What is it about Betty Neels? What makes her so fascinating? She re-uses the same few plots over and over. There is precious little variation in the descriptions of her heroes. Her heroines are usually one of two types (the plain and sensible "Araminta" with lovely eyes, or the tall and beautiful "Olivia"), with the occasional outlier. Betty was born in 1909 so she likely wrote what she knew and was comfortable with; her books are set in a vague timewarp that showcases values and culture more fitting of the 1930s-1950s than their actual publishing date (1969 to 2001). Some of those values are very outdated indeed, and they were already very outdated by the time she reached the early years of her writing career. Her descriptions of food, clothes, venerable stately homes, etc. are wonderful if repetitive. But despite all this, her books are a fascinating glimpse into the past, written in a way that is very accessible.
Betty also had some odd ideas about female beauty and the lack of it. To a newcomer to her work, it can be off-putting in the extreme to have other characters comment quite matter-of-factly on the heroine having "no looks." Sometimes this insistence (harping, really) on the heroine's plain face is annoying as all hell. (I note that Betty frequently observed makeup made no difference but using modern makeup techniques, I assert that with their flawless skin, thick and shiny hair, and large, lovely eyes, there is very little chance they wouldn't be stunning. But Betty's point is that it is their characters that give them spiritual beauty, and that's not a bad point at all. I just wish Betty hadn't relied so much on the perceived lack of physical beauty as a plot device.)
Which brings us to A Girl in a Million. Written in 1993 but smacking of the 1950s or early 1960s, it features the Araminta type and her romance with one of Betty's archetypal tall, "vast," blond, blue-eyed Rich Dutch Doctors (RDD), this time an anesthesiologist named Marius Van Houben. The heroine Caroline Frisby is a student nurse. She's calm, practical, kind, gets along with everyone. The story is that after meeting Marius briefly in Amsterdam while on vacation (she delivers some books to him from his cousin Corinna, who is Caroline's friend and fellow nurse), she meets him again when he comes to her hospital. It seems his very young nephew has had a bad accident while his mother is in England and Caroline is the nurse chosen to "special" him following brain surgery. Caroline eventually accompanies the family to Holland for several weeks to care for the child while he recovers.
So Caroline and Marius get thrown together quite a bit. She's definitely interested in him but she knows she has no chance because she isn't pretty. Sadly, Marius agrees with her, as we understand from both the considerable hero POV we get as well as conversations he has with his dog about Caroline. This goes on for most of the book. Marius finds himself wishing for her company, or arranging dates with her, all while telling himself that He Is Not Interested.
Meanwhile, Caroline is pining away but also trying to talk herself into being sensible about her poor chances of attracting him. I got a little tired of this. It went on too long. We needed a catalyst to bring things to a tipping point and lo and behold, Betty delivers in the form of a lonely young doctor working for a short time at Caroline's hospital until he can marry his fiance Miriam. He befriends Caroline (Miriam knows and approves because Caroline and the young doctor feel like brother and sister to each other). But the hospital grapevine, not reading the situation quite right, eventually lets Marius know Caroline has a love interest. Marius is suddenly struck down with a severe case of jealousy. Events unfold. He finally allows himself to acknowledge the truth of his feelings.
I liked this one. I didn't love it. Unlike some Araminta-focused BN stories, it didn't feel like he was marrying her out of pity or because the Araminta is always the right child-bearing, housekeeping wife for an RDD. Or at least, not profoundly so. But even though we can see that he is developing feelings, even if it takes him getting hit over the head with a brick (that is, a brick called JEALOUSY) to acknowledge those feelings, I did struggle a bit to feel any chemistry between them. Maybe this particular RDD was written specifically to be very closed off, but a few kisses a little earlier in the story would have been nice and helped me understand the attraction better.
So: three and a half stars, rounded down to three.