Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Pirates & Faith #1

The Pirate Daughter's Promise

Rate this book
Orphaned at a young age, Skylar McHenry grew up as little more than a servant and shunned by everyone around her because of her reputation as a pirate's daughter. Each day Skye faces is marked by some new struggle. Her only hope is to rely on her heavenly Father's care and comfort and the solace of her best friend, Will, who has become more than dear to her. Just when an unexpected encounter gives Skye a small glimmer of hope that things might change in her favor, her world is shattered. She is awakened in the night by cannon blasts. Pirates storm the orphanage, drag her away, and force her aboard their ship. The cruel captain's intentions are clear. He will extract from her, through any means necessary, the location of the treasure hidden by her father. For Skye to divulge the location would mean breaking the last promise she made to him. She's certain she never will, but what happens when the lives of those dearest to her are at stake? The Pirate Daughter's Promise is full of daring high seas adventure; sweet, wholesome romance; surprising discoveries; unlikely new friends; and the rewards of trusting in God even when life seems impossible.(Young Adult/Christian Fiction)

227 pages, Kindle Edition

First published May 1, 2008

14 people are currently reading
527 people want to read

About the author

Molly Evangeline

11 books127 followers
Molly Evangeline has been using her active imagination to create stories since she was eight years old, encouraged by her mom's own love for writing. For years she wrote as a pastime until age fifteen when she began writing her first historical Christian novel, The Pirate Daughter's Promise, book one of her Pirates & Faith series. Three years later, it became the first of her books to be published.

Molly credits her success to God and her mom's teaching, guidance, and decision to homeschool her from kindergarten through high school. Since graduating she has actively pursued her independent writing career while living with her family in Wisconsin.

Now writes and publishes as Jaye L. Knight

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
63 (32%)
4 stars
59 (30%)
3 stars
46 (23%)
2 stars
18 (9%)
1 star
6 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
Profile Image for Faith.
Author 5 books258 followers
August 23, 2017
You know a book is good when you stay up until after midnight to finish it. Yep. That's what I did with this one! So good, so rich in adventure, action, and sweet romance – it was nearly impossible to put this gem down!
From the very beginning, I was hooked. And I'll go ahead and admit that this one made me cry. (The prologue, chapter 16, chapter 19...oh, yeah. :'( )
Skye, Will and Matthew are great, sweet characters and I just love them all! Kate and John, too, and they made me laugh several times.
Francis Kelley made me shudder. He's SO AWFUL!!! His character (all of them really) is very well written and well developed, I believe. :)
There were several great twists in the story, and I didn't expect any of them! I loved that. :) Then that...discovery? at the ending...wowser! I've still got all the good fangirl-y feels from this book. xD

I enjoyed this book very much! It's definitely a favorite and always will be. ;) I hope to soon read more by this amazingly talented author! :D
Profile Image for Ѽ tazannah Ѽ.
224 reviews299 followers
Want to read
August 3, 2024
A Christian romance pirate book? I NEED IT RN.

I’m a sucker for pirate books, and bonus points if it’s faith filled 🤗

Seems a little similar to “held captive” written by Grace A Johnson! I haven’t read it, but the premise is kinda similar?
Profile Image for Bailey Marissa.
1,181 reviews61 followers
April 15, 2017
Ok, so I don't understand all the complaints on the Amazon reviews. I see the slight Mary Sue tendencies and the odd POV changes, but it was Ms. Evangeline's first book.

Also, it says Young Adult, but it could almost pass as a Middle Grade book.

11/12+ for pirateness and some violence (never graphic).
Profile Image for Sarah Ryder.
1,054 reviews244 followers
Read
August 3, 2024
****DNFed at 33%****

Ummmm…I was bored. 🤷🏼‍♀️🫣

Not to mention it was getting repetitive with what was happening (we get on a boat, we get off a boat, we sail on a boat, we get threatened, we refuse to give information, etc, etc, etc…) and I honestly didn’t care. It has vibes of Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl but without the banter or good pacing.

