What do you think?
Rate this book
LeaderShift: A Call for Americans to Finally Stand Up and Lead
LeaderShift is a compelling and timely business parable that challenges Americans to stop being so placid in their daily lives and to help get us back on the right track.
Based upon what really happened with the Founding Fathers when they crafted the Constitution, Woodward and DeMille lay out the Five Laws of Decline that has gripped the United States in recent times. This book, which calls for the top 10 percent of America to step up and take an active role in our government and our businesses, presents a revolutionary approach to lift us out of the economic doldrums and make us fully engaged with the freedoms we take for granted. The storyline focuses on David Mersher, the successful CEO of Indytech who, at the end of his career, is trying to find out why the United States had lost its edge as a world economic power, and what he can do to help the US lift itself out of its financial malaise. Mersher gathers his trusted advisers to see what they can do to rally Americans to lead -- be it economically, financially, or politically. Their conclusions are powerful and unexpected and will generate tremendous debate.
208 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2013
48 people are currently reading
1191 people want to read
About the author
Orrin Woodward
58 books297 followersGuinness World Record holder for largest book signing ever with the release of And Justice For All, Orrin Woodward is an Inc Magazine Top 20 Leader. Further, he is a NY Times bestselling author of LeaderShift and Launching a Leadership Revolution. His first solo book RESOLVED: 13 Resolutions for LIFE made the Top 100 All-Time Best Leadership Books List and the resolutions are the framework for the bestselling Mental Fitness Challenge personal development program.
Orrin has co-founded two multi-million dollar leadership companies and serves as the Chairman of the Board of the LIFE Business. He has a B.S. degree from GMI-EMI (now Kettering University) in manufacturing systems engineering. He holds four U.S. patents, and won an exclusive National Technical Benchmarking Award.
He follows the sun between residences in Michigan and Florida with his lovely wife Laurie and their children. Orrin's leadership thoughts are shared on his blog - orrinwoodwardblog.com.
Orrin has co-founded two multi-million dollar leadership companies and serves as the Chairman of the Board of the LIFE Business. He has a B.S. degree from GMI-EMI (now Kettering University) in manufacturing systems engineering. He holds four U.S. patents, and won an exclusive National Technical Benchmarking Award.
He follows the sun between residences in Michigan and Florida with his lovely wife Laurie and their children. Orrin's leadership thoughts are shared on his blog - orrinwoodwardblog.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews
April 19, 2013
This book is amazing! Many books I have read inspire me to better myself. But LeaderShift is one of the few books that I have read that truly aroused my desire to be part of accomplishing something great in life. It is not just a fun book to read. It is also intellectually stimulating as you follow the thought processes of the characters to figuring out a solution to the problems that are plaguing the United States politically and economically and how to reverse the Five Laws of Decline. And the solution they present would be a win for the American people. Forget whatever party you belong to. This book is not Republican and it is not Democrat. It is American! Whether you are passionate about freedom or not, I recommend this book! The cost for our kids will be too great if we do nothing.
April 20, 2013
Amazingly well constructed - the mixing of fable/parable w/ real life authors/book titles/known names is a stroke of ingenuity and creativity that cannot be understated. Easy to give this the top ranking since it is easy to read, yet is incredibly deep in its implications & levels of thought. Additionally, it is completely untainted by notions of politics as we've unfortunately come to understand in our modern times. (i.e., two sides hunker down, interrupt one another, finger point, use weak logic, and blame each other for what went wrong, what is wrong, or what will go wrong.)
In short/sum: A must-read.
In short/sum: A must-read.
April 18, 2013
One of the things about the book that impressed me and was extremely refreshing was that the proposals were very concrete, non-partisan and are aimed at the root of our country's problems rather than the symptoms. Woodward and DeMille did a great job helping the reader understand the five laws of decline and how the proposed solutions would work. They were very smart to deliver it in the form of a story, as it can be used to reach those that would never read about history, politics, economics, etc on their own. Overall, they put together a fantastic book that I believe will make an impact in our country.
I'll be writing a more in-depth review over the coming days on my blog.
I'll be writing a more in-depth review over the coming days on my blog.
July 9, 2013
The questions that always come up during a true conversation on freedom like how do you get people involved and pay attention, are answered here, but instead of just outlining a proposal for change you will get thrown into the debate wile on a retreat of thinkers which include the generation that started it all. No matter if you are new to the conversation or you have been at it for years the answers will surprise you. Great book
June 6, 2013
I finished the book. I didn't love it. My 2-stars are primarily the poor delivery. The proposals are a 5-star but seem so unreachable the average Joe that I gave it a 2 star.
