What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lost Songs
The day Lutie Painter takes the city bus north instead of the school bus west, cutting class for the first time ever, her aunt and uncle have no idea what she is up to. They cannot prevent her from riding into danger.
That same morning, Lutie's pastor, Miss Veola, whispers as always, "This is the day that the Lord hath made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it."
A block from Miss Veola and up a hill in Chalk, Train Greene, thin and hungry, burns with anger. He has a decision to make, and he's running out of time.
A few miles away, among finer houses, Kelvin Hartley yawns and gets ready for another day at school, where he is a friend to all and makes an effort at nothing.
And Doria Bell, who recently moved to the South from Connecticut, walks to the bus stop, hoping the high school kids who live nearby will say hello.
All of these lives intertwine and—in surprising ways—become connected to Lutie's ancestors, who are buried in the cemetery in Chalk. Who would have dreamed that the long-dead Mabel Painter, who passed down the Laundry List songs to her great-great-granddaughter Lutie, had passed along a piece of American history that speaks to so many who feel lost and need hope. Big changes are in store for all, and things will never be the same.
In this luminous novel, Caroline B. Cooney delves deeply into a Southern community. Cooney reveals the comfort, inspiration, and hope its members draw from the power of faith, the glory of music, and the meaning of family.
From the Hardcover edition.
That same morning, Lutie's pastor, Miss Veola, whispers as always, "This is the day that the Lord hath made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it."
A block from Miss Veola and up a hill in Chalk, Train Greene, thin and hungry, burns with anger. He has a decision to make, and he's running out of time.
A few miles away, among finer houses, Kelvin Hartley yawns and gets ready for another day at school, where he is a friend to all and makes an effort at nothing.
And Doria Bell, who recently moved to the South from Connecticut, walks to the bus stop, hoping the high school kids who live nearby will say hello.
All of these lives intertwine and—in surprising ways—become connected to Lutie's ancestors, who are buried in the cemetery in Chalk. Who would have dreamed that the long-dead Mabel Painter, who passed down the Laundry List songs to her great-great-granddaughter Lutie, had passed along a piece of American history that speaks to so many who feel lost and need hope. Big changes are in store for all, and things will never be the same.
In this luminous novel, Caroline B. Cooney delves deeply into a Southern community. Cooney reveals the comfort, inspiration, and hope its members draw from the power of faith, the glory of music, and the meaning of family.
From the Hardcover edition.
256 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 11, 2011
15 people are currently reading
412 people want to read
About the author
Caroline B. Cooney
129 books1,771 followersCaroline Cooney knew in sixth grade that she wanted to be a writer when "the best teacher I ever had in my life" made writing her main focus. "He used to rip off covers from The New Yorker and pass them around and make us write a short story on whichever cover we got. I started writing then and never stopped!"
When her children were young, Caroline started writing books for young people -- with remarkable results. She began to sell stories to Seventeen magazine and soon after began writing books. Suspense novels are her favorites to read and write. "In a suspense novel, you can count on action."
To keep her stories realistic, Caroline visits many schools outside of her area, learning more about teenagers all the time. She often organizes what she calls a "plotting game," in which students work together to create plots for stories. Caroline lives in Westbrook, Connecticut and when she's not writing she volunteers at a hospital, plays piano for the school musicals and daydreams!
- Scholastic.com
When her children were young, Caroline started writing books for young people -- with remarkable results. She began to sell stories to Seventeen magazine and soon after began writing books. Suspense novels are her favorites to read and write. "In a suspense novel, you can count on action."
To keep her stories realistic, Caroline visits many schools outside of her area, learning more about teenagers all the time. She often organizes what she calls a "plotting game," in which students work together to create plots for stories. Caroline lives in Westbrook, Connecticut and when she's not writing she volunteers at a hospital, plays piano for the school musicals and daydreams!
- Scholastic.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews
June 3, 2012
Put music notes on a book cover and I'll stop in my tracks, but most books "about" music disappoint. Not this one. This is the best book I've read in a long time. Meet Lutie, raised between suburban America and gritty, impoverished Chalk--smart, a gifted singer, ashamed of her drug addict mother. Meet Doria, new to the South, organist extraordinaire and misfit. Meet Train, struggling to find enough "badness" in him. Cooney's characters are so vivid, they surely must be real people somewhere. Their stories collide when a music history professor comes in search of "The Laundry List," a series of songs written by Lutie's great-great grandmother that capture the African American experience.
The book is labeled YA, but although it reads fast, like most YA, I couldn't help thinking it was stealth "literary." It is not Christian fiction, and yet the religion of the south is so integrated into it that you wonder how she managed to write it without crossing the line. An amazing book.
The book is labeled YA, but although it reads fast, like most YA, I couldn't help thinking it was stealth "literary." It is not Christian fiction, and yet the religion of the south is so integrated into it that you wonder how she managed to write it without crossing the line. An amazing book.
March 17, 2012
One knows it's a good book when one (physically) cannot stop reading to have dinner or go to sleep. I don't cry. The Lost Songs made me get teary-eyed more than once. How Caroline Cooney writes prayers and verses to touch the soul like that i can never fathom. This book has inspired me in more ways than one. The musical, social, and spiritual depth imparticular, all had a very profound effect on myself. Thank you, Ms. Cooney, for putting amazing YA literature out there. :)
July 9, 2020
I’m of several minds about this one. I like Cooney’s writing and I like her stories, but this one made me cringe with stereotypes in some places, and I’d love to know what a BIPOC reader would think of it. Is this hers to tell? Even though she told it well? Hm I’m not sure. (Bonus points for a teenager organist as a character, which you NEVER see in books and sort of delighted me.)
May 2, 2016
I randomly picked this book from the library and I'm glad I did. It's not often a book can make me cry and while it didn't make me stream tears I definitely teared up. It was sad but not entirely. The good came, too. I didn't connect with all the characters. Not even the "main" character, Lutie. My heart leaped for Cliff. I'm a sucker for happy endings and in my mind he went on to have one!