It’s not bad, but it’s not great either.


‼️Content (up to 33%)‼️

Violence: in the past a man was hung for being a pirate (not shown); cannons are fired on a town; a girl hits men with a chair; fighting with weapons (not detailed)

Other: pirates; a character is kidnapped/tied up/imprisoned; a character is tied to the mast
Profile Image for Jesseca Wheaton.
Author 13 books192 followers
February 3, 2016
While it took me a little while to get into the story, once I actually got into it, it was amazing! I don't read many books about pirates, so it was quite fascinating to read one from a Christian perspective. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I can't wait to read more books be Molly Evangeline!! :)
Profile Image for Sam (The Favorites Shelf).
77 reviews20 followers
June 5, 2025
4 stars

With pirates, treasure hunts, and tropical islands, this book is one of those rare gems with so many of my favorite topics. The adventure quickly drew me in, and its twist ending left me smiling in satisfaction!

I also enjoyed the characters. The FMC Skye, is one of my favorites (I loved her steadfast and loyal personality), but her entire found-family is great too. And the romance is so sweet. Skye and Will are perfect for each other, and the growth of their relationship remains very clean.

The aspect I enjoyed most is the faith content! Characters rely heavily on God for their strength. They study the Bible, share their beliefs with others, and pray in tough situations. It earns the series its title - Pirates and Faith.

Throughout the story, I did notice some writing/grammar errors, but I enjoyed the plot and other aspects enough that my overall enjoyment wasn't affected. Also, I learned this is a debut novel that came out quite a few years ago. I'm definitely planning to read the author's more recent books - including sequels in this series - and I'm excited to see how her style has evolved!

*Content to note* Characters are held captive and treated poorly on pirate ships; some injuries/action scenes/fights occur (high stakes but not graphic).
Profile Image for Kendra Ardnek.
Author 68 books277 followers
February 10, 2017
After reading and reviewing the first two books of Molly’s fantasy trilogy, I offered to read and review her Historical Fiction as well.

The Pirate Daughter’s Promise was Molly’s first book, so I knew that to have the same high expectations I had gleaned from Makilien would be unreasonable. Pirates aren’t my usual forte, but I do enjoy good historical fiction, so I was willing to give it a go.

The prologue was somewhat hard to get into, but I knew to expect that from reading other reviews. Once I got past the prologue, it was a whirlwind of a book that twisted and turned and kept me guessing. I was never able to guess what would happen to Skye – all I knew was that somehow she and Will would somehow come through in the end (and that only from reading the description of the second book). My biggest complaint in that area is that the twists felt, at times, contrived. They were too out of the blue. They made sense after they were explained … but … still …

While reading the book, I couldn’t help but compare Skye to Makilien. On the whole, I think I preferred Skye as a main character and as a person in general. She seemed more human to me – more of a woman. She was already a good fighter at the beginning of the book, but it made sense because she spent her first seven years of her life on the open sea, and the village weapon smith – who is pretty much her only friend beyond Will – helped her keep her skills up. Not only that, her years in the orphanage had softened her. Her name bothered me as out of place for the era, but I got used to it. It suited her.

Normally pirates and faith don’t mix – but it did for this book. The pirates aren’t the good guys. Skye’s father, though he had been a pirate, repented of his crimes. His treasure was amassed of the rewards he had gotten for recapturing and returning what pirates had stolen from others.

However, due to his pirate past, he was arrested and put in prison. Then punished the way all pirates ought to be punished: hanging. Skye was only seven. The last time she saw him he extracted from her a promise to never tell anyone where the treasure is hidden. Until she’s eighteen, the promise is easy. She’s in an orphanage, and there’s no one who wants to know, and even those she is close to would not be able to help her get the treasure. Telling would be pointless, and possibly dangerous.

But then the man that had been her father’s captain during his pirate days appears and kidnaps her. And his goal isn’t exactly a pleasure cruise. He’s got his heart set on that treasure, you see, and she’s the only one who knows where it is hidden.

