What do you think?
Rate this book
Fallen Rose #1
Roses in the Devil's Garden
Official Description: In a city overrun by lawlessness and corruption, best friends and lovers- Prohibition Agents Harlan Mackay and Nathan Reilly, are fighting a losing battle. With bootleggers running amuck and countless speakeasies materializing every day, how can two men possibly hope to make a difference? Especially when they can't even trust their own bureau?
If dealing with hoodlums wasn't enough, a ghost from Nathan's past threatens to destroy everything Harlan and Nathan hold dear.
Original Prompt:
Dear Author,
Please tell me why this man is armed and dangerous and who it is he belongs to. I really would like to know if he is defending his beloved or about to shoot him for cheating.
Photo Description: A rugged, muscular man provocatively holds one arm up beside his head as he looks down at you. His other arm is across his chest, and in his hand is a gun. The words I am my beloved’s are tattooed across his forearm. He looks sexy and dangerous.
Download the story, read it online or find it in Love Is Always Write: Volume 8.
__________
Genre: Gay Historical Romance (1925)
Word count: 18,779
If dealing with hoodlums wasn't enough, a ghost from Nathan's past threatens to destroy everything Harlan and Nathan hold dear.
Original Prompt:
Dear Author,
Please tell me why this man is armed and dangerous and who it is he belongs to. I really would like to know if he is defending his beloved or about to shoot him for cheating.
Photo Description: A rugged, muscular man provocatively holds one arm up beside his head as he looks down at you. His other arm is across his chest, and in his hand is a gun. The words I am my beloved’s are tattooed across his forearm. He looks sexy and dangerous.
Download the story, read it online or find it in Love Is Always Write: Volume 8.
__________
Genre: Gay Historical Romance (1925)
Word count: 18,779
64 pages, ebook
First published May 15, 2012
284 people are currently reading
617 people want to read
About the author
Charlie Cochet
136 books3,517 followersStep into a world of romance, humor, and heart-pounding action with Charlie Cochet, the international bestselling author behind the captivating THIRDS series. Embrace a fusion of Cuban flair and American charm as you dive into her stories with unforgettable characters and a dash of delightful mayhem.
Fueled by a love for classic rock and Cuban lattes, Charlie resides in Central Florida with her rascally Doxiepoo and a very opinionated German Shepherd. When she isn’t writing, she’s losing herself in a whirlwind of books and movies.
Charlie’s stories will stir your imagination and ignite your passion. So grab your favorite coffee, turn up the music, and prepare for your next adventure.
Website: http://www.charliecochet.com
Patreon: http://www.thirdshq.com
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/charliecochet
Join Charlie's FB fan group
Fueled by a love for classic rock and Cuban lattes, Charlie resides in Central Florida with her rascally Doxiepoo and a very opinionated German Shepherd. When she isn’t writing, she’s losing herself in a whirlwind of books and movies.
Charlie’s stories will stir your imagination and ignite your passion. So grab your favorite coffee, turn up the music, and prepare for your next adventure.
Website: http://www.charliecochet.com
Patreon: http://www.thirdshq.com
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/charliecochet
Join Charlie's FB fan group
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
January 24, 2020
3.5 Stars
I don’t know what it is about the 1920’s but it’s not a particular favorite time period for me to read about. However, Cochet really got the setting down and it had a great Untouchables vibe to it and I quite enjoyed myself.
Basically, this involves two Prohibition officers Harlan and Nate, who are one of the few that aren’t corrupted. They’re an established couple, and this story does a bit of reminiscing on how they met and found each other during the war, as well as updating the reader how they’re faring now as lovers.
Harlan is a great gentle (or not so gentle) giant, and it was sweet to see how tender he got with his hot headed partner Nate. Conflict comes in the form of a person from Nate’s past and the pace was interesting with good dashes of sexy and feels.
Again, a nice surprise regarding a less liked trope and its original form can be found as a free offering from DRitC! Enjoy!
I don’t know what it is about the 1920’s but it’s not a particular favorite time period for me to read about. However, Cochet really got the setting down and it had a great Untouchables vibe to it and I quite enjoyed myself.
Basically, this involves two Prohibition officers Harlan and Nate, who are one of the few that aren’t corrupted. They’re an established couple, and this story does a bit of reminiscing on how they met and found each other during the war, as well as updating the reader how they’re faring now as lovers.
Harlan is a great gentle (or not so gentle) giant, and it was sweet to see how tender he got with his hot headed partner Nate. Conflict comes in the form of a person from Nate’s past and the pace was interesting with good dashes of sexy and feels.
Again, a nice surprise regarding a less liked trope and its original form can be found as a free offering from DRitC! Enjoy!
September 22, 2024
3.5 Stars
Set in prohibition-era NYC, this little story follows established couple Harlan ‘Harley’ Mackay and Nathan Reilly. These two men met during world war one, first becoming best friends and lovers, before eventually settling in NYC where they now live and work together for the Bureau of Prohibition.
Nathan and Harley are both dealing with some pretty traumatic ghosts from their pasts, and it doesn’t help that their current jobs as prohibition agents leads them into dangerous situations on the regular. They keep a lot of their feelings close to the vest, but they love each other dearly and will fight for what they have together. However, both men are pushed to their limits when Nathan faces a blast from the past which threatens their happiness as a couple.
Although not my favourite time period to read about, the roaring twenties setting was very distinctive and immersive. Specifically, the language and fashions of the time were impressively captured, giving the story a truly genuine feel.
