What do you think?
Rate this book
An Elizabeth Parker Mystery #3
Murder Most Persuasive
After the death of Elizabeth Parker’s great-uncle Martin Reynolds, the family’s house in the picturesque Maryland town of St. Michaels is sold. When the new owners dig up the pool, they find the body of the man thought to have run off eight years earlier after embezzling over a million dollars from the family business.
This grisly discovery not only unearths old questions about what really happened to the stolen money, but it brings Detective Joe Muldoon back into the family’s lives. Eight years ago Elizabeth’s cousin Ann reluctantly broke off her relationship with Joe due to family pressure. Ann always regretted that decision and now fears that it is too late for her and Joe–especially after she becomes the main suspect.
In this clever and entertaining mystery, rich with echoes of Jane Austen’s Persuasion, Elizabeth tries to match wits against a killer who’s had an eight-year head start as she also tries her hand at matchmaking. Mystery lovers are in for a treat.
This grisly discovery not only unearths old questions about what really happened to the stolen money, but it brings Detective Joe Muldoon back into the family’s lives. Eight years ago Elizabeth’s cousin Ann reluctantly broke off her relationship with Joe due to family pressure. Ann always regretted that decision and now fears that it is too late for her and Joe–especially after she becomes the main suspect.
In this clever and entertaining mystery, rich with echoes of Jane Austen’s Persuasion, Elizabeth tries to match wits against a killer who’s had an eight-year head start as she also tries her hand at matchmaking. Mystery lovers are in for a treat.
304 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2011
18 people are currently reading
430 people want to read
About the author
Tracy Kiely
11 books156 followersTracy Kiely graduated from Trinity College in 1990 with a degree in English. Tracy's first novel, Murder at Longbourn, is a mystery set in Cape Cod, and combines her love of the classic English country house murder and Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. She currently lives in Maryland with her husband, Matt, and their three children.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews
September 17, 2011
It seems like Elizabeth Parker, my favorite Austen-Inspired sleuth, has once again stumbled upon a murder mystery! Just days after Uncle Marty's death, someone unearthed a surprising family skeleton – literally! It looks like the new homeowners of Uncle Marty's house in St. Michaels found the body of ex-fiancée and ex-employee Michael Barrow buried under their in-ground pool. The last time the Reynolds family saw Michael Barrow was eight years ago, just before he ended his engagement with cousin Reggie and embezzled over a million dollars from the family business.
Poor Ann Reynolds, Elizabeth's cousin, is emotionally and physically exhausted by all the events that have proceeded her father's death. With two sisters who are narcissistic and irresponsible and a step-mother who has immediately absconded to a spa retreat, Ann is left with the responsibility of sorting through her father's belongings, cataloging items in her father's will, and planning a ridiculous memorial party that her step-mother insists on throwing. Add to that a murder investigation that names her as the prime suspect! Can it get any worse?!
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
Poor Ann Reynolds, Elizabeth's cousin, is emotionally and physically exhausted by all the events that have proceeded her father's death. With two sisters who are narcissistic and irresponsible and a step-mother who has immediately absconded to a spa retreat, Ann is left with the responsibility of sorting through her father's belongings, cataloging items in her father's will, and planning a ridiculous memorial party that her step-mother insists on throwing. Add to that a murder investigation that names her as the prime suspect! Can it get any worse?!
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
May 14, 2018
Delightful cozy mystery - well crafted, leaving one guessing until the last chapter. Laugh out loud sentences pepper the plot of this entertaining whodunit.
January 25, 2013
I loved the first of these books, don't think I liked the second much as I didn't write a review or give it any stars, but did mark it as "read" which is my MO when I don't want to give a book a high rating, but also don't want to diss it.
However, I really enjoyed this one. I thought, as I have before, that the dialogue is a bit stilted, but this might be Kiely going for a more formal Austen air, I'm not sure.
This one was funnier than I remember the others being, which I think is what made me like it so much. I will definitely read the next one.
However, I really enjoyed this one. I thought, as I have before, that the dialogue is a bit stilted, but this might be Kiely going for a more formal Austen air, I'm not sure.
This one was funnier than I remember the others being, which I think is what made me like it so much. I will definitely read the next one.
February 7, 2017
Book 3 in this fun Austen-infused modern series was another exciting murder mystery solved by our engaging heroine Elizabeth. The story line had some interesting homages back to Jane Austen's "Persuasion," of course with additional quotes from most of Jane Austen's books. It was a cute story that gave us a fresh twist on something so familiar and beloved. Now this isn't Jane Austen, who would probably cringe at some of the vulgarity within. What it is and can claim to be is intriguing fan fiction from the pen of one who obviously is a fellow Janeite.
