It is difficult knowing how to rate this book. The content is very much worth 5 stars, is high impact, and should be known and appreciated by all American citizens, but the gratuitous and intense use of vulgar and obscene language very much limits the scope of who should be reading it. I realize that the graphic language and description is the reality in the extreme stress environment in which the troops live, but the author goes beyond quotes and uses offensive language himself to drive home the point often. Young adults should know the content but I would not want to hand the book to a teenage (or younger)son or daughter for fear of sending the wrong message to them. So the book does not speak effectively to those who should benefit.
The constant use of military acronyms is a big source of confusion for readers. At minimum, a glossary of Acronyms should be provided. So that was an obstacle. Once you got past the vulgar language and the acronyms, the message was high impact and you felt real affinity with those troops on the ground.
Reading this book now at the same time that the news is filled with the ISIS attempt to take over Iraq and more drove home the book's message and impact. We went into Iraq after 9/11 with the intent of establishing a free Iraq without the repression of it's past in the midst of an Islamic culture. The book describes the impossible situation for the troops on the ground. They had to fight an enemy that masqueraded as local citizens so that troops could not freely fight back. Meanwhile, they were charged with building trust within the locals in order to establish a free country for which they would later assume responsibility. While it was amazingly successful at the time against all odds, it needs to be maintained. Following is a paragraph from the book.
“Would the next election encourage the Islamic radicals by revealing a lack of American resolve, a weakness to be exploited by those already planning their next terrorist attack on American soil? To cut and run at this critical point, as so many political hacks were advocating anything if it would win them a few more votes, meant that everything American soldiers had achieved in Iraq would be thrown out like yesterday’s garbage. To have won the war, then abandon it and the country’s people back to tyranny, was nothing more than a betrayal of sacrifices made by American soldiers like Chris Messer, Joe Given, Sergeant Connell, Courneyea, Schober, Murphy, Fouty, Jimenez, Anzak, and all the others” ~ Charles W Sasser in None Left Behind: The 10th Mountain Division and the Triangle of Death, p 299
Indeed, we elected an administration that chose to walk away prematurely and we now are seeing ISIS, which is the same Al-Qaida Sunni Muslim branch that were launching attacks on our men overrunning large portions of Iraq. As of this writing are threatening to take over the area termed the triangle of death in which our men sacrificed so much and died. It is so sad that, indeed,we told ourselves that we won the war, then abandoned it and the country’s people back to tyranny. It was nothing more than a betrayal of sacrifices made by American soldiers. Reading this book brings home this point more than watching the news ever could.
Another couple of quotes follow that was interesting concerned the importance of Iraq historically and Biblically.
“Israel is mentioned more times in the Bible than any other nation. But Iraq is a close second place, although that’s not the name used in the Bible. It’s called Babylon, Land of Shinar, and Mesopotamia.” ~ Chaplain Jeff Bryan quoted by Charles W Sasser on p 156-157
“Iraq was the approximate location of the Garden of Eden, where God created Adam and Eve in the beginning. The Greatest Story Ever Told unfolded from there step by step, event by event.
Satan made his first recorded appearance in Iraq. The Tower of Babel was built in Iraq, followed by the confusion of languages. Abraham hailed from a city from a city in Iraq, as did Isaac’s wife. Jacob spent twenty years between the two rivers. Iraq was the site of Persia, the world’s first empire. The greatest Christian revival in history occurred in Nineveh, now the city of Mosul. The events in the book of Esther took place in Iraq. The book of Nahum prophesied against a city in Iraq. The Euphrates was the far eastern border of the land God promised Abraham. Finally, the book of Revelation warned against the resurrection of Babylon.
The Euphrates River was 1,800 miles long. According to Revelation, it would dry up after a full scale invasion of the West coming from the East. And blood would rise to the level of a horse’s bridle.” ~ Charles W Sasser citing input from Chaplain Jeff Bryan and PFC William Henderson in None Left Behind: The 10th Mountain Division and the Triangle of Death. p 157
There may be a couple of small errors in this quote, but it makes it clear that Iraq is very important Biblically and historically.