Reread 12/2020: I gave this book 5 stars in 2008, but I couldn't remember anything about it except that I liked it. My book club chose this as our January read and I was excited to revisit it. I didn't love it as much this time around. I liked Allie and the residents of Twisted Creek, but it was a little slow and the suspense plot did nothing for me. Still, I'm glad I reread it.
3.75 out of 5
Original review 2008: This story is written in alternating 1st and 3rd POV. At first I wasn’t sure it would work, but in the end I think the story would have suffered if it hadn’t been written that way.
I really liked Allie. As the story progressed I enjoyed watching her grow and become confident in herself. Though she seems broken in the beginning, it isn’t long before we see the well of inner strength she’s kept hidden. Though it takes her awhile to open up, it isn’t long before she’s the backbone of the community. I enjoyed Luke’s character as well. He was reserved and quiet, afraid to open himself up, but unable to stop it from happening as he spent time with Allie. I love that he was quiet and didn’t say much, but you could still see the attachment forming between him and Allie.
I loved the secondary characters – all the odd little people who make the lake their home. As we came to know them, just like Allie, I began to care for them, to become invested in their lives. I truly felt like I was in Twisted Creek right along with them. Honestly, if I could talk my husband into it, I’d be tempted to head off to Texas in search of a Twisted Creek of my own.
The suspense plot worked really well with the romance and honestly didn’t detract from the overall romance, in my opinion. The story focused on Allie and Luke as they learn to trust each other and open up to one another, the suspense plot was just window dressing to that. Not to say it wasn’t well done, because it was, but it wasn’t the main focus of the story.
Overall I loved it. The characters, the plot, the writing. All of it.
5 out of 5