Book 2 of the "Love's Valley" series sees Ellie, who broke off her engagement with the greedy man whom she discovered only wanted her money, not her, chained by leg shackles in a filthy cabin, the chains secured outside the cabin, with a high fever. She has been starved, beaten, and given barely enough water to keep her alive. She is left there with the door open, to die.
Her rebel, half Irish, half Mexican sister in law Douglass has begged her brother Colum, an excellent tracker, to stay and find Ellie and bring her home.
And so he does, with the differences between Rebel and Yankee fading as they get to know one another...despite the scratches she put on his face when he was trying to rescue Douglass, who didn't - unknown to him - need or want to be rescued from one of the best kisses of her life.
Ellie knows she is ruined. She knows no one would believe she wasn't raped, nor that she and Colum hadn't touched each other, nor that the ordeal had made her stronger. She was considered ruined and people would believe the ordeal would eventually drive her crazy.
They make it back to Love's Valley, but have a few close calls along the way and once they get home, that doesn't stop. The unforgiving early snow impedes their return and Colum realizes he is stuck until the spring thaw. A carpenter by trade, Monroe hires him as the foreman to work on their new house. Indigo makes trouble at the house over Colum being a rebel, as do some of the workers, but the rest learn to respect Colum.
But as the house goes up, Ellie and Colum realize, separately, that they're falling for each other. Is this just the aftermath of the rescue & the difficult journey home, or the real thing? If it's real, can they admit it, or say goodbye if it's not?