One of the most interesting books about New Orleans to be published in the past dozen years isn’t a guidebook or a novel or a book of poems. It's THE BROTHERS NEVILLE, an oral biography of--guess who?--from 2000 edited by David Ritz. From their childhood in the New Orleans streets to their difficulties with drugs to their re-embrace of Christianity, the path each brother has been on is different but interestingly parallel—almost like a giant song, with harmony laid upon harmony. Such voices will be a small but sustaining comfort as New Orleans continues to reassemble its many pieces, even if many of them fit together peculiarly by outside standards. Michael Brown, the much-excoriated former head of FEMA, was revolting in his refusal to accept any blame he might bear in the man-made tragedy that followed Katrina. Nevertheless, he had a point when he called the state of Louisiana in general and New Orleans in particular “dysfunctional.” (As Randy Newman puts it, “New Orleans is not the place to go to get your car fixed.”) Why, after all, did the city’s founders elect to build one of the country’s most important port cities on land lower than the waters surrounding it? There are many answers to that question, and many explanations of how the situation became worse with the destruction of Louisiana’s wetlands and the construction of ever-higher levees. And yet that testifies to a crucial part of the character of the city, even of its literature: its stubborn immutability.
(originally published, in somewhat different form, in the NASHVILLE SCENE / Village Voice Media, 2005)