434 books
—
563 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “حوار مع صديقي الملحد” as Want to Read:
حوار مع صديقي الملحد
by
رد على أسئله لملحدين على الدين الإسلامي, رد رائع بالدلائل والأمثله يجيب عن تساؤلات عقلنا فى فترة ما نمر بها ويرد بها على الآخرين الماديين.
صديقى رجل يحب الجدل ويهوى الكلام وهو يعتقد أننا نحن المؤمنون السذج نقتات بالاوهام ونضحك على أنفسنا بالجنة والحوار العين وتفوتنا لذات الدنيا ومفاتنها.. وصديقى بهذه المناسبة تخرج من فرنسا وحصل على دكتوراه وعاش مع الهيبيز وأصبح ينكر كل شئ.
...more
صديقى رجل يحب الجدل ويهوى الكلام وهو يعتقد أننا نحن المؤمنون السذج نقتات بالاوهام ونضحك على أنفسنا بالجنة والحوار العين وتفوتنا لذات الدنيا ومفاتنها.. وصديقى بهذه المناسبة تخرج من فرنسا وحصل على دكتوراه وعاش مع الهيبيز وأصبح ينكر كل شئ.
...more
Get A Copy
Paperback, 140 pages
Published
2001
by دار أخبار اليوم - قطاع الثقافة
(first published 1970)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
حوار مع صديقي الملحد,
please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of حوار مع صديقي الملحد
It's pretty much a discussion between an intelligent religious person who obviously studied Quran and Islamic philosophy and a stupid atheist(Doctor?) who knows basically shit and who is in it for the pleasures of materialism.
I imagine it went something like this:
http://i.imgur.com/J58aoHi.gif ...more
I imagine it went something like this:
http://i.imgur.com/J58aoHi.gif ...more
It is not a dialogue, the author takes up the common questions of atheists and he tries to answer without any discussion.
A disappointing book on several aspects, the author tries to convince an atheist by Islam by arguing on a number of questions.
In the first place, the majority of the arguments are repetitive, it repeats what Christians have worked out for decades. For example, he speaks of the `` problem of evil '' which was first developed by Epicurus: “Is God willing to prevent evil, but not ...more
A disappointing book on several aspects, the author tries to convince an atheist by Islam by arguing on a number of questions.
In the first place, the majority of the arguments are repetitive, it repeats what Christians have worked out for decades. For example, he speaks of the `` problem of evil '' which was first developed by Epicurus: “Is God willing to prevent evil, but not ...more
After the end of each chapter, I had to stop myself from saying out loud: “And then everyone clapped”.
A single star for the comic relief and because I don’t have much of a choice when it comes to Goodreads rating system.
A single star for the comic relief and because I don’t have much of a choice when it comes to Goodreads rating system.
I amalready a big fan Of Dr.Mostafa Mahmoud,yet still reading:)
Maybe a 2012-year young man will not be overwhelmed by Mustapha Mahmoud's style in writing, but getting back to know when this book was first published (1986), you realize it was a masterpiece digging inside the souls and getting out all doubts in there. Using reason and facts, before spirituals, Mustapha Mahmoud puts you before your doubts and kills them gradually and smoothly in a way that gets you sure that a thing like this was only written by someone who has been there and that, before he t
...more
Thinking beating your wife for being a whore is a BDSM play and a quranic miracle, really? Trash!
AWESOME book for whoever interested in such a topic!
this book replay and answer about most of the questions which spin in your head, just read it and enjoy :)
its my first time reading such a book and i was quite disapointed.
- first: the book is supposed to be a dialogue, a conversation, a give and take with enough arguments to support both opinions.
yet in this one the atheist friend has got only one question, one line per each chapter, but the writer "the muslim side in the convo" has got the whole chapter explaining and giving arguments. it would have been more helpful if he supported the atheistic side with more arguments rather than one qst, so th ...more
- first: the book is supposed to be a dialogue, a conversation, a give and take with enough arguments to support both opinions.
yet in this one the atheist friend has got only one question, one line per each chapter, but the writer "the muslim side in the convo" has got the whole chapter explaining and giving arguments. it would have been more helpful if he supported the atheistic side with more arguments rather than one qst, so th ...more
Moustafa Mahmoud was a colossal idiot. He got popular in Egypt because most people are ignorant and really know nothing about science, history or anything.
In this remarkably dumb book, he claims to have a conversation with his past atheist self, and goes on pointing out the wrong ideas he had. The main problem Mustafa Mahmoud had, again, was that he is an idiot. He became an atheist because he thought it was cool and hip (his own description). Do I need to say more?