Established couples usually aren’t my thing either, but I liked Nathan and Harley a lot nonetheless. Harley in particular was a lovable gentle giant for whom I always seem to have a soft spot and go gaga over.
This was an effortless read and one I enjoyed a great deal. Although I read the recent second edition release of this story, it was originally released as one of the M/M Groups Don’t Read in the Closet offerings and can be found HERE.
Set in prohibition-era NYC, this little story follows established couple Harlan ‘Harley’ Mackay and Nathan Reilly. These two men met during world war one, first becoming best friends and lovers, before eventually settling in NYC where they now live and work together for the Bureau of Prohibition.
Nathan and Harley are both dealing with some pretty traumatic ghosts from their pasts, and it doesn’t help that their current jobs as prohibition agents leads them into dangerous situations on the regular. They keep a lot of their feelings close to the vest, but they love each other dearly and will fight for what they have together. However, both men are pushed to their limits when Nathan faces a blast from the past which threatens their happiness as a couple.
Although not my favourite time period to read about, the roaring twenties setting was very distinctive and immersive. Specifically, the language and fashions of the time were impressively captured, giving the story a truly genuine feel.
Established couples usually aren’t my thing either, but I liked Nathan and Harley a lot nonetheless. Harley in particular was a lovable gentle giant for whom I always seem to have a soft spot and go gaga over.
This was an effortless read and one I enjoyed a great deal. Although I read the recent second edition release of this story, it was originally released as one of the M/M Groups Don’t Read in the Closet offerings and can be found HERE.
May 17, 2018
"Roses in the Devil's Garden" is a short story set after WWI. It's also the first book in a series and as such it sets the atmosphere for the next stories, it introduces characters and it leaves loose ends to be tied up in the future.
I loved the first part of the book where we get to know Harlan and Nathan, see their relationship and their connection, see how they work together and how well they understand each other. I liked the jealousy and the bump in their lives when the past made an unexpected appearance. I liked what they did about it and I liked the whole idea for the plot about a couple who are best friends, parners in life and partners at work.
The thing is that the second part felt like another story. The focus wasn't on the main characters anymore but on those around them who, I believe, are getting their own stories. From the moment the focus left the MCs, the whole story became too complicated with many names thrown in the mix, friendships sprutting up as if from nowhere and potential coupledom appearing everywhere.
Harlan and Nathan were amazing though, so 3 stars just for them.
This review has been cross-posted on The Novel Approach Reviews.
*A copy of this book was kindly provided to me by the publisher via The Novel Approach Reviews in exchange for an honest review. *
I loved the first part of the book where we get to know Harlan and Nathan, see their relationship and their connection, see how they work together and how well they understand each other. I liked the jealousy and the bump in their lives when the past made an unexpected appearance. I liked what they did about it and I liked the whole idea for the plot about a couple who are best friends, parners in life and partners at work.
The thing is that the second part felt like another story. The focus wasn't on the main characters anymore but on those around them who, I believe, are getting their own stories. From the moment the focus left the MCs, the whole story became too complicated with many names thrown in the mix, friendships sprutting up as if from nowhere and potential coupledom appearing everywhere.
Harlan and Nathan were amazing though, so 3 stars just for them.
This review has been cross-posted on The Novel Approach Reviews.
*A copy of this book was kindly provided to me by the publisher via The Novel Approach Reviews in exchange for an honest review. *
May 26, 2012
One of the LiAW stories reviewed at The Armchair Reader.
4.5 stars
A couple weeks ago Charlie Cochet became my most recent favorite author when I read her short story When Love Walked In and her novella The Amethyst Cat Caper. So I was so happy to see that she’d written a story for the LiAW event! I’ve never been a big fan of historicals, but I now snatch up anything she writes. The magic of her stories is the time period she writes in — I don’t know how she’d do with another period, but she really seems to have the 1930′s Depression era down. In this story, she steps back just a few years to Prohibition NYC in 1925 and the magic is just the same. Like the others, this story is saturated with period language that lends authenticity to the voice. Apparently these guys are coming back for more in the future and I can’t wait!
4.5 stars
A couple weeks ago Charlie Cochet became my most recent favorite author when I read her short story When Love Walked In and her novella The Amethyst Cat Caper. So I was so happy to see that she’d written a story for the LiAW event! I’ve never been a big fan of historicals, but I now snatch up anything she writes. The magic of her stories is the time period she writes in — I don’t know how she’d do with another period, but she really seems to have the 1930′s Depression era down. In this story, she steps back just a few years to Prohibition NYC in 1925 and the magic is just the same. Like the others, this story is saturated with period language that lends authenticity to the voice. Apparently these guys are coming back for more in the future and I can’t wait!
April 6, 2018
The Roaring Twenties, The Guilded Age, Prohibition - that time period between the end of the Great War and before the Wall Street Crash - when America seemed determined to live life to the max.
This re-release of Charlie Cochet's delightful novella is packed with smokey speakeasies, dodgy moonshine and hard bitten cops in the finest of Sam Spade traditions.
Harley and Nate are partners in life as well as on the force and getting weary of the corruption, the strikeouts and the raids. I loved the atmosphere of this narrative, you could hear the clink of glasses, the piano tinkling away as some lounge singer extols the virtues of the Jazz Age.
Originally written for the Goodreads Love Is Always Write event, this has been given a beautiful new cover and re-released by Dreamspinner Press.
#ARC kindly provided by the publishers Dreamspinner Press in return for an honest and unbiased review.
PS: Is it just me or does that look like the divine Ben Whishaw on the cover?! (I know it's probably not but I could see him in a TV show based on this book!)
