Kevin L. Donihe is brilliant. One of the most creative, most original authors out there, Donihe is in my top five list of sure things. When I need a little surrealism, a little thought to my scare and tear, it’s him I sprint to. Only come to find out, and I say this with a frown that would move Hitler to empathy, even Mr. Donihe can have a bad day.
In what was one of the most banal storylines that I have ever read, Donihe managed to make hell about as interesting as an Iowa cornfield*. That’s right, feel my pain. Without even so much as a clue or explanation on why Hell has gone out of business, the plot centers on Charles – a former minion from the ninth gate in hell – and his daily life. Charles, more moralistic than any priest I’ve ever met, spends his days doing the 9 to 5 thing, while still finding time to bitch and moan about the good ole’ days in hell. You see, apparently when Hell closed down shop, the world’s deviants took over on earth.
Well, at least that’s my guess since Donihe never quite explained it. Anyway, so while society maims, defiles, and murders their friends and strangers alike, Charles just moves about the day in what can only be the best advertisement I’ve ever seen for Zoloft. Oh, and he’s not the only one. Overweight, needy, and pitiful, Satan is actually more pathetic than Charles. And that, people, is a hard thing to accomplish. Bravo!
So, aside from the plot and characters, how was the rest of the book you want to know? I’m glad you asked, but first, to be fair, let me say this: after I received this book, I got an email from the author explaining that he knew there were some typos and that they would be fixed the following day. Said author was even sweet enough to email me a list of the boo-boo’s and their corrections. But, and you knew there had to be a but in there, I found more issues. Which, compiled onto the list of already discovered typos, made this novella one of the most marked up books I own.
But what kills me is that through it all: the emaciated storyline, the ever-elusive atmosphere, the apathetic cast, and a pace that seemed to move with the speed of a tortoise, Donihe’s style of writing – his imagery, his ability to string words together that can create a sense of clarity and awe in the reader, and his originality is still there…barely. You just have to look, preferably with a magnifying glass and a big margarita.
My rating? I give it a 1. Now, maybe it’s because I have my own presuppositions of Donihe or maybe it’s because I hold him so high on a pedestal, but I expected a lot more from him and you should to. My advice: skip this novella and wait for his next release. From what I hear, he has quite a few coming out soon.
-As posted on Horror-Web.com