He doesn't understand any of ...more
In this remarkably dumb book, he claims to have a conversation with his past atheist self, and goes on pointing out the wrong ideas he had. The main problem Mustafa Mahmoud had, again, was that he is an idiot. He became an atheist because he thought it was cool and hip (his own description). Do I need to say more?
He doesn't understand any of ...more
I liked the conversation and the logical ways in which Mostafa Mahmoud proved his point of view. I loved his writing style and this made me want to read more books by him.
One thing I disliked was although this book is relatively short, I found myself skimming over the words and not actually reading and giving each word its time. I found it to be really boring half way through.
Nonetheless, it's a good book and an interesting one indeed. ...more
One thing I disliked was although this book is relatively short, I found myself skimming over the words and not actually reading and giving each word its time. I found it to be really boring half way through.
Nonetheless, it's a good book and an interesting one indeed. ...more
This book raised a lot of questions , that I thought before they are red lines not to be crossed , it supported me to ask some questions and understand my religion on understanding base not just what I have been tough since I was a kid .
Yet I was convinced by all the answers and this will encourage me to search more about issues I never though I knew nothing about them.
Brilliant
Yet I was convinced by all the answers and this will encourage me to search more about issues I never though I knew nothing about them.
Brilliant
it's a remarkable book ~ it's the second time i read this book .. and i know i'm gonna read it again :)
...more
I have this long-life dream to read all Mustafa Mahmoued's books, all of them , no excuses.
I read more than 10 books so far, which is a pretty good start, as I started quite short time ago.
for this book, I read more than one review in goodreads , and everything was asking me to pick this particularly book to read.
And I did, it is the most powerful book I've ever read for the author till now (after Einstein and relativity).
It is mainly about religion , about how every single thing in the universe ...more
I read more than 10 books so far, which is a pretty good start, as I started quite short time ago.
for this book, I read more than one review in goodreads , and everything was asking me to pick this particularly book to read.
And I did, it is the most powerful book I've ever read for the author till now (after Einstein and relativity).
It is mainly about religion , about how every single thing in the universe ...more
Oct 09, 2015
Mehwish Mughal
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
my-own-my-precious,
recommendations
A friend recommended a part of this book. I couldn't bring myself to read just one part so I ended up reading the entire book and I am glad I did.
The book answers ~30 questions asked by an atheist who had a fair knowledge of Islam. I say fair knowledge because most of his questions were asked within the framework of Islam.
My first reaction to the book (as communicated to my friend) was:
1) The Atheist has his own language
2) The Scholar has his own language
3) Both of them do not understand each o ...more
The book answers ~30 questions asked by an atheist who had a fair knowledge of Islam. I say fair knowledge because most of his questions were asked within the framework of Islam.
My first reaction to the book (as communicated to my friend) was:
1) The Atheist has his own language
2) The Scholar has his own language
3) Both of them do not understand each o ...more
This book is clearly not targeted at anyone who has doubts about Islam as a Religion, In fact it is obvious the book is aimed at strengthing the believers beliefs, and making fun of anydoubts they could think of. It tries to Manipulate the readers judgement by using a smart aleck approach demeaning any doubts a Not so believer could have...showing that anyone who doubts Islam must be narrow-minded and missing a lot of " Not so logical " proofs, Overall I didn't really like it, as I found the wri
...more
Great religious Book -
That every Words and every answers That He said in response to the atheist's Questions - literally based on scientific Facts and logic
- Far away from Emotional words and he is totally not answering at fanaticism way as we see mostly.
- i think it is not just Good and perfect book for a atheists even for Believers to make their faith stronger .
Yes Dr.Mostafa YOU did great Job .
...more
That every Words and every answers That He said in response to the atheist's Questions - literally based on scientific Facts and logic
- Far away from Emotional words and he is totally not answering at fanaticism way as we see mostly.
- i think it is not just Good and perfect book for a atheists even for Believers to make their faith stronger .
Yes Dr.Mostafa YOU did great Job .
...more
I thought blind faith was bad, but what's worse is trying to prove garbage ideologies with scientific concepts you don't fully comprehend. I would have given it one star but that's way too much credit for the author. Mustafa Mahmoud is a fraud. He's a failed physician and a failed artist. Arab Muslims give him undeserving credit because he panders to their already set in stone beliefs. This book was a waste of time.
...more
May 15, 2012
Amany
rated it
did not like it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
islam-related-books,
atheism-skypticism
what the 5ara is that
One of the most important books in history
the amount of fallacies in this book is too damn high :D
i loved this book so much it is very important to answer essential question in life like why did God created evil .... .... i recommend all friends to read it.
