Received this book for free through Goodreads First Reads.
I have been thinking about how to rate this book for the past day, since finishing, and to be honest, I am still not sure if I want to give it a 2 or 3 star rating.
There were things that I liked about the book but really I felt that there was not enough. I was kept wanting more, and not necessarily in a good way. I felt that there were bits that were rushed through, parts that could've been explored deeper; things, incidents, and questions that could've been fleshed out more. I felt that this book had potential.
I really liked that we have a future that is not one race. We have characters that are not all mainstream and yet the book is not pro-one particular race. And I liked that it is not a main focal point, it just merely is. I also really liked the concept, the last Earthling. Imaginative and intriguing. The author also managed to make it not as much science fiction as a compelling insight into humanity and how even despite advancement, we are flawed creatures. There are some great questions about human beliefs and actions. And it reminds me of a quote from Men In Black (just recently on TV) when K says that a person is smart but people are panicky-not sure of exact quote. While a person could see the dangers of what humans are capable of when they think themselves superior to any particular group and in other matters of gravity, collectively they become harder to control and more volatile.
What brought down the story was the way that the story was written; the writing itself was fine. It's just that I am not sure if this was meant to be a personal memoir or a political one. There were parts that were written as if for the public and in general explanation of what had happened, and yet most of it was personal experiences mixed in with some philosophical thoughts thrown in. It began as if it was to be a public memoir of what happened to bring the humans to where they are today, and while I understand that personal parts will be in there, I felt that there was a change in tone of the speaker between the parts that left me disconnected from the speaker. Additionally I wasn't sure where Queen Eliza's POV came in to play. Where are we getting her POV from? Was it from public record of Rooninans, which based on the society I doubt. Based on the title, I expected that we were getting Eliza's POV from Adeena, that she had somehow befriended the queen and got her story. And yet the only contact that Eliza and Adeena have is that they meet once. I would have preferred them to have some degree of relationship because of the title.
The title kept getting to me, and still does because of the above. Based on the title, I expected them to meet and have some type of relationship so that Adeena was actually seen as the Earth Girl. No where in the story is she called the Earth Girl and there was so much focus on the other characters and how they still felt the loss of Earth that she really wasn't anyone special-except when she sixty and writing the memoir, but you would expect her to be known somewhere in the novel as the Earth Girl. Also, Queen Eliza would need to be seen as the Queen, not just from her POV.
I thought that there was some very well done science fiction aspects, and the aliens that were presented were well done. I liked the Yadans and the Rooninians and liked the questions that they presented to Adeena about who really was more advanced and what is the correct measurement of advancement given that although humans are considered advanced, we still manage to make the same incorrect decisions over and over regardless of where we might be.
There seemed to be so much that was rushed through and that if it was a professional memoir, there would have been more focus and exploration about the group experience. There could have been more focus on the psychological impact of the loss of Earth, the aliens, the new environment, etc. While there was some, I felt that more than just numbness would and should occur and that it should have been explored.
One a smaller note, the romance I found hard to really believe in. I didn't feel that there was a real lead-up to the resolution of feelings. The ending also seemed rushed. What happened on the new planet between landing and her turning sixty?