This is a beautiful story, though it was a tad bit rough around the edges. I recommend it just as highly as I do her Fantasy trilogy. I’m eager to read the rest of the series once I finish with the last book of her trilogy.
Profile Image for Sarah.
Author 46 books459 followers
February 11, 2016
How far would you go to keep a promise? Skyler McHenry is faced with this question in the thrilling high seas adventure by Molly Evangline.

When Molly agreed to do an interview for Homeschool authors, I went to her website to do some research. When I saw that The Pirate Daughter’s Promise was only 99 cents, I decided to buy it. I am so glad I did.

From the gripping opening to the final, touching page, I was enthralled with Skyler's story. Orphaned and with only two friends in the world, Skyler leads a hard life. She keeps a secret her father had made her promise not to reveal until she finds someone who loves her and she trusts completely. A secret concerning a hidden pirate treasure.

I was skeptical when I began this book, as I have never really liked pirate stories. As a lover of history, I had learned too much about pirates to ever think of them as good guys in films or books. I was delightfully surprised at this book. This was not about a “Christian” pirate, nor was piracy shown as acceptable. The good captain and his crew hunt pirates and return the stolen goods.

I loved the faith and morals displayed in The Pirate Daughter’s Promise. Prayer not only is a normal part of life, it works. The romance will stand up to the highest moral standards. This book is very wholesome and refreshing.

If you are looking for a book full of adventure that is faith building, The Pirate Daughter’s Promise is a wonderful choice.
Profile Image for Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls).
2,174 reviews5,139 followers
April 22, 2016
About this book:

“Skylar McHenry knew the love of her parents and a doting grandfather until her sixth year was marked by the tragic loss of her mother. When her father's secret past as a pirate came to light, father and daughter fled to a life at sea. Although Daniel McHenry's life had changed and he now robbed pirates to return the stolen goods to their rightful owners, his ship was captured by authorities, and he was hung for piracy.
Skye grew up in an orphanage, little more than a servant and shunned by everyone around her. Now a young woman, each day Skye faces is marked by some new struggle. Her only hope has been to rely on her heavenly Father's care and comfort, and the solace of her best friend Will, who has become more than dear to her.
Just when an unexpected encounter with her grandfather gives Skye a small glimmer of hope that things might change in her favor, her world is shattered. She is awakened in the night by cannon blasts. Pirates storm the orphanage, drag her away into the night, and force her aboard their ship. The cruel captain's intentions are clear. He will extract from her, through any means necessary, the location of the hidden treasure rewarded to Daniel by those whose belongings he had returned. For Skye to divulge the location would mean breaking the last promise she made to her father. She's certain she never will, but what happens when the lives of those dearest to her are at stake?

The Pirate Daughter's Promise is full of daring high seas adventure; sweet, wholesome romance; surprising discoveries; unlikely new friends; and the rewards of trusting in God even when life seems impossible.”


Series: Book #1 in the “Pirates and Faith” series.


Spiritual Content- Psalm 9:9-10 at the beginning; Many, many, many prayers; Very Strong Faiths; Witnessing; Bible reading; A couple Scriptures are read; Many, many talks about God, His plans & trusting Him; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Many, many mentions of prayers; Many mentions of Bibles, Bible reading & studying the Bible; Many mentions of cross necklaces; Mentions of church going; Mentions of miraculous;
*Note: A couple mentions of the devil himself; A couple mentions of a ship called the ‘Sea Devil’.


Negative Content- Minor cussing including: an ‘idiot’ and a ‘stupid’; Mentions of curses (said, not written); A bit of sarcasm; A Kidnapping along with Pain, Blood, Being Slapped & Whipped (semi-detailed); Fighting & Swords (semi-detailed); Threats; Mentions of whippings, being tied, hit, beaten, lashes, wounds & blood (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of hangings, executions, murders, killings & being left to die (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of guns that were aimed & those who were shot; Mentions of slaves; Mentions of taverns, drunks, drinking & rum; A couple mentions of suicide missions; A mention of skeletons.


