Adam Graham's Blog: Christians and Superheroes

February 25, 2017

Doctor Who: The Tenth Doctor Volume 4 - The Endless SongDoctor Who: The Tenth Doctor Volume 4 - The Endless Song by Nick Abadzis

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book collects the Tenth Doctor Year 2, Issues 1-5.

The titular two issue story is great. It's everything a Doctor Who comic story should be. An adventure the Doctor could believably have, but really couldn't work on TV and hear we have a floating city in the cloud with gaseous tree cows and a conceptual musical being made of cosmic foam. The art brings this to life and drives the whole story.

The middle story is not all that great. It has some interesting art with Cindy reading a letter from Gabby, but is essentially a Doctor-lite issue with a plot that goes nowhere in this book but hopefully sets up events for a later book.

The final two issue story has the Doctor and Gabby heading back to pre-historic times where they encounter a Neanderthal medicine man. The story wasn't bad and it exceeded my expectations given the general history of Doctor Who and Cave Man stories.

Overall, the book is above average.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 25, 2017 16:25 • 21 views • Tags: doctor-who, the-tenth-doctor

February 24, 2017

The Batman Chronicles, Vol. 6The Batman Chronicles, Vol. 6 by Bill Finger

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book collect early Batman stories from 1942 in World's Finest #5 and #6, Batman 10 and 11, and Batman #62-65.

The story's are pretty but slightly below standard for Batman golden age stories but still above average for Golden Age stories in general.

Some highlights:

The Princess of Plunder (Batman #10): Catwoman's only appearance in the book and she pulls off some very clever heists the dynamic duo has to foil.

Sheriff of Ghost Town (Batman #10): Batman and Robin go to a Ghost Town that's about 50 years behind the times. It's a fun if silly story in which Batman and Robin spend a lot of the story on horseback but it has some nice heartfelt moment in it too.

The Joker's Advertising Game (Batman #11): The Joker uses clues in the classifieds to stage a crime campaign. This is fun and clever, though in later years, this sort of plot would go to the Riddler.

Four Birds of a Feather (Batman #11): The Penguin and three confederates to Florida to work a scam only to find that Batman's down there. Best part of the story, Batman punches out an octopus.

The Secret of Bruce Wayne (World's Finest #6): An earnest reporter is given an assignment to uncover Batman's secret identity. The reporter is actually an interesting character with a very believable conflict between his morality and his need to get the story. It also covers a lot of ground.

The Cop Who Hated Batman (Detective Comics #65): Another interesting character. This time it's a police officer who has a dislike for the Dark Knight. A very engaging story with some nice twists.

The Lowlights of the book:

Crime Takes a Holiday (World's Finest #5): It starts off promising enough as criminals agree to a plan to abandon crime in Gotham. What happens afterwards just doesn't live up to the premise. It falls flat.

Laugh Town Laugh (Detective Comics #62): The Joker isn't amused when he finds out America's top comics have been invited to compete for clues leading to the fortune of the World's funniest man. This was later the basis for an episode of Batman: The New Animated Series, but this one plays out as a very samey Batman story.

The Isle That Time Forgot (Batman #10): A somewhat dumb story that has Batman and Robin getting onto an island with primitives and monsters.

A Gentleman in Gotham (Detective Comics #63): What did we need a Raffles knock off named Baffles? Gets more off putting each time I read it.

The Most Jokerish story:

The Joker Walks the Last Mile (Detective Comics #64): The Joker turns himself in so he can get executed and then he gets a pill that makes alive again so that he can live a normal life as he's already been executed for his old crimes and immediately goes out and starts committing more crimes because he's the Joker.

The other stories are all at least servicable and there's enough good ones to make this worthwhile. Overall, I'd give it 3.5 stars, round it up to 4.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 24, 2017 17:30 • 16 views • Tags: golden-age-batman

February 20, 2017

Marvel Masterworks: Atlas Era Heroes, Vol. 3Marvel Masterworks: Atlas Era Heroes, Vol. 3 by Bill Everett

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book collects the brief revival of the Sub-mariner in his own comic from Issues 33-42.

The bulk of the comic stories feature the Sub-mariner. Original artist Bill Everett to draw all the Sub-mariner stories an the art in this book is absolutely superb and a cut above most Silver Age art. The stories are mostly well-written.