I was greatly intrigued with the proposal of new ways to elect local, state and federal leaders while leaving the rest of the Constitution in place, but would allow, encourage and almost demand (without force) citizen involvement, something that is sorely lacking in our current political climate. I also loved the tax plan. I see some issues with the proposal but I certainly don't have other alternatives to propose. I definitely love that it is bottom-up leadership but at a controlled, not a mob-style, level.
I was strongly turned off by the implication that the founding fathers were coming down and helping the group. We are likely not going to experience that in our day (although I don't believe it is impossible). It lends fallibility to what potential success that might be achieved if we don't have their help.
I also was completely turned off and almost offended by the implication that the group that started this was quite wealthy. Meetings were held at spas and ski resorts. Members of the initial group talked of fancy cars, expensive watches ($95,000!!!) and billions of dollars. The whole point of the book was to encourage the local citizen to get involved but it was elitist from the first page. It is a detriment to the goals of the authors to imply that only those with wealth and/or business leaders have enough sway to start a citizen movement. You have already pushed down 99% of the country.
I did not like how the story developed over months in order to come up with the plan and then in a few pages, years had passed and they were testifying before a committee in DC and then more years had passed and the whole country was changed radically and then the book was over. It felt unfinished and egotistically prideful with no plan and no details as to how the group moved forward. Maybe that was intentional but it left the story feeling unfinished and a bit unpleasant.
This book has some great points and a lot of great discussion. I am not sure its delivery is such that it will have much impact. Its unreachable where we currently are as a nation which the authors understood, but the presentation of the plan and the manner in which it is developed within the story will not help their cause much if at all.
But maybe I am not one of their 10%. Maybe I don't fit their criteria and so the book wasn't intended to reach someone like me. I don't know. I am pretty sure they want as many people involved as possible but the way it was written doesn't encourage the average middle-class employee (not entrepreneur) to feel very hopeful about getting involved.
I did love the 5 Laws of Decline all five of which currently apply in our country. I think the hardest one to fight against is the last one.
1. Sturgeon's Law - 10% of anything is great and 90% is junk. That includes products and leaders.
2. Bastiat's Law - Humans desire to satisfy their wants by doing the least amount of work possible.
3. Gresham's Law - When bad behavior is rewarded, more of the bad behavior will be done, and that in turn will drive out the good behaviors.
4. Law of Diminishing Returns - "To continue without significant changes after a certain level of performance has been reached will result in a decline in effectiveness."
5. Law of Inertia - An object at rest tends to stay at rest, and an object in motion tends to stay in motion.
I am sure I am a bit cynical. I don't tend to be so negative, but this book did not move me. I have read so much recently that was inspiring and hopeful on so many levels and this book did not evoke that at all.
I was greatly intrigued with the proposal of new ways to elect local, state and federal leaders while leaving the rest of the Constitution in place, but would allow, encourage and almost demand (without force) citizen involvement, something that is sorely lacking in our current political climate. I also loved the tax plan. I see some issues with the proposal but I certainly don't have other alternatives to propose. I definitely love that it is bottom-up leadership but at a controlled, not a mob-style, level.
I was strongly turned off by the implication that the founding fathers were coming down and helping the group. We are likely not going to experience that in our day (although I don't believe it is impossible). It lends fallibility to what potential success that might be achieved if we don't have their help.
I also was completely turned off and almost offended by the implication that the group that started this was quite wealthy. Meetings were held at spas and ski resorts. Members of the initial group talked of fancy cars, expensive watches ($95,000!!!) and billions of dollars. The whole point of the book was to encourage the local citizen to get involved but it was elitist from the first page. It is a detriment to the goals of the authors to imply that only those with wealth and/or business leaders have enough sway to start a citizen movement. You have already pushed down 99% of the country.
I did not like how the story developed over months in order to come up with the plan and then in a few pages, years had passed and they were testifying before a committee in DC and then more years had passed and the whole country was changed radically and then the book was over. It felt unfinished and egotistically prideful with no plan and no details as to how the group moved forward. Maybe that was intentional but it left the story feeling unfinished and a bit unpleasant.
This book has some great points and a lot of great discussion. I am not sure its delivery is such that it will have much impact. Its unreachable where we currently are as a nation which the authors understood, but the presentation of the plan and the manner in which it is developed within the story will not help their cause much if at all.