Currently reading
May 20, 2020Lutie and her friends Doria, Train, and Kelvin are teens who attend the same high school. The beginning of the book shows Lutie's story of a drug addict mother, Saravette, and two new guardians, Lutie's successful aunts and uncle. Lutie was advised to stay away from her mother, but Lutie chose to skip school and see her mother. Lutie was granted the lost songs or the laundry list by her grandmother before she passed. Lutie chose to hid these songs as her own even though others wanted the laundry list, such as her teacher. Lutie, Doria, Kelvin, and Train were all part of the choir and church. Lutie's teacher thought that the laundry list will be great exposure for all of them to get their work far. However, Lutie's plans were no farther than finding how important these lost songs truly were. Lutie discovered the laundry list was created in Paradise, where workers used sing the time by. Lutie's findings showed how important the songs were and the work that Lutie's great-great-great grandma did. The laundry list was essential to more than just music, but the beauty behind the work of the slaves. In the end, Lutie found her way to showing some songs used in the history of the slaves at hand in Paradise.
The three main literary devices used were foreshadowing, flashbacks, and hyperboles. Foreshadowing was used in the beginning and towards the middle of the novel. This was used in predicting how important the laundry list will be. For example, Lutie's teacher was trying to influence the songs to be put out on a platform for exposure. Flashbacks were shown in the middle and a little towards the end of the book. Flashbacks were intertwined with Lutie's great-great-great grandma. For example, the book had a flashback to Lutie's great-great-great grandma and her song use in Paradise. Also, hyperboles were used mainly towards the end of the novel. This literary device was used to explain the significance of the lost songs and how important they were to the workers. For example, the laundry list was established as the heart of Paradise. This truly was meant as the laundry list being the base or establishment of Paradise. These literary devices made the book much more intriguing to read and stay attached throughout the entire novel.
I really enjoyed this book once the background was finally all revealed. However, in the beginning I was making myself read the book and hoping that I will start liking it sooner or later. The beginning was very boring because it gave kind of a boring background story to everyone besides Lutie. This showed Lutie as the main character from the start since the author highlighted her story over others. This book had such great details and poems that were actually very interesting to read. I liked the use of words and how easy it was to tell the type of people the characters were. The only downside of the book was the background story of all the other characters because it made them more of a "fill in" to the novel. Overall, I enjoyed this book for it's deeper meaning of beauty and history.
The three main literary devices used were foreshadowing, flashbacks, and hyperboles. Foreshadowing was used in the beginning and towards the middle of the novel. This was used in predicting how important the laundry list will be. For example, Lutie's teacher was trying to influence the songs to be put out on a platform for exposure. Flashbacks were shown in the middle and a little towards the end of the book. Flashbacks were intertwined with Lutie's great-great-great grandma. For example, the book had a flashback to Lutie's great-great-great grandma and her song use in Paradise. Also, hyperboles were used mainly towards the end of the novel. This literary device was used to explain the significance of the lost songs and how important they were to the workers. For example, the laundry list was established as the heart of Paradise. This truly was meant as the laundry list being the base or establishment of Paradise. These literary devices made the book much more intriguing to read and stay attached throughout the entire novel.
I really enjoyed this book once the background was finally all revealed. However, in the beginning I was making myself read the book and hoping that I will start liking it sooner or later. The beginning was very boring because it gave kind of a boring background story to everyone besides Lutie. This showed Lutie as the main character from the start since the author highlighted her story over others. This book had such great details and poems that were actually very interesting to read. I liked the use of words and how easy it was to tell the type of people the characters were. The only downside of the book was the background story of all the other characters because it made them more of a "fill in" to the novel. Overall, I enjoyed this book for it's deeper meaning of beauty and history.
Read
May 18, 2022Caroline B. Cooney came out with a contemporary fiction book for teens that includes some aspects of suspense, mystery, revealing secrets, and developing characters. Those developing characters are both frightening and fascinating. The Lost Songs is the story of four Southern teens whose separate lives become intertwined.
In addition to that, going into detail about the four main characters. Lutie, who's the central character, is popular and an exceptional singer. Doria is the new girl at school, who’s a talented musician, having a difficult time fitting in. She is infatuated with Kelvin, a friend to all who eats a little too much and is not very interested in school success. The fourth named Train is a disturbed and angry young gentleman, who is always trying to live up to the image of his brother, who is in prison for blinding a boy.
Therefore, Lutie didn’t live with any of her parents, instead she lived with her grandmother who had recently passed away. Added to this is her grandmother sang all the “lost songs” which are undocumented songs of slaves and hardworking black women. Now that she passed she spends time with her two aunts. As one day she had skipped school to visit her drug attict mother who she told she broke all ten of the schools commandments, construing an account of murder. Also, causing some problems with the other three teens in the story.
In other words, The Lost Songs characters are Christian who have prayers to Jesus, church mission work that are a part of their lives. Reading this book made me fall in love with some of the characters while fearing the others, wanting to know more about their lives, and hoping all turns out right knowing it possibly can not happen. This book focuses on the power of prayer, caring for one another, hope for the future, respect for the past, repentance and forgiveness.
As known, Cooney’s books are a great choice for reluctant readers, grabbing the reader’s attention and never letting go. In conclusion to all, I clearly recommend for teens to look forward to reading this book who are interested in mystery with developing characters.
In addition to that, going into detail about the four main characters. Lutie, who's the central character, is popular and an exceptional singer. Doria is the new girl at school, who’s a talented musician, having a difficult time fitting in. She is infatuated with Kelvin, a friend to all who eats a little too much and is not very interested in school success. The fourth named Train is a disturbed and angry young gentleman, who is always trying to live up to the image of his brother, who is in prison for blinding a boy.
Therefore, Lutie didn’t live with any of her parents, instead she lived with her grandmother who had recently passed away. Added to this is her grandmother sang all the “lost songs” which are undocumented songs of slaves and hardworking black women. Now that she passed she spends time with her two aunts. As one day she had skipped school to visit her drug attict mother who she told she broke all ten of the schools commandments, construing an account of murder. Also, causing some problems with the other three teens in the story.