THE FIRST BOOK I READ :D
FANTASTIC :)
FANTASTIC :)
Mar 09, 2016
Mohamad Rasul
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
answered-many-questions-actually
Answered some important questions
It is an interesting book but sadly it did not provide enough arguments to convince the opponent nor the reader. Islam is so much more than what was mentioned here.
too shallow ideas and explanations
Chad Muslim good.
Strawman Atheist bad.
Strawman Atheist bad.
After my first book for this author called "my journey from doubt to faith" I decided to go for this one as well since I was blown away with the easy and heart-warming writing style.
This one is called "a dialogue with an atheist" is an imaginary dialogue,which I thought was real between the writer and an atheist. Which is counterproductive right? Well, the writer's intention is to explain some of the most common statements atheists come up with when it comes to Islamic religion. He did a good j
...more
This one is called "a dialogue with an atheist" is an imaginary dialogue,
Refute A رد على كتاب - حوار مع صديقي الملحد - لمصطفى محمود " http://www.ahewar.org/debat/show.art.... "
Refute B God of the Paradox " http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7jCly... "
And to clarify Faith it self requires no logical order or Evidential proves hence It can NOT be refuted or argued with by logic.
"I believe in god as much as I believe in unicorns"- Richard Dawkins
RECOMMENDATION: read Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion ...more
Refute B God of the Paradox " http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7jCly... "
And to clarify Faith it self requires no logical order or Evidential proves hence It can NOT be refuted or argued with by logic.
"I believe in god as much as I believe in unicorns"- Richard Dawkins
RECOMMENDATION: read Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion ...more
In the beginning i felt he added some of the basics of philosophy that are arguments for th existence of God. But i felt الروح chapter was new/great.
The one about women is provoking. And the darwin thing is so FAIR and humble!
A very simple language, clear ideas, and open ended question, I;ll definitely search for the rest of his books isAllah :)
The one about women is provoking. And the darwin thing is so FAIR and humble!
A very simple language, clear ideas, and open ended question, I;ll definitely search for the rest of his books isAllah :)
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| بعض الانتقادات لكتاب حوار مع صديقى الملحد | 66 | 1271 | Jan 19, 2019 06:06AM | |
| الكمال لله وحده :D | 1 | 27 | Mar 16, 2016 04:29AM | |
| النقد | 1 | 19 | May 19, 2015 06:43AM | |
| كتاب ماتع | 2 | 28 | Jan 12, 2015 04:33AM | |
| من مربتجربة الشك من قبل؟ | 33 | 614 | Oct 08, 2014 02:31AM | |
| جميل | 1 | 12 | Sep 02, 2014 02:50PM | |
| كتب صوتية من اقرأ لي: النسخة الكاملة لكتاب حوار مع صديقي الملحد | 1 | 151 | Aug 24, 2014 02:41AM |
Readers also enjoyed
مصطفى محمود هو مصطفى كمال محمود حسين آل محفوظ، من الأشراف، ينتهي نسبه إلى عليّ زين العابدين، ولد عام 1921 بشبين الكوم، بمحافظة المنوفية بمصر، وكان توأما لأخ توفي في نفس العام، مفكر وطبيب وكاتب وأديب مصري، توفي والده عام 1939 بعد سنوات من الشلل، درس الطب وتخرج عام 1953 ولكنه تفرغ للكتابة والبحث عام 1960، وتزوج عام 1961 وانتهى الزواج بالطلاق عام 1973، رزق بولدين أمل وأدهم، وتزوج ثانية عام 1983 وانته
...more
News & Interviews
Kazuo Ishiguro insists he’s an optimist about technology.
“I'm not one of these people who thinks it's going to come and destroy us,” he...
264 likes · 26 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“الله الكريم سمح لنا أن ندخل عليه فى أى وقت بلا ميعاد، ونبقى في حضرته ما شئنا وندعوه ما وسعنا.. بمجرد أن نبسط سجادة الصلاة ونقول "الله أكبر" نصبح فى حضرته نطلب منه ما نشاء.
أين هو الملك الذى نستطيع أن ندخل عليه بلا ميعاد ونلبث في حضرته مانشاء؟!”
—
1391 likes
أين هو الملك الذى نستطيع أن ندخل عليه بلا ميعاد ونلبث في حضرته مانشاء؟!”
“لا تستطيع أن تحيط بحالة إلا إذا خرجت خارجها”
—
441 likes
More quotes…