This re-release of Charlie Cochet's delightful novella is packed with smokey speakeasies, dodgy moonshine and hard bitten cops in the finest of Sam Spade traditions.
Harley and Nate are partners in life as well as on the force and getting weary of the corruption, the strikeouts and the raids. I loved the atmosphere of this narrative, you could hear the clink of glasses, the piano tinkling away as some lounge singer extols the virtues of the Jazz Age.
Originally written for the Goodreads Love Is Always Write event, this has been given a beautiful new cover and re-released by Dreamspinner Press.
#ARC kindly provided by the publishers Dreamspinner Press in return for an honest and unbiased review.
PS: Is it just me or does that look like the divine Ben Whishaw on the cover?! (I know it's probably not but I could see him in a TV show based on this book!)
March 17, 2013
Offered for FREE from the M/M Romance Group, Love Is Always Write: Volume Eight.
I'm not sure why, but for some reason I'm always hesitant about historicals. There really wasn't any need. This had just the right amount of '20's slang to make it fun and give you the right vibe, but it's a great story that could have taken place in any era.
They easily could have ended this in a few places earlier and it still would have been good, but I'm glad it was flushed out (I hope this author joins the next event and writes John and Danny's story!)
This was sweet. The sex scenes were hot. And to be honest, the guy in the pic didn'really do it for me, too beefy. But I loved Harley so much and then the perfect explanation/reveal of the tattoo... love it now!
August 4, 2012
America had become the devil's den, and New York City its Garden
I love Charlie Cochet's writing, but historical is not my favorite genre. So when this free story first came out as part of the Love Is Always Write Event, I just skimmed through it, and left it to come back to it another day. Just today I had the urge to read this again, now with the proper focus the story needed.
There are already so many reviews for this one, so I don't want to say much except that ... it's another eloquent piece of story. Though I don't know much about the history of Prohibition Era in United States and there are some names thrown here that are probably more recognizable for the Americans ...
HOWEVER, I'm easily pulled in with the emotion shown by the relationship between Nathan and Harley. I love established couples. Yes, sure, I wish I can read the story about how Nathan and Harley met, but I have no problem of reading about them at this moment of their relationship ... when someone from Nathan's past returns and both men have to deal with that. The part where Harley confronts Nathan -- and they talk, and they have that a bit rough (sort of like punishment) sex, I'm simply enchanted by it.
I'm also intrigued with the possible romance blooming with the secondary characters and I'm filled with joy, knowing that Julius will have his own story.
Will definitely wait for Julius's story (which at the time I'm writing this, the status is "near complete")
I love Charlie Cochet's writing, but historical is not my favorite genre. So when this free story first came out as part of the Love Is Always Write Event, I just skimmed through it, and left it to come back to it another day. Just today I had the urge to read this again, now with the proper focus the story needed.
There are already so many reviews for this one, so I don't want to say much except that ... it's another eloquent piece of story. Though I don't know much about the history of Prohibition Era in United States and there are some names thrown here that are probably more recognizable for the Americans ...
HOWEVER, I'm easily pulled in with the emotion shown by the relationship between Nathan and Harley. I love established couples. Yes, sure, I wish I can read the story about how Nathan and Harley met, but I have no problem of reading about them at this moment of their relationship ... when someone from Nathan's past returns and both men have to deal with that. The part where Harley confronts Nathan -- and they talk, and they have that a bit rough (sort of like punishment) sex, I'm simply enchanted by it.
I'm also intrigued with the possible romance blooming with the secondary characters and I'm filled with joy, knowing that Julius will have his own story.
Will definitely wait for Julius's story (which at the time I'm writing this, the status is "near complete")
April 24, 2018
For such a short novella, Cochet does a wonderful job of giving us the feel of the Prohibition era in New York City. Harlan McKay and Nathan Reilly first met during World War I and have been together for seven years, working for the Bureau. Each man carries the weight of wartime memories and they've been to hell and back together; the love and trust they share is strong.
I like that Nate and Harley are an established couple and have a life together. Danny and John seem to be headed for a relationship, and Julius seems to have an interesting backstory as well. There is a second book in the Fallen Rose series and I look forward to this and any additional books in the series. A strong 4 stars for "Roses in the Devil's Garden."
I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Review also posted at Gay Book Reviews - check it out!
“No more suffering in silence. What we saw over there… what we experienced? No one walked away from that untouched. I know you’re trying to protect me, but don’t. I love you, all of you, and I’m here with you.That love is tested when childhood friend (and ex-lover) Danny Brogan reappears in Nathan's life and the men, along with Detective John Flynn, work together to bring down a dangerous criminal and ferret out police corruption.
I like that Nate and Harley are an established couple and have a life together. Danny and John seem to be headed for a relationship, and Julius seems to have an interesting backstory as well. There is a second book in the Fallen Rose series and I look forward to this and any additional books in the series. A strong 4 stars for "Roses in the Devil's Garden."
I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Review also posted at Gay Book Reviews - check it out!
May 15, 2012
I liked this free sort, it was set in a time period that I'm usually not a fan of, but I liked the guys and wished I had found out more about their background, how they became partners and their future at the bureau.
July 2, 2013
3.5-4 stars – An overall fun historical romance novella that has the extra bonus of being free. Set during the U.S. prohibition era, the story follows Harlan and Nate, two Prohibition Agents who, unlike many in their field, are on the up-and-up. They’re also together, and have been for six years, both survivors of WWI.
