This is a superb book. One of the best top gun, air combat books I've ever read.
It has everything - except sex - bravado, human tragedy, human ego, bickering, jokes, detailed air duels, historical and political background on the Falklands conflict, personal stories and anectodes, slow and engagning buildup prior to the conflict, step-by-step depiction of the escalation and the eventual confrontation, naval battles, air battles, ground attack, strategic warfare, tactical warfare, the aftermath of the war, and so much more. It's almost impossible to list it all, and it's amazing the author actually managed to put everything into a relatively short book.
Now ...
The book revolves around one Sharkey Ward, the CO of 801 Sqn flying the Sea Harrier from the deck of the VSTOL carrier Invincible, one of the two sent by the UK establishment to the Falklands, to reclaim the islands from Argentina. In fact, the book narrows down to the tactical and operational differences and rivalry between 801 Sqn on board the Invincible and 800 Sqn on board the Hermes, and how these differences and petty issues cost lives.
Sharkey pulls no punches. He tells an angry story of politics, office madness, yesmanship, and bureaucracy that stood in his way, both in peacetime and during the war, and how he led this Sqn despite severe operational blunders standing in his way. He didn't bother to shave or sort out his bunk, he allowed his pilots to engage first (despite a legal-like book of rules produced by the British government that allowed the pilots to fire only if fired upon = getting killed), and he voiced his objection to how 800 Sqn handled the CAP. The other squadron had no night flying experience and didn't trust the Sea Harrier radar, so they flew visual CAP at height, allowing the Argentinian attacks to slip through and attack the carrier group, leading to a tragic loss of ships and life.
He is also quite vocal on "Whitehall mandarins", the yesmanship required for promotion, the dry rules written by people with zero flight knowledge and experience, and he ever had personal fights with the Wing commander, and refused to obey "stupid" orders when he felt they jeopardized his crew.
In between his frustration and anger you get splendid air combat.
Sharkey spares no detail - he tells all about what happened, maneuvers, cannon fire, missiles, ejections, all of it. Really cool. You feel like you're reading a Top Gun book. Speaking of Top Gun, the Sea Harrier fared superbly against most modern jets in ACM/DACM training, often with high kill ratios. Also, the UK government expected only 25% of their Sea Harrier pilots to survive, when in fact they scored 20 air kills with no losses (except ground fire and accidents), proving the dry and brutal statistics (these figures were insensitively shared with the pilots' wives by the officials while the carriers still sailed to the islands) wrong.
Sharkey is also critical of the RAF - who took all the glory and did only a fraction of the fighting. He disapproves of the "TV popular" Vulcan bombing from Ascension, which he calls a sham, as they wasted immense amount of money (fuel and support) with minimal damage. Roughly 200,000 gallons of fuel per flight, with 13 VC tankers in support, 63 bombs dropped including 21 that were not armed properly, and only margin damage to the end of the runway, at the cost of roughly 1,500 Sea Harrier sorties with 4,500 bombs.
He also believes it was a mistake to retire the Sea Harrier - it could have been kept in the service at a fraction of the cost of the Eurofighter and F-35, but of course, Sharkey ignores the fact the thriving military industry supports hundreds of thousands of jobs and such, but he is focusing purely on the cold, efficient side of warfare. If only the world was so simple.
Then, there's the scorn and rivalry among the squadrons, funny jokes, beautiful attention to detail, tons of stories around night flying and training, what happened in Port Stanley after it was taken back, how Sharkey was received back in the UK after the war, and more. It's an incredible story, and even though it's one's man personal say on what happened back in the 1982, it's still fascinating and poignant. It's a classic tale of war - absurb, cynical, crazy, tragic, hilarious.
Extremely recommended. I will definitely see if there's more from Sharkey.
6/5.
Igor