But maybe I am not one of their 10%. Maybe I don't fit their criteria and so the book wasn't intended to reach someone like me. I don't know. I am pretty sure they want as many people involved as possible but the way it was written doesn't encourage the average middle-class employee (not entrepreneur) to feel very hopeful about getting involved.
I did love the 5 Laws of Decline all five of which currently apply in our country. I think the hardest one to fight against is the last one.
1. Sturgeon's Law - 10% of anything is great and 90% is junk. That includes products and leaders.
2. Bastiat's Law - Humans desire to satisfy their wants by doing the least amount of work possible.
3. Gresham's Law - When bad behavior is rewarded, more of the bad behavior will be done, and that in turn will drive out the good behaviors.
4. Law of Diminishing Returns - "To continue without significant changes after a certain level of performance has been reached will result in a decline in effectiveness."
5. Law of Inertia - An object at rest tends to stay at rest, and an object in motion tends to stay in motion.
I am sure I am a bit cynical. I don't tend to be so negative, but this book did not move me. I have read so much recently that was inspiring and hopeful on so many levels and this book did not evoke that at all.
April 25, 2013
This book blew me away and rocked my life! I literally couldn't put it down and finished it in 2 sittings over a 24 hour period. This is an ABSOLUTELY MUST READ for every parent, businessperson, entrepreneur, politician, pastor/clergyman, community leader, executive, teacher, concerned citizen and anyone else who can successfully fog a mirror!! Orrin & Oliver have knocked the cover off the ball and put forth a proposal that will finally accelerate the healing process for a nation, reversing the decline in our economy, the government, our families and more. The LeaderShift is here! I am so thankful that these guys had the courage to write this book and that I picked it up!
May 3, 2013
LeaderShift is an absolutely excellent book and a must read for anyone truly concerned about the decline of freedom in America. Woodward and DeMille have written a masterpiece that should be read and re-read by everyone, including traditionally non-political citizens. The book brings to bear the importance for the people to take up an active role in governance to ensure freedom for future generations. This book should also serve as a harbinger to the overreaching federal government that there are people concerned, committed, and coming to change the gross misconduct of overspending, taxing, legislating, and misinforming of the American people.
April 21, 2013
LeaderShift is a masterpiece, and both Orrin and Oliver are geniuses. They converted a complex idea in such a simple yet thought-provoking way that is going to impact not only the USA but the entire world as well. It is a must read for anyone who is concerned about the future of freedom in this country & in the entire world. It is a real callout for people to step up, lead, and turn around the cycle of decline in our society by offering a step-by-step solution. The question is: who is going to be among the 10%???
April 23, 2013
I almost hesitated to write a review if this book since it is so well written my words will hardly do it justice. This book is the blend of storytelling, information and inspiration all wrapped into one. It is hard hitting in that it cuts to the very heart of the matter of what's plaguing our country. It does so all without venturing off into the weeds of partisan politics! Well done Orrin and Oliver my only regret is that there are only five stars to give this book and not the fifty that represent the nation whose Leadershift is badly needed!
May 2, 2013
A truly remarkable read.
If you are frustrated with the current state of politics in America (or Canada) and the fact that more and more of our freedoms seem to be taken away from us, this book will give you an accurate account of what has caused these issues to arise. It doesn't just explain what is wrong with today's government but offers very realistic solutions to ensure not only our freedoms, but freedoms for future generations.
If you are concerned about freedom, you need to read this book.
If you are frustrated with the current state of politics in America (or Canada) and the fact that more and more of our freedoms seem to be taken away from us, this book will give you an accurate account of what has caused these issues to arise. It doesn't just explain what is wrong with today's government but offers very realistic solutions to ensure not only our freedoms, but freedoms for future generations.
If you are concerned about freedom, you need to read this book.
April 22, 2015
This is an amazing book. Easy to read as it's written in the form of a fable. But unlike most other books that discuss our current problems in freedom this actually does offer real solutions to getting our country and our economy back on track. If you're concerned for freedom at all I would make this a priority read.
April 22, 2013
I've recently taken an interest in restoring America's freedoms but have felt frustered and gaurded on where to start because of lack of knowledge and hope. Orrin Woodward and Oliver DeMille have lead the charge in restoring the hope and freedoms of Americans by proposing an original, thought provoking plan! I can't wait to share this book with others! I couldn't put it down!
November 22, 2020
A good book for Americans to read to understand our democracy and republic and to lead as the founding fathers wanted us.
