I gave it an extra star because the art is quite attractive. I like the color palette and I like the use of digital layering effects to give it a lot of texture.
The book itself though, lacked everything worthwhile.
It's a song. A song about activism, and how you need to use your voice...or your sign language...to speak out against anything and everything that is wrong while making sure to listen and learn from everyone else.
You know, it's really quite hard to listen to other people when you are busy using your voice. Using your voice usually requires you to be talking...or singing, or some such thing which makes it quite difficult to hear what others are saying. Try it sometime, talk and read at the same time. I don't mean read aloud. I mean maintain a conversation while reading something. See how much you retain. Very little. Or just take out the maintaining a conversation part, read something and listen to someone else talking, you retain very little. I know, my students try it constantly under the guise of multi-tasking. Then they complain when they get a low grade, or say 'you never covered this in class'. Oh yes I did. It's right there on slide 4. Sigh.
I'm not an advocate of the old school saying that children are to be seen and not heard. But neither am I an advocate of today's phenomenon where children are to be listened to about everything and pandered to. A child should not lead us, simply because of the lack of experience and cognitive abilities. Children are innocent, that doesn't make them wise. I do think they should use their voices, but I think they should use their voices to ask questions, and then they should listen to the answers, because that's how they learn. Even the title makes me shiver "My voice is a trumpet." Trumpets are really loud, you can't really hear anything else when you have a trumpet going off in your ear. If everyone is trumpeting, no one is listening, if no one is listening, what's the point of trying to communicate at all?
Shallow nostrums.
Narrative: Nonexistent
Art: Cute
Price: $17.99
I have recently learned, from the marketing specialist at my job, that the reason these books are so expensive is because of the printing techniques that they use. Apparently they are quite expensive. I don't know, Berenstein bears and Dr. Seuss don't use such fancy printing techniques and they are still quite popular. I think these books are trying to compensate for their shallowness.