A real problem in a REAL world..expressed unrealistically 😞
‘A Thread Unbroken’ reveals a very important narrative. Human trafficking in China. Whether it is now or the past, it remains a problem that unfortunately still exists in China and many other countries today.
The author, Kay Bratt, wrote ‘Tales of the Scavenger's Daughters’ of which, I say is brilliant. Ms. Bratt also advocates for children as well. Which brings me to my next comment regarding
‘The Thread Unbroken’. It was so cliched. Along with a flatness I didn’t understand, and too simple that I honestly felt as if it was written by a middle schooler for a writing project. It’s just not written well. Many times I imagined myself reading this to my children when they were 8 years old at bedtime.
The subject of ‘human trafficking’ and kidnapping of girls in China, then sold to be brides isn’t spoken about enough. Or abandoning children because of a birth defect, or the baby is a girl, instead of a boy. Those are facts and Kay Bratt has written several books about these issues. I expected a book that was written by an author who knows the unfortunate facts very well, what I read was a book trying to explore ‘human trafficking’ with scenes quite unimaginable.
Families in villages with primitive living conditions, yet they have cell phones? Mixing modern day technology with old customs is one thing, this was too far fetched that I didn’t have a clue after reading quite a bit, that it was meant to be in this century.
Those were a few more of the instances that were too big of a stretch to be believed. Along with a “floating island”refereed to as a “city” yet the boats on the island were on water? I tried very hard, but in my imagination, I no longer could see what was being described. There are many more instances..
I wanted to read and finish this book, based not only upon the summary which says: “Chai and Josi share a bond that transcends ordinary friendship. Chai has always been Josi’s protector—ever since they were toddlers, growing up together in a small Chinese village—she finds herself helpless when they are both abducted from their families and sold to faraway strangers.”
As the reader/listener Chai and Josi were put in the story as if it was the early 1900s or even earlier. Ms. Bratt interjects casual mention of cell phones, computers, and other present-day items—which did not add to the story, but completely took away from it.
In ending—this was a book I really wanted to learn from, the horrors of what both went through. Yes, I read a beautiful story of Chai & Josi, who hung on to each other through every step—but I never heard them express any sort of REAL emotion nor REAL anger for what they went through and it completely upset me—it did not show me the reality of what REAL ‘human trafficking’ is REALLY like.