Sexual Content- A bit of Noticing; Blushes; Mentions of love & feelings; Mentions of bar girls & unwanted attention; Declaring love for another.

-Skylar McHenry, age 18
P.O.V. switches between Skylar, Daniel, Will & a few others
Set in 1713 (Prologue set in 1702)
240 pages

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars (and a half)
Hmmm! I loved Skye & Will’s strong faiths in this novel…lots of Spiritual Content which was so refreshing. Being a pirate book, I wasn’t sure what to expect Spiritual Content wise, but I was pleasantly surprised. The overall romance was very clean, and the great faiths were a big plus! The writing was well done, though some parts did seem a bit forced or stiff. I teared up at the prologue and that ending was great. In all honestly, this book could have been a stand-alone book, since everything wraps up every well, but you won’t hear me complaining as I’m looking forward to reading the rest of the series. Skye & Will are so cute together!


Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...


*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
Profile Image for Shantelle.
Author 2 books373 followers
November 25, 2015
I find that I just really like Molly Evangeline/Jaye L. Knight's writings. I read first her Makilien series, then Resistance, the first book for her new fantasy series. And now I just finally finished the first book, The Pirate Daughter's Promise, in her historical series. I really enjoyed it, even with it being her first published book, and perhaps not as polished and perfected as her others.

The Pirate Daughter's Promise was a sweet, exciting adventure with a deep faith theme, tender romances, and little mysterious mixed in. Pirates abound, dangerous ports are visited, fantastic ships sail the seas. Skye is a lovely young woman of eighteen years who has lived at the orphanage since her beloved, former pirate father was hung. She works hard in exchange for a roof over her head; and is sometimes treated cruelly by the orphanage owners, and her wealthy grandfather, who refuses to acknowledge her existence. The thing that holds her together is her faith in God, and also His gift to her in the person of William. But Skye's fairly predictable life is about to change forever. A massive treasure is sought. A kidnapping ensues. An old pirate friend is found. An unimaginable secret is about to be uncovered.

I liked the range of characters. From Skye, to Will, to Matthew, to Kate. There's always secondary characters that tug at your heart in Molly's books! :) I also like the pirates theme, which is softened by faith. This book somewhat reminds me of Marylu Tyndall's swashbuckling pirate stories! Although, The Pirate Daughter's Promise is definitely written for a younger audience. It was completely enjoyable. —Nothing nagged at me or made me feel the least bit uncomfortable.

So... I read the version with a more plain cover, brown tones and a ship on the sea. It was published through Pleasant Words I think. The paperback I ended up reading was slightly different than the Kindle version I had started with... So I think Molly Evangeline updated The Pirate Daughter's Promise, but I ended up reading the old version. Yeah... this is probably confusing. Just read the version published through CreateSpace, and I think you'll get the updated version! :)

Anyway, I lovely story overall. I am excited to read the next book in this series, Every Tear, and all the others! :)
Profile Image for Sarah.
200 reviews13 followers
May 25, 2020
The setting is the Caribbean Sea and a majority of the book's events take place on ships, that was a plus and was actually the main reason that I picked this book up.

The reasons that I didn't rate this book higher was because to me, the setting was the best part. The character arc for the protagonist was hard for me to see. She seemed to start off nigh-on perfect and in the end if you asked me what she learned I would say it has to do with loving the people around you enough to know when to break a promise? The thing that I think fell flat was the fact that while Skye may have learned her lesson there wasn't much of a struggle to get to that point. As soon as her promise was endangering more than herself she backed off. So if that's what she was supposed to learn, I think she already knew it.

Outside of characters, the story line was disappointing. It was things like that, that don't make for a enjoyable read for me.

