Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

John Putnam Thatcher #3

Accounting for Murder

Rate this book
The elegant, silver-haired banker-detective who charmed readers in Banking on Death returns in a mystery involving miscalculations and murder at the National Calculating Company, where an accountant is found strangled with his adding machine cord. Reprint.

186 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1964

14 people are currently reading
99 people want to read

About the author

Emma Lathen

41 books22 followers
Aka R.B. Dominic

Emma Lathen is the pen name of two American businesswomen: an attorney Mary Jane Latsis (July 12, 1927 -October 29, 1997) and an economic analyst Martha Henissart (b. 1929),who received her B.A. in physics from Mount Holyoke College in 1950.

http://www.nytimes.com/1997/10/31/boo...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
81 (33%)
4 stars
93 (37%)
3 stars
52 (21%)
2 stars
15 (6%)
1 star
4 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
Profile Image for Lisa Kucharski.
1,057 reviews
November 22, 2012
The wonderful thing about the early Lathen's is that they feature Thatcher a great deal. And in this story his sharp tongued mind is on full display. A great mystery, that involves accounting! It may seem that accounting is dull to many people but, having some exposure to it, it actually is interesting and this mystery certainly gets down to the power of numbers and how they are read!

Profile Image for Nicholas Ball.
202 reviews2 followers
March 11, 2019
I quite like murder mysteries and especially the older ones (think: Chandler, Hammett, Sayers, Crispin) but I was surprised to find I had never heard of this prodigious duo. Two professional women (from memory one a lawyer, the other an accountant?) adopted a pseudonym comprising elements of both their names so that they could write with anonymity without jeapodising their careers and then wrote several dozen mystery novels set in the world of high finance and trade.

But enough background, the book itself: I found it a charming whimsical read that had a lot of warmth in the casual ways they analysed the underlying personalities - the protagonist is a pleasure to accompany throughout the book. If I had to pick a failing, I would say there is a significantly larger body of work in the personalities that the underlying events. Once a character is murdered, there was a brief description of how the body was found and then this aspect wasn't covered or investigated by anyone again. It is true the greater mystery was the motive behind the murder (a significant fraud that people are trying to detect and unravel) but right up until the last 15% of the book basically nothing had been discovered or resolved. I was nervous about it having a reasonable resolution - and I was not let down. Some key characters cover the entire thing suitably and briefly, and in order that the reader didn't feel cheated, some clever hints that were hidden in the first 85% are dusted off to show that they were sort-of playing fair all along. It's well written but still a bit of cheat. I haven't read any of their other books but if this comes up again I suspect I have the authors' measure.

Anyway, as it stood it was a brief little mystery novel set in the financial services industry with well drawn characterisation and clever observations on society. Well worth a punt.
Profile Image for Nancy.
1,424 reviews49 followers
September 26, 2009
This is a quite standard mystery centered around a simple but unusual accounting fraud. This book was first published in 1964 and takes place at that time. The business of business was definitely still a man's world then. I found it interesting to follow the descriptions of Mrs. Cobb as she interacted with the male managers. She is described as "nominally the assistant division manager... in Research and Development, actually the guiding intelligence in a division notable for the rapid turnover of its chiefs."
Profile Image for Vicki Cline.
779 reviews45 followers
August 6, 2011
Another good business mystery. And I guessed the murderer! One of the things I like best about this series is the chapter headings. They are always centered around a theme. In this case, since the victim is named Fortinbras, the theme is Shakespeare's Hamlet. Some examples -
2. Enter Fortinbras
8. Weepings and Lamentations
11. Distant Revelry
15. Behind the Arras
20. Exeunt Omnes
Also, in this book we learn that Thatcher is 60 years old. I don't think he ever ages, even though the books were written between 1961 and 1997.
Profile Image for Jeronimo.
79 reviews1 follower
June 1, 2018
Being myself an accountant, it was a nice experience to find notions of accounting and finance mixed with one of my favourite genres, as mystery is.
On an absolute partial and subjective point of view, I liked it very much because of the background. As complexity, I can say it was a good read. Nevertheless it is the first book I read from this author, so I hope to find out in the future if her (their) idea kept along further production or stood original within this book.
Profile Image for Robert.
397 reviews38 followers
June 24, 2008
This is actually a 1964 book. An early entry in the John Putnam Thatcher series. It is clear that the authors were just developing their style. The humor is not bad but not as well-done as in later offerings. The plot resolution is a bit hard to follow and depends upon a greater understanding of the characters than the authors have provided.
Profile Image for Pamela Mclaren.
1,694 reviews114 followers
May 23, 2016
I like Emma Lathen's writing and I like her banker, John Putnam Thatcher, but I have to admit that part of this book was a little too complicated to follow. But the general idea shines through and for all the TCP/IS something or other, this is a surprisingly entrancing mystery to follow.
Profile Image for Marc.
Author 24 books8 followers
June 30, 2012
This 1964 Wall Street murder mystery was often fun to read, but the story never generated any real suspense or grabbed my interest. It's a series of cleverly-observed character studies and situations that never really cohere into an engaging mystery story.