May 3, 2013
Wow! What a profound book! I had a little trouble with the business parable, because my brain does not work that way, but in all I think I was able to grasp the magnitude of what the authors are trying to teach Americans. We must all become citizen-leaders. No way around it.
In general I found the reading style very easy to understand, other than as I stated above, the business terms are beyond me sometimes. I wish I understood it better. If I did, I would most likely be more successful in business.
I can see influences of Cleon Skousen in this book and the definitions of what needs to change and the proposals made by the fictional characters to the Constitution are definitely in that category of Skousen-es thinking. I truly love Skousen's books and logic, so this greatly appeals to me on many levels. The type of think-tank the book describes is beyond anything I've ever experienced and I would not know the first thing about forming, attending, or becoming part of one.
As I read Part IV, I kept thinking in my mind, "the general citizenship is too lazy to do this." Who will put down there remotes, phones, tablets, etc. long enough to do the kind of work this new direction for America needs from its citizens? In the Founders time, they did not have the menagerie of entertainment. Yet, they also spent more time in the basics without the time saving conveniences we have. So, did they really have more time on their hands?
I hate to say it, but I don't think most people will buy in to the idea. Most will say, "Wow! Cool book." and then put it down and never do anything about what they learned. I guess that is why the book talks repeatedly about the 10% needed to make this happen. But will 10% even take the time? I hope so!
My last thought is about myself. What part do I play? Where should my efforts be spent? Who else can I bring along? What do I do?
In general I found the reading style very easy to understand, other than as I stated above, the business terms are beyond me sometimes. I wish I understood it better. If I did, I would most likely be more successful in business.
I can see influences of Cleon Skousen in this book and the definitions of what needs to change and the proposals made by the fictional characters to the Constitution are definitely in that category of Skousen-es thinking. I truly love Skousen's books and logic, so this greatly appeals to me on many levels. The type of think-tank the book describes is beyond anything I've ever experienced and I would not know the first thing about forming, attending, or becoming part of one.
As I read Part IV, I kept thinking in my mind, "the general citizenship is too lazy to do this." Who will put down there remotes, phones, tablets, etc. long enough to do the kind of work this new direction for America needs from its citizens? In the Founders time, they did not have the menagerie of entertainment. Yet, they also spent more time in the basics without the time saving conveniences we have. So, did they really have more time on their hands?
I hate to say it, but I don't think most people will buy in to the idea. Most will say, "Wow! Cool book." and then put it down and never do anything about what they learned. I guess that is why the book talks repeatedly about the 10% needed to make this happen. But will 10% even take the time? I hope so!
My last thought is about myself. What part do I play? Where should my efforts be spent? Who else can I bring along? What do I do?
May 1, 2013
A MUST read for all Canadians regardless of the subtitle. LeaderShift: A Call for Americans to Finally Stand Up and Lead by Orrin Woodward and Oliver DeMille really inspire (then equip) you to be better citizens in your respective countries or groups (and how to fix things too)
The teaching is semi subtle, though enjoyable , through a story / parable that introduces some rather profound and rather big (but important) concepts, over time. Woodward's Leadership background really shines as he goes through reasons why things are heading the direction they are in our countries and how best to counter them. Combined with DeMille's passion for true Classical Education, coupled with his life long passion for Freedom really fires you up to do the same you have an amazing combo.
At one point I had to put down the book and actually do something to better myself. It was THAT powerful in creating in me a hunger for great and not mediocre things.
Highly suggested for all to read. Its a fast fun read too. Be intrigued. Argue with the Authors even. Implement some of their concepts within your sphere of influence. DO SOMETHING different then you've done thus far. Start by reading this book then see what happens next. You won't be disappointed.
The teaching is semi subtle, though enjoyable , through a story / parable that introduces some rather profound and rather big (but important) concepts, over time. Woodward's Leadership background really shines as he goes through reasons why things are heading the direction they are in our countries and how best to counter them. Combined with DeMille's passion for true Classical Education, coupled with his life long passion for Freedom really fires you up to do the same you have an amazing combo.
At one point I had to put down the book and actually do something to better myself. It was THAT powerful in creating in me a hunger for great and not mediocre things.
Highly suggested for all to read. Its a fast fun read too. Be intrigued. Argue with the Authors even. Implement some of their concepts within your sphere of influence. DO SOMETHING different then you've done thus far. Start by reading this book then see what happens next. You won't be disappointed.
April 26, 2013
A fascinating read. I cannot wait to go back and study it. I have so many questions to ponder. I am particularly intrigued by the 28 proposals for fixing the Constitution and the attention to local involvement/governance, taxes and the end of the party system. The book is both idealistic and realistic and far from elitist. Loved the illustration of the universality of laws.