It's not a bad book, but it's also not what I would call a good book. It didn't grip me and I won't be rereading it.
Profile Image for Rhys-Marie.
282 reviews
December 21, 2023
This is likely the most mediocre book I’ve read this year–which in itself is an amazing accomplishment for such a mediocre story. With most books I read, I derive some enjoyment from the characters, prose, or setting–but not with this one. I’m not even sure why I kept reading, except that I rarely DNF books because I feel like I’m wasting time if I don’t finish a book I start. And at least, to its credit, The Pirate Daughter’s Promise was pretty short.

Let’s begin with the characters. Skye (her name would have been extremely rare in the 18th century) was too perfect and unrelatable for me to like. For some reason, her flawless personality grated on me, as I suppose it would for many other readers. Will was not much better–perhaps if he had been more realistic, the story would have been saved. As it was, I couldn’t care much about their romance. The only thing about this book that I liked was the side characters John and Kate, and even they weren’t particularly compelling.

The writing style, while not the worst I’ve ever read, was quite stilted, and I noticed a few annoying errors. The plot never gripped me, and it seemed rather simplistic. The plot issue that bothered me the most was Skye’s grandfather’s abrupt change of heart–it simply didn’t feel believable. Though there was a lot of Christian content in this book, which I usually consider a good thing, I found it hard to relate to because of the characters’ perfection. I did, however, like the theme of sacrificial love.
Profile Image for Addyson Huneke.
147 reviews3 followers
December 7, 2017
The Pirate Daughter's Promise by Molly Evangeline is a good, clean, Christian book that is about pirates. Unlike most stories about pirates, it does not paint the pirates as the good guys. I liked this. It is refreshing to read a book with high-sea adventure, pirates, and action where the bad is not glorified as good. The book also had some romance, but it was clean and God-honoring romance, which was also refreshing.

Writing: 4/5

The writing in this book was fairly well done. There wasn't anything to detract from the story, but it wasn't as good as later books show this author can be. The words flowed well, and there was no unnecessary wordiness or too-flowery description (that I can remember). There were a few typographical errors, but that is to be expected in any book.

Setting: 5/5

This book was set in the early 1700s in the Caribbean Sea. The setting was believable, and the author obviously did her research. The majority of the story was on board various ships. The setting was well-done and consistent, and enough was left to the reader's imagination to satisfy the most imaginative reader.

Plot: 5/5

The plot. Wonderful. Exciting. And mainly character-driven. It was original, there was some action, and the pirates weren't the good guys! (Can I emphasize how much I loved that little bit?) The plot didn't seem to drag, it didn't seem forced, and while a teeny bit predictable, still very enjoyable.

Character Development: 5/5

The character development was also well-done. They were easy to get into and the emotions were strong. The more minor characters had their own stories, and all of the supporting cast was well-rounded and not flat. The good characters were a little too good, but I enjoyed them anyways. Over all, the characters were well done.

I enjoyed this book very much. It is a good size, not too long for younger readers, and well-formatted. This book would be good to read by yourself or as a family. I highly recommend this book to readers of all ages.
Profile Image for Bruce Judisch.
Author 11 books47 followers
June 21, 2010
A delightful tale of high seas adventure, faith and perseverance, and a young girl’s steadfast honor for her earthly father and love for her Heavenly Father.

Orphaned at a young age, Skye McHenry’s life seems destined to drudgery and hopelessness, but for the love and care of a boy, Will James, also orphaned. Her life takes a drastic turn when she is kidnapped from the orphanage by the merciless pirate, Francis Kelley, for the knowledge she possesses of a hidden treasure. Kelley will stop at nothing to wrench the secret from Skye—and Skye is equally determined to resist Kelley’s tortures, for there is a promise to keep. Sail with Will, Captain John Morgan and the crew of the Good Fortune as they pursue the infamous Kelley in a quest to rescue Skye. Turn after turn, twist after twist await you until the final showdown between Will and Kelley, when the most unexpected twist of all bursts onto the scene. And through it all, God’s overriding faithfulness and protection over His loved ones endure.