August 1, 2011
I won this book on a goodreads giveaway and I am really glad that I did. I really enjoyed reading this book. When I read a murder mystery I like to see if I can predict what can happen next. I was surprised at the ending. I will be keeping an eye out for any other books by Tracy Kiely.
October 13, 2011
This was a compelling "chick-flick" mystery that kept me moving through its pages wanting to know what came next. The multi-generational characters kept the story lively and the reader guessing. I am anxious to read more of Tracy Kiely's work.
September 25, 2011
I just could not find any interest in this mystery.
August 19, 2019
I really enjoy this series, and this book was just as fun as the first two!
As Pride and Prejudice is my favourite book, the fact that main character Elizabeth is a Jane Austen super-fan is a fun feature. Every chapter starts with a quote from an Austen book that is a fit for the events in the chapter, and Elizabeth and Aunt Winnie are constantly quoting Austen to one another about the events going on. It's silly and fun, and for an Austen fan it adds to the enjoyment of the story.
Elizabeth is a determined sleuth, to the dismay of her boyfriend and the disgust of her irritating sister, Kit, but she is spunky and clever, and, like it or not she does eventually turn out to be right, so it's hard to argue with success.
The cast of nutty characters is just plain fun. The people in Elizabeth's world could easily slide into any Agatha Christie story. There is plenty of misdirection and red herrings, but for those who like to try to figure things out before the reveal, I think there are enough clues.
This is just a really fun, entertaining light read, as are all the books in this series. There is a lot of sarcastic humour in these books, and that is a big plus for me. I laugh out loud a lot reading these books which makes them extra enjoyable.
As Pride and Prejudice is my favourite book, the fact that main character Elizabeth is a Jane Austen super-fan is a fun feature. Every chapter starts with a quote from an Austen book that is a fit for the events in the chapter, and Elizabeth and Aunt Winnie are constantly quoting Austen to one another about the events going on. It's silly and fun, and for an Austen fan it adds to the enjoyment of the story.
Elizabeth is a determined sleuth, to the dismay of her boyfriend and the disgust of her irritating sister, Kit, but she is spunky and clever, and, like it or not she does eventually turn out to be right, so it's hard to argue with success.
The cast of nutty characters is just plain fun. The people in Elizabeth's world could easily slide into any Agatha Christie story. There is plenty of misdirection and red herrings, but for those who like to try to figure things out before the reveal, I think there are enough clues.
This is just a really fun, entertaining light read, as are all the books in this series. There is a lot of sarcastic humour in these books, and that is a big plus for me. I laugh out loud a lot reading these books which makes them extra enjoyable.
August 26, 2020
"Elizabeth Parker has been warned to stop playing detective, but when her cousin Ann becomes a murder suspect, Elizabeth sets out to find the real killer. The victim is Michael Barrow, a man who supposedly stole nearly one million dollars from the family business and disappeared eight years ago. Now everyone has a motive, from Ann's unhappy stepmother to her glamorous sister -- who was Michael's fiancee. But Ann was the last person to see Michael alive, and the investigating detective seems determined to prove Ann guilty, even though he and Ann were once in love.
"As Elizabeth works to clear Ann's name, she unearths even more family dirt. Soon another killing brings her closer to the truth ... and the missing money. But the clever culprit who once got away with murder isn't about to let anything -- or anyone -- stop him now."
~~back cover
The first 5/6ths of this book was just filler -- repeats of previous scenes and conversations, bringing no new clues or information. All the action happened in the last 1/6th of the book, so the first part was boring and the second part was hanging onto your seat. Not the best pacing, as far as I'm concerned.
"As Elizabeth works to clear Ann's name, she unearths even more family dirt. Soon another killing brings her closer to the truth ... and the missing money. But the clever culprit who once got away with murder isn't about to let anything -- or anyone -- stop him now."
~~back cover
The first 5/6ths of this book was just filler -- repeats of previous scenes and conversations, bringing no new clues or information. All the action happened in the last 1/6th of the book, so the first part was boring and the second part was hanging onto your seat. Not the best pacing, as far as I'm concerned.
October 26, 2021
The first book in this series I didn’t really like that much. I felt the main character, Elizabeth was ridiculously whiny and irritating. I already had the second book in the series and didn’t dislike the first enough to give up. Good thing because I really enjoyed that one. So much so that I ordered the remaining two. That leads me to this one which, for me, is somewhere in between the first two. I liked it but some of the characters were so annoying I eventually wound up skimming the parts where they spoke. The sister Kit is unbelievably irritating and yet everyone just ignores her instead of giving her a good hand slap or maybe just a telling off since she is pregnant in this book. Still, you get the point. Some of the other characters are equally irritating that it’s almost unbearable. But then a few funny quips from the main character helps to lighten the mood. That said, I did really like the book. It’s well written and funny. Worth a read and looking forward to the 4th and last installment.
May 14, 2020
So I am (quite accidentally) reading this series backwards. Whoops.
But I don't think that's actively detracting from this story, or it's major arcs. It's a cozy series, ticking along in a cozy sort of way.
I was interested to read this one, as I am quite fond of Persuasion by Austen, but while this started out with interesting parallels, it sort abandons them part way though. When those parallels are dropped, then it becomes a fairly basic mystery.
I found that there were rather too many characters, and not enough character development. There wasn't quite the time or depth given to the cast to make you really feel anything about them, beyond a basic background buzz. Here are the characters. You will be told what they are like and what to feel about them. You will not particularlly care who dies, who finds love, and who was a red herring all along.
But it does it's job well enough, a modestly diverting read, which was easy to read, even if I did accidentally spill tea on it.
But I don't think that's actively detracting from this story, or it's major arcs. It's a cozy series, ticking along in a cozy sort of way.
I was interested to read this one, as I am quite fond of Persuasion by Austen, but while this started out with interesting parallels, it sort abandons them part way though. When those parallels are dropped, then it becomes a fairly basic mystery.
I found that there were rather too many characters, and not enough character development. There wasn't quite the time or depth given to the cast to make you really feel anything about them, beyond a basic background buzz. Here are the characters. You will be told what they are like and what to feel about them. You will not particularlly care who dies, who finds love, and who was a red herring all along.
But it does it's job well enough, a modestly diverting read, which was easy to read, even if I did accidentally spill tea on it.
June 23, 2017
Tracy Kiley writes a truly entertaining cozy mystery. Figuring prominently: a large cast of characters ie, suspects, a surprise ending, background romance, likable sleauth. All are critical elements in the cozy mystery, and Kiley has them down pat! In Murder Most Persuasive, Elizabeth Parker is once again up to the eyeballs in a murder involving friends and loved ones. Turns out the cement at the bottom of Uncle Martin's pool has been a tomb for quite some time - not that anyone is shedding tears over the embezzler who wound up there. The mystery heats up when the cops turn the spotlight on Elizabeth's cousin - a Elizabeth goes to work again.
These are light-hearted mysteries, but so much fun. Enjoying this series a lot!
These are light-hearted mysteries, but so much fun. Enjoying this series a lot!
May 1, 2023
After reading the first book, I ordered the other three from the library. The only reason I read the third book after the second was so bad was that I had the book at home. This one did little to improve the series:
My main issue with 2 was that the relationship with Peter was poorly handled. I left book 2 convinced that Peter had cheated. Where was Peter in this book? Why is he basically written out? As for romance, I feel they might as well have broken up.
Second, the murder was solvable this time. So great on that, but too easy.
Three, the final set up to catch the killer… what police detective would go for that? There are a million ways to get evidence that don’t involve putting people at risk.
If I didn’t already have book 4, I would not bother.
My main issue with 2 was that the relationship with Peter was poorly handled. I left book 2 convinced that Peter had cheated. Where was Peter in this book? Why is he basically written out? As for romance, I feel they might as well have broken up.
Second, the murder was solvable this time. So great on that, but too easy.
Three, the final set up to catch the killer… what police detective would go for that? There are a million ways to get evidence that don’t involve putting people at risk.
If I didn’t already have book 4, I would not bother.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 9, 2018
I struggled with this one. I enjoy the Austen references, but I don't particularly like Elizabeth Parker (the main character). Plus, there were a number of grammatical and editorial problems that made it difficult to read. At one point, Kit's hair was "shinning" and early on Elizabeth said, "You didn't expect him to act any way else, did you?" 2.5 stars
January 28, 2021
This was the kind of book I stay up till 2:00 o'clock in the morning to finish! For Jane Austen's fans, each chapter has a quote from one of her books as the main character, Elizabeth, is a Jane Austen-ite and Anglophile, as is the author. You will also spot qualities of some of Jane's characters throughout the book. Murder Most Enjoyable!
August 2, 2017
Aside from the fact that the profanity increases throughout, this is an excellent retelling of Persuasion bound up in a mystery. The characters are believable, and Elizabeth's choices make sense.
September 19, 2017
Extremely enjoyable series. Lots of great snappy dialogue and humor.
February 4, 2023
A sweet, if slightly corny, cozy mystery. Easy to read, funny narrator voice, I'd pick up another!
August 29, 2024
I love this book, the characters and story line were great.
September 5, 2011
Murder Most Persuasive is Tracy Kiely's 3rd mystery based on loosely on Jane Austen's novels. One can readily guess the influence from the title. Elizabeth Parker makes her third appearance as a sleuth. Much like Miss Marple she finds herself at the right place at the right time. Like Miss Marple, Elizabeth understands that she has a talent for solving mysteries.
In this instance, Elizabeth happens to be gathered for the funeral of great-uncle Martin Reynolds. When Uncle Martie's house in St. Michael's is sold for the benefit of his three daughters, the body of Michael Barrow is discovered buried underneath the swimming pool. Michael, who was to have married Reggie, Martie's eldest daughter, had disappeared the night before the wedding and only days before the pool was built.
Along with Michael went a great deal of Uncle Martie's money, embezzled it was presumed. Now, with the discovery of Michael's body the questions uppermost in everyone's minds are: how did Michael wind up under that slab of cement and what happened to the money?
As with Tracy's other novels, the writing style is light and breezy and the mystery fun to follow. In this instance, the parallel to Persuasion is hard to ignore. Ann, Uncle Marty's middle daughter, broke up with young Joe Muldoon under the influence of her father and her dead mother's dearest friend, an action she still regrets 8 years later. A mousy professor who has lost her looks, she encounters Joe, now a successful man and the detective on the case. Will this star crossed couple come to find love again? Curious minds want to know.
I could describe the plot in more detail, but I don't want to spoil it for you. Of Tracy's three mysteries, this is my favorite so far (as is Persuasion). I enjoyed meeting the characters so much that I quite forgot to follow the clues. Still, even when I tried to solve the mystery, I was pleasantly surprised to find out who had done the dastardly deed.
Tracy writes mysteries in the old style. No gritty reality and base language sully her pretty towns and well-drawn characters. Blood, while mentioned, is not described down to its forensic core. Thus I recommend that you read Tracy's book on a lazy afternoon in a sunny alcove, with a pot of steaming hot tea and some scones and clotted cream, and a cat on your lap and a dog at your feet. I give this delightful tale four out of five Regency tea cups.
In this instance, Elizabeth happens to be gathered for the funeral of great-uncle Martin Reynolds. When Uncle Martie's house in St. Michael's is sold for the benefit of his three daughters, the body of Michael Barrow is discovered buried underneath the swimming pool. Michael, who was to have married Reggie, Martie's eldest daughter, had disappeared the night before the wedding and only days before the pool was built.
Along with Michael went a great deal of Uncle Martie's money, embezzled it was presumed. Now, with the discovery of Michael's body the questions uppermost in everyone's minds are: how did Michael wind up under that slab of cement and what happened to the money?
As with Tracy's other novels, the writing style is light and breezy and the mystery fun to follow. In this instance, the parallel to Persuasion is hard to ignore. Ann, Uncle Marty's middle daughter, broke up with young Joe Muldoon under the influence of her father and her dead mother's dearest friend, an action she still regrets 8 years later. A mousy professor who has lost her looks, she encounters Joe, now a successful man and the detective on the case. Will this star crossed couple come to find love again? Curious minds want to know.
I could describe the plot in more detail, but I don't want to spoil it for you. Of Tracy's three mysteries, this is my favorite so far (as is Persuasion). I enjoyed meeting the characters so much that I quite forgot to follow the clues. Still, even when I tried to solve the mystery, I was pleasantly surprised to find out who had done the dastardly deed.
Tracy writes mysteries in the old style. No gritty reality and base language sully her pretty towns and well-drawn characters. Blood, while mentioned, is not described down to its forensic core. Thus I recommend that you read Tracy's book on a lazy afternoon in a sunny alcove, with a pot of steaming hot tea and some scones and clotted cream, and a cat on your lap and a dog at your feet. I give this delightful tale four out of five Regency tea cups.
September 19, 2011
The Reynolds’ family thinks they have all they can deal with when the patriarch of the family, Martin, dies. But that’s just the beginning of the drama that is about to be unsurfaced. When Martin’s lavish home is sold, the new owners dig up the pool and find the body of a young man who was not only engaged to Martin’s daughter, but disappeared nearly a decade ago after embezzling $1 million from the family company.
Now the drama they thought they had put to rest so long ago is back, but now there’s a murderer on the loose, and eight years later, it’s as serious as the day Michael went missing. And all clues are pointing to someone in the family.
This is the third book in Tracy Kiely’s Elizabeth Parker series. The books take the old literature of Jane Austen and bring them to present day. I didn’t read the first two books, but after reading this one, want to go back. The good thing about this series, Murder Most Persuasive stood well alone. I’m sure if I’d read the other two, a couple of parts would have made more sense, but it wasn’t necessary. But those aren’t the only books I need to read. I am a disgrace to book bloggers everywhere. I have never read Jane Austen. Not a single book! They’re all on my TBR list, I just never get to them. Maybe that’ll be my goal for the winter months. I love reading the classics then spin offs with a today twist.
In Murder Most Persuasive, Kiely did a fantastic job of bringing murder mystery to live with family, love and laughs. Not only does Elizabeth Parker happen to be in the right place at the right time for the third book in a row to solve a murder, she’s also playing matchmaker for her cousin. And she has an awesome cast to help her out. I love books with crazy families and this one definitely has it.
This book definitely reminds me of the Stephanie Plum series, minus the whole Jersey aspect.
I give Murder Most Persuasive 5 bookmarks.
Now the drama they thought they had put to rest so long ago is back, but now there’s a murderer on the loose, and eight years later, it’s as serious as the day Michael went missing. And all clues are pointing to someone in the family.
This is the third book in Tracy Kiely’s Elizabeth Parker series. The books take the old literature of Jane Austen and bring them to present day. I didn’t read the first two books, but after reading this one, want to go back. The good thing about this series, Murder Most Persuasive stood well alone. I’m sure if I’d read the other two, a couple of parts would have made more sense, but it wasn’t necessary. But those aren’t the only books I need to read. I am a disgrace to book bloggers everywhere. I have never read Jane Austen. Not a single book! They’re all on my TBR list, I just never get to them. Maybe that’ll be my goal for the winter months. I love reading the classics then spin offs with a today twist.
In Murder Most Persuasive, Kiely did a fantastic job of bringing murder mystery to live with family, love and laughs. Not only does Elizabeth Parker happen to be in the right place at the right time for the third book in a row to solve a murder, she’s also playing matchmaker for her cousin. And she has an awesome cast to help her out. I love books with crazy families and this one definitely has it.
This book definitely reminds me of the Stephanie Plum series, minus the whole Jersey aspect.
I give Murder Most Persuasive 5 bookmarks.
October 10, 2011
Martin Reynolds sold his vacation home in Maryland shortly before he died, with the proceeds to be divided between his three children. When the new owners begin renovations, they find a body buried underneath the pool, which turns out have been the former fiancé of Martin's daughter Reggie. Michael Barrow had disappeared the day after Reggie broke off their engagement, along with a million dollars from the Reynold's family business, where he worked. It was assumed that he'd absconded with the money upon realizing that he'd no longer have a job.
The book is written from the point of view of Elizabeth Parker, Martin's niece. Elizabeth is very, very fond of Jane Austen. She and her Aunt Winnie (Martin's sister) are given to inserting quotes from the Austen oeuvre into their daily conversation. Elizabeth also has a reputation in the family as a detective, having "assisted" the police on two earlier murder investigations involving the family.
The detective assigned to the case is Joe Muldoon, who happened to be involved with Martin's other daughter Ann, years earlier. Their relationship was quashed by Ann's aunt Laura, who thought that Joe wasn't good enough for her niece.
This nod to Austen's Persuasion, which one might expect to be awkward or heavy-handed, is actually quite seamless and slips into the plot quite comfortably. Also, the idea of a young woman being discouraged from marrying a man she loves because of his "prospects" is not at all far-fetched in conjunction with a high-society family from the East Coast.
Like Austen, Kiely is snarkily funny. Her Elizabeth is underemployed and has little on which to use her intellect and wit, and so interferes in police investigations and mocks whenever she can. This reviewer will definitely be searching for the previous titles in this series!
*Many thanks to Library Thing's Early Reviewers program for the Advance Reading Copy.
The book is written from the point of view of Elizabeth Parker, Martin's niece. Elizabeth is very, very fond of Jane Austen. She and her Aunt Winnie (Martin's sister) are given to inserting quotes from the Austen oeuvre into their daily conversation. Elizabeth also has a reputation in the family as a detective, having "assisted" the police on two earlier murder investigations involving the family.