The story starts with Harlan and Nate busting a speakeasy and arresting a key lackey who’s been selling poisonous blinding booze to unsuspecting patrons. But when they go down to the precinct to interrogate him, Nate is faced with someone from his past, someone who he thought was long-dead, and suddenly things get a little unsteady for his and Harlan’s rock-solid relationship.
Overall it was a fun read, and at over 18,000 words, was a nice sizeable story. Cochet’s writing has the same light, period bounciness that I like so much in the Amethyst Cat Caper, and like that book, this one also felt like I was reading an old black & white caper film, zinging dialogue and all. The stories both share some similarities but I just went with the flow. I think I felt the size constraints more on this one, and the climax was a little underwhelming, but I did dig the relationship between Harley and Nate and how much they supported and loved each other.
I’m definitely a fan of Cochet’s historicals though--I find them light, fun, and breezy. I think my favorite still is the Remi and Hawk stories, but this one was definitely a good read, so recommended, especially if you’re an m/m historicals fan. (And you can’t beat the free!)
An ebook version can be downloaded from its GR page, and it’s available in multiple formats for free from All Romance Ebooks.
The story starts with Harlan and Nate busting a speakeasy and arresting a key lackey who’s been selling poisonous blinding booze to unsuspecting patrons. But when they go down to the precinct to interrogate him, Nate is faced with someone from his past, someone who he thought was long-dead, and suddenly things get a little unsteady for his and Harlan’s rock-solid relationship.
Overall it was a fun read, and at over 18,000 words, was a nice sizeable story. Cochet’s writing has the same light, period bounciness that I like so much in the Amethyst Cat Caper, and like that book, this one also felt like I was reading an old black & white caper film, zinging dialogue and all. The stories both share some similarities but I just went with the flow. I think I felt the size constraints more on this one, and the climax was a little underwhelming, but I did dig the relationship between Harley and Nate and how much they supported and loved each other.
I’m definitely a fan of Cochet’s historicals though--I find them light, fun, and breezy. I think my favorite still is the Remi and Hawk stories, but this one was definitely a good read, so recommended, especially if you’re an m/m historicals fan. (And you can’t beat the free!)
An ebook version can be downloaded from its GR page, and it’s available in multiple formats for free from All Romance Ebooks.
July 30, 2012
Another gem from the author, I love Charlie's historical romances. I am always drawn into the time period it somehow comes alive. No exception here lovely appealing characters and fascinating secondary ones too. I can't wait for the next story.
July 25, 2012
Very good short historical m/m romance about two NYC Prohibition agents who constantly have to be on the lookout for agents on the take. Definitely looking forward to reading the next book!
October 13, 2014
Loved this short historical! Harlan and Nathan! *sigh*
September 12, 2014
Partnered prohibition agents and lovers for the last six years, Harlan Mackay and Nathan Reilly find that their relationship might be in jeopardy when Nathan’s long-lost friend and former lover turns up working on one of their cases.
I really enjoyed this little story. I can’t recall reading any romances set during the prohibition era and I found that I am really interested in reading more of this time period, especially one where prohibition is key to the story. The author does an amazing job with her descriptions and development of the setting: from the flapper girls to Harlan’s Buick Roadster. I could imagine it all!
I always say how I am not a fan of established lovers/couples (same character series excluded) and I was a bit worried at the beginning once I realized that Harlan and Nathan had been together for so long. It wasn’t until Nathan’s old friend Danny showed up and threw a kink in the happy couple’s life when I really got hooked into the story.
It did get a bit angsty there for a bit when Nathan screwed up. I abhor cheating and while both characters cross into very gray territory of what defines infidelity, I felt it to be very believable and their reactions just as true.
Harlan and Nathan were both very likable characters and as a couple they were HOT with plenty of tenderness and sweetness in between. Harlan’s tattoo of “I am my Beloved’s” is just so sexy!! And the passion they displayed between them during the love scenes was just… I have no words!!
The prohibition case that the MCs were working was a bit too complicated and involved for such a short story. Or maybe I just didn’t find it as interesting since it took a backseat to the romance drama. Anyway, I would love to read more!
There were three very prominent secondary characters that I would love to know more about: Danny, John and Julius. Looks like Julius will get his own book next!
Can’t wait to read book two of the Fallen Rose series A Rose By Any Other Name.
Reviewed for The Blogger Girls
I really enjoyed this little story. I can’t recall reading any romances set during the prohibition era and I found that I am really interested in reading more of this time period, especially one where prohibition is key to the story. The author does an amazing job with her descriptions and development of the setting: from the flapper girls to Harlan’s Buick Roadster. I could imagine it all!
I always say how I am not a fan of established lovers/couples (same character series excluded) and I was a bit worried at the beginning once I realized that Harlan and Nathan had been together for so long. It wasn’t until Nathan’s old friend Danny showed up and threw a kink in the happy couple’s life when I really got hooked into the story.
It did get a bit angsty there for a bit when Nathan screwed up. I abhor cheating and while both characters cross into very gray territory of what defines infidelity, I felt it to be very believable and their reactions just as true.
Harlan and Nathan were both very likable characters and as a couple they were HOT with plenty of tenderness and sweetness in between. Harlan’s tattoo of “I am my Beloved’s” is just so sexy!! And the passion they displayed between them during the love scenes was just… I have no words!!
The prohibition case that the MCs were working was a bit too complicated and involved for such a short story. Or maybe I just didn’t find it as interesting since it took a backseat to the romance drama. Anyway, I would love to read more!
