It’s hard to describe the Maze Agency after reading this short collection that made up the first five issues of the late 80s comic book series, but if I had to I would have to say it’s dated but still fun in a lot of ways.
On a positive note, I loved the interactions between the two lead characters: Jennifer Mays and Gabriel Webb. Mays, the head of a highly respected private investigator firm called the Maze Agency often teams up with Webb, a true-crime writer and amateur detective in his own right. Together they make an effective team, but more importantly they are just plain fun. Mays tends to be more professional, more serious, and more financially well off than Webb, Mike Barr created a pretty plausible and likable “opposites attract” duo in Mays and Webb and its fun to see how they even compliment each other’s weaknesses. Mays sees things that Webb never would and vice versa, but they are both meticulous and highly intelligent.
But in the end much of the graphic novel feels badly dated. Each issue fees like your reading a late 80s “Murder She Wrote” clone with a younger, hipper lead. The police, who is usually represented by a Detective named Lt. Bliss, are completely unable to solve anything on their own without the help of the Maze Agency. I’d almost call them inept but if they were then they had enough self awareness to recognize that they needed the help of Mayes and Webb and tended to stay out of their way. The crimes that sparked the murders in each issue tended to be wildly implausible (trying to destroy a corpse so it can’t be resurrected, killing a panel of Jack the Ripper experts while copying the Rippers messages and style of killing, filming an imitation of a popular 50s sitcom with modern actors to try and gain the royalties and hope nobody notices the actors are either different or 30 years older) and in classic Scooby Doo fashion, when the killer is confronted with the evidence of his crimes he (or she) always ends up confessing everything. With the exception of one murder, where the killer still had the victims blood on them, each of these were solved with the flimsiest of evidence that would, at best, establish probable cause for a search warrant but would have hardly been enough to end the case.
With that being said, it was still a fun read and worth spending a few hours checking out if you come across a copy.