Classically narrated, The Pirate Daughter’s Promise is an ideal book for extended family reading. Cluster the kids on the bed and transport them to a time when pirates ruled the seas, but not the hearts of men—or the heart of a young woman. They’ll hang on every word as Ms. Evangeline takes them from storm-ridden seas to sun-baked deserted islands, dingy orphanages to wealthy mansions, and the depths of man’s greed to the heights of God’s grace. Your only problem will be settling their protests when it comes time to close the cover for another evening.

Molly Evangeline is a recent home-school graduate who has been writing since she was eight years old. This is her debut novel—but you can bet it won’t be her last.
Profile Image for Mikayla.
1,209 reviews
March 2, 2017
There was so many things I liked about this book, Skye, Will, the awesome adventure, and the strong faith message. There were just a couple of things I didn't enjoy as much. 1. Skye wearing pants. Early 1700's? Would not have happened. Period. I understand that there might have been girls back then that didn't love dresses, but most of them probably wouldn't have thought about going out in pants, it was horrifying. Plus, if you've been raised in skirts, like Skye would have been, you probably don't even care for pants.
Profile Image for Maya.
48 reviews
November 22, 2016
I liked parts of this book. I really liked the idea of a pirate story from a christian point of view. Although the plot was exciting, I couldn't help but think that parts of it was a little cheesy or too generic. A lot of the characters were too perfect...I would have liked there to be a little more realistic aspects. I also didn't like the fact that a lot of the plot line was too similar to the plot line of Pirates of the Caribbean. One of the main characters is not only named Will but acts a lot like the Will character in the movie. But, it was fun nonetheless....
Profile Image for Sarah Grace Grzy.
634 reviews940 followers
February 20, 2017
Wow! Despite the fact that the story dragged on somewhat, the characters were shallow, and the writing was somewhat amateurish, it DID have one doozy of a plot twist! That my friends, was a plot twist to end all plot twists! Goodness! I literally stopped breathing for nearly 30 seconds.

All that being said, this was an okay book, I probably won't read it again, and I probably will check out the next book in the series.
Profile Image for Olivia.
73 reviews4 followers
April 13, 2023
I enjoyed that. It was a nice change to read about pirates (and in a Christian perspective, so neat!) Only a small complaint…I felt like the writing was a little forced here and there, and at some parts there were some weird POV changes. Overall, I thought it was intriguing and I really loved the characters. Definitely reading the rest of the series!
Profile Image for Keira-- OLD ACCOUNT.
172 reviews13 followers
February 15, 2022
Orphaned at a young age, Skylar McHenry grew up as little more than a servant and shunned by everyone around her because of her reputation as a pirate's daughter. Each day Skye faces is marked by some new struggle. Her only hope is to rely on her heavenly Father's care and comfort and the solace of her best friend, Will, who has become more than dear to her.
Just when an unexpected encounter gives Skye a small glimmer of hope that things might change in her favor, her world is shattered. She is awakened in the night by cannon blasts. Pirates storm the orphanage, drag her away, and force her aboard their ship. The cruel captain's intentions are clear. He will extract from her, through any means necessary, the location of the treasure hidden by her father. For Skye to divulge the location would mean breaking the last promise she made to him. She's certain she never will, but what happens when the lives of those dearest to her are at stake?
The Pirate Daughter's Promise is full of daring high seas adventure; sweet, wholesome romance; surprising discoveries; unlikely new friends; and the rewards of trusting in God even when life seems impossible.


4 of 5 stars
This was a very refreshing read. Super clean, and I definitely enjoyed the romance. It wasn't a very long book (I read it in a couple of hours), and I'm going to remember this one. It was just such a very nice, Christian pirate story. Far from original (in my opinion), but still a very nice book, and very wholesome. Thanks, Molly Evangeline!
Profile Image for Ailey Leman.
75 reviews
April 1, 2025
**3.5 stars**

