Spoilers for the book! If you haven’t read it yet and you want to, please skip this review!
Okay, as a lifelong Transformers fan and someone who grew up watching the Bayverse movies, I really wasn’t expecting a whole lot from this book. After all, the Bayverse Transformers films aren’t exactly known for their stellar scripts, so the main reason why I picked up Ghosts of Tomorrow was purely due to me being a Transformers fan and wanting to read every Transformers novel that’s been out out there. After finishing the book however, I can happily say that I was pleasantly surprised! This book isn’t all that bad! The writing is good, and the author seems to have a good grasp of the lore they were trying to create for these films. Is it a perfect read? Eh, not exactly. There were some moments where I definitely thought the chapters were dragging and some things could be cut out. The sequence with the dead planet and the underground snake-worms seemed kind of pointless. It gave the protagonists a level of peril and also provided an opening for the Ghost crew to meet Optimus and Bumblebee, thus leading to proper introductions and the two groups teaming up. But there could have been a more meaningful way for the Autobots and humans to unite I feel? I don’t know exactly how I would rewrite it, but it sort of just felt like they were there, they met, and they were gone. Nothing to really contribute to the plot itself besides the very abrupt introductions.
Another thing that had me thinking was how the whole first contact scenario between the humans and Cybertronians played out. I’ve read A LOT of Transformers first contact writings over my years as a Transformers fan, and one thing this particular one was missing was the purely alien feeling Cybertronians give us. The language barrier was solved way too quickly. You can blame that on the drastic difference between Cybertronian technology and 1960’s human technology, but I feel like there should have been a period of time where the characters had to work together without knowing what each other are saying. There was also just…way too much immediate trust shown to Starscream by the Ghost crew. This is literally the first human-Cybertronian interaction to ever occur in this universe. And Starscream is not a friendly-looking bot. Why just trust what he says? Take a good look at Starscream, then compare him to Optimus Prime; you better believe I’m thinking the latter is more benevolent than the former. Maybe I’m looking way too into this, but the book just seems to rush into these interactions way too quickly, and I feel like the author should have taken a more tentative approach.
That being said, this isn’t a book totally without feels! The ending was especially sad! I wasn’t expecting the Ghost crew to die at all! I actually got a little emotional! These characters weren’t the best at being fleshed out, and I definitely wasn’t attached to them, but I still felt disbelief when Starscream blew them up in the end! But I guess that explains why no one was there to talk about these events in the 2007 Bayverse movie. But still, the chapters leading up to the end definitely had some emotional scenes and quotes in them that tugged at my heart strings!
My favorite scene in the whole book was when Megatron woke up. That was a greatly written moment that really displayed how menacing it would be for us to meet a Cybertronian for the first time. It was everything the Ghost crew’s interactions with the bots was lacking: the initial terror of seeing something so massive, so inhuman, awaken and cause so much destruction without even doing much. Megatron was barely awake and he caused so much destruction. Really good.
All in all, if you are a Transformers fan, I recommend reading this book! It gives ample backstory to the Bayverse films and provides great moments of the Autobots and Decepticons, especially Starscream and Jazz. It’s a slow read with a lot of details and human scenes, so if you’re in it purely for the robots, you might get bored. But it’s a good instruction novel, and for people who don’t know much about Transformers behind them being giant mechs from space, you can read this and not have to know anything about the lore. 4/5 stars!