In other words, The Lost Songs characters are Christian who have prayers to Jesus, church mission work that are a part of their lives. Reading this book made me fall in love with some of the characters while fearing the others, wanting to know more about their lives, and hoping all turns out right knowing it possibly can not happen. This book focuses on the power of prayer, caring for one another, hope for the future, respect for the past, repentance and forgiveness.
As known, Cooney’s books are a great choice for reluctant readers, grabbing the reader’s attention and never letting go. In conclusion to all, I clearly recommend for teens to look forward to reading this book who are interested in mystery with developing characters.
December 12, 2016
The Lost Songs by Caroline B. Cooney is a book about 4 teenagers somewhere in the South of the US. One of them, Lutie, has a phenomenal voice and ‘secret songs’ inherited by her great-great-grandmother. Train, who is skinny and scary, mostly because his brother is in jail, Doria, the newschooler who moved from beautiful and safe Connecticut to the South and is missing her friends, and Kelvin, who is always bright and a plenty full of friends. The book through 4 stories of those characters describes a portion of the history of the United States touching slavery times and also nowadays problems. Lutie’s mom, Saravette was a drug addict, so she couldn’t take care of Lutie. Lutie had to grow up with her aunts switching homes once in awhile. Besides keeping a horrible secret inside, she had another beautiful secret to be proud of. Her great-great-great-grandma was the author of list of songs called ‘Laundry List’. This was sang from grandma, to grandma, to grandma, until it came to Lutie. Lutie was a very intelligent girl, loved school, and loved singing and music. Her great-great-great-grandma was a poem lover, but in the time of slavery. She worked at laundry and during long exhausting days sang beautiful songs “written” by her heart, but at those hard times she couldn’t develop her talents. So if she would still live today, she probably would be a famous poet and singer.
At the end, “The Lost Songs” was worth it to read, because it teaches the readers, that they should not judge people from how they look or from where they come from. For example, Train comes from a very criminal neighborhood where his brother was sent to jail for blinding another teenager. So everyone thinks that Train is dangerous and scary too and people just stay away from him. Only Doria who doesn’t know his brother’s, story treats him normally, and calling him his real name, makes him behaving nicer. Or another example where Lutie’s mother is a drug addict and also a murderer “Lutie pointed at Saravette. ‘She’s waiting for me.’ The driver took in the sight of Saravatte. Thirty years old, looked eighty. Sunken cheeks from lost teeth. Tattoos and piercings no longer brave and sassy, but pitiful. Wearing two sweaters on an already hot morning. Both dirty. My mother, thought Lutie.”(7). But really Lutie is just an ordinary girl, that is very smart and has a lot of nice friends. Caroline B. Cooney is a great author of thrillers for young people and “The Lost Songs” is one of them. In conclusion, The Lost Songs is a great book for those who like investigating stories, obviously, and to have more than one main character in the book.
At the end, “The Lost Songs” was worth it to read, because it teaches the readers, that they should not judge people from how they look or from where they come from. For example, Train comes from a very criminal neighborhood where his brother was sent to jail for blinding another teenager. So everyone thinks that Train is dangerous and scary too and people just stay away from him. Only Doria who doesn’t know his brother’s, story treats him normally, and calling him his real name, makes him behaving nicer. Or another example where Lutie’s mother is a drug addict and also a murderer “Lutie pointed at Saravette. ‘She’s waiting for me.’ The driver took in the sight of Saravatte. Thirty years old, looked eighty. Sunken cheeks from lost teeth. Tattoos and piercings no longer brave and sassy, but pitiful. Wearing two sweaters on an already hot morning. Both dirty. My mother, thought Lutie.”(7). But really Lutie is just an ordinary girl, that is very smart and has a lot of nice friends. Caroline B. Cooney is a great author of thrillers for young people and “The Lost Songs” is one of them. In conclusion, The Lost Songs is a great book for those who like investigating stories, obviously, and to have more than one main character in the book.
June 30, 2018
2.5 Stars - I struggled through the first half of the book trying to get a feel for the characters or an investment in the story line. With the exception of possibly Miss Veola I felt that there was a lot of inconsistencies in the development of the characters; while I have trouble putting an exact finger on it they didn't ring true to life.
The last chapter, although a bit of a stretch for reality, managed to better the story as a whole. It gave me pause for thought which I appreciate in any book.
Parents of young readers should be aware that this books strives to show very plainly the real life side of an inner city neighborhood including topics that may disturb younger readers. Violence in particular is in parts referenced somewhat graphically, especially as portrayed through a youth who planning violent acts in detail. I would definitely suggest this is a more appropriate read for high school age and older.
The last chapter, although a bit of a stretch for reality, managed to better the story as a whole. It gave me pause for thought which I appreciate in any book.
Parents of young readers should be aware that this books strives to show very plainly the real life side of an inner city neighborhood including topics that may disturb younger readers. Violence in particular is in parts referenced somewhat graphically, especially as portrayed through a youth who planning violent acts in detail. I would definitely suggest this is a more appropriate read for high school age and older.
September 19, 2023
Sometimes a book comes along at the time that it’s needed. This was this book. One of my favorite authors of all time has done it again, this time in a different, beautiful manner, and even though it’s done I don’t feel like I’ve finished it.
July 5, 2018
An interesting look at how we view ourselves vs. how others view us....and what they expect of us as well as how our expectations of ourselves influence our actions.
November 12, 2018
Not a bad book, great characters and an ending that kept me interested. A bit too long for the story line though
December 27, 2018
This book surprised me. My son received it free at a doctor's appointment, so I assumed it was a throw away book. It turned out to be entertaining with some good gems in it.
August 13, 2022
2.5
I really wanted to like this book, but not much really happens. It just kind of meandered around until the last two chapters or so
I really wanted to like this book, but not much really happens. It just kind of meandered around until the last two chapters or so
August 24, 2025
3.5 stars
January 31, 2012
The Lost Songs
The Lost Songs is a captivating book with surprises at every turn. The book was written by Caroline B. Cooney and published in the United States by Delacorte Press in 2011. The Lost Songs is an interesting book that has danger, many great messages, and relatable characters.