The content is packed. It will take some time and study to wrap my mind around all that was presented. The storyline is decent with a realistic ending; not for entertainment but a great vehicle for presenting the ideas and principles both straightforward and subtle or metaphorical. I appreciated the opportunity to participate in the thought processes and conversations of the characters. The inclusion of dialogue between the Founders and their intervention was reminiscent of Freedom Factor by Gerald Lund.
Though I often resonate with Oliver DeMille, I came to this book with a fair amount of skepticism, unsure at first if I was even going to read it. I am extremely glad that I did! A brilliant partnership between DeMille and Woodward for sure. I highly recommend it if you care at all about freedom. The principles are vital. The solutions are concrete and worth considering. The intentions and motivations are pure. We the people are the key. The time is now.
The content is packed. It will take some time and study to wrap my mind around all that was presented. The storyline is decent with a realistic ending; not for entertainment but a great vehicle for presenting the ideas and principles both straightforward and subtle or metaphorical. I appreciated the opportunity to participate in the thought processes and conversations of the characters. The inclusion of dialogue between the Founders and their intervention was reminiscent of Freedom Factor by Gerald Lund.
Though I often resonate with Oliver DeMille, I came to this book with a fair amount of skepticism, unsure at first if I was even going to read it. I am extremely glad that I did! A brilliant partnership between DeMille and Woodward for sure. I highly recommend it if you care at all about freedom. The principles are vital. The solutions are concrete and worth considering. The intentions and motivations are pure. We the people are the key. The time is now.
April 24, 2013
I have trouble warming up to this book. It is a short presentation of ideas on leadership in America to solve our decline. The ideas are presented as dialogue among two sets of fictitious characters. One set is in the present, the other set is comprised of the ghosts of our founding fathers in the spirit world. Kind of corny. The book is pessimistic about our current political problems and optimistic that changes could be made through grassroots involvement in local politics, not national politics. I felt motivated to get involved locally, but I see the problems at higher levels. My local government seems fairly tame and innocuous. Anyway, the ideas pivot around the Five Laws of Decline (FLD) which have names like Sturgeon's law, Gresham's law, Bastiat's law, law of diminishing returns, and the law of inertia. These names don't jump up in your mind and readily roll off the tongue. I felt the authors could have developed some kind of mnemonic to help the reader.
May 13, 2013
Many would suggest that we are at a crossroads in the USA politically and economically and Woodward and DeMille (almost sounds like a duo from the past) make their case for change in this parable of our times. With visits from the political leaders of the past, this modern day group of leaders make an argument for bottoms up change in how the United States conducts business. Based upon The Five Laws of Decline, this contemporary band of Revolutionary leaders present a call for action for what some would call radical, while others may only view the them as foundational, changes in the political process. This is the first of either authors books that I have read and I questioned throughout if it would have flowed better for me had I read earlier of their works since it almost seemed to build on other of their works. I would certainly recommend it to any with a serious concern for the direction of this great nation, no matter your party affiliation.
November 2, 2015
This was a great book. Very easy read.
Woodward and DeMille have created a plan to solve America. They talk about the Five Laws of Decline and how they naturally occur in any field. Not only do they reveal these five laws, they create a plan to counteract the laws.
This book is also not partisan. It's not Democrat or Republican. It's not one side blaming the other. This book is only designed to help reveal the problems and to create a solution to these problems.
This book is highly recommended. It is a must read for those who love and are concerned about freedom, not only in the United States, but in any nation.
Woodward and DeMille have created a plan to solve America. They talk about the Five Laws of Decline and how they naturally occur in any field. Not only do they reveal these five laws, they create a plan to counteract the laws.
This book is also not partisan. It's not Democrat or Republican. It's not one side blaming the other. This book is only designed to help reveal the problems and to create a solution to these problems.
This book is highly recommended. It is a must read for those who love and are concerned about freedom, not only in the United States, but in any nation.
April 25, 2013
A book fit for time . Something about a book you just any put down , very captivating ! The truths are weaved in with real answers to get on the right track . Orrin & Oliver have minds of wisdom that when collide together exude simple truths & teaching ! Thank God for men of such discipline in freedoms for our country in these times . America needs more ! Lets stand together for the movement and reach the 10 percent who will be part of the entrepreneur leadership freedom that our country needs!
