This book caught me by surprise. Sometimes a book cover catches my eye; sometimes it’s a blurb or another review. With First Earth, the premise of the young protagonist’s story lured me in to “Look Inside” and read the first few pages. I was hooked right away. Fortunately, I received a full digital copy in exchange for an honest review.
When I told my wife (an elementary school teacher) what I was reading, she too was intrigued. Soon we were reading aloud together. We couldn’t wait for each opportunity to read more.
At the risk of overstatement, I would not be surprised if this series becomes a classic for young readers and cherished bedtime reading for parents and grandparents…assuming it finds its way to enough readers. It’s that good.
First Earth is one of those classic teen/YA fantasy tales with a timeless appeal for adult fantasy lovers too. I found it an entirely enjoyable adventure, very well written with smooth pacing from start to finish. There were times when I smiled at scenes that reminded me of my favorite portal fantasy/alternate reality classics like Alice in Wonderland and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. The diverse and intriguing cast of characters provides an excellent complement for the young protagonist, Agnes, and the enemy that she and her companions battle is complex, dark, and more difficult to defeat than a wicked witch.
First Earth is not the first fantasy novel to include a protagonist who lives with a disability. But what appeals to me about Agnes’ story is that her disability is rooted in a tragic childhood accident. As a result, she has struggled with emotional scars and—especially as a teen—with the ostracism of peers that sometimes comes with physical scars. Her perception of others and herself, her reactions, responses, and dialogue are consistent and believable (not always easy for an adult author to pull off). The degree of healing that Agnes experiences as she learns to accept her natural and magical gifts as well as her disabilities, and the marginal transformation in her self esteem are also believable and wonderfully inspiring.
Agnes is the hero of the story but she’s no superhero. She’s a real-life, down-to-second-earth sixteen-year-old who is instantly likable. Her struggles and victories kept me cheering for her to the end. Thankfully, her story isn’t over. I’m recommending this book whenever I can and am looking forward to reading more in the series as Agnes’ adventures throughout the Jent Paths continue. I’m just not sure if I’ll be able to wait and read aloud with my wife.