Caroline B Cooney’s book takes a different approach to traditional writing. She switches the point of view between the different characters which, although can be confusing if you are not paying attention, gives you many different ways of looking at the same events.
The danger of part of the setting and a character in the story keeps you on the edge of your seat. The story takes place in Court Hill. A poor part of Court Hill, known as Chalk, is dangerous if you are not carful. Chalk is where men sit and drink all day and moms try desperately to provide for their children. This is where the criminal wannabe, Train lives. He prowls around at night. The other kids that go to his high school all fear him. Train however, is not the common bully. He poses a real threat. His brother, DeRade, is in jail for blinding a kid. DeRade also killed someone, but the police did not have enough evidence to convict him. Train always tagged along with his older brother and is now trying to outdo him.
Cooney keeps the story interesting by slowly revealing information about Lutie’s family to the reader. We know that Lutie lives with her aunts and that her mother, Saravette, is a wreck. She is a drug addict, smokes, and drinks excessively. Then, we find out that Lutie’s mother had her at a young age and left her with Lutie’s grandmother, presently deceased. Later, Lutie and the reader get the shocking news that Saravette killed Lutie’s grandmother. Lutie then hates her mother. Almost as startling, we discover that Saravette has died from overdose. These gradual surprises keep the reader engrossed in the book. Lutie realizes at the funeral for her mother that she should have tried to help her mother. She should have shown her love instead of hiding from her. She feels guilty because she had an opportunity to make a difference and didn’t even think about taking it.
Cooney writes to a large audience by creating many characters, each with a different personality. Everyone can relate to at least one of the characters. One of the characters, Kelvin, is laid back. He has no ambition, but his carefree attitude causes everyone to like him. He is a guy that everyone likes, but he doesn’t amount to much. He is kind, but that’s really the only thing that he has going for him. Cooney demonstrates that you have to work hard at something to get anywhere. Kelvin realizes this at the end of the book and decides to step up his game. He realizes that to make a difference, he has to go out and help others instead of just sitting on the couch. This is a good message for anyone.
Through the story, Doria learns to step out and make friends. She is new to Court Hill and has no friends. She is lonely, but is waiting for someone to come to her and be friends. She realizes that if she wants friends, she is going to have to be friendly. Cooney creates a likable character with which many people can relate to. Doria is smart and has ambition, but is an introvert. Her journey to find friends is one that almost everyone can relate to.
The Lost Songs is a fascinating story that has threats, numerous important themes, and relatable characters. It is an interesting, well written book. Cooney demonstrates her amazing story writing and character developing skills in this exciting novel.
The Lost Songs is a captivating book with surprises at every turn. The book was written by Caroline B. Cooney and published in the United States by Delacorte Press in 2011. The Lost Songs is an interesting book that has danger, many great messages, and relatable characters.
Caroline B Cooney’s book takes a different approach to traditional writing. She switches the point of view between the different characters which, although can be confusing if you are not paying attention, gives you many different ways of looking at the same events.
The danger of part of the setting and a character in the story keeps you on the edge of your seat. The story takes place in Court Hill. A poor part of Court Hill, known as Chalk, is dangerous if you are not carful. Chalk is where men sit and drink all day and moms try desperately to provide for their children. This is where the criminal wannabe, Train lives. He prowls around at night. The other kids that go to his high school all fear him. Train however, is not the common bully. He poses a real threat. His brother, DeRade, is in jail for blinding a kid. DeRade also killed someone, but the police did not have enough evidence to convict him. Train always tagged along with his older brother and is now trying to outdo him.
Cooney keeps the story interesting by slowly revealing information about Lutie’s family to the reader. We know that Lutie lives with her aunts and that her mother, Saravette, is a wreck. She is a drug addict, smokes, and drinks excessively. Then, we find out that Lutie’s mother had her at a young age and left her with Lutie’s grandmother, presently deceased. Later, Lutie and the reader get the shocking news that Saravette killed Lutie’s grandmother. Lutie then hates her mother. Almost as startling, we discover that Saravette has died from overdose. These gradual surprises keep the reader engrossed in the book. Lutie realizes at the funeral for her mother that she should have tried to help her mother. She should have shown her love instead of hiding from her. She feels guilty because she had an opportunity to make a difference and didn’t even think about taking it.
Cooney writes to a large audience by creating many characters, each with a different personality. Everyone can relate to at least one of the characters. One of the characters, Kelvin, is laid back. He has no ambition, but his carefree attitude causes everyone to like him. He is a guy that everyone likes, but he doesn’t amount to much. He is kind, but that’s really the only thing that he has going for him. Cooney demonstrates that you have to work hard at something to get anywhere. Kelvin realizes this at the end of the book and decides to step up his game. He realizes that to make a difference, he has to go out and help others instead of just sitting on the couch. This is a good message for anyone.
Through the story, Doria learns to step out and make friends. She is new to Court Hill and has no friends. She is lonely, but is waiting for someone to come to her and be friends. She realizes that if she wants friends, she is going to have to be friendly. Cooney creates a likable character with which many people can relate to. Doria is smart and has ambition, but is an introvert. Her journey to find friends is one that almost everyone can relate to.
The Lost Songs is a fascinating story that has threats, numerous important themes, and relatable characters. It is an interesting, well written book. Cooney demonstrates her amazing story writing and character developing skills in this exciting novel.
October 21, 2011
This quite ‘cool’ story that mixes present-day with a time in history that is still filled with mystery and questions, is a real treat.
Lutie Painter is our main character. Lutie is one of those girls that, from the outside, has it all. She is lovely, fun, has tons of friends, can sing like an angel from ‘on high,’ and has relatives who truly love and care for her - especially her MeeMaw - her grandmother who has passed away. The one thing Lutie doesn’t have is a mother. Yes, the woman is present and lives on the other side of town in the worst neighborhood in the world, but she is so drugged out of her mind that being a parent was never going to be something she could do.
