Quite a few great ideas have made the transition from the internet into book form. Many of them are quite hilarious on the internet, particularly when they pop up every so often, but just don’t work out nearly so well when published all together in a book. Mil Millington’s “Things My Girlfriend and I Have Argued About” was one such internet sensation that didn’t translate well into novel form and, sadly, October Jones’ “Texts From Dog” is another.
It’s a fantastic idea, about what a dog would text to an owner if it could text. As dog owners might predict, many of the texts involve chasing balls or sticks, eating and breaking things and either barking at or chasing other people and animals, most commonly the postman and a local cat and squirrels. It’s interesting to see a dog’s perspective on these things and particularly what a dog might think of its owner, which is rarely complimentary unless there is food or a bowl involved.
However, it is when the texts branch away from standard dog behaviour that the texts are at their funniest. When dog pulls a curtain rail down to use as a cape and becomes Batdog, to start battling his enemy Catcat, this is generally quite funny. There are also moments of fine observational humour, such as when dog drinks some Red Bull, which is brilliantly described and the moment where he gets into trouble with the police or decides to leave a game of fetch part way through.
Sadly, there is a lack of consistency in the approach, as dog is sometimes brilliant at seeing through his owner’s plans, but is more frequently portrayed as a dog without much of what we would recognise as human intelligence. There are also moments where dog’s opinions of his owner are that he is a complete idiot, but at other times, he treats him something akin to a butler, which seems more akin to cat behaviour towards humans than dog behaviour. Occasionally, these contrasts will occur on the same double page spread and the inconsistency is a little confusing and shows how reading occasional texts on an internet page works better than reading a lot together in a book.
Whilst the content is generally quite good fun, the way it’s been put together in this book is a bit of a let-down. Three of the texts are repeated, which is a shame when there are only around 200 in here to start with and some of them aren’t in the right order, meaning that an event referred to early in the book only makes sense when you get to the corresponding earlier events later in the book. The cartoons are also amusing, but in a book where there are only 2 texts – the main content of the book – to a page, removing one of them to replace it with a drawing that doesn’t shine any light on the text, feels like space filling.
There are moments of great amusement here, but these are not consistent enough to make for a great book. “Texts From Dog” is something worth looking out for, but not in this format, when it is available for free in a format which actually makes it more fun.