Good story and some great faith content, but I just didn’t get into this one as much as I wanted too. That could have also been because it was on Kindle, and I’ve gotten burnt out at reading books on my phone. But, I would definitely recommend this to teen girls who are interested in a pirate story. It was super clean, and is a fun setting.
Profile Image for Danica.
173 reviews
August 13, 2025
I have been looking for a pirate Christian fiction like this for ages. There is something about this era and the sea that gets me. I immediately fell in love!!! I found the character a bit... how do I word it? I feel disassociated at times, like sometimes there is a lack of emotion, and then in other chapters, there is lots of description. But I love the faith content!
Profile Image for Jessica.
255 reviews1 follower
April 13, 2012
I received this book (and the rest of the series) as a birthday present from a friend. To be honest, I both loved and hated this book. In terms of the characters especially, I really enjoyed following them on their journey and learning new things about them. I loved the Authors writing, aside from her excessive use of the word "Finally" and the way she wove Christian values throughout the book was wonderful.

The one thing I didn't like was the similarities with the "Pirates of the Caribbean" Disney movies. Some of the similarities included the main character Skye being kidnapped by pirates after a raid on the port she lived in, the male hero she liked being named William (will), a trip to Tortuga, and being marooned on an island. Some of the similarities I was able to overlook but I felt a bit disappointed. I opened up the book expecting to find a unique, Christian pirate book that would have me surprised and thrilled at every turn and I ended up feeling a bit of disappointment at how alike the plot was with the disney movies.

I kept reading hoping that it was just a few unintended similarities but they kept popping up. It wasn't until halfway through the book that the plotline took a turn. After that, I really enjoyed myself. The ending was especially good and I can't wait to read the next book. Aside from those few little things, I really liked this book and the Authors writing style.

If I could have, I would have rated it more as a 4.4 but I wasn't allowed to take off half a star. I was a bit irked by the similarities with the movies as I said, but I loved everything else. (especially the characters) If I hadn't seen the movies, I know I would have loved this book and easily given it five stars without a second thought.

I'm apprehensively going to move on to the second book and am hoping that it will prove to be a more unique, and have a surprising plotline.


As a side note to the author, who I know is on goodreads and probably looks over her reviews...

"From one writer to another, fear not, I'm still a fan. I like your writing itself, and the story, I was just hoping for a bit more creativity. Keep up the good work and thank you for writing a Christ-centered action book. I think this is something my brothers will enjoy reading also!"
Profile Image for Leanne.
96 reviews3 followers
July 2, 2015
Becoming a orphan at a young age was very hard for Skylar McHenry. She was treated more like a servant and shunned by almost everyone because she was a pirate's daughter. But even through a hard life Skye never lost hope in relying on her heavenly Father's care, and her friendship with Will. Who was a dear friend that she grew up with.

But just when things start looking like they may get better, her world falls apart. One night the town is attacked with blasts from a ships cannon. And before Skye knows what is going on the pirates brake into the orphanage... to get only her. After being taken to their ship she discovers what they are after. The cruel captain wants the location of the treasure hidden by her father. But telling him where it is would be braking the last promise she made to her father. But when the lives of the the people dearest to her are threatened she must do something.

The Pirate Daughter's Promise is a wonderfully done book. When you think of books that have a message of faith in them pirate stories are probably not the first kind you think about. But that is exactly what Molly Evangeline wrote. And I really enjoyed it! She worked the faith part into the story very nicely. And I really liked the way you could see the characters faith at work, instead of only hearing them talk about it.

Yet at the same time the pirates were very realistic. There were some very exciting scenes, and all of the places the characters went felt very real. And there were some amazing surprises along the way that I never seen coming! This was a great book and I would love to read more stories from this author!

I received this book free from the author, Molly Evangeline, for my honest review. The opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Leah Good.
Author 2 books203 followers
January 7, 2013
Skye McHenry has led a difficult life cheered only by her faith and her two friends, Will and Matthew. As the daughter of a pirate, most people despise her. When pirates kidnap Skye, she knows they are hunting for her father's treasure. She is determined to keep her promise to never reveal the location of the treasure. Can Will and Matthew rescue her before it's too late?

