I recently saw the 2019 documentary, Pavarotti, and instantly wanted to read his books. This being the first of his publications, I thought surely it would be a true autobiography by the great tenor.
I have to admit to being a bit disappointed in this story. The documentary gave an impression of a Man- not just Pavarotti, the number 1 Tenor in the world, not the master of operatic music- the Man who was, despite his incredible gift, emotional, flawed, loving, curious, and above all else, simply human. I expected this telling to be an expansion on the ideas and experiences that made up the bulk of that documentary (considering the source, and the time in which it was published). In reality, this is less autobiography, and more a compilation of reminiscences from his friends, coworkers/agents, and some from the artist himself. Though the beginning of My Own Story was engaging and built anticipation for more, I can honestly say the best parts of the book as a story of the man himself, are the first and last quarters. The middle sections of this book became stiff and seemed more about the business of opera productions and how to market artists as opposed to the story and true experience of THIS artist, which I found disappointing.
As a vocalist, yes it is always interesting to read about technique and the art and practices that accompany both performance and the success of great talents, but when a life story becomes more of a general manual that doesn't neither achieves an educational content, or tells a captivating version of events, the discussion falls flat. Luciano Pavarotti was anything BUT flat.
Overall, was the book enjoyable? 3/5 stars says mostly, yes. Would I read it again? No, probably not. Will I read his other book? Perhaps in the future after I recover from slogging through the perspectives of his agents and coworkers and what They did to create Pavarotti as we know him- the business side, rather than the man who actually DID the work and made such beautiful music, for himself and for the world. I realize this may be akin to saying "watch the movie instead of reading the book", but truly, I would recommend watching the documentary before wading through these books for two reasons. First, the documentary is both about and in great part narrated BY Pavarotti, and thus you get his speaking voice and personality in your head which will help get through the written experiences and perspectives included in this book. Secondly, the film, having been produced long after his death, gives a more complete picture of the whole person and both his professional And personal experiences which serve then to pique your interest to read his books in the first place.
By the end of both the film And this book, I feel a heightened affection for someone so charismatic and pure hearted. For a person to be That talented and that Dedicated to pursuing his craft and vocation, it is not unusual for perfectionism and anxiety to flourish- this was definitely the case for Pavarotti. All in all, it is easy to see how he became what he was, and in all honesty, I was left with the strongest desire as a fan and fellow human being, to simply give the man a Hug.