I read this book because it was referenced/quoted in another book I really enjoyed. I do think there were some valuable things in here, but it fell short for me for several reasons. Mainly, the term “5 conversations” implies that the book is about 5 specific conversations to have throughout your son’s childhood, when in reality the format of the book is much more sprawling and general than clear and concise. And the information is presented less as “conversations to have with your son” as it is “topics for mom to ponder pertaining to sons.” Also, this book claims to be applicable from “cradle to college,” but most of what it addresses relates to mothers of sons 13 years and up. Aside from the occasional nod to “laying a foundation,” very little was said about small boys, which is where I’m at in life right now. So perhaps a better title would be “5 broad and general topics to think about when raising teenage boys.” Not as catchy, I know. XD
While there are some helpful suggestions in this book, most of the meat of the content seems to be personal anecdotes, quoting other authors, listing off statistics, and repeating things that I’d term plain old common sense. There’s also a large amount of assumption going on— the author simply assumes her readers are on the same page with her theologically and in parenting style. (She says as much in the introduction with statements like: “if you picked up this book, then…”)
Because I do tend to agree with her for the most part, this wasn’t particularly bothersome, but I would’ve appreciated a chapter or introduction that laid out a basic statement of faith, worldview, and scriptural basis for her values. That way I could’ve headed into the parenting advice section fully equipped to know what I should filter. Just because someone claims to be a Christian author does not mean that you can take everything they say as biblically sound. And while I’m certainly not accusing this author of heresy, I was disappointed in how much of her “wisdom” was drawn from cultural sources (studies, statistics, and contemporary authors and psychologists) and personal experience rather than biblical truth. Which is sad, because I know she knows biblical truth; she just assumes everyone is on the same page as her without feeling the need to ground her claims in scripture. Because “if you picked up this book” you probably already know scripture, right? Um… biblical truth CANNOT BE OVERSTATED. We all need constant reminders. Just repeat it anyway, sister, even if everyone already knows it. It’s worth saying every time.
I’d treat this more as an overgrown mommy blog than a parenting book (complete with a condescending tone and a handful of editing errors, yikes.) It is well intended, but as I was reading, I felt like I was just chatting with another Christian mom, rather than receiving solid biblical teaching. Which of course there’s a time and place for. I just was expecting this book to pack a bigger punch.
(Also, directly quoting a one star Amazon review of one of your books in the text of another of your books is just in poor authorial taste IMHO.)