This book should be mandatory for all people who want to learn about the struggle for Black liberation, not because everything in it is correct or right, but because of the Hon. Marcus Garvey’s impact on Black consciousness and organizing. Message to the People compiles some of Garvey’s many insights on education / learning, leadership, the UNIA, Black Nationalism, sociopolitical and governmental formation, reformism and revolution, anti-communism, and racialism, into a short easy-to-read volume. It is essentially an instruction manual on Black Nationalism and Black Nationalist organizing.
One of Garvey’s most interesting (but least talked about) viewpoints is his belief that African Americans should not engage in open rebellion against the white power structure. Garvey argued that Black people should respect law enforcement, avoid calling for or engaging in revolutionary action, and embrace capitalist and bourgeoisie democratic norms, so as to avoid conflict with the repressive apparatus of the state. This led him (in part) to an anti-communist position, as well as a general disdain for revolutionary confrontation. However, unlike many Black conservatives who articulate a similar view, Garvey is not advocating for perpetual Black acquiescence to white domination. Rather, he is saying that Black people should focus on building and controlling their own institutions (and thus should engage the political process to those ends), with the ultimate goal of supporting the creation and development of a strong, unified, independent African nation. For Garvey, the ultimate goal was separatism and nation-building on the continent of Africa. For Black people living under white rule in the United States, trying to bring about social revolution was a suicidal impossibility. This is a position that still divides Black political circles today.
Similarly, Garvey’s anti-communism is also illuminating. Not only does he think socialist organizing among Black folks is dangerous due to the state’s repressive forces, he thinks it would ultimately be futile, as a socialist revolution carries the possibility of empowering an irredeemably racist white masses, rather than a smaller white capitalist elite that at least has the monetary incentive to sometimes use Black labor. While this position shows that Garvey had a keen sense of the ever-present terroristic anti-Blackness of the white masses, it also reveals his naiveté with regard to capitalism. While Garvey does note that capitalism is a “bad system,” he goes on to applaud cutthroats like Carnegie and Rockefeller as “self-made” men, ignoring their extractive, monopolistic plundering. Garvey further fails to provide any real analysis of capitalism as a system that requires the degradation and exploitation of the masses of Black people. In short, Garvey believes that Black Americans can use capitalism (either as wage earners or small capitalists themselves) to fund the UNIA and build Black institutions, ultimately toward the aim of developing a Black nation-state in Africa. This belief ignores the destruction and underdevelopment that capitalism inevitably reeks on Black communities.
Message to the People is a must-read because Garvey is a titan of Black philosophy, organizing, and resistance. One cannot call himself a student of the history of African resistance without taking Marcus Garvey’s words and program seriously, whether you ultimately agree with them or not.