The most stupid thing any woman could do to mess up her life is read this book!
Unless you are a teenage virgin perhaps... but, even then, it doesn't prepare you for navigating the real world for long.
Yes, taking responsibility for your own actions is crucial. Lots of women don't do this. They annoy me too. However, it is pointless to expect life to run smoothly because you've followed the advice in this book.
There are not 'good men' and 'bad men'. It is not that simple. There are men with good intentions and men with bad intentions. Even men with good intentions can go awry. Intentions change. A marriage is a commitment decades long and people's intentions, needs and ability to manage vary over time.
What worries me is the effect of her words on women with life experience. It is too easy to take what Dr S says and beat yourself up for 'choosing a bad man' when actually you chose a man for all the right reasons, who appeared to want just what you did, had no obvious issues, but events down the line meant it didn't work out.
E.g.
Should we be telling the battered wife, whose husband was great for years, until he lost his job and started drinking and getting angry, that this was her fault?
Er, no. His reactions are his reactions and only he can be held responsible for them. Women are no more blessed with being able to predict the future than anyone else and should not be made to feel responsible for someone else's bad behaviour. This woman did not choose a 'bad man'. She chose a man who did not cope with what the future dealt him.
Should we be telling the single mum, battling on with three kids, that she is to blame for their father, her partner - who, let's say, was very commited for years but understandably wouldn't marry because he'd suffered his own mother's abandonment and his parents' brutal subsequent divorce as a child - moving out because he'd found someone else?
Nope. Again, women are not witches with crystal balls who can predict a man's actions and reactions through the years. This single mum should be supported and applauded. If she decides to give up on her kids too, the government will have a hefty annual care bill of £100,000+ to pay and her children will be scarred for life.
And just how is she to consider marriage/commitment with someone else following Dr Schlessinger's advice here? Hmm. Probably she'll be too caught up trying to find a way to forgive herself for choosing a 'bad man' by not insisting he marry her despite his obvious intention to stay in the relationship long term and do the best by his children, even in the worst case scenario he could imagine? Imagine the stress of trying to choose a new man, when she feels she chose a 'bad' one before?
Short sighted Dr S.
Do we all want marriage anyway? After reading this book and thinking over the marriages I have known, marriage is not always desirable. Like reading a book, marriage requires a suspension of disbelief: "it is all going to go well and this is going to be a success..." In reality, we can NEVER know this though. Life throws us into unforseen situations and events unfold around us that make people do things we never imagined they would.
Yes, take responsibility for YOUR own actions in a marriage. But remember that your other half is a seperate being who must also take responsibility for theirs. And you cannot predict what they'll do....
If you are Christian, think of it this way: God is supposed to judge us at the end of our lives (heaven/hell) by which time we have been tested in lots of ways to show how we will react. If God can only make the decision who is good/bad at this point, how can a woman decide if someone is good or bad before they've had a life to observe? Crazy.
As for this book -
Take it from me (a very well educated and independent woman - yet still a divorcee??) this is condescending drivel from an obliviously entitled and well-supported woman who does not live in the real world. Read it at your peril.