Uh…. I advise potential readers to read the warning before diving in as this story is ultimately a romance between a bullied girl and her tormentor set a couple years after graduating high school and their separation.
Our female lead, Colette, is from the poorer side of town, but meets her filthy rich bully, Velspar, as a child. Given she stutters it’s easy enough to tease her, and by high school, when she has earned a scholarship to the rich prep school he and his friends attend, the torments have escalated to breaking her things, stealing or deliberately destroying her lunch and even a physical beating from his followers.
Now we find Colette realizing her new cleaning job is for Velspar… a live-in position she unfortunately can’t afford to pass up, and as time passes Colette slowly learns that Velspar isn’t all he seemed.
Does the excuses for his actions forgive him even if he is still cruel or does the occasionally kind words make up for the hateful ones? I should hope not. But then some people do deserve forgiveness, based on their actions and regrets. Having been bullied, I don’t care how pretty a guy is or if he justifies his actions by saying it was done in love- nope. Nope, nope, nope.
I can forgive, yes, even without apology or without speaking to said bullies again, because staying angry hurts me not them- why let someone I haven’t seen in years live rent free in my head? But this “romance” between a former punching bag and the man who still is a jerk is not for me. I found myself more queasy than anything, and I don’t care that he’s a traumatized mess because of his own circumstances… you want to make it up then get some therapy don’t toss your twisted ideas of what love is out there and expect your warped feelings to be returned.
This relationship is just toxic, pure and simple, whether fiction or not. No young girl or teens should be reading this and start thinking this is remotely healthy- girls, red flags are just that- great big neon warning signs to steer clear. It isn’t your job to try and love someone who hurts you because you aren’t about to change him. There are some things only time, therapy and perhaps medication will help, but he has to do this for himself.
Please never put yourself in a position to be mistreated and told that this is love.
Did the book have cute moments? Yes. But Velspar is a walking billboard for mental health issues as he isn’t capable of a kind and loving relationship at this point in his life. The fact that Colette gets tangled in his way of thinking that causing pain is okay if you’re in love isn’t healthy. I’m not against those who like pain with their pleasure, but we are to believe a good girl suddenly is into manipulation, lies and hurtful gestures and the power rush of being in control? It’s a rather sudden leap for it to be believable.
Reading this as a romance between a dominant and a submissive in a relationship with healthy boundaries is something else- and maybe that’s where it was supposed to go, but , as written, I just can’t find a HEA here. I’m hoping if you go ahead and read this that you can. If the bullying hadn’t been involved, had two broken people found one another, maybe? I mean both characters have their good points, which is why I gave this three stars… I just wished it could have come from a more loving space.
For those who haven’t gone through bullying and abuse- feel free to read and enjoy this for the fiction it is. For those, like myself, whether you have worked past your abuse or not- I’d think twice before picking this one up.