Lutie’s MeeMaw and Aunt’s have told Lutie to stay away from her because she’s basically done with the world and is nothing but trouble. But one morning, Lutie has to follow the ‘call’ she receives from her Mom saying the words, “You have to know.” Getting on a bus leading her into the most horrific world she’s ever seen, to meet a mother who decides - once again - that drugs are more important than the information she called Lutie about.
Soon, Lutie is back in school in her music class where an odd man and her own professor begin talking to her about The Laundry List. This list is basically a book of songs that were written down by her ancestors. These slaves, at the time, had penned and sung some truly amazing lyrics that could quite possibly change the world, and only Lutie, supposedly, has them. MeeMaw left them to her, but Lutie knows that those songs are her ancestral history - and NOT something that can be bought and sold by others. Soon, even Miss Veola - the preacher - wants them, too, and Lutie is stuck in a world that suddenly will do anything to get what they want.
There are other friends and not-so-friendly types that end up being a part of Lutie’s world. Kelvin, a baritone in music class, is a kind young man who has had a crush on Lutie forever. Dora Bell is a Yankee in the South. She has just come into the neighborhood and can play the piano like a master - knowing all the notes the second she looks at them. She can’t, however, seem to make friends. She is an outsider, and until Lutie gives her the nod, Dora has to be content playing her piano and ‘crushing’ on Kelvin.
There is also Train Greene. Train used to be a nice boy by the name of Cliff, but when his older brother became a serious troublemaker and ended up in jail, Cliff soon turned into Train, as if he were emulating the one person he should’ve been forgetting about.
These friendships are illuminating, and the author does a fantastic job of blending the present and the past; discussing all the difficulties in both time periods. The Laundry List is a very interesting premise, and Lutie is a character that one and all will route for from beginning to end.
A unique and innovative YA. Leaving ‘vampires’ behind, this author has created a truly interesting story.
Lutie Painter is our main character. Lutie is one of those girls that, from the outside, has it all. She is lovely, fun, has tons of friends, can sing like an angel from ‘on high,’ and has relatives who truly love and care for her - especially her MeeMaw - her grandmother who has passed away. The one thing Lutie doesn’t have is a mother. Yes, the woman is present and lives on the other side of town in the worst neighborhood in the world, but she is so drugged out of her mind that being a parent was never going to be something she could do.
Lutie’s MeeMaw and Aunt’s have told Lutie to stay away from her because she’s basically done with the world and is nothing but trouble. But one morning, Lutie has to follow the ‘call’ she receives from her Mom saying the words, “You have to know.” Getting on a bus leading her into the most horrific world she’s ever seen, to meet a mother who decides - once again - that drugs are more important than the information she called Lutie about.
Soon, Lutie is back in school in her music class where an odd man and her own professor begin talking to her about The Laundry List. This list is basically a book of songs that were written down by her ancestors. These slaves, at the time, had penned and sung some truly amazing lyrics that could quite possibly change the world, and only Lutie, supposedly, has them. MeeMaw left them to her, but Lutie knows that those songs are her ancestral history - and NOT something that can be bought and sold by others. Soon, even Miss Veola - the preacher - wants them, too, and Lutie is stuck in a world that suddenly will do anything to get what they want.
There are other friends and not-so-friendly types that end up being a part of Lutie’s world. Kelvin, a baritone in music class, is a kind young man who has had a crush on Lutie forever. Dora Bell is a Yankee in the South. She has just come into the neighborhood and can play the piano like a master - knowing all the notes the second she looks at them. She can’t, however, seem to make friends. She is an outsider, and until Lutie gives her the nod, Dora has to be content playing her piano and ‘crushing’ on Kelvin.
There is also Train Greene. Train used to be a nice boy by the name of Cliff, but when his older brother became a serious troublemaker and ended up in jail, Cliff soon turned into Train, as if he were emulating the one person he should’ve been forgetting about.
These friendships are illuminating, and the author does a fantastic job of blending the present and the past; discussing all the difficulties in both time periods. The Laundry List is a very interesting premise, and Lutie is a character that one and all will route for from beginning to end.
A unique and innovative YA. Leaving ‘vampires’ behind, this author has created a truly interesting story.
July 28, 2015
Review taken from my blog, The Haunting of Orchid Forsythia
First Sentence:
"Lutie Painter had never skipped school before."
Ever since I found out that Caroline B. Cooney had a new book releasing (its already out) I knew that I would have to read it. Was The Lost Songs comparable to her previous works that I have read, no. The reason I say no is because The Lost Songs is nothing like anything I have read by her before. You'll find out below why its so different from her other books and why I loved it so.
The Lost Songs has to be one of the most vivid and beautifully written books of Ms. Cooney's that I have read to date.
What really made this an enjoyable read for me would have to be, well, that it was a new Caroline B. Cooney book and how she masterfully conquered a different type of book from what I have read by her before, as well, as that she yet again was able to pull me so far into the lives of her characters that I failed to accomplish more than devouring her book till the last page was turned. I always look forward to new books by her because had I not read her (and a few other authors) I may not be the reader that I am today. So a thank you to CBC for always entertaining me with her genius.
The one bad thing about The Lost Songs is that it made me tear up near the end as Lutie realized that she has not been as kind as she should have been, and that she was not trying her best to reach out to those who needed her. It was just sad especially since the realization came a little too late for her to be able to reach out to one who could have used a hand or encouraging word. I am not saying that this was bad, I just do not like to cry or almost cry. Because that means that I have to put the book down till the almost tears vanish and I can clearly see the page again. If sad books make you well up, I would suggest having tissues at hand when reading this one.
Final Verdict: The Lost Songs this book deeply touched me and was just brilliantly beautiful...one of the best books I have read that was filled with hope, faith and a sense of community.
The Lost Songs earns 5 of 5 pineapples.
First Sentence:
"Lutie Painter had never skipped school before."
Ever since I found out that Caroline B. Cooney had a new book releasing (its already out) I knew that I would have to read it. Was The Lost Songs comparable to her previous works that I have read, no. The reason I say no is because The Lost Songs is nothing like anything I have read by her before. You'll find out below why its so different from her other books and why I loved it so.
The Lost Songs has to be one of the most vivid and beautifully written books of Ms. Cooney's that I have read to date.
What really made this an enjoyable read for me would have to be, well, that it was a new Caroline B. Cooney book and how she masterfully conquered a different type of book from what I have read by her before, as well, as that she yet again was able to pull me so far into the lives of her characters that I failed to accomplish more than devouring her book till the last page was turned. I always look forward to new books by her because had I not read her (and a few other authors) I may not be the reader that I am today. So a thank you to CBC for always entertaining me with her genius.
The one bad thing about The Lost Songs is that it made me tear up near the end as Lutie realized that she has not been as kind as she should have been, and that she was not trying her best to reach out to those who needed her. It was just sad especially since the realization came a little too late for her to be able to reach out to one who could have used a hand or encouraging word. I am not saying that this was bad, I just do not like to cry or almost cry. Because that means that I have to put the book down till the almost tears vanish and I can clearly see the page again. If sad books make you well up, I would suggest having tissues at hand when reading this one.
Final Verdict: The Lost Songs this book deeply touched me and was just brilliantly beautiful...one of the best books I have read that was filled with hope, faith and a sense of community.
The Lost Songs earns 5 of 5 pineapples.
March 26, 2014
Reviewed for http://fantasticalpaperrealm.blogspot...
The story:
Lutie’s special, always has been, it’s just a fact of life. She’s in honor and advance placement classes at school, she’s the star of the school choir, and she has more friends then she could ever count. Now, people want her to share one of the more sacred things that make her special, her families songs. But, Lutie does not think that those songs are a national treasure, she thinks they’re her treasure. She also has a secret, her mother. She does not want anyone to know that her mother was that bum you just passed, the one with the dirty sweaters and missing teeth. The one you look the other way so you never have to look her in the eye.
Doria is new to town. She hides herself behind a piano at school, an organ at church, and a smile at home. She does not fit in and does not think she ever will. But, maybe if she helps the people around her, they’ll accept her. Or, maybe she just has to learn to speak up.
My thoughts:
This book is told from the perspective of 6 different teenagers, all with very different lives. Lutie is the main character and the book focuses on her story, her songs. But, the others all have individual stories that contribute perfectly to the big picture.
The Lost Song’s is full of music, as you may guess, and I loved that. The story of Lutie’s great-great-great grandmother singing her soul out to God while she worked is a beautiful one.
This is a story of finding yourself, sharing what makes you special, and discovering each other; and it’s a beautiful journey.
I had a hard time getting into it, right at first. But, after I hit about 50 pages the book really took off! All the different characters kept it interesting and full of life. The writing was not incredible, but, it told the story well.
The character that I identified most with was Doria. I think because of the amount of characters everybody could find someone who is like them, and that always makes a book more enjoyable
Content:
Language: None
Sexual Content: None
Violence: Moderate- A characters older brother’s crime(that landed him in jail) is talked about quite a bit, wrapping a boy who snitched on him in barbed wire. And the younger brother thinks about what his “mark” should be.
The story:
Lutie’s special, always has been, it’s just a fact of life. She’s in honor and advance placement classes at school, she’s the star of the school choir, and she has more friends then she could ever count. Now, people want her to share one of the more sacred things that make her special, her families songs. But, Lutie does not think that those songs are a national treasure, she thinks they’re her treasure. She also has a secret, her mother. She does not want anyone to know that her mother was that bum you just passed, the one with the dirty sweaters and missing teeth. The one you look the other way so you never have to look her in the eye.
Doria is new to town. She hides herself behind a piano at school, an organ at church, and a smile at home. She does not fit in and does not think she ever will. But, maybe if she helps the people around her, they’ll accept her. Or, maybe she just has to learn to speak up.
My thoughts:
This book is told from the perspective of 6 different teenagers, all with very different lives. Lutie is the main character and the book focuses on her story, her songs. But, the others all have individual stories that contribute perfectly to the big picture.
The Lost Song’s is full of music, as you may guess, and I loved that. The story of Lutie’s great-great-great grandmother singing her soul out to God while she worked is a beautiful one.
This is a story of finding yourself, sharing what makes you special, and discovering each other; and it’s a beautiful journey.
I had a hard time getting into it, right at first. But, after I hit about 50 pages the book really took off! All the different characters kept it interesting and full of life. The writing was not incredible, but, it told the story well.
The character that I identified most with was Doria. I think because of the amount of characters everybody could find someone who is like them, and that always makes a book more enjoyable
Content:
Language: None
Sexual Content: None
Violence: Moderate- A characters older brother’s crime(that landed him in jail) is talked about quite a bit, wrapping a boy who snitched on him in barbed wire. And the younger brother thinks about what his “mark” should be.
February 3, 2012
You can read this review and others at www.thesepaperwings.blogspot.com
My favorite character in this book had to be Doria. She was struggling with moving to a new place, and meeting new people. She had so much to offer, yet she felt as if she just couldn’t show that to people. I really identified with this character right from the beginning. After moving to a totally new state myself, I knew exactly how she felt. She was shy, didn’t quite know how to make friends, and the friends she had before she moved seemed to be drifting farther and farther away every day consumed, of course, with their own lives.
On the other hand, I really didn’t care much for Lutie in the beginning, especially her attitude towards Doria. At some points in the book it just seems like she’s almost disgusted by Doria, just because she’s a little socially awkward. She even describes being friends with Doria as being the same as adopting a stray dog. Lutie is still growing as a person though, and by the end of the book it seems like she is closer to being on the right track.
What really made me want to read this book was the religious theme in it. I was curious about how God would be represented, and what the overall message would end up being. While I didn’t quite agree with everything that was said in respect to this, I did love the end. To me it seemed like the whole story ended up being about forgiveness. Lutie forgiving her mom, friends forgiving friends who got a little lost, and God forgiving people in general for getting a little lost at times as well.
The Lost Songs also seemed to be about caring for others, despite their flaws, which I suppose kind of goes hand-in-hand with the forgiveness aspect (after all, how can you look past a person’s flaws without being able to forgive those flaws?). I don’t want to give too much away, but the end really sums it up quite nicely.
All in all, I really enjoyed this book, despite the fact that I’m usually into books with more of a fantasy element in them. I loved the message and I’m glad I gave this book a try! I would certainly recommend this book!
My favorite character in this book had to be Doria. She was struggling with moving to a new place, and meeting new people. She had so much to offer, yet she felt as if she just couldn’t show that to people. I really identified with this character right from the beginning. After moving to a totally new state myself, I knew exactly how she felt. She was shy, didn’t quite know how to make friends, and the friends she had before she moved seemed to be drifting farther and farther away every day consumed, of course, with their own lives.
On the other hand, I really didn’t care much for Lutie in the beginning, especially her attitude towards Doria. At some points in the book it just seems like she’s almost disgusted by Doria, just because she’s a little socially awkward. She even describes being friends with Doria as being the same as adopting a stray dog. Lutie is still growing as a person though, and by the end of the book it seems like she is closer to being on the right track.
What really made me want to read this book was the religious theme in it. I was curious about how God would be represented, and what the overall message would end up being. While I didn’t quite agree with everything that was said in respect to this, I did love the end. To me it seemed like the whole story ended up being about forgiveness. Lutie forgiving her mom, friends forgiving friends who got a little lost, and God forgiving people in general for getting a little lost at times as well.
The Lost Songs also seemed to be about caring for others, despite their flaws, which I suppose kind of goes hand-in-hand with the forgiveness aspect (after all, how can you look past a person’s flaws without being able to forgive those flaws?). I don’t want to give too much away, but the end really sums it up quite nicely.
All in all, I really enjoyed this book, despite the fact that I’m usually into books with more of a fantasy element in them. I loved the message and I’m glad I gave this book a try! I would certainly recommend this book!
December 4, 2014
The depth of each character was so deep, the average person could drown in the shallow end of that pool. It's growing up and staying young and finding your true self. Train's true self had a name, Cliff; and although it took awhile, Cliff remembered how to swim again and he managed to save himself from drowning. He believed in fear more than hope or love; he hid himself behind a firewall and did things to impress his older brother, to get attention. And isn't that what everyone wants? Just to be noticed? Cliff Greene may have gone about it the wrong way, but it shows how easily people can turn on you when they're afraid. Luttie and Kelvin may not have given a second thought about letting go and swimming away together, but in the end they realized it, and they wrung theirs souls out clean to their lord. Doria believed in Cliff from almost the start; she believed that he was a nice person and that he could be normal, and she did contribute to pulling him back up. She was always alone, even when she wasn't; when she was with Luttie, often Luttie hated her but never came out and said it. In that way, Doria was unknowingly alone.
When Miss Kendra said flirting and Luttie agreed, so did I, I agreed. Cliff loves Doria, there's no questioning it. Personally? I do ship them off together; Pierce is nice but not nearly as deep. Simply comedic.
This book was beautiful, because in addition to all of the above, I loved how God was viewed to them. The fact that he was a sinner as well, and that you CAN look at the person you're talking to in prayer. That maybe churches can be bubblegum pink and have lady pastors with a voice that carries unto heaven. That maybe things aren't set in stone, and as they wear away, new ideas can finally begin to come through.
When Miss Kendra said flirting and Luttie agreed, so did I, I agreed. Cliff loves Doria, there's no questioning it. Personally? I do ship them off together; Pierce is nice but not nearly as deep. Simply comedic.
This book was beautiful, because in addition to all of the above, I loved how God was viewed to them. The fact that he was a sinner as well, and that you CAN look at the person you're talking to in prayer. That maybe churches can be bubblegum pink and have lady pastors with a voice that carries unto heaven. That maybe things aren't set in stone, and as they wear away, new ideas can finally begin to come through.
August 6, 2015
I kept seeing this book on the shelves of my local library and something about the cover always spoke out to me. After one frustrating day of having everything on my list already checked out, I picked it up and gave it a try. I'll admit it took me a while to get into it, and even when I did it certainly wasn't a gripping-to-every-word-can't-turn-the-page-fast-enough-never-want-to-put-it-down read. Slowly it's rural southern charm grew on me. At first the switching of characters annoyed me. These kids had nothing to do with eachother! Why do I care about a lonely organist's crush on some dumb boy? As I kept reading though, each chapter something clicked into place. Everyone became connected one way or the other which strengthened the author's message of community. By the last few chapters I was tearing up. Even though I saw Saravette's death coming, I cried along with everyone at the funeral. The imagery of Train standing in front of everyone who'd lost hope in him was incredibly moving. I don't consider myself religious, I was as a child but when my family moved states and stopped going to church I strayed. Not for any particular reason and although I don't see myself committing to going back, stories like these always warm my heart and remind me to keep putting love out into the world so it can find it's way back to me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 11, 2011
I always look forward to a new novel by Caroline B. Cooney. The Lost Songs is set in the South in a down and out African American community. Lutie Painter has an amazing singing voice and acts as the guardian of a series of songs/hymns created by her great grandmother. The "Laundry List" of songs passed down through the generations through oral tradition, have come to the attention of a musicologist who tries to convince Lutie to share them with the world. Church organist, Doria, a new girl in school, who has moved down from the North, is fascinated by the songs too. Slowly, the two girls form a friendship, while Lutie deals with other troubling family issues. Although this novel wasn't one of my favorites by Cooney, I particularly enjoyed the scenes in which Doria plays the organ.
December 21, 2011
I've read a LOT of good books this month. I loved this one, too, although it's not much of a surprise for a Caroline B. Cooney book.
I thought that the characterization in this book was wonderful. The motivations of the characters were very realistic and well thought-through. As a Yankee, I thought the Northern/Southern culture differences were well done (I have no clue what a Southerner would think!)