April 29, 2013
Quite possibly the most influential book I have ever read. The ideas and concepts expressed in this book would undoubtedly pull America out of the enormous hole we are in as a nation. It takes us, those of us who are restless, to passionately embrace a freedom loving society, to once and for all be sick & tired of the excuses and entitlement issues we've grown accustomed to for so long. This is a true call to all leaders and those destined for leadership, to make a difference for future generations. Time for a Leadershift!
April 29, 2013
Left me wanting more in a good way. LeaderShift outlines the solution that is needed, a shift back to what our founding fathers envisioned for this United States. It is written in our Declaration of Independence ...That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government... until now this seemed impossible for 'We The People' LeaderShift tells us how we can take our country back! Can't wait for the 2nd book!
May 14, 2013
I absolutely loved this book. I loved that it was in story form which made it easy to follow. This book is going to be a game changer to help turn around the decline of America. I can't wait to read this book again. This book is a must read for everyone. If you want to know what you can do to help the decline in North America so that you and your children and children's children can have a better future...you must read this book.
May 7, 2013
A simple book with a lot of information. Done in a conversational way, ideas are brought out and while a quick read, has so much meat. If you spent the time reading just the books that are talked about you would find yourself well educated in politics and / or business quickly.
April 3, 2017
A MUST READ!!!!
June 6, 2013
this book is one of the best books ever. im going to read it over and over. they really did a good job on this book. great job orrin and oliver.
August 21, 2013
Read this book 3 times!!! A must read for all Americans!
September 17, 2017
I think this book is a crucial read for all American citizens.
January 14, 2017
I feel REALLY weird/awkward here going against the grain... rating this book with only 2 stars, but I would be lying to you of my true feelings towards it if I rated it any higher.
I read this with really high hopes to be truly inspired and motivated with implementable ideas on how I can "stand up and lead." Instead, I experienced feelings of distraction and annoyance as I read.
One of the biggest distractions for me was characters' constant referencing to people, books, ideas, and historic happenings with which the authors are definitely well versed in. After finishing the book I went back through it and wrote them all down and put them into a spreadsheet to see how many there actually were: 78 different people, 31 different books, 26 unique ideas that can be attributed to someone, and 32 historic events, people or places. A total of 167 references and there were only 188 pages in the book. Now, I have nothing against studying the kind of people and material that was referenced in this book, (in fact, now I have a great list of material that I can turn to in order to further my personal education on freedom principles if I so wish) but I felt there was just too much referenced insomuch that it took away from the flow of the story. If you're looking for recommendations on what to study, it's a great resource. But I was looking for inspiration while reading this, and didn't find it. I feel that all the referencing of material could be overwhelming to the average American citizen. It communicates the idea that one cannot become truly involved unless one has studied this kind of material first, else they wouldn't really know what they were doing. That seems like it would turn off a lot of people to citizen leadership, rather than inspire them to want to get involved first and then begin learning more as they go along.
Now on to the things that annoyed me. As a "story" it sucked. There was no character development at all and I couldn't relate to the "emotions" the characters felt at all. Like the moments in the story when they are all holding their breath because the energy in the room was palpable... in my head, I'm thinking, "What energy? Where did it come from? Why is it there? I must be missing something." Or when the characters all burst into sustained laughter over Marcus' stupid watch jokes. It wasn't funny and just felt fake. None of the interactions between the characters felt like any kind of interactions that I've had with others in my own life, therefore they were completely unrelatable to me. They didn't have any depth to them.
I also felt annoyed because I found nothing but lip service being given to what I feel is the most important source of leadership: the home. The character Michelle says, "A lot of the top leaders are mothers who are focused on raising their children." And later she refers to the importance of "mothers and fathers" as leaders, but that's it. No character agrees with her, they just move on in their discussion. No ensuing discussions stem from her comments. Here I am, a mother, devoted to raising my children in my home, and also passionate about principles of leadership and freedom, and I honestly found nothing in this book to inspire me in this role I've chosen. Another reason I felt like only lip service was given is that barely anything was heard from the female characters in this book that were wives and mothers: Amy & Michelle. The only female character who really makes a difference in the course of the story is Kami, who of course, is single without any children. So what's the message to me there of the impact of my efforts as a wife and mother in the battle for freedom? Am I even in a position to make an impact or do I have to be a single, powerful CEO to do that?
This issue was brought up by one of the characters, but then virtually ignored as the characters plowed on to their destination: "As long as people have to divide their lives between the needs and wants of their families and careers, they're not going to have much time left over for political influence." Um, yes! Hello! That IS definitely true, so what's the solution? The proposed format of local government laid out in this book is nice in theory, but what about practicality? This issue needs to be addressed. I didn't see the connection between the proposed government and this problem of people feeling they have to divide their lives between their family and careers. What is going to suddenly make people feel like they now have time to meet every single month to vote in town council meetings? It is a nice idea, and yes, I believe it would work, if it would work, but I don't believe it would work. How's that for twisted?
Another annoyance was that this books's subtitle feels unsuited to its content. It's titled: "A Call for Americans to Finally Stand Up and Lead." And what it really should be is: "A Call for Business Leaders to Finally Stand Up and Lead." Within the book, one character says, "What we really want are Creators - business leaders who will put freedom and leadership first. This really matters." The book is written to wealthy business owners. Those are the people who can relate to it and answer the call. I'm not sure if the intent of the book was to reach the heart of the average American, but if it was, then it was a magnificient fail because the average American doesn't talk about their $95,000 watch purchase. The average American isn't making use of their meditative moments in one of their many small pavilions on their expansive estate. The average American isn't taking weekend getaways with like-minded individuals at ski resorts and basking in hot tubs while discussing freedom ideas. The average American isn't a self-made billionaire in the oil industry and investor on Wall Street, or a top CEO of a successful turnaround company. The average American isn't going to relate to this book at all because it's not about them. As I was reading, there was something bothering me about it. Just as I was able to formulate my thoughts on what that was: (the whole wealthy elitist feel to it) I had to laugh at the irony that the characters began discussing elitism and its ability to shut down their success. This book just didn't feel like a call to me: an average American mom, to stand up and lead. I didn't feel one moment of inspiation while reading it, and believe me, I was looking for it!
Lastly, there was a glaring absence in this book for me. I believe that the principles of freedom are not the end-all be-all. They are the means to the end. I believe that the work of this life is to learn to submit myself to God's will and plan for me and that nothing at all is meaningful without the Atonement of Jesus Christ, the Savior of the world. And there was nothing, not even a hint, of this idea within the pages of this book. It's hard for me to feel inspired to do much of anything unless I can see and feel how it relates to the plan for my life in the eternal scheme of things.
And that's my review. As a sidenote, I'll save that spreadsheet I created, and if you're interested in it send me a message and I'll email it to you. :)
I read this with really high hopes to be truly inspired and motivated with implementable ideas on how I can "stand up and lead." Instead, I experienced feelings of distraction and annoyance as I read.
One of the biggest distractions for me was characters' constant referencing to people, books, ideas, and historic happenings with which the authors are definitely well versed in. After finishing the book I went back through it and wrote them all down and put them into a spreadsheet to see how many there actually were: 78 different people, 31 different books, 26 unique ideas that can be attributed to someone, and 32 historic events, people or places. A total of 167 references and there were only 188 pages in the book. Now, I have nothing against studying the kind of people and material that was referenced in this book, (in fact, now I have a great list of material that I can turn to in order to further my personal education on freedom principles if I so wish) but I felt there was just too much referenced insomuch that it took away from the flow of the story. If you're looking for recommendations on what to study, it's a great resource. But I was looking for inspiration while reading this, and didn't find it. I feel that all the referencing of material could be overwhelming to the average American citizen. It communicates the idea that one cannot become truly involved unless one has studied this kind of material first, else they wouldn't really know what they were doing. That seems like it would turn off a lot of people to citizen leadership, rather than inspire them to want to get involved first and then begin learning more as they go along.
Now on to the things that annoyed me. As a "story" it sucked. There was no character development at all and I couldn't relate to the "emotions" the characters felt at all. Like the moments in the story when they are all holding their breath because the energy in the room was palpable... in my head, I'm thinking, "What energy? Where did it come from? Why is it there? I must be missing something." Or when the characters all burst into sustained laughter over Marcus' stupid watch jokes. It wasn't funny and just felt fake. None of the interactions between the characters felt like any kind of interactions that I've had with others in my own life, therefore they were completely unrelatable to me. They didn't have any depth to them.
I also felt annoyed because I found nothing but lip service being given to what I feel is the most important source of leadership: the home. The character Michelle says, "A lot of the top leaders are mothers who are focused on raising their children." And later she refers to the importance of "mothers and fathers" as leaders, but that's it. No character agrees with her, they just move on in their discussion. No ensuing discussions stem from her comments. Here I am, a mother, devoted to raising my children in my home, and also passionate about principles of leadership and freedom, and I honestly found nothing in this book to inspire me in this role I've chosen. Another reason I felt like only lip service was given is that barely anything was heard from the female characters in this book that were wives and mothers: Amy & Michelle. The only female character who really makes a difference in the course of the story is Kami, who of course, is single without any children. So what's the message to me there of the impact of my efforts as a wife and mother in the battle for freedom? Am I even in a position to make an impact or do I have to be a single, powerful CEO to do that?
This issue was brought up by one of the characters, but then virtually ignored as the characters plowed on to their destination: "As long as people have to divide their lives between the needs and wants of their families and careers, they're not going to have much time left over for political influence." Um, yes! Hello! That IS definitely true, so what's the solution? The proposed format of local government laid out in this book is nice in theory, but what about practicality? This issue needs to be addressed. I didn't see the connection between the proposed government and this problem of people feeling they have to divide their lives between their family and careers. What is going to suddenly make people feel like they now have time to meet every single month to vote in town council meetings? It is a nice idea, and yes, I believe it would work, if it would work, but I don't believe it would work. How's that for twisted?
Another annoyance was that this books's subtitle feels unsuited to its content. It's titled: "A Call for Americans to Finally Stand Up and Lead." And what it really should be is: "A Call for Business Leaders to Finally Stand Up and Lead." Within the book, one character says, "What we really want are Creators - business leaders who will put freedom and leadership first. This really matters." The book is written to wealthy business owners. Those are the people who can relate to it and answer the call. I'm not sure if the intent of the book was to reach the heart of the average American, but if it was, then it was a magnificient fail because the average American doesn't talk about their $95,000 watch purchase. The average American isn't making use of their meditative moments in one of their many small pavilions on their expansive estate. The average American isn't taking weekend getaways with like-minded individuals at ski resorts and basking in hot tubs while discussing freedom ideas. The average American isn't a self-made billionaire in the oil industry and investor on Wall Street, or a top CEO of a successful turnaround company. The average American isn't going to relate to this book at all because it's not about them. As I was reading, there was something bothering me about it. Just as I was able to formulate my thoughts on what that was: (the whole wealthy elitist feel to it) I had to laugh at the irony that the characters began discussing elitism and its ability to shut down their success. This book just didn't feel like a call to me: an average American mom, to stand up and lead. I didn't feel one moment of inspiation while reading it, and believe me, I was looking for it!
Lastly, there was a glaring absence in this book for me. I believe that the principles of freedom are not the end-all be-all. They are the means to the end. I believe that the work of this life is to learn to submit myself to God's will and plan for me and that nothing at all is meaningful without the Atonement of Jesus Christ, the Savior of the world. And there was nothing, not even a hint, of this idea within the pages of this book. It's hard for me to feel inspired to do much of anything unless I can see and feel how it relates to the plan for my life in the eternal scheme of things.
And that's my review. As a sidenote, I'll save that spreadsheet I created, and if you're interested in it send me a message and I'll email it to you. :)
January 26, 2022
An interesting read which prefaces a re-establishment of local politics via business leaders who buy into an originalist interpretation of the Constitution.
On the pro side, I concur with the emphasis on the importance of local politics, and certainly from an objective historical position I'd support an originalist interpretation of the Constitution; c.f. Blackstone's Commentary on English Common Law and the proper interpretation of law.
Where I'd differ from this author, actually two authors as it was co-written by Orrin Woodward and Oliver DeMille, is in regard to the faith that is placed in business leaders. Big business leaders tend to be more international and transnational; there is little patriotism left in the business world, and with the age of the internet all businesses, even SMEs, operate in a global world.
If there is to be a resurgence of local politics it's going to be a grassroots movement; I'd not wait for our business leaders to have a sudden change of heart.
It's still worth a read even though I'm not sure I'd agree with the the proffered solution.
On the pro side, I concur with the emphasis on the importance of local politics, and certainly from an objective historical position I'd support an originalist interpretation of the Constitution; c.f. Blackstone's Commentary on English Common Law and the proper interpretation of law.
Where I'd differ from this author, actually two authors as it was co-written by Orrin Woodward and Oliver DeMille, is in regard to the faith that is placed in business leaders. Big business leaders tend to be more international and transnational; there is little patriotism left in the business world, and with the age of the internet all businesses, even SMEs, operate in a global world.
If there is to be a resurgence of local politics it's going to be a grassroots movement; I'd not wait for our business leaders to have a sudden change of heart.
It's still worth a read even though I'm not sure I'd agree with the the proffered solution.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews