"The Artist's Way" was a revelatory book for me, and I wanted more of it, so I picked up "Walking in This World." I have just reached 12 weeks of reading the chapters and doing the exercises, so I definitely gave it a real chance.
It failed to inspire me. In fact, it frequently made me testy and impatient.
First off, this adds nothing to TAW's weekly plan save for, "Oh, BTW, take a walk." Seriously. The walk is mentioned at the beginning of the book and then never comes up again except for being checked off weekly. I was expecting tasks that were based around walks--choosing certain kinds of places to walk, or suggesting ideas to meditate on during your walk. Nothing of that sort. Nada. So it felt like she forgot the premise of the book right from the start.
Second, unlike TAW, which comes from a philosophy that we are all artists by our very nature and, whether or not one chooses art as a career, artistic expression heals all our souls, this book is very focused on careers in the arts. That rubbed me the wrong way time and again, because there was a smugness to her tone--no longer was it, "everyone can benefit from fostering their own creativity, whether it's painting, writing, or creating a welcoming home." No, now it was, "we artists are just so much more enlightened and superior," and even a focus that felt dismissive of people who happily make art around their careers and aren't interested in turning their artistic endeavors into full-time jobs. It felt off-putting for me; my book buddy, who is the "welcoming home" kind of artist and happy with that, found it alienating.
Finally, there is so much whining. Almost every chapter included a task that amounted to, "someone in your past must be responsible for why your life isn't perfect now" or "you've probably never even considered this as a problem, but let me encourage you to feel sorry for yourself." When I worked my way through TAW, I did almost every exercise. This book? I started out doing those exercises but then thought, "why am I searching for ways to be miserable"? and began skipping over them.
All in all, this felt very threadbare when it came to ideas and insights, and I was disappointed. I finished because I am compulsively completist and for no other reason. I expect in another year or two to repeat working through TAW. This one? It's going to the used book store.