In the Silver Age, comic books would become obsessed with telling what Superheroes did during their childhood, ranging from the often weak tales of Aquaman and Wonder Woman to the epic Asgard tales of young Thor and Loki. Everett was ahead of his time in the mid-1950s, from Issue 35-42 we get eight tales looking at adventures of Namor as a child and they're far above the quality of most Silver Age stories. (Though not quite as epic as Thor's.)

The adult stories were mostly fun tales of the Sub-marienr taking on criminals, commies, and an alien here or there. The biggest problem I had with those stories was some of the consistency. For the first half of the book, Sub-mariner was the friend of surface people and tried to thwart his evil Stepbrother's attempts to start trouble. Then the Emperor of Atlantis powers him up and orders him to declare war on the surface people and he does lackadaisically, half-heartedly, and at times a disregard for lives, and then towards the end, the war is dropped. It's weird because the reason this book was kept going while Captain America and Human Torch were cancelled was because they planned on making a TV series out of Sub-mariner. Hard to do that with someone trying to wipe out mankind.

Other than that betrayal of the character and a few stories hindered by the rigid space requirement, the stories were all enjoyable.

The Human Torch appears in three back upstories and they're okay if unremarkable. Probably the best story is in Issue #33 which has the Torch taking on weird alien creatures. The art is really fun on that one. The other two involve a plague outbreak, and an attempt to frame the Human Torch.

After the Torch leaves, the back up feature becomes sea-based and doesn't feature recurring characters. The ones involving people at sea are good, but the four nature comics that center on the struggle of a sea creature features outstanding art and some great action as the they fight for their lives.

The text stories are okay. They're forgettable but will pass a couple minutes and allowed the comic company to ship out a lower rate.

The rare comics reprinted are a joy with solid artwork and enjoyable stories. Recommended for any fan of comic history or Namor.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 20, 2017 22:28 • 29 views • Tags: atlas-age, marvel, submariner

February 18, 2017

Green Lanterns, Volume 1: Rage PlanetGreen Lanterns, Volume 1: Rage Planet by Sam Humphries

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This is a very different sort of Superhero book. Ostensibly it's about a Red Lantern invasion of Earth with Earth's Fifth and Sixth Green Lanterns Simon Baz and Jessica Cruz having to defend Earth. Yet, our heroes have a problem.

Simon has a chip on his shoulder from being sent to Guantanamo though he was innocent. Even though he's relatively new to being a Green Lantern, he's really sure that he doesn't need Jessica. Jessica suffers from anxiety and has spent the past three years living in her own apartment, can't use her ring to make a construct, and isn't sure she's up to the job.

Admittedly, this book isn't for everyone. It's about the heroes fighting their own demons as much as it is fighting the Red Lantern core. Yet, I think writer Sam Humphries manages to balance the personal journeys of the characters with the action plot most of the time and the pay off in the final chapter of the story was worth the read to me. I liked how he worked in several nice little sub-plots that are resolved in this volume while leaving some larger questions for later exploration.

The emotional stuff can get a bit heavy, but I found myself liking and cheering for these characters, so even though it's not a typical comic book story, I really enjoyed it.



View all my reviews
1 like ·   •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 18, 2017 08:12 • 33 views • Tags: anxiety, green-lanterns

February 17, 2017

Penguins of Madagascar: When in Rome... (Vol. 1)Penguins of Madagascar: When in Rome... by Alex Matthews

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book collects three separate tales featuring the Penguins of Madagascar.

"The Great Drain Robbery" is probably the weakest of the three. It has the Penguins battling an army of rats over food in New York City. It's not bad, and it's the most normal thing they do in this book.

"When in Rome" is the best story and the Penguins look most like themselves. They investigate a magic act that's competing with their circus and there's a twist as to what's going on. The story's gotten a certain insanity to it. I wish the resolution had been better, but this plenty enjoyable.

"Night Out" is typical Penguins mayhem as they hit the town after borrowing a hot car from a celebrity. If you love the Penguins doing crazy things, this is great story.

The book is geared towards younger kids and the extra features reflect that. The pin-ups are all bright and fun to look at and the games are fun if nothing special.

If you love the Penguins or your kids do, this is a worthwhile and fun book to check out.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 17, 2017 22:13 • 7 views • Tags: penguins-of-madagascar

February 16, 2017

Superman: Earth One, Volume 1Superman: Earth One, Volume 1 by J. Michael Straczynski

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book is a modern retelling of Superman's origin tale with a modern Superman. There are many ways this should not have worked, yet JMS brings a lot to the table to make it work.

First, it was great how he explored Clark Kent having other options in his career. With his brain and might, the book explores the idea of him having many options and being torn as to what to choose with big piles of money being offered on one hand. This mirrors many of the struggles of Millennials and their search for fulfillment.

I liked the Planet staff. The people were written like real journalists, Perry White specifically. Too often these characters are written by people who don't understand how a real newspaper works. It was a nice touch having Jimmy and Lois play a part in Superman's decision.

I also thought the portrayal of how the Kents instilled the values that made him who he was was actually quite moving. Their advice was mostly good and inspirational, so they sheer volume of epigrams is slightly overwhelming. The book's storyline offers many ideas that were adopted by the film Man of Steel. It's a pity the portrayal of the Kents here wasn't what we got Man of Steel.

Beyond that, the book is very well done. While this Superman is a reinvention of the character, I still think JMS captures his essence and that, particularly for an origin story, this is Superman. The art is beautiful and the action is exciting.

The book's biggest flaw was just not knowing where to stop. There are two natural stopping places, it drives right through after the main plot's been resolved.

Still, other than that, this is an intriguing and worthwhile take on Superman.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 16, 2017 17:11 • 27 views • Tags: jms, superman

February 13, 2017

Atomic Robo and the Shadow from Beyond Time (Atomic Robo, #3)Atomic Robo and the Shadow from Beyond Time by Brian Clevinger

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


Atomic Robo is a robot who has been around since the 1920 when he was created by Nikola Tesla and starting in 1929 one shadow has chased him throughout his life, a lovecraftian creature who exists outside linear time--and (as we learn early in this book) actually sprang out of H.P. Lovecraft.

This story is a high concept thrill ride that takes advantage of Robo's long life to tell a tale that involves Robo and friends throughout his life. There's 1920s Robo teaming up with Charles Fort, cold war Robo, 1970s Robo getting help from Carl Sagan, and of course the modern robo an the scientists of Tesladyne, and the ultimate team up in the final issue.

The art is fun and imaginative. The story is engaging. Writer Brian Clevinger does a good job having Robo "age" as each version of Robo has slight differences in personality as he's learned more over time. He still remains wise cracking and charming at any age.

The back up stories are not nearly as fun. At best, they're amusing, with the funniest piece being a text interview with Robo. Not bad, but certainly not as good as the main story.

Still, this is a very enjoyable read. Highly recommended.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 13, 2017 18:55 • 28 views • Tags: atomic-robo

February 12, 2017

Doctor Who: The Fourth Doctor Volume 1 - Gaze of the MedusaDoctor Who: The Fourth Doctor Volume 1 - Gaze of the Medusa by Gordon Rennie

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


The Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith find themselves in London in 1887 and at the center of a mad plot by Lady Emily Carstairs to re-awaken an ancient entity for her own purposes.

This book is a great piece of nostalgia. Featuring the Doctor and his most beloved companion, Sarah Jane Smith, the story feels like something that could have been aired on Doctor Who during Season 13. Every page has that gothic horror feel that was so characteristic of the Philip Hinchcliffe era on Doctor Who: the settings, the monsters. In that way, it's perfect. The story and the human guest villain are solid, but not particularly great other than in their design.

My main criticism of the book is that Sarah Jane is taken out of the action for nearly two full issues out of five in the book. In a limited series, having Sarah Jane is a big deal and so taking her out of the action seems ill-advised, and the substitute companion is okay but there's no real good substitute for Sarah Jane.

Other than that, the book is worth a read for how brings a long ago era of Doctor Who to life in comic books.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 12, 2017 17:45 • 35 views • Tags: comics, doctor-who, fourth-doctor

February 11, 2017

The Flash, Vol. 1: Lightning Strikes TwiceThe Flash, Vol. 1: Lightning Strikes Twice by Joshua Williamson

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This book collects the Flash: Rebirth and the first eight issues of the new Flash series.

The book is a couple issues longer than the usual rebirth book has been but with good reason. It's an exploration of the Flash as a character. The Rebirth event brings Wally West back into the DC Universe and this event is more personal for the Flash and it tugs on what's been missing from him. Barry Allen is portrayed as a man who is the fastest man alive but is always late, always behind, never able to be where he needs to be in time...and alone.

Over time, the Flash became more than just a single hero...It became a brotherhood, a tradition, with speedsters like Jay Garrick, Wally West, and Bart Allen part of something larger and always there for each other. In Flash's own book, he has pretty much been on his own since the new 52.

But he's not on his own for long in this book. An old friend gets speed powers after being hit by lightning and then it happens to people all over Central City. Meanwhile, the other Wally West is developing powers of his own but not telling his Aunt or the Flash. We get to see Barry as teacher and mentor and he rediscovers joy and a bit of love.

This story is incredibly effective with some solid new characters and a great emotional journey. There's also several mysteries beyond the big one involving Doctor Manhattan. There's the question of whose behind giving so many people speed powers which is never answered. As well as a search for a killer speedster named Godspeed who shows up towards the middle of the book. In addition, there are some very cool speedster scenes which are just a joy to read.

The book is a great jumping on point for new readers to the Flash, although there are a few Easter eggs for old fans as well. Taken together with the solid action, great characters, and fundamental examination of Barry Allen as a character, this is a great book to check out for fans curious about the Rebirth event.



View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 11, 2017 15:34 • 26 views • Tags: flash, rebirth

February 10, 2017

Batman: The Silver Age Newspaper Comics Volume 2 (1968-1969)Batman: The Silver Age Newspaper Comics Volume 2 by Whitney Ellsworth

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This second volume of Batman newspaper strips contains Batman comic strips from 1968 and 1969 and it's a bit different from the first volume. While the first volume was chock full of Batman's rogue's gallery and evoked the TV show a lot, this one has no guest appearance from a regular Batman rogue the entire two years but does feature guest appearances by Batman's friends Superman, Batman, and Aquaman.

There's a lot to like about this volume. The story feels more like an adventure strip with the stories going on pretty much as long as required with the book beginning with a story that had been going on for the last four and a half months of 1967 for a total of 8 months, and the story lines in this book are five, seven, and six months long respectively ending in the middle of 1969.

"Shivering Max, Pretty Boy Floy, and Flo:" This story about a mafia reward for Batman's demise continues in this volume as Batman's survival endangers those who originally collected the award. There's cross and double cross, as well as luxurious island where Batman is exiled forever. The way this plays out is a lot of adventure strip fun.

"Diabolical Professor Zinkk" : Superman needs Batman's help as someone is robbing him of his powers. Zinkk has an insane plan and is just one of those crazy mad scientists who is a lot of fun to read and certainly, the Batman and Superman friendship is on display as never before in comic strips.

"Breathing Underwater," A young woman takes illegally desperate measures to get Batman's attention because she needs Batman's help to locate Aquaman because Aquaman had been working on a formula with her father to allow people to breathe underwater. Both she and Batman take the underwater breathing pills only to discover that they, like Aquaman, have to get back to the water within an hour or die. The story is probably my least favorite in here. While the underwater breathing pills seem silly, there are technologies that are somewhat reminiscent of that in early development. My big problem with it is that Batman is only needed as a means to contact Aquaman and the story is mostly what happens while they wait. It's not horrible, but I prefer stories where Batman's more central.

"I Want Bruce Wayne's Identity," A wanted criminal decides he wants to take over Bruce Wayne's life and turn Bruce Wayne into him. Wayne unwittingly helps this plot by sending Dick, his new tutors, and Alfred overseas on vacation. The story has some fun twists and is a good adventure that goes beyond the typical superhero amnesia story in comics because of the length you can get away within in a comic strip that goes on for months. Oddly, it's almost like a Silver Age comic strip version of Face Off. Overall, a fun tale.

If you love the Silver Age of Batman or adventure strips in general, you'll get a lot out of this book.





View all my reviews
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Twitter icon
Published on February 10, 2017 16:15 • 23 views • Tags: batman, silver-age

Christians and Superheroes

Adam Graham
I'm a Christian who writes superhero fiction (some parody and some serious.)

On this blog, we'll take a look at:

1) Superhero stories
2) Issues of faith in relation to Superhero stories
3) Writing Superhe
...more
Follow Adam Graham's blog with rss.