There were three very prominent secondary characters that I would love to know more about: Danny, John and Julius. Looks like Julius will get his own book next!
Can’t wait to read book two of the Fallen Rose series A Rose By Any Other Name.
Reviewed for The Blogger Girls
January 2, 2013
Written for a Goodreads writing fest, (Love is Always Write) this is now out in ebook form and is a nice quick read. The more I read from Charlie Cochet the more I appreciate her. She knows her era, she specialises in the 20′s and 30′s in America- and I don’t know of anyone doing the era better than she does.
This is the story of Harlan and Nathan–two cops working in the Prohibition Unit in New York. Lovers and partners they have successfully managed to avoid anyone finding out about their love affair. At work they are as hard bitten and tough as any of the other cops on duty–and why should they not be, after all? The only thing that I didn’t like about these guys was the fact that their names were too similar because I am a bear of little brain and can’t remember which is which.
What I particularly like about Cochet’s writing is her economy; somehow she manages to push a quart into a pint pot, as it were, and in the space of a small novella–hardly more than a longish short story, there’s action, romance, jealousy, character building, backstory, promise of more to come and more action. She makes it look easy and believe me it isn’t.
She intrigues with her characters. Small hints are thrown out, the fact that Harlan is loaded–money from his family–but we aren’t told very much more than that and I for one wanted to know more. Then there’s a character introduction that deals with Nathan’s past, and again, you want to know the full story behind that too. Don’t get me wrong, Cochet doesn’t leave you hanging with these plotlines, she tells you exactly as much as you need to know for this story, but if you are like me you’ll be writing to her and saying “more please!”
The historical details are, or seem to be, spot on. She’s a “safe pair of hands” and there are no jarring moments which throw you back into the 21st century, these are men of their time, and if that makes them bigoted and makes them say things that we would find objectionable, then so be it. If a guy is considered a fairy by 1920′s standards, then he’s described as such as so it should be. No political correctness in Prohibition Noo Yawk no sirree!
Highly recommended and even better – its a FREE READ!
This is the story of Harlan and Nathan–two cops working in the Prohibition Unit in New York. Lovers and partners they have successfully managed to avoid anyone finding out about their love affair. At work they are as hard bitten and tough as any of the other cops on duty–and why should they not be, after all? The only thing that I didn’t like about these guys was the fact that their names were too similar because I am a bear of little brain and can’t remember which is which.
What I particularly like about Cochet’s writing is her economy; somehow she manages to push a quart into a pint pot, as it were, and in the space of a small novella–hardly more than a longish short story, there’s action, romance, jealousy, character building, backstory, promise of more to come and more action. She makes it look easy and believe me it isn’t.
She intrigues with her characters. Small hints are thrown out, the fact that Harlan is loaded–money from his family–but we aren’t told very much more than that and I for one wanted to know more. Then there’s a character introduction that deals with Nathan’s past, and again, you want to know the full story behind that too. Don’t get me wrong, Cochet doesn’t leave you hanging with these plotlines, she tells you exactly as much as you need to know for this story, but if you are like me you’ll be writing to her and saying “more please!”
The historical details are, or seem to be, spot on. She’s a “safe pair of hands” and there are no jarring moments which throw you back into the 21st century, these are men of their time, and if that makes them bigoted and makes them say things that we would find objectionable, then so be it. If a guy is considered a fairy by 1920′s standards, then he’s described as such as so it should be. No political correctness in Prohibition Noo Yawk no sirree!
Highly recommended and even better – its a FREE READ!
September 12, 2014
~ ~ ~
Download and read this short historical free , here!!!
Then go pre-order
, 'cus it's soooo good :)
A Rose By Any Other Name releases September 12th.
~ ~ ~
Take a look at my Male/Male Romance Book Blog:
http://www.attentionisarbitrary.com
Download and read this short historical free , here!!!
Then go pre-order
, 'cus it's soooo good :)A Rose By Any Other Name releases September 12th.
~ ~ ~
Take a look at my Male/Male Romance Book Blog:
http://www.attentionisarbitrary.com
May 26, 2012
Despite my general lack of enthusiasm for anything historical, this story overcame that hurdle and I found myself very engaged vs. skimming the lines. It’s really a story about great characters with true historical references subtly enhancing the experience vs. dominating it. Harlan’s a very hot dude and impressive guy – Nate’s a lucky man:) I’d love to read more about this couple and their potential with the FBI, and really hope to see sequels with John and Danny (Julius too)! A fantastic story!!
May 28, 2012
There were some phrases and things I didn't understand. I think because of the time/culture it's set in. I'm also not a fan of historicals but I mostly enjoyed this one. I felt like the last 40% or so was all setting up a relationship with Danny and John. I got kind of bored with that.
I honestly have no interest in reading a continuation of any of these characters. While I liked the beginning I felt like the story fizzled the last half. Maybe that was because I just didn't like Danny? And lots of stuff is mentioned and not explained, by the end I just didn't care.
I honestly have no interest in reading a continuation of any of these characters. While I liked the beginning I felt like the story fizzled the last half. Maybe that was because I just didn't like Danny? And lots of stuff is mentioned and not explained, by the end I just didn't care.
January 15, 2015
I do love a good Roaring Twenties detective story and paired with a forbidden romance and the temptation of a lost love? Gah, so much better!
This one offered passion, tension, strong characters, twists, suspense and overall good writing. I would definitely read more from this author.
This one offered passion, tension, strong characters, twists, suspense and overall good writing. I would definitely read more from this author.
September 7, 2014
Really enjoyed this.