I thoroughly enjoyed this story and read the entire book the same day I got it. The writing style is a bit unpolished at times, but this does little to detract from the story. Skye's faith and determination are admirable, and I love Will's chivalry. I also like the fact that the entire family can read this book. The action and clean romance will keep older readers engaged while there is nothing inappropriate for a younger audience. I am looking forward to reading more of Molly Evangeline's work.

Disclosure: I received a free reviewer's copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinion's stated are my own.
Profile Image for Morgan.
Author 15 books100 followers
July 26, 2013
I loved this book! In fact, though a few months ago I didn't even know Molly Evangeline existed, I have not only read all her books, I have read The Pirate Daughter's Promise twice.

Molly is really good at creating likeable characters. She really gets you to care about what happens to them. I love the characters in Pirates and Faith. Skye is very brave and adventurous, but very feminine as well. Will is very chivalrous, something I really loved about him (and also something missing from our culture). I also liked how Molly was able to create an exciting pirate story without making the pirates the good guys. Pirates are bad, and they are portrayed as such. The message was a wonderful one, that God always has a reason for things, whether we know what it is or not.

I don't really have any criticisms to make, except maybe that there are only four books in the series (I wish there were many more). The Pirate Daughter's Promise has definitely made me into a Molly Evangeline fan and I strongly recommend it for everyone.
Profile Image for Sarah Cnossen.
215 reviews25 followers
July 29, 2014
This novel was quite enjoyable to read. It is so very rare to find a fiction book that combines the adventures of pirates with that of faith in God, and this one does well. You could call it a Christian Pirates of the Caribbean, with the absence of Jack Sparrow, of course. :]

However, the quality of the writing is not professional, but is geared perfectly towards a younger audience. The Point of View (POV) changed often while in the same paragraph, causing slight disorientation. For example, you are in the mind of the main character, Skye, one moment, and in the next sentence or two, it is her friend Will or another character. The writing was altogether flat and shallow, with a good bit of telling rather than showing. Still, the story was fun and active, with a strong faith and trust that shows just how much God loves us, and will never leave us alone, no matter the circumstances.

Overall, I found this a fun tale and would recommend to ages 11 and up.
Profile Image for Micailah.
20 reviews5 followers
January 1, 2015
This review is from: The Pirate Daughter's Promise: Pirates & Faith, Book 1 (Paperback)
This book is filled with God's truth, and love. Skye is a pirate's daughter and devoted christian who is captured by pirates who want the location of her father's treasure. Throughout tough times Skye never looses her faith in God, and the plans he has for her. She finds true friends in unexpected places, and reunites with friends she never bought she'd see again. This is a great book, by a fantastic author. Having read her newest release (under a new pen name) I can definitely see how her writing has matured. I did find the characters a bit hard to relate to, and some parts of the story to be a bit unbelievable, but overall a wonderful read.
Profile Image for Kaitlin Grace.
7 reviews2 followers
July 3, 2013
Not bad for a debut novel. It has its rough spots, but a good story nonetheless. After all, she was only 18 when she published it and her writing has gotten markedly improved with subsequent books. I loved the characters and the message of trust in God. A great story if you're looking for a fun, sweet, pirate adventure. Especially good for teens. It's great that Molly Evangeline is writing clean fiction, especially clean romance, to combat the less wholesome fiction that's being published and pushed at kids these days.
Profile Image for serena482*.
135 reviews
July 4, 2014
wow! This is an amazing book you don't want to miss. An adventure full of danger and excitement, and best of all love from the love of God to the love of another person. There is not one thing I don't like about this book and I am so excited to read the next books. Thank you for writing these wonderful stories Molly Evangeline! :)
64 reviews1 follower
June 4, 2024
I don't remember reading this book before. It was signed by the author. I thought the story was predictable in places. What stood out for me was her trust in God t deliver her from the most awful circumstances. He did in most unexpected ways. It was a reminder that he is faithful and has a plan for me no matter what comes my way.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.