Having read quite a few books on Colonial Latin America in recent months - Garcia Marquez, a couple of Carpentiers - this seemed like a good time to pick up Rolena Adorno's book on the literature of that era. The companion volume in the VSI series, Gonzalez Echevarria on Modern Latin American Literature, was a genuine eye-opener for me, and this book too strives to do its capacious subject some justice within its slender confines.
As per Adorno, the discoverer himself dispatched the first literary work on Latin America - Columbus and his 1493 "Letter of Discovery". In the following chapters, we meet some of the best-known writers of the next three centuries. Bartolome de las Casas, whose "Destruction of the Indies" is dubbed "the most infamous book of the entire Spanish colonial period". Hernan Cortes, whose conqueror's account of the overthrow of the Aztec Empire is challenged (or complemented?) by Bernal Diaz's "Conquest of New Spain", the view of an ordinary foot soldier in the colonizing army. There is an excellent chapter on the polemics of possession - how religious scholars and philosophers had to twist and turn to justify wars of conquest against a peaceable native population, by inventing casus belli such as purported cannibalism and human sacrifice. Did the Treaty of Tordesillas (splitting South America between Spain and Portugal) only allow for evangelical work by missionaries, or did it actually authorize aggression? Such was the degree of unhelpful disputation, of scholarly argument and counter-argument, that eventually Charles V decided to shut down their colloquy, as it "presented more problems than it resolved".
Something of an aside then: a chapter on the explorer Cabeza de Vaca whose epic adventures across two continents have inspired generations of writers and scholars since, most recently Laila Lalami's Booker- and Pulitzer-nominated novel The Moor's Account, which tracks Cabeza de Vaca's peregrinations through the eyes of the slave Estevanico, one of the first blacks, and also one of the first Muslims, to widely explore the new continent. There is a look at the polemics of resistance: Ercilla's "Araucana", and El Inca Garcilaso's account, in polished Castilian, of the demise of the native civilization whose very name he carries. And then, at last, we get to the Baroque of the Indies which, to my mind, is the region's most original and attractive cultural contribution.
There is a wonderful comment by Carlos Fuentes in his interview with the Paris Review, where he says: "There is a culture of the Caribbean, I would say, that includes Faulkner, Carpentier, García Márquez, Derek Walcott, and Aimé Césaire, a trilingual culture in and around the whirlpool of the baroque which is the Caribbean, the Gulf of Mexico." Once you have immersed yourself in the literature - in the rococo phrasings of Marquez and Carpentier, in the fluid verses of Walcott - once you have experienced the land itself, stunned by the tropic sun in old Havana or mesmerized by the sheer exuberance of nature on the wild coast of Colombia, you finally begin to understand something of the astonishing fecundity of a relatively tiny region that has given us no fewer than six Nobel Prize winners, if you also include Naipaul and Asturias and Saint John Perse. Adorno considers Sor Juana in this vein, the mother-poet of an entire continent.
And so to the final lap, the age of independence, seen primarily through the works of Fray Servando and Andres Bello. Two names that I had NOT known before particularly caught my eye: Oviedo, whom Adorno calls the finest nature writer of the new continent, and Guaman Poma whose 800-page chronicle sounds like a work of great intrigue.
Urban baroque Oquendo lima Guaman poma inca spectacular autograph ms’s Freile bogota carnero Caviedes lima
High baroque Balbuena father of Barocco Indios Medrano Lunarejo Sor Juana supreme poetess Siguenza Gongora
Independencia Vandera Clavigero Fray Servando Andres Bello repossess the language