The authors (a duo working under the Emma Lathen pseudonym) take an ironic posture toward their story and its characters, but they devote more effort to witty observations and clever dialogue than to crafting a compelling narrative. One problem is that the murder doesn't take place until almost halfway through the book, and events leading up to the crime tend to meander among an at-times confusingly large number of characters. Another is that Thatcher, the "detective" (actually an executive of a Wall Street bank), is just one of several major characters in the story. We don't come to know him very well and never really get inside his head, and in any event Thatcher doesn't assume a proactive role in the murder investigation until the last two chapters. (I should note that Thatcher is a recurring character in a series of books, so perhaps he is better defined in other books which we are meant to have read before this one.)

The setup is very reminiscent of Agatha Christie: we're presented with a large number of suspects, and we're invited to play along with the detective in trying to figure out whodunit. But the crucial clues are not revealed until near the end, so it's not possible to logically solve the mystery before Thatcher does. And the lighthearted ironic tone of the book works against the reader's inclination to muster any sympathy for the murder victim or desire for justice to be done.

All of this being said, I am assigning the book a rating of 3 stars out of 5 because the dialogue and the authors' observations really are quite funny and trenchant, and the book also has some anthropological significance, providing a vivid glimpse into the world of American business, circa 1964. But prospective readers should be forewarned that this book's setting and context may be of limited interest: most of the scenes take place in corporate offices, and the plot is heavily concerned with financial accounting.
399 reviews5 followers
September 6, 2020
This is a 1964 book written by Emma Lathen. Emma Lathen is the pen name of two American authors Mary Jane Latsis (an economic analyst) and Martha Henissart (an attorney). The setting is in 1964 New York City. It is one of those rare business mysteries written by authors who have a deep insight into the world of finance and accounting and develop a thoughtful plot around it. The story is pretty much one of how an accounting fraud went awry and led to murder. It is also about and the role of forensic accounting in uncovering financial frauds. The version I read has a good introduction on the background of the authors and the history of the 24 books series and how it evolves. I also find it useful that the authors provide a full cast of characters up front to make it easy for readers to follow along (the book has quite a few corporate characters). The writing is efficient and crisp and started out strong. However, the story slowed down in the second half and dragged on quite a bit. Overall, I find the book has a very interesting plot and it is a good engaging read.

The story is about a publicly traded company in New York City called National Calculating, which manufactures both cash registers and computers. For many years the company has lost money. Finally, a group of activist stockholders formed the National Calculating Stockholders’ Protest Committee and got a court order to audit National Calculating’s books and financial records. The audit is led by a famed accountant called Clarence Fortinbras (who wrote an authoritative work called Fortinbras on Accounts Receivable), is an expert who other accountants go to when they have difficult problems. In the course of his audit, Fortinbras was surprised that two divisions of National Calculating (Commercial Sales selling to commercial markets and Government Contracts selling to the US Army), head by different people but sell a similar computer equipment, would have one division having big losses and the other having big profits. While Fortinbras’ initial suspicions fell on the head of Commercial Sales as to whether the loss is caused by embezzlement or incompetence, he finally concluded Commercial Sales’ book is in order. Just when he turned his focus on the profit making division Government Contracts, and was ready to demand a physical inventory of the division, Fortinbras was found murdered in his office, strangled with the cord of the adding machine on his desk. Unfortunately for Fortinbras and other people in the case, he never let on what he found prior to his death.

After that, John Putnam Thatcher, a Senior Vice President of Sloan Guaranty Trust, described by the authors as the third largest bank in the world at that time, played the role of a reluctant detective to solve the case. Sloan has a big bond position in National Calculating Therefore, Thatcher has influence over management. After a lot of back and forth and some red herring, as well as an attempted murder on another accountant, Stanley Draper, Thatcher were able to unmask the murderer. It turns out to be Jay Rutledge, the division head of the Government Contracts division. What Rutledge did was to mislead the army into believing that the computer systems National Calculating sold the US Army which is used for artillery targeting has a one-year service life and must be returned and replaced after that. In fact, those systems have a two-year or more service life. So, every year the US Army returns the used computer systems on each artillery piece to National Calculating. Rutledge then moved the returned computer systems around the factory and repackaged them and sold it to the US Army again as new units at full price. This netted the company over $100 million in extra profits over the years and benefited Rutledge personally through bonuses and stock options. Rutledge also cooked the books so that the company’s auditors did not notice the fraud. When Fortinbras requests a physical inventory of the warehouse and raided some satellite offices to get books before Rutledge gets to doctor them, Rutledge knows he may be caught so he murdered Fortinbras. In the end, after Thatcher has pieced all these together, Rutledge knew his game is up and he committed suicide by jumping out his office window.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Teri-K.
2,491 reviews56 followers
July 10, 2019
Not many authors could take a mystery based on accounting and make it both intriguing and amusing, but fortunately for the reader, this author did just that. National Calculating's profits are on a downward slump and the stockholders are unhappy. That might not matter too much, except the leader of the Stockholder's Protest Committee is Clarence Fortinbras, author of the famous textbook on accounting, and a man who loves using numbers to ferret out a company's secrets. Fortinbras has turned his sights on Nat'l Calculating, and the company may never recover.

John Thatcher, Senior Vice-President of the world's third largest bank, is unwillingly drawn into this mess but intends to remain out of the fray as much as possible, until someone is murdered. Then he turns all of his curiosity and deductive powers to the situation. Throw in some ineffective leadership, a charming four-star general and a deadly telephone cord, and the reader will be whisked back in time to a delightful 1960's mystery. A solid 3 stars

The Series:
Thatcher is an intelligent, detached, wry observer of human nature; a widower with almost no social life. No profanity, sex or violence here. Instead these books feel to me much like Agatha Christie novels, with a focus on a few likable characters and the mystery itself. All the clues the reader needs to unwind the puzzle are included but they're pretty deftly hidden.

The stories are very well-written, intelligent, and the contain some dry humor. People are presented in all their strengths and weaknesses, but Thatcher's general kindness keeps them from looking ridiculous. Usually, anyway. Another strength of the series is the variety of settings. The mysteries don't actually take place at the bank, but instead in different businesses the bank has an interest in, so later books give the reader an insider's look into aspects of these businesses. I really enjoy these forays, as well as the minor characters we meet as the stories develop.

A possible complaint is that, despite the fact that the author was actually two highly successful professional women, all the MCs are men. The only females here are wives, daughters and secretaries. This never bothered me, I think because when the women do show up they're generally pretty sharp and independent. Also, times have changed enough that these books feel more historical than contemporary to me. Still it's too bad no one broke the glass ceiling at Sloan Guarantee and Trust during this series. (Although, it's not like the men are paragons of intelligence or virtue, either. There's a sweetly cynical cast to everyone in these books that I enjoy.)

I've been a fan of this author for decades - I own all of her (their) books, picked up in pre-Internet days from used book stores and library sales. Still, I'm very happy to see the books available on ebook for reasonable prices. You don't always have access to your books, (mine are in storage in another state right now), and it's easier to recommend books to friends if they're actually available to the reader. So, yeah ebooks! (Some Amazon reviews mention terrible typos and other errors. Apparently these have been fixed in the titles I've purchased so far. You can always try an ebook and return it to Amazon if the typos aren't fixed.)

It's not necessary to read the series in order, as each book is very much a stand alone. My favorites are: When in Greece, Murder to Go, Pick Up Sticks, Ashes to Ashes, Murder Without Icing, Going for the Gold and Right on the Money. This author really deserves to be much more widely read. I hope she soon will be.
Profile Image for Joy.
1,409 reviews23 followers
July 31, 2018
Auditor Clarence Fortinbras was so ferociously dedicated to finding a suspected fraud that only death was going to stop him. Someone saw the writing on the wall and provided that death. The fraud is so striking that I remembered it from the last time I read it, 30 years ago. Lathen's intelligently amusing writing pulls the reader non-stop to the solution.

While the head office of National Calculating was thrown into chaos by the murder investigation: “Miss Quackenbush, the office manager, chose this period to institute a new supply room control system, designed to cut down the pilfering of ball-point pens, and created so complex a procedure that for several days it was impossible to obtain any carbon paper without requisitioning it on seven carbons, a self-defeating aspect of the scheme that had escaped her."

“Thatcher was relieved to find that [Richter] appreciated the situation without elaboration. After a few days of dealing with Mason, Thatcher had begun to develop an explanatory technique which bordered on the offensive.”


Read 3 times
Profile Image for Emmanuel Gustin.
412 reviews25 followers
October 22, 2024
This is the second book of the authors (Emma Lathen is a duo) and in the first chapters they haven’t found their voice yet, which means that the style is a bit clunky. It improves as your progress through the book and they have more opportunities to be mildly satirical. The hapless executives of National Computing foreshadow the numerous incompetents that are encountered in later works.

Happily, the plot is all about money, giving ample opportunity to a disgruntled John Thatcher to figure it out. The marital adventures of Tom Robichaux provide additional diversion, making one feel some regret that he figured less in later books. The end is wrapped up a bit too abruptly, but satisfactorily.
14 reviews
December 3, 2024
Unfortunately, I have not had the opportunity to read the first two books penned by the two ladies as I was given three of their stories and read this one first. I enjoyed all the banter, the constant poking of fun and the strong woman in a male world exhibited in this book.
Inevitably a point is reached in this narrative when it becomes clear that all is not as presented, so determining the guilty individual is straightforward. The mechanism used is pure academia if you are an accountant, but possibly a challenge, if you aren't. I now intend to read a second title to see just how devious the Sixties Wall Street might have been
Profile Image for Suzi.
1,342 reviews14 followers
May 16, 2021
Interesting reading mysteries set in the 1960s where women were secretaries or wives or temptresses. Most are portrayed as smart but not given responsible jobs.

Interesting twist in the mystery. I am old and it's fun to look back on our lives during the times this series was written and popular. I wish I were more committed to writing about what I read. I think there's a story here and maybe a mystery, although not a murder! Getting older is not as bad as I thought and I've loved 14 months of staying home and reading.
431 reviews1 follower
March 14, 2020
I suppose this book was pretty popular 50+ years ago when it was written. I felt the characters were not well developed. I never knew who anyone was. The story wasn't very interesting. There was no dramatic build-up. No constant second guessing of who-dun-it. No connection with the characters. At the end, I was underwhelmed. As an accountant, I thought this was going to be clever and entertaining. But, it wasn't.
Profile Image for Marsha Valance.
3,840 reviews60 followers
June 7, 2020
Author of the classic textbook "Fortinbras on Accounts Receivable", retired Professor Clarence Fortinbras is concerned about the books at the National Calculating Company. Do the discrepancies point to inefficiency, or fraud? As a stockholder he obtains an injunction to conduct an audit. When he is strangled with the cord of his own adding machine, Banker John Putnam Thatcher investigates.
303 reviews7 followers
August 1, 2020
I really enjoy John Putnam Thatcher. He is such a gentleman! Of course it was not easy getting these books here in South Africa as for some reason, no Emma Lathen books are on sale. The only way was to order them from used bookshops from all over the world. Took me years to complete my collection, but I now have them all. Great read!
456 reviews2 followers
January 5, 2021
Fortinbras definitely is one of my favorite victims, partly because I’m such a fan of the Bard!
Profile Image for Susan.
429 reviews5 followers
February 14, 2021
A fun if breezy book with some fun moments.
Profile Image for Chris Wackett.
159 reviews1 follower
October 9, 2021
Good story only slightly marred by slightly hesitant narration on an audio book
259 reviews
January 4, 2024
I didn't really finish this book. His style of writing just wasn't for me. I had gotten 3 other books by him 5hat I will donate back to ECHO.
693 reviews4 followers
December 29, 2024
Picked up from a little free library and really enjoyed - just a quick mystery from the 60s that made me think of what my job might be like if there was a murder at one of the companies
12 reviews
January 12, 2025
Very odd but interesting. Will read more of this author for sure.
40 reviews
August 13, 2024
Well-written, and a pleasure to read. Takes me to a different time and place.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.