It wasn't my favorite recent Cooney book (Three Black Swans was), but it was really good. And, as usual, it mystified me how it was published in the secular market, because there was SO MUCH Christianity in it. It was actually quite convicting in places. And YA lit isn't usually where I think to go for a Holy Spirit conscience check...
Definitely a must-read if you like Cooney's later work at all.
I thought that the characterization in this book was wonderful. The motivations of the characters were very realistic and well thought-through. As a Yankee, I thought the Northern/Southern culture differences were well done (I have no clue what a Southerner would think!)
It wasn't my favorite recent Cooney book (Three Black Swans was), but it was really good. And, as usual, it mystified me how it was published in the secular market, because there was SO MUCH Christianity in it. It was actually quite convicting in places. And YA lit isn't usually where I think to go for a Holy Spirit conscience check...
Definitely a must-read if you like Cooney's later work at all.
December 27, 2011
This book is very different from Cooney's other books, no suspense, no mystery, yet a book filled with connections and interwoven stories. The story is very much the way life works. Perhaps because I read it in December the message of love, faith, and forgiveness seemed heightened.
I am always intrigued by stories about music so searching for the lost songs was something I wanted to know about. I make up songs about my ordinary life, sing them outloud, sometimes to the embarassment of my own daughter. Music recalls memories to me, helps me control my emotions, especially when I have to deal with technology, and reminds me that a different life exists if I step out of my surroundings.
This book is currently in Colorado being read by a young friend of mine. I can't wait to hear if she liked it as much as I did.
I am always intrigued by stories about music so searching for the lost songs was something I wanted to know about. I make up songs about my ordinary life, sing them outloud, sometimes to the embarassment of my own daughter. Music recalls memories to me, helps me control my emotions, especially when I have to deal with technology, and reminds me that a different life exists if I step out of my surroundings.
This book is currently in Colorado being read by a young friend of mine. I can't wait to hear if she liked it as much as I did.
April 8, 2013
Caroline Cooney is a solid writer. I had to stick with this a bit but it was well worth it. A book with hope, and heart. It's obvious Cooney knows her stuff when describing music, especially organ music, and that's not a very broad niche. I felt her authentic voice when she talked about the feelings those sweeping pieces would bring out in her character, Doria, who was an incredible musician. The voice was not as authentic when she described Lutie, our African-American singer, but the descriptions were poetic. At risk kids, the cultural differences between rich and poor, Yankee and Southerner permeated this story. I think kids with music in their souls would like this book, but it will be a tough sell unless they have that connection. (much like Notes from an Accidental Band Geek)
Well worth it for those kids with an interest.
Well worth it for those kids with an interest.
October 24, 2013
Caroline B. Cooney has written a heartfelt book about how families change. Lutie Painter is a high school student whose mother is a drug addict and is not really a part of her life. Lutie lives with her grandmother until her she fell off her porch and died. Her favorite class is choir, until the choir teacher brings in someone to quiz Lutie about her family's "lost songs." These were passed down from generation to generation.....songs from the days of slaves that have great historical and possibly monetary value. Lutie doesn't want to share them, she believes that the belong to her. Lutie's pastor thinks she should and donate the money to her church. Lutie isn't sure what to do. With the pressures of school, her friends, and so called friends,Lutie has some grown up decisions to make.
I liked the book. It was interesting.
I liked the book. It was interesting.
September 16, 2015
In this haunting and lyrical novel Caroline B. Cooney weaves together the stories of four teenagers whose paths cross in a small South Carolina town. Lutie Painter is struggling to come to terms with a terrible knowledge about her mother. Doria Bell just wants someone—anyone—to see her as more than the accompanist on the bench. Kelvin Hartley is happy to enjoy everything and work at nothing. And Traine Greene is on fire, just waiting for the chance to truly burn.
The book grabs you from the beginning as you yearn to know more about each character and become invested in their decisions. The unique voice of each character and Cooney's vivid portrayal of a Southern town where troubles simmer just under the sleepy exterior brings the story to life. A bit of a different approach for Cooney, but one that pays off.
The book grabs you from the beginning as you yearn to know more about each character and become invested in their decisions. The unique voice of each character and Cooney's vivid portrayal of a Southern town where troubles simmer just under the sleepy exterior brings the story to life. A bit of a different approach for Cooney, but one that pays off.
January 27, 2012
The Lost Songs is a beautifully written story about the South and its musical roots. Lutie is the unofficial "owner" of a set of gospel songs sung by her great-great grandmother Mabel years ago as Mabel struggled with her relationship with God while she worked to make a life for her family when her status was barely above that of a slave. A museum curator in the present day has heard of this Laundry List, and traced it to Lutie, who must decide whether to share the songs with the world so that they can take their rightful place in the history of gospel music, or whether she should guard them as her own, which she feels is her obligation to her family. Book clubs might enjoy a discussion about ... (see full review here: http://www.storysnoops.com/detail.php...)
November 25, 2015
This is a book I would definitely pick up again. The Lost Songs follows 4 totally different teens with only 1 thing in common. Music. Cooney does switch narrators between them so the reader can get their different perspectives. I found this worked well for this story. Being inside of each teen's head brings the stories together fluidly and allows the story to complete well by the ending. I did like the characters. Cooney gave just enough background of each to give the characters a little fuller depth to what each was struggling with as a teen. The one thing that I thought wasn't quite right was the character, Lutie, having 2 different residents and choosing daily between which aunt to stay with. Over all, though, I did enjoy the book and would recommend it.
July 18, 2012
I wanted so much more than this book could give. I was drawn in because I love books/movies where you see an unexpected intertwining of lives through the stories that are told; though the cover promised this exact plot line, it didn't deliver. There was never enough character development and when the book ended there was only a sense of incompleteness. The concept could have been wonderful and I was surprised from such a well known author that this book just didn't deliver. I'm giving this three stars simply for the aspects that I did like including the idea of the lost songs and the change in Train by the end of the book, but this is not one that I would recommend.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews