I'm a graphic designer about to start law school and I was given this book as a Christmas gift last year. I finally sat down to read it and I think it is a great resource to have on my bookshelf going into school and starting my new career!
After my brother gave this to me, it blew my dad's mind that people actually spent MONEY to BUY FONTS. He asked me what was wrong with the fonts that came with Microsoft Word and also what was wrong with the default settings on Word when he was creating documents for work. I had some reasons why all those things were horrible, but I was coming from an artist's perspective. I wanted to read this book to answer his questions and the ultimate question, does typography matter to a lawyer?
Butterick answers strongly in the affirmative. He first states that it matters because typography is the visual component of the written word and thus has a utilitarian function--sure, typography doesn't change the substance of the text at all but it makes it easier/more enjoyable for the reader and thus more likely to be read and understood. Obviously attorneys have to work hard to formulate solid arguments and just like good speaking skills are necessary to help get the message across in oral arguments, good typography is equally as necessary in written ones. Getting one's arguments across is one of the most important jobs of being an attorney. His second reason for why typography matters is it's demonstrative of the care that is put into their work--why not show up to a client meeting in sweat pants? Why not hold counsel in your garage? Attorneys are professional writers and need to adopt professional writing techniques. So there you go, dad.
Some parts of the book were harder to get through--mainly the text composition and formatting text chapters, just because there was a lot of detailed descriptions of grammar, punctuation, and stuff Microsoft Word does that I've never even heard of in my life. It was all great information though and Butterick presents it in a pedantic yet funny and engaging way so it's way easier to follow along than a textbook or hs English Class.
I especially like the chapter on sample documents were he shows a lot of documents/templates that lawyers use--contracts, caption pages, motions, resumes, letterhead, business cards, etc and shows common "befores" and things to optimize them for improved "afters". I'm not an attorney yet but my resume looks a million times before than it did before.
Law is so competitive and I really do believe good typography matters. I would recommend this to any attorney or aspiring one to keep on the reference shelf next to the Blue Book. I actually find that I use a lot of these concepts in my job and everyday life right now so even if you're not an attorney, I would recommend Butterick's other book, "Practical Typography," which is basically the same thing but not dialed in for attorneys.