What I Liked:
The general sentiment behind the book was fabulous. I loved the encouragement to take up pen and paper and handwrite personal notes and letters.
From page 3: What's so often missing from our lives today is the richness of shared humanity, those moments when we feel really connected to other human beings. The act of writing personal notes not only feeds our own soul, but also lets us share ourselves with others - offering hope, affirming life, connecting.
From page 4: Instant communications allow us to function too close to the surface, writing on the run from only that top, thin layer of our thoughts; responding without going deeper, opening our inner well, or drawing out that flow of spirit and words that will really connect us to another.
What I Didn't Like:
The actual advice given was sometimes random and incorrect.
For example, from the chart on pages 9-14:
- Send thank you notes from wedding showers within 1 week.
- Send thank you notes from baby showers within 1 week.
- Send thank you notes for wedding gifts within 3 months.
- Send thank you notes for birth/adoption gifts within 4 weeks.
- Send thank you notes for birthday gifts within 3 days.
- Send thank you notes for holiday gifts within 2-3 days.
- Send thank you notes for hostess gifts within 2-3 days.
- Send thank you notes for condolences within 6 weeks.
All of these time limits seem arbitrary and incorrect. I was taught that thank you notes are sent immediately upon receiving a gift. Ideally within a day. If you are incapacitated (due to sickness, new baby, ect) or out of town (honeymoon), you send the notes as soon as possible.
On page 11, she says that etiquette requires you to state a reason when declining an invitation. In fact, the opposite it true.
The book was filled with samples of "good" notes, which often seemed a bit kooky. Read all together, they seemed over the top with sentimentality. And incomplete sentences.
This book was published in 2003 by an elderly author. Some of her comments and observations struck me as odd. For example, she says that emoticons are silly and annoying. She says you should not use them in emails, unless you are sure the recipient wants to receive them. She also says that you should NOT email, but instead handwrite a letter, when you will need/want a permanent record of something. [Both examples from pages 15 & 16.]
On page 52, she warns against sending birthday cards to women, unless you know for sure that they want to acknowledge their birthday. Ughhh! Birthday cards are my thing! I'd never send a card to someone I know doesn't want to be reminded of their birthday. But I also don't think I have to check ahead of time with each person, before sending out a card.
Also, this book was oddly written with the blatant assumption that all the readers will be female.