The detective assigned to the case is Joe Muldoon, who happened to be involved with Martin's other daughter Ann, years earlier. Their relationship was quashed by Ann's aunt Laura, who thought that Joe wasn't good enough for her niece.
This nod to Austen's Persuasion, which one might expect to be awkward or heavy-handed, is actually quite seamless and slips into the plot quite comfortably. Also, the idea of a young woman being discouraged from marrying a man she loves because of his "prospects" is not at all far-fetched in conjunction with a high-society family from the East Coast.
Like Austen, Kiely is snarkily funny. Her Elizabeth is underemployed and has little on which to use her intellect and wit, and so interferes in police investigations and mocks whenever she can. This reviewer will definitely be searching for the previous titles in this series!
*Many thanks to Library Thing's Early Reviewers program for the Advance Reading Copy.
October 13, 2011
Martin Reynolds sold his vacation home in Maryland shortly before he died, with the proceeds to be divided between his three children. When the new owners begin renovations, they find a body buried underneath the pool, which turns out have been the former fiancé of Martin's daughter Reggie. Michael Barrow had disappeared the day after Reggie broke off their engagement, along with a million dollars from the Reynold's family business, where he worked. It was assumed that he'd absconded with the money upon realizing that he'd no longer have a job.
The book is written from the point of view of Elizabeth Parker, Martin's niece. Elizabeth is very, very fond of Jane Austen. She and her Aunt Winnie (Martin's sister) are given to inserting quotes from the Austen oeuvre into their daily conversation. Elizabeth also has a reputation in the family as a detective, having "assisted" the police on two earlier murder investigations involving the family.
The detective assigned to the case is Joe Muldoon, who happened to be involved with Martin's other daughter Ann, years earlier. Their relationship was quashed by Ann's aunt Laura, who thought that Joe wasn't good enough for her niece.
This nod to Austen's Persuasion, which one might expect to be awkward or heavy-handed, is actually quite seamless and slips into the plot quite comfortably. Also, the idea of a young woman being discouraged from marrying a man she loves because of his "prospects" is not at all far-fetched in conjunction with a high-society family from the East Coast.
Like Austen, Kiely is snarkily funny. Her Elizabeth is underemployed and has little on which to use her intellect and wit, and so interferes in police investigations and mocks whenever she can.
The book is written from the point of view of Elizabeth Parker, Martin's niece. Elizabeth is very, very fond of Jane Austen. She and her Aunt Winnie (Martin's sister) are given to inserting quotes from the Austen oeuvre into their daily conversation. Elizabeth also has a reputation in the family as a detective, having "assisted" the police on two earlier murder investigations involving the family.
The detective assigned to the case is Joe Muldoon, who happened to be involved with Martin's other daughter Ann, years earlier. Their relationship was quashed by Ann's aunt Laura, who thought that Joe wasn't good enough for her niece.
This nod to Austen's Persuasion, which one might expect to be awkward or heavy-handed, is actually quite seamless and slips into the plot quite comfortably. Also, the idea of a young woman being discouraged from marrying a man she loves because of his "prospects" is not at all far-fetched in conjunction with a high-society family from the East Coast.
Like Austen, Kiely is snarkily funny. Her Elizabeth is underemployed and has little on which to use her intellect and wit, and so interferes in police investigations and mocks whenever she can.
May 19, 2012
3.5/5
While browsing through the new releases at my library, I came across this title and immediately wondered if it was a modern Persuasion retelling. After reading the synopsis, I knew it was and as a long-time Austen fan, I thought I would enjoy this so I snatched it up.
And I did mostly enjoy this. Main character Elizabeth Parker has aided in two previous murder investigations (see the previous books in the series) and fancies herself somewhat of an amateur detective, perhaps along the lines of Golden Age detective Adela Bradley. She is also a huge fan of Jane Austen and is always quick with a quip, providing for some of the most entertaining lines of the book. The Persuasion subplot comes in the form of her cousin Ann whose ex is now the police detective investigating the murder that is at the center of this book.
The writing style was easy and I read this book very quickly. There is a good cast of characters with distinct personalities so I never confused anyone with anyone else. Nor was I able to solve the murder with its many pieces. The threads of the mystery were a little confusing although I guess that is partly the point. There are several pieces that seem to be unconnected as the murderer seems to be trying to make them be, to cast suspicion on anyone but him/herself. I do think we could have had a few more clues about whodunnit but maybe other readers thought we were given plenty so that is simply a matter of personal preference.
Overall: I enjoyed my introduction to the world of Elizabeth Parker. I definitely want to check out the first two books as well as the fourth which sounds like it will be set in Bath at the Jane Austen Festival!
While browsing through the new releases at my library, I came across this title and immediately wondered if it was a modern Persuasion retelling. After reading the synopsis, I knew it was and as a long-time Austen fan, I thought I would enjoy this so I snatched it up.
And I did mostly enjoy this. Main character Elizabeth Parker has aided in two previous murder investigations (see the previous books in the series) and fancies herself somewhat of an amateur detective, perhaps along the lines of Golden Age detective Adela Bradley. She is also a huge fan of Jane Austen and is always quick with a quip, providing for some of the most entertaining lines of the book. The Persuasion subplot comes in the form of her cousin Ann whose ex is now the police detective investigating the murder that is at the center of this book.
The writing style was easy and I read this book very quickly. There is a good cast of characters with distinct personalities so I never confused anyone with anyone else. Nor was I able to solve the murder with its many pieces. The threads of the mystery were a little confusing although I guess that is partly the point. There are several pieces that seem to be unconnected as the murderer seems to be trying to make them be, to cast suspicion on anyone but him/herself. I do think we could have had a few more clues about whodunnit but maybe other readers thought we were given plenty so that is simply a matter of personal preference.
Overall: I enjoyed my introduction to the world of Elizabeth Parker. I definitely want to check out the first two books as well as the fourth which sounds like it will be set in Bath at the Jane Austen Festival!
November 15, 2013
This mystery is a take on Persuasion. It's more direct than any of the other mysteries in the series. The family is closely modeled on the Eliots which makes none of them likable except Ann. They're all pretty much direct copies of their original counterparts except that a few characters are combined to create Ann Elliot's cousin William Walter. I liked the way the story paralleled the original but the original is a love story and this is a mystery. The love story takes a back seat so it's not really developed on page. I would have liked a bit more of the relationship between Ann and Joe to echo Ann and Frederick's. The mystery kept me guessing and guessing. I honestly couldn't figure out "whodunnit." The reveal was a surprise because the motive just wasn't realistic. The author tried to hard to match the original plot but it just seems far fetched in today's world. I don't know how Elizabeth figured it out. She seems to have some kind of super memory even though things keep fleeing out of reach. I have an excellent memory and couldn't remember the minute details she did. That too felt unrealistic. The story was similar to Murder of the Bride's Side since it revolves around a family close to Elizabeth and a wicked stepmother. The story kept me reading when I had other things to do with my life. It has a lot of funny moments; I like Elizabeth's snarky sense of humor, however, it lacks the beautiful language and social satire of Jane Austen's original. If you love Persuasion and enjoy a good mystery, you will like this one.
September 5, 2011
I received this book through a Goodreads Giveaway.
If I had not won this book through the giveaway, I would have never heard of it, and I probably wouldn't have picked it up. I do not know the realm of murder mysteries well, but I have read a few Mary Higgins Clark novels, and I have read Jane Austen.
Though not quite the same, this is what I imagine their babies would look like -- their less inspiriting babies, but babies nonetheless. The characters are instantly flawed and likable (some are so unlikable, that you like that about them).
Murder Most Persuasive is the third book in the series, and Elizabeth finds herself in the middle of a murder investigation, again. It works as a standalone novel, because you get enough information about the previous investigations and the characters in order to work.
After the death of Elizabeth's Uncle Marty, a body is found under the foundation of the pool in the house the family just sold. It's a former fiance and ex-employee turned embezzler, and while no one is sad that's he gone, they are all looking rather guilty. Elizabeth takes it upon herself to clear the names of her cousins, and to do a little matchmaking besides, since the detective on the case is an old flame of Ann's -- the prime suspect.
Over all, a good, quick read that is enjoyable.
If I had not won this book through the giveaway, I would have never heard of it, and I probably wouldn't have picked it up. I do not know the realm of murder mysteries well, but I have read a few Mary Higgins Clark novels, and I have read Jane Austen.
Though not quite the same, this is what I imagine their babies would look like -- their less inspiriting babies, but babies nonetheless. The characters are instantly flawed and likable (some are so unlikable, that you like that about them).
Murder Most Persuasive is the third book in the series, and Elizabeth finds herself in the middle of a murder investigation, again. It works as a standalone novel, because you get enough information about the previous investigations and the characters in order to work.
After the death of Elizabeth's Uncle Marty, a body is found under the foundation of the pool in the house the family just sold. It's a former fiance and ex-employee turned embezzler, and while no one is sad that's he gone, they are all looking rather guilty. Elizabeth takes it upon herself to clear the names of her cousins, and to do a little matchmaking besides, since the detective on the case is an old flame of Ann's -- the prime suspect.
Over all, a good, quick read that is enjoyable.
September 15, 2011
Light and fun!
I admit, Persuasion isn't my favorite Jane Austen novel, and listening to it while reading Murder Most Persuasive confirmed that. Still, I'm glad I revisited it, because I would have missed most of the Austen references in this book, and then I would have missed out on much of the fun.
I haven't read any of the previous books in the Elizabeth Parker series, but that didn't present any problems here.
The characters are lively and well-drawn. I suspect there is a little more depth if you watch them from book to book, but I enjoyed them as presented. I particularly enjoyed Elizabeth, as she struggled with a job she didn't love and a sister she loved but didn't always like (with good reason!).
The mystery was reasonably complex and well presented. I figured out the murderer fairly early on, but there really was some luck involved in that guess, and I did have my doubts as the story moved along.
And (as I mentioned above) the Austen references were lots of fun! The book never tries to be a retelling of Persuasion, so there isn't any worry about getting the details wrong. It simply is a story with amusing references and parallels.
Mystery loving Austen fans should check out this series.
I admit, Persuasion isn't my favorite Jane Austen novel, and listening to it while reading Murder Most Persuasive confirmed that. Still, I'm glad I revisited it, because I would have missed most of the Austen references in this book, and then I would have missed out on much of the fun.
I haven't read any of the previous books in the Elizabeth Parker series, but that didn't present any problems here.
The characters are lively and well-drawn. I suspect there is a little more depth if you watch them from book to book, but I enjoyed them as presented. I particularly enjoyed Elizabeth, as she struggled with a job she didn't love and a sister she loved but didn't always like (with good reason!).
The mystery was reasonably complex and well presented. I figured out the murderer fairly early on, but there really was some luck involved in that guess, and I did have my doubts as the story moved along.
And (as I mentioned above) the Austen references were lots of fun! The book never tries to be a retelling of Persuasion, so there isn't any worry about getting the details wrong. It simply is a story with amusing references and parallels.
Mystery loving Austen fans should check out this series.
September 11, 2011
I am a great fan of this series, the plots are always well written and the killer hidden to the near end of the book.
I gave this one four stars as opposed to the five stars I gave the two other books in the series because of characters. This may be entirely personal, but when an annoying character is written into a plot, it does have it's purpose for substance and antagonism, but I think you have to be very careful not to over expose them. That was my problem with this book. The annoying sister was so annoying I just wanted to put the book down and walk away from her and the book. Though the other characters and the plot eventually won me over, I did skip several passages just to avoid this character and her thoughts.
Don't make a stable character so awful that it reminds us of those we have to deal with in everyday life and think,"Oh no! I cannot have this annoyance in my 'escape' book, so I will just move onto something else."
Despite that gripe, I thought it was a fine book. I am glad I stuck with it, and will look forward to reading the next installment. Hopefully the sister character will be on a sabbatical!
August 2, 2011
(This was a goodreads give-away.)
I had some trepidation about the Austen-ness when I first started the book. (It's been my experience that a lot of writers of themed mysteries pretty much use the theme to prop up a 3rd rate story and 2nd rate writing skills.)
There were quite a few Austen references at the beginning--one of the most painful being Aust-Inn-tatious for the name of a planned bed and breakfast. This was at about page 17 so, not being an Austen fan, I was starting to get worried.
Then, like magic, the Austen references thinned out and away we went.
The book was a joy to read--crisp, clever, and funny.
The best way to describe it is a very cozy Evanovich Janet. It's as enjoyable as any of the Evanovich works, but without all the sexual angst and explosions. And as an added bonus--a real mystery to solve!
All in all, a very good read, perfect for when you want something light and fluffy that will make you smile.
I had some trepidation about the Austen-ness when I first started the book. (It's been my experience that a lot of writers of themed mysteries pretty much use the theme to prop up a 3rd rate story and 2nd rate writing skills.)
There were quite a few Austen references at the beginning--one of the most painful being Aust-Inn-tatious for the name of a planned bed and breakfast. This was at about page 17 so, not being an Austen fan, I was starting to get worried.
Then, like magic, the Austen references thinned out and away we went.
The book was a joy to read--crisp, clever, and funny.
The best way to describe it is a very cozy Evanovich Janet. It's as enjoyable as any of the Evanovich works, but without all the sexual angst and explosions. And as an added bonus--a real mystery to solve!
All in all, a very good read, perfect for when you want something light and fluffy that will make you smile.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews