What do you think?
Rate this book
Unknown Binding
First published June 21, 2006
At first, I wasn't going to write a review, but I decided that not leaving one would be a disservice. I'm not necessarily a fan of Marie Forleo, but I appreciate her content and she seems like a well-spoken and wise individual. Why am I reading a book about attracting men? Because I thought I could improve in that area. And besides, Forleo promised over and over that this dating book is different from the rest and that I should forget about the rules. Did she deliver what she preached?
I appreciated Forleo's easygoing forwardness, it was an easy read and I had a good time going through the whole book. One of the things that stood up to me is the importance of prioritizing yourself and understanding that a relationship will not save you. If you go into the mindset that you need a man to be complete and treat relationships as guarantees, you are setting yourself up for failure. This idea about "like attracting like" isn't new in the slightest, but it is a good reminder on how you should approach relationships. If you spend your life being negative about others and yourself, no one is going to see how attractive you can be. This book isn't so much about making every man want you, but it is about fixing yourself. Not groundbreaking, but it is a nice message.
Did I mention how unoriginal this advice was? I'll say it again: Nothing that Forleo said was groundbreaking. Men find cattiness, neediness, and desperation unattractive? No fucking shit, anyone could have told me that. Oh, but it gets better! If you are boring in bed, say goodbye to your irresistibility! Granted, this is just my opinion, but encouraging women to just sleep around under the guise of just living in the moment is probably the least uplifting thing I had the misfortune to read. I approve of sexual liberation and doing whatever you want with your body, but it just came up so muddled and embarrassing coming from her. If I recall correctly, she also encourages the reader to just date whoever, you know, under the guise of "just going with the flow." That is just not something I can't vibe with; there's nothing wrong with setting standards for yourself, not every man deserves a chance. If that's somehow against my "irresistibility", I don't care. There's a time and place for going with the flow and this just isn't it.
Forleo also tells you to throw away your list and rules because they don't matter. She tells a story about how she used to have a list of what her ideal man looks like, but once she met her current husband (who was described as not being near what she had on her list), she felt it was time to be more open-minded and allow herself to just love him. I understand what is she trying to say with this one; sometimes the people who are best suited for you tend to be the most unexpected people, trust me, I get it, but this is the book's main problem. Her results are situational, it does not mean they should be the standard. I'm going to say this one more time: There's nothing wrong with setting standards for yourself. Sure, if your list about your ideal man is shallow, then you are setting yourself up for disappointment, but if you want a man who has great qualities, you shouldn't throw that list out the window. Lists and rules exist because they work, forget the idea that it is not attractive. We are humans, we have our own standards, it is not manipulative.
Speaking of that . . .
Forleo likes to say her book is more legitimate than others because other dating books want women to manipulate men and that is why relationships fail! It's rare I see self-help books bashing their competition, so this came as a surprise. If what you say is valid, you show it, don't put yourself that high on the pedestal. The reason why I feel like calling out that small detail is that most of what she preaches can be classified as manipulative. Forleo asks her readers to make everything your "is-ness". What does she mean by that? Treat everything that happens to you as if you wanted it to happen in the first place. You are stuck in traffic? This is what you want! Your printer breaks? This is what you want! You've been on hold for 45 minutes? This is what you want! According to Forleo, when you pretend that bad things happening to you is what you want, "you become aware of all the ways you resist your is-ness and unwittingly create misery, frustration, and upset in your life." Yes, really.
This may seem more of a rant than anything else, but I really dislike this mentality that if something bad happens to you, you made that happen, it is your fault! It wouldn't surprise me if most of Forleo's ideology comes from Rhonda Byrne's doctrine because that's exactly how it feels. Hey, sometimes bad stuff happens because people are assholes! Sometimes you can be in the wrong place and the wrong time. Stop blaming individuals for their misfortune, for the love of God! Oh, by the way, once I finish reading The Secret, you'll get more insight about how I truly feel about this mindset.
Why do I feel that this is manipulative? It is very much grounded in victim-blaming and no amount of "living in the moment" is going to remediate how I should feel about any misfortune. If I get fired from a job, am I really going to say "this is what I wanted"? No, I'm allowed to be upset! People are allowed to have negative feelings, no one truly is going to hold it against them. Sure, I understand if you are a negative person and treat others like trash, you are not going to be likable, but I get the sense that if you a person with trauma, Forleo is not going to have much sympathy for you. Change your mindset, it's NOT that hard!
"But, Merary," you may ask, "Does she ever tell you how to look irresistible?" Of course, she does! Get a personal image consultant (or just buy books from the What Not To Wear series,) get your hair done, put on makeup, drink water, eat well, exercise, just get it together, woman! Never mind that this is common sense, but I said it so it's valid! I'm not going to spend too much time on it because you should know this already (DUH!), just do it!
An additional favorite part about this book is that Forleo asks you to stop resenting men and forget the gender war because men can sense that and it is SO unattractive. Fine, I get it, it comes back to the point about not being a bitter woman because men hate that, whatever. It just makes me laugh because I feel that this book is more detrimental to men than a bitter "harpy" will ever be because it doesn't give men enough credit. It pretends it can, but it seriously doesn't. I briefly touched on the "accepting men as is but change yourself for them" part, but I feel that this book loves to play on gender stereotypes more than anything else, and yes, it does not paint men in good lighting either. Men, apparently, are too easy to influence (which, by the way, Forleo bashes other books about this subject because of it), and all it takes to win them over is to look good and think good. I don't know, I want to believe that there are good men out there who are encouraging, supportive, and wouldn't hold your past against you. I want to believe that men have the same complexities that women do and the whole formation of relationships come naturally, not because I'm supposedly the hottest thing since sliced bread. Nope, I'm wrong, men like to HUNT! Don't play hard to get, but make sure you give men the chance to have a little chase, "don't rob him of the pleasure he gets from acting on his primal, MALE instincts." Yes, that's a real quote. Yes, really. Ah, Forleo, here we go again with the double-sided contradictions that only make sense to you.
Oh, and on a different note, I found it cringy that Forleo attributed quotes from Maya Angelou and other civil rights activists to suit her irresistibility "philosophy." How does that look like? "You know, my dear reader, I used to do mistakes in dating, but like the great Maya Angelou said, 'when you know better, do better.' Also, I'm going to make myself look even better by introducing some chapters with quotes by activists to inspire your inner irresistibility because I see them as props." That is such a white feminist liberal thing to do and I applaud her for fulfilling expectations. Bravo!
I initially had this book at 2 stars because there's so minimal value and it was a fast read. However, after thinking deeply about it, I was left so dissatisfied, and honestly, I'm angry. Yikes, my irresistibility just dropped! I'm complaining! GASP! I can't believe The Bitch Switch by Omarosa felt more fun and valuable compared to this disappointment, even though I said there were better books out there. Well, the same thing stands. There are better books about dating in the market, this will not be the last book I will read about this, sorry to say, Mrs. Forleo. I feel that I could go on, but that's enough. What if a man is reading this? Shoot, I missed my chance to be irresistible, I'm so negative and mean, wow.