be an anti-cancel culture or anti-woke book, but then it turns into a sort of self-help book? Is it for people who have been canceled, people who are worried about being canceled, or people who join in online mobs? Well, it’s kind of targeting all of them…I think?
That’s why this book is just poorly written, but now, let’s jump into some of the subject matter.
Aside from the book being bad, this book is potentially harmful in my opinion. When the book is targeting people afraid of getting canceled, it gives terrible advice. She uses anecdotes about people who spoke their mind and managed to come out ahead when the internet came after them. I’m one of the countless people that did not happen to, and that’s the problem, right? Unless really big names come out and have your back or unless you somehow manage to turn your canceling into a grift, you’re pretty screwed. So, just hyping people up like it’ll all work out as long as you’re brave enough (or as she calls it, a “being a maverick” to harness her inner Logan Paul) is absolutely awful advice.
It’s like the books that tell you to not go to college or quit your job and just pursue your passions because it worked out for a few of the rare billionaires.
I think the most frustrating and disappointing part of this book is how much potential it has. When I was canceled, there were no resources for me. My therapist didn’t even know how to help, and I’ve heard the same from many others. This book could have focused on those people and potentially provided some solid advice, but it did none of that.
Usually, at the end of my reviews I can say, “If you like ____ then you may like this book,” but I don’t even think I can say that for this one. This was a huge miss by the author, the editors, and the publisher.