April 6, 2018
A Joyfully Jay review.
3.5 stars
I was first introduced to Charlie Cochet by reading her historicals, so I was eager to pick this one up. As with her other historical books, Cochet does a great job really grounding the story in the time period. Everything from the language, to the setting, to way the men interact just feels very authentic to the era. While Cochet is probably best known for her THIRDS series (which I totally love), I find that she really has great skill at writing historicals and I really enjoyed that aspect of this book.
However, I did find other aspects of the story a little rocky. The biggest issue is that it just seems like too much story for the number of pages. The guys are already a couple here and aspects of their past relationship, as well as their experiences in the military, definitely affect still them. So they are dealing with some big issues, but we only get the barest of information about them and with such a short story, there is never time to really get us up to speed. The story itself moves very quickly and covers a lot of ground, but only at the most surface level. They men arrest a bad guy and it seems to be leading to a more in depth investigation, but the story moves on, only to wrap the arrest plot up quickly at the end and sort of set up future books in the series. The pair are threatened by a past boyfriend of Nathan’s resurfacing and it immediately becomes a crisis and then resolved. Here again, the lack of background on their relationship threw me as Harlan freaks out when he finds them together in a compromising position, threatening Nathan with a gun and kicking him out. We are told how Nathan hadn’t settled down before Harlan, so presumably this is playing a role in Harlan’s quickness to doubt Nathan. But we get so little information about the past that it all felt over the top and the conflict somewhat contrived. I think if I had a better sense of the demons these guys are battling, the story would have felt less rushed and better developed. We also spend time focused on Nathan’s ex and his potential new relationship, and again, it was just too much going on without time to really explore any of it.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
3.5 stars
I was first introduced to Charlie Cochet by reading her historicals, so I was eager to pick this one up. As with her other historical books, Cochet does a great job really grounding the story in the time period. Everything from the language, to the setting, to way the men interact just feels very authentic to the era. While Cochet is probably best known for her THIRDS series (which I totally love), I find that she really has great skill at writing historicals and I really enjoyed that aspect of this book.
However, I did find other aspects of the story a little rocky. The biggest issue is that it just seems like too much story for the number of pages. The guys are already a couple here and aspects of their past relationship, as well as their experiences in the military, definitely affect still them. So they are dealing with some big issues, but we only get the barest of information about them and with such a short story, there is never time to really get us up to speed. The story itself moves very quickly and covers a lot of ground, but only at the most surface level. They men arrest a bad guy and it seems to be leading to a more in depth investigation, but the story moves on, only to wrap the arrest plot up quickly at the end and sort of set up future books in the series. The pair are threatened by a past boyfriend of Nathan’s resurfacing and it immediately becomes a crisis and then resolved. Here again, the lack of background on their relationship threw me as Harlan freaks out when he finds them together in a compromising position, threatening Nathan with a gun and kicking him out. We are told how Nathan hadn’t settled down before Harlan, so presumably this is playing a role in Harlan’s quickness to doubt Nathan. But we get so little information about the past that it all felt over the top and the conflict somewhat contrived. I think if I had a better sense of the demons these guys are battling, the story would have felt less rushed and better developed. We also spend time focused on Nathan’s ex and his potential new relationship, and again, it was just too much going on without time to really explore any of it.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
April 11, 2018
Roses in the Devil’s Garden is a short story set after WWI. It’s also the first book in a series and as such, it sets the atmosphere for the next stories. It introduces characters and it leaves loose ends to be tied up in the future.
I loved the first part of the book where we get to know Harlan and Nathan, see their relationship and their connection, see how they work together and how well they understand each other. I liked the jealousy and the bump in their lives when the past made an unexpected appearance. I liked what they did about it, and I liked the whole idea for the plot about a couple who are best friends, partners in life and partners at work.
The thing is that the second part felt like another story. The focus wasn’t on the main characters anymore but on those around them who, I believe, are getting their own stories. From the moment the focus left the MCs, the whole story became too complicated with many names thrown in the mix, friendships sprouting up as if from nowhere, and potential coupledom appearing everywhere.
Harlan and Nathan were amazing, though, so 3 stars just for them.
Reviewed by Ky for The Novel Approach
I loved the first part of the book where we get to know Harlan and Nathan, see their relationship and their connection, see how they work together and how well they understand each other. I liked the jealousy and the bump in their lives when the past made an unexpected appearance. I liked what they did about it, and I liked the whole idea for the plot about a couple who are best friends, partners in life and partners at work.
The thing is that the second part felt like another story. The focus wasn’t on the main characters anymore but on those around them who, I believe, are getting their own stories. From the moment the focus left the MCs, the whole story became too complicated with many names thrown in the mix, friendships sprouting up as if from nowhere, and potential coupledom appearing everywhere.
Harlan and Nathan were amazing, though, so 3 stars just for them.
Reviewed by Ky for The Novel Approach
April 6, 2018
Review to follow at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words.
ARC provided by Dreamspinner Press in exchange for an honest review.
ARC provided by Dreamspinner Press in exchange for an honest review.
April 7, 2018
As the first line of 'Roses in the Devil's Garden' by Charlie Cochet says, “This story has no moral, this story has no end, it only goes to show there ain't no good in men” with me recognizing the lyrics to the song 'Frankie and Johnnie' and having the irresistible urge to finish the phrase with: ”He was her man, but he done her wrong.” It is a fitting way to begin a story about corruption in Manhattan, NY, during the Roaring Twenties. Nathan and Harlan realized that being with the prohibition unit was an exercise in futility. On one hand, it was their job to uphold the law regardless of their opinions about it. On the other, they couldn't help but be lenient sometimes, showing their compassionate side, especially in the case of Julian, a young man they met in a speak easy, who I adored for his part in supporting their relationship. Harlan and Nathan are amazingly loyal and considerate of each other which makes them an unstoppable team.
One of the most endearing things about Nathan and Harlan is their easy banter and the amazing way they can be so incredibly intimate without touching. Being partners lends itself to a closeness which is not unusual for men in law enforcement who, quite literally, watch out for each other because their lives do depend on it. In spite of the dark world around them and the odds being against them, they forge a close, loving, passionate relationship which is admirable. When Danny, a specter from the past, appears to threaten their closeness, they falter, but do not fall. I sympathized with both of their positions concerning Danny. Even when Danny backed off and became interested in someone else, it was still hard for me to like him due to his incredibly selfish behavior.
'Roses in the Devil's Garden', although set in the 1920s, could be just as applicable today. The Eighteenth Amendment was an inane effort to legislate morals and, as in the case of today to control behavior, it failed miserably, causing law abiding people to suffer and the drug cartels, black markets, and other assorted criminals to profit. Even after 100 years, things are still the same. If you like historical literature which includes lifestyles, morals, same sex relationships, passion, intrigue, and angst, then you may enjoy this story. Thanks, Charlie, for the intriguing, honest look at the prohibition time period.
Even in the best of circumstances, many of us falter when love beckons us. We doubt whether we're smart enough, pretty enough, passionate enough. We may even wonder if we deserve the love we are being offered. With that in mind, try to imagine how Matthew Rideaux of 'Love Bade me Welcome' by Tom Jemielity feels when all of his life he'd been told that, because he was gay, he was evil, an abomination, completely undeserving of love. Fortunately, he meets Todd Milonik who becomes his best friend, lover, and companion through life's journey; through this relationship, he discovers that it is possible to have the intimacy and fulfillment he so desires.
Todd and Matthew are a wonderful couple, so compatible, so compassionate with each other. They weather the storms of life together, fiercely, but as discreetly as possible, defending their right to love each other and be together. It isn't easy in 1966 to be homosexual. In fact, it could be downright dangerous not only physically, but socially. Todd and Matt hate the covertness of their situation, but they are willing to do anything to protect their relationship. Fortunately, they have good friends, including one very special priest, and family along the way who love and support them. I loved both of their mothers who, in my humble opinion, are as much heroes in this story as their sons are. They stand up against anyone who threatens them and there is no wrath greater than a mother's when they perceive their child is in danger.
This is a poignant story written in a more formal language style which fits nicely with circumstances of the time period. There's very little overt sex, but the guys love each other with an intensity which is tangible and further explicitly simply isn't necessary to capture the moment. For me, the real charm of the story was in the subtle, cautious, but deeply-felt emotions which are revealed to us in a slow but steady pace.
I'd recommend this story to anyone who wants to enjoy a lovely, subtle, but meaningful story about true love overcoming the challenges that life throws at them. Thank you, Tom, for a comfortable, enjoyable reading experience.
NOTE: This book was provided by Dreamspinner Press for the purpose of a review on Rainbow Book Reviews.
One of the most endearing things about Nathan and Harlan is their easy banter and the amazing way they can be so incredibly intimate without touching. Being partners lends itself to a closeness which is not unusual for men in law enforcement who, quite literally, watch out for each other because their lives do depend on it. In spite of the dark world around them and the odds being against them, they forge a close, loving, passionate relationship which is admirable. When Danny, a specter from the past, appears to threaten their closeness, they falter, but do not fall. I sympathized with both of their positions concerning Danny. Even when Danny backed off and became interested in someone else, it was still hard for me to like him due to his incredibly selfish behavior.
'Roses in the Devil's Garden', although set in the 1920s, could be just as applicable today. The Eighteenth Amendment was an inane effort to legislate morals and, as in the case of today to control behavior, it failed miserably, causing law abiding people to suffer and the drug cartels, black markets, and other assorted criminals to profit. Even after 100 years, things are still the same. If you like historical literature which includes lifestyles, morals, same sex relationships, passion, intrigue, and angst, then you may enjoy this story. Thanks, Charlie, for the intriguing, honest look at the prohibition time period.
Even in the best of circumstances, many of us falter when love beckons us. We doubt whether we're smart enough, pretty enough, passionate enough. We may even wonder if we deserve the love we are being offered. With that in mind, try to imagine how Matthew Rideaux of 'Love Bade me Welcome' by Tom Jemielity feels when all of his life he'd been told that, because he was gay, he was evil, an abomination, completely undeserving of love. Fortunately, he meets Todd Milonik who becomes his best friend, lover, and companion through life's journey; through this relationship, he discovers that it is possible to have the intimacy and fulfillment he so desires.
Todd and Matthew are a wonderful couple, so compatible, so compassionate with each other. They weather the storms of life together, fiercely, but as discreetly as possible, defending their right to love each other and be together. It isn't easy in 1966 to be homosexual. In fact, it could be downright dangerous not only physically, but socially. Todd and Matt hate the covertness of their situation, but they are willing to do anything to protect their relationship. Fortunately, they have good friends, including one very special priest, and family along the way who love and support them. I loved both of their mothers who, in my humble opinion, are as much heroes in this story as their sons are. They stand up against anyone who threatens them and there is no wrath greater than a mother's when they perceive their child is in danger.
This is a poignant story written in a more formal language style which fits nicely with circumstances of the time period. There's very little overt sex, but the guys love each other with an intensity which is tangible and further explicitly simply isn't necessary to capture the moment. For me, the real charm of the story was in the subtle, cautious, but deeply-felt emotions which are revealed to us in a slow but steady pace.
I'd recommend this story to anyone who wants to enjoy a lovely, subtle, but meaningful story about true love overcoming the challenges that life throws at them. Thank you, Tom, for a comfortable, enjoyable reading experience.
NOTE: This book was provided by Dreamspinner Press for the purpose of a review on Rainbow Book Reviews.
September 19, 2014
I really enjoyed this free short story by one of my now favorite authors, Charlie Cochet. I actually read this in the early stages of the story, during the 2012 event and it was my first introduction to her work. I've been in love with her writing ever since.
But I hadn't read it in published form and I just read it so that I could refresh my memory before I dive into A Rose By Any Other Name. I really enjoyed these MCs, Harlan and Nathan and the brief intro to the character of Julius, who I think is going to be the MC of the next book. Even the supporting characters of Danny and Johnny were very intriguing.
This is a historical piece from the Prohibition Era in the US, and it's fun to see how the guys interact with each other in that era. If you haven't read this story, pick it up. Free just can't be beat.
But I hadn't read it in published form and I just read it so that I could refresh my memory before I dive into A Rose By Any Other Name. I really enjoyed these MCs, Harlan and Nathan and the brief intro to the character of Julius, who I think is going to be the MC of the next book. Even the supporting characters of Danny and Johnny were very intriguing.
This is a historical piece from the Prohibition Era in the US, and it's fun to see how the guys interact with each other in that era. If you haven't read this story, pick it up. Free just can't be beat.
January 7, 2015
C'est le premier récit historique que je lis de Charlie Cochet et surement pas le dernier, cette auteure est aussi douée dans l'action que dans ce genre. Ce court récit qui se déroule sous la prohibition américaine est un bon aperçu de ce que Charlie Cochet est capable d'écrire dans ce genre pas si évident qu'il n'y parait, surtout si le couple de héros sont deux hommes.
Harlan et Nathan sont deux agents qui vivent ensembles depuis six années, c'est un couple stable qui détonne à cette époque, tous deux sont des survivants de la première guerre mondiale, et c'est un fantôme du passé qui va bouleverser cette relation bien établie. Il n'est pas facile avec si peu de pages de développer des personnages et pourtant c'est réussi, alors oui j'aurais aimé un peu plus d'action et de suspense,plus de descriptions sur cette période, cependant j'ai aimé ma lecture, les scènes sensuelles sont sexys et chaudes et je suis définitivement accro à cet auteure.
Harlan et Nathan sont deux agents qui vivent ensembles depuis six années, c'est un couple stable qui détonne à cette époque, tous deux sont des survivants de la première guerre mondiale, et c'est un fantôme du passé qui va bouleverser cette relation bien établie. Il n'est pas facile avec si peu de pages de développer des personnages et pourtant c'est réussi, alors oui j'aurais aimé un peu plus d'action et de suspense,plus de descriptions sur cette période, cependant j'ai aimé ma lecture, les scènes sensuelles sont sexys et chaudes et je suis définitivement accro à cet auteure.
September 25, 2012
Really really liked this story of Harlan and Nathan, two prohibition agents who are partners at work and in life. Nathan and Harlan have been together for a while - they both went through WWI and are damaged from that and from life. I remember my auntie talking about her all her friends and relatives that died during the influenza pandemic and Harlan has lost his family to it in this story. The supporting characters were well-written and greatly contributed to the story - especially John and Danny. Julian was a revelation as well. I love the way Charlie writes about this era. But really I just love the way she writes her characters. Once again, well done!
February 3, 2016
*4.25 stars*
Loved the setting -- prohibition era New York. Also loved that the MCs -- both prohibition officers -- are already established lovers. The first half of this was 5 star worthy -- the setting, the sexiness and the tenderness between Nathan and Harlan. In the second half, the story seemed to lose its focus with the introduction of new characters and plot lines. Nevertheless, this was still an enjoyable read and I'd certainly read more M/M set in this time period.
Loved the setting -- prohibition era New York. Also loved that the MCs -- both prohibition officers -- are already established lovers. The first half of this was 5 star worthy -- the setting, the sexiness and the tenderness between Nathan and Harlan. In the second half, the story seemed to lose its focus with the introduction of new characters and plot lines. Nevertheless, this was still an enjoyable read and I'd certainly read more M/M set in this time period.
September 30, 2014
4.5 Stars
A great cast of characters set in prohibition America. Charlie Cochet has managed to capture the flavour of that time very well - speakeasies, bootleg liquor, jazz... right down to the slang of the time.
I'm looking forward to future adventures with ALL of these well-drawn, complex characters! (Yes, that's a hint for more!)
A great cast of characters set in prohibition America. Charlie Cochet has managed to capture the flavour of that time very well - speakeasies, bootleg liquor, jazz... right down to the slang of the time.
I'm looking forward to future adventures with ALL of these well-drawn, complex characters! (Yes, that's a hint for more!)
January 13, 2013
I'm a huge fan of the HBO series, Boardwalk Empire, and this story was like getting to read an episode of that show but with gay -- handsome, smart, cunning, clever, and fabulously named -- heroes. Cochet's writing is a treat. Tidy, cohesive, and seamless, the plots are well-laid, the history well-researched, and the characters well-rounded. Thank you